• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Legend of Zelda Mafia |OT| A Lynch to the Past

Ynnek7

Member
Finally out of work and sitting in my car while it warms up. We were pretty busy today, hopefully it will be slower later in the week when Day 2 comes around.

After reading the past few pages I'm voting for

Vote: CCS

If you aren't scum, then you're one of the most anti-town townies I've ever seen. Acohrs is looking pretty bad right now, too, with the recent voting shenanigans, but not as bad as you in my opinion.
 

Kawl_USC

Member
agreed, but what do we learn here if they flip town? how can I blame anyone voting them tomorrow.
You can't. Hence the issue with anti town play.

Odds are you don't hit scum regardless. So we can vote outside of these two, likely still not hit scum and not even have the benefit or removing anti town behavior. Or vote in this two.

Yea I'm creating a pigeonhole narrative fight me Sorian
 

*Splinter

Member
I haven't read the last three pages but it seems to be between CCS, acohrs and maybe Sophia.

Already said I wanted to vote between CCS and acohrs, and the latter seems more likely to be scum.

VOTE: acohrs
 

Ty4on

Member
Hello.
Can anyone give me a short recap ?

CCS selfvoted, said it was so people could see he was town and that they should trust him acohrs also was town.

Acohrs selfvoted to protect CCS

CCS said he didn't have any special information, just that he reads acohrs as town.

Note: CCS made a "force read" of acohrs in Pop. Basically he said something like that to cabot, got a reply which he thought meant he was right and acohrs was town. He stated this in thread and all of us thinking he had some sort of ability responded by not lynching acohrs who was scum...
 

Sorian

Banned
You can't. Hence the issue with anti town play.

Odds are you don't hit scum regardless. So we can vote outside of these two, likely still not hit scum and not even have the benefit or removing anti town behavior. Or vote in this two.

Yea I'm creating a pigeonhole narrative fight me Sorian

You are because you can just as easily look at what they did BEFORE the self-vote non-sense. If people want to think CCS was scummier before then fine but voting on reasoning since then has lower odds of hitting right if there even is a right answer, it could just as easily be they both shit themselves and that's that.
 
On the one hand, the CCS/Acohrs situation is obviously forefront, yet Sophia has the second most votes, so I'm a bit curious about the votes on her. I'm somewhat suspicious of Ty4on, but I generally town read Czar. I do not really agree with CCS voting Sophia over Acohrs though. It would have made more sense to vote Acohrs and increase the vote differential between the two. Why are you so convinced Acohrs is town?
 

franconp

Member
On the one hand, the CCS/Acohrs situation is obviously forefront, yet Sophia has the second most votes, so I'm a bit curious about the votes on her. I'm somewhat suspicious of Ty4on, but I generally town read Czar. I do not really agree with CCS voting Sophia over Acohrs though. It would have made more sense to vote Acohrs and increase the vote differential between the two. Why are you so convinced Acohrs is town?

Nope, CCS 6, acohrs 5 and Sophia 4
 

nin1000

Banned
CCS selfvoted, said it was so people could see he was town and that they should trust him acohrs also was town.

Acohrs selfvoted to protect CCS

CCS said he didn't have any special information, just that he reads acohrs as town.

Note: CCS made a "force read" of acohrs in Pop. Basically he said something like that to cabot, got a reply which he thought meant he was right and acohrs was town. He stated this in thread and all of us thinking he had some sort of ability responded by not lynching acohrs who was scum...

thats why i thought that you implied that they could be lovers.

Lets see

VOTE: acohrs
 
THREE MINUTES REMAIN

ccs (6)
melonrabbit 756
stanleypalmtree 829
kawl_usc 865
ccs 873 (991)
bronx-man 987
sophia 1007
ynnek7 1062

acohrs (5)
natiko 362 (427)
sorian 456 (516)
natiko 590
franconp 770
acohrs 889 (997)
cabot 979
sorian 1048
*splinter 1069

sophia (4)
pop-o-matic 253
czartim 364 (585)
ty4on 827
czartim 903
ccs 991

sorian (1)
ty4on 246 (547)
sophia 323 (477)
acohrs 669 (889)
acohrs 1018

melonrabbit (1)
bronx-man 251 (491)
cabot 765 (811)
czartim 774 (903)
kyanrute 931

absolutbro (1)
ccs 377 (658)
cabot 612 (765)
magnumboy20xx 664
 

Natiko

Banned
This should be clear from my posts, but no. Acohrs flip gives CCS too much room if he's scum IMO to be comfortable there.

At this point I don't think either of their flips will clear either one anymore. Especially CCS. Not sure what could clear him of all suspicion minus a town PR having extra info.
 
Nope, CCS 6, acohrs 5 and Sophia 4
Yeah, votes were coming in as I was reloading Flush's vote counter I guess.

I'm not a big fan of the triad we have going here.

Vote: CCS

I do not particularly scum read either CCS or Acohrs, but the early claim and being the first to selfvote make me dislike CCS more than Acohrs.
 

franconp

Member
THREE MINUTES REMAIN

ccs (6)
melonrabbit 756
stanleypalmtree 829
kawl_usc 865
ccs 873 (991)
bronx-man 987
sophia 1007
ynnek7 1062

acohrs (5)
natiko 362 (427)
sorian 456 (516)
natiko 590
franconp 770
acohrs 889 (997)
cabot 979
sorian 1048
*splinter 1069

sophia (4)
pop-o-matic 253
czartim 364 (585)
ty4on 827
czartim 903
ccs 991

sorian (1)
ty4on 246 (547)
sophia 323 (477)
acohrs 669 (889)
acohrs 1018

melonrabbit (1)
bronx-man 251 (491)
cabot 765 (811)
czartim 774 (903)
kyanrute 931

absolutbro (1)
ccs 377 (658)
cabot 612 (765)
magnumboy20xx 664

This an old votecount. There are several more votes on acohrs.
 

Kawl_USC

Member

If acohrs is town: "see I told you guys focusing on those two was ducking stupid, let's move on to something else"

If acohrs is scum: "no way they were w/w CCS is in the clear"

I don't think acohrs gets the same benefit of a CCS flip either way and think both are possible scum/harmful town
 
Top Bottom