• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

ET found in landfill [Xbox troll = ban]

From the OP:

https://twitter.com/kobunheat/status/460158489998815233/photo/1
"There is so much stuff they've pulled up. This is all just atari 2600 games."

GhYFV39.jpg


Seriously, are you not even willing to read the very first post of this thread?

Lies...there is a tire !
 

Fox_Mulder

Rockefellers. Skull and Bones. Microsoft. Al Qaeda. A Cabal of Bankers. The melting point of steel. What do these things have in common? Wake up sheeple, the landfill wasn't even REAL!
So basically, you have nothing to contribute to this thread. Why do you write here?
I'm only skeptical. Nothing more, nothing less.
Can i have the right to be skeptical?
 

RetroStu

Banned
This story isn't as romantic as i thought. I always thought the rumour was that Atari took thousands of cartridges out to the desert and buried them in a random 'grave'.
I didn't realise they just put them in a rubbish landfill which is semi-normal really.
 
I'm only skeptical. Nothing more, nothing less.
Can i have the right to be skeptical?

You have the right to ignore evidence and facts. Yes.

This story isn't as romantic as i thought. I always thought the rumour was that Atari took thousands of cartridges out to the desert and buried them in a random 'grave'.
I didn't realise they just put them in a rubbish landfill which is semi-normal really.

Same here.
 

Jea Song

Did the right thing
Well if this is true then it's very interesting and kinda cool. Personally I think they sold have left it alone. What's the point of this really?

I don't like how this is probably going to be part of Xbox one original programming. It's an interesting part of gaming that should be available to everyone.

Microsoft being behind this doesn't sit well with me for some reason. Not trying to gather a conspiracy but just doesn't sit right with me .
 

saunderez

Member
Well if this is true then it's very interesting and kinda cool. Personally I think they sold have left it alone. What's the point of this really?
Half the people in this thread thought it was a myth. It's pretty obvious why they did it. There's ample evidence that the burial took place, witnesses to the burial and witnesses to the excavation. It makes no sense for this to be a hoax.
 

RetroStu

Banned
Well if this is true then it's very interesting and kinda cool. Personally I think they sold have left it alone. What's the point of this really?

I don't like how this is probably going to be part of Xbox one original programming. It's an interesting part of gaming that should be available to everyone.

Microsoft being behind this doesn't sit well with me for some reason. Not trying to gather a conspiracy but just doesn't sit right with me .

They really can't do no right no matter what they do can they with some people?, jesus.
 
Well if this is true then it's very interesting and kinda cool. Personally I think they sold have left it alone. What's the point of this really?

I don't like how this is probably going to be part of Xbox one original programming. It's an interesting part of gaming that should be available to everyone.

Microsoft being behind this doesn't sit well with me for some reason. Not trying to gather a conspiracy but just doesn't sit right with me .

This is an awesome story in video history. Stop being a fanboy.
 

Dr. Kaos

Banned
Well if this is true then it's very interesting and kinda cool. Personally I think they sold have left it alone. What's the point of this really?

I don't like how this is probably going to be part of Xbox one original programming. It's an interesting part of gaming that should be available to everyone.

Microsoft being behind this doesn't sit well with me for some reason. Not trying to gather a conspiracy but just doesn't sit right with me .

Atari released a really shitty game as a movie tie-in. Didn't sell, they threw it in the dumpster.

What's so interesting about it? I really don't see the appeal...
 

Jea Song

Did the right thing
This is an awesome story in video history. Stop being a fanboy.

Fanboy? I own a Wii u, ps4, and Xbox one.

If Sony did this it wouldn't sit well either. Somehow I think it would be a conflict of interest. I said i think the story is cool and interesting.

I just hope it's not exclusive Xbox one content and they put the documentary on Netflix or something so anyone could watch it.
 

DECK'ARD

The Amiga Brotherhood
Atari released a really shitty game as a movie tie-in. Didn't sell, they threw it in the dumpster.

What's so interesting about it? I really don't see the appeal...

It's videogame history, albeit US-centric.

Any story of a company creating and dominating an industry, to then crashing and burning is interesting. ET is just the symbolic bookend to that period, the documentary is about Atari in general.
 
Fanboy? I own a Wii u, ps4, and Xbox one.

If Sony did this it wouldn't sit well either. Somehow I think it would be a conflict of interest. I said i think the story is cool and interesting.

I just hope it's not exclusive Xbox one content and they put the documentary on Netflix or something so anyone could watch it.

Everyone? Netflix is a paywall too.

I'm glad they did it. Nobody else was willing or able to.
 
Well yeah i meant someone from Atari at the time.

Howard Scott Warshaw was there, he's in one of the pictures, I don't know whether he ever commented on the subject though. He did write one of the better columns in retro GamesTM though, fascinating stories about his days at Atari.
 

Peru

Member
Atari released a really shitty game as a movie tie-in. Didn't sell, they threw it in the dumpster.

What's so interesting about it? I really don't see the appeal...

Even people who don't follow videogames may have heard the 'myth' of the ET game crashing so hard that they dumped them in landfills. It's a great image as well as a symbolic one in gaming history, as mentioned by the above poster. And not a myth but a true story, as we've seen now.
 

RetroStu

Banned
Fanboy? I own a Wii u, ps4, and Xbox one.

If Sony did this it wouldn't sit well either. Somehow I think it would be a conflict of interest. I said i think the story is cool and interesting.

I just hope it's not exclusive Xbox one content and they put the documentary on Netflix or something so anyone could watch it.

It would be on Youtube within a day even if it was exclusive content. There is no reason to have yet another go at Microsoft for something when they have investigated a real modern gaming legend and solved it and we are going to see it first hand.
 
Atari released a really shitty game as a movie tie-in. Didn't sell, they threw it in the dumpster.

What's so interesting about it? I really don't see the appeal...
It's more of a defining moment of the North American crash in 83, when nobody was buying or making games like they were before and even the ones that did sell (ET and Pac-Man 2600 sold well initially) had sky high expectations that they could never meet.

ET wasn't just a shitty movie tie-in in the sense you're thinking of, it was a major release from a company that seemed unstoppable until recently before. And it was an embarrassing disaster that they had to bury in the trash along with a lot of other unsold inventory.



Given that this is a documentary about Atari's history, it's a notable incident that can be used to illustrate what was happening as it all came crashing down.
 
if they dont want new theories/urban myths to begin, they should better show some close ups of a lot of boxes^^

They've already pulled up tax returns from that date, I'm sure there are newspapers from 1983 in there as well. It's brilliant, it's not just the cartridges, it's a time capsule of an era that I adored, and still adore.

America was, literally, an undiscovered country to me at that time as a 12 year old. I mean, I flipped (and still do) when they went into that amazing castle arcade on an episode of CHiPs. I love this shit.
 

iMax

Member
Fanboy? I own a Wii u, ps4, and Xbox one.

If Sony did this it wouldn't sit well either. Somehow I think it would be a conflict of interest. I said i think the story is cool and interesting.

I just hope it's not exclusive Xbox one content and they put the documentary on Netflix or something so anyone could watch it.

It's not exclusive to Xbox consoles, AFAIK. It's exclusive to the Xbox platform. So you can watch it at https://video.xbox.com. No more locked down than Netflix, really.
 

Hawk269

Member
There is a pic in the beginning of the thread that shows a master box with 6 copies of the game inside of it. I am a member of older Gaf here and I worked retail back in the day and that box is how 2600 games came in. On big titles we would get a larger box of 24 selling units, each larger box contained 4 smaller ones of 6 games per box. The one photo where it looks like the top of the pack of 6 is opened and it showing the games is how these games came packed back in the day.

Can't believe people still don't believe this. It did happen.
 

Jea Song

Did the right thing
Look it was a myth and apparently it's been proven to be true.

We haven't seen the documentary yet.

So yes people will be skeptable.

Hopefully it will all be settled. It's cool, fun , a bit pointless imo cause its more fun as a myth, but it's entertainment and I plan to watch it.
 
What's the point of this really?
It's a part of their Atari documentary.

I don't like how this is probably going to be part of Xbox one original programming. It's an interesting part of gaming that should be available to everyone.
It probably will be, but it's been written that it is planned for initial availability for both Xbox platforms and will likely be available on other services after a time. MS is funding it, after all.

Microsoft being behind this doesn't sit well with me for some reason. Not trying to gather a conspiracy but just doesn't sit right with me .
Why? MS is the only American console maker, just as Atari once was. I never once read that Ninty or Sony cared about or praised Atari, but influential people at Xbox have, like J Allard.
 

klaus

Member
if they dont want new theories/urban myths to begin, they should better show some close ups of a lot of boxes^^

If they are clever, they won't do that - why not let the discussion whether this is staged or not just linger on and keep the public interest awake until the documentary releases? Kinda the same thing as with a striptease - you don't show everything in the beginning, in order to stimulate the imagination and keep the interest at peak level :)
 
Look it was a myth and apparently it's been proven to be true.

We haven't seen the documentary yet.

So yes people will be skeptable.

Hopefully it will all be settled. It's cool, fun , a bit pointless imo cause its more fun as a myth, but it's entertainment and I plan to watch it.

It was more than a myth, we knew something happened but never knew the truth of it (unless you're one of those people who Scooby-Doo-knew-it-was-true all along) it was a compelling mystery as much as a myth. I think even the limited evidence of this thread is enough to nail that truth, seeing as most of us knew the assumed details and it mostly confirms them.

Cool story, but I hate seeing all that crap buried under ground. Landfills bug me ;P

Pretty much everything we've ever done is buried under our feet (except for that US vs Russian firefight on the Moon that time, and that supergroup we fired into the Sun)
 
Fanboy? I own a Wii u, ps4, and Xbox one.

If Sony did this it wouldn't sit well either. Somehow I think it would be a conflict of interest. I said i think the story is cool and interesting.

I just hope it's not exclusive Xbox one content and they put the documentary on Netflix or something so anyone could watch it.

They sponsor the documentary ... there are plenty of show exclusive to certain subscription. Should Netflix put all their show out on Hulu, Amazon etc because you don't want to subscribe to it? I am not sure what you are getting at, it still read like you are mad because it's Microsoft that finance the documentary.
 
Top Bottom