I guess it is worth pointing out that the Asian Americans polled for their opinion on the film were the ones that chose to go in the first place. You have some self-selection going on there.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Deadline: Ghost in the Shell will Lose $60M+
- Thread starter kswiston
- Start date
- Status
I guess it is worth pointing out that the Asian Americans polled for their opinion on the film were the ones that chose to go in the first place. You have some self-selection going on there.
Conversations die when they become semantic debates...
Nonetheless, you're actually redefining "star power" as to "ScarJo gets paid".
Then yeah, every high profile star has "star power" in so far as they can bring in money, for themselves. But this doesn't explain what "star power" has to do with projected gross from a movie, which is the context in which this discussion is happening in the first place. People say, "ScarJo was cast because of her star power". By your definition, this translates to "ScarJo was cast because she gets paid".
PSA: ASIAN AMERICANS ARE NOT THE SAME GROUP OF PEOPLE AS MAINLANDER ASIANS. THEY HAVE DIFFERENT CULTURES, SOCIAL HISTORIES AND PRIORITIES.
Dash_Riprock
Member
You're taking a "some of my best friends are black!" defense.
MHWilliams
Member
Chris already proved that they watch for Thor, not himself. Red Dawn, Blackhat, Huntsman 2, and Rush is on the edge.
old manatee
Banned
Gentleman Jack
Member
The argument isn't being framed in terms of whether or not ScarJo inherently deserves her paycheck. She earned it regardless of the success of the film because that's how contracts work, duh.
The framing is whether or not the expenditure on big names provides consistent enough returns for the studio to justify the belief in the 'star power guarantees success' theorem. The prevailing evidence for many, many stars trends towards an answer of "No," and that the insane returns on hits that star her hinges on something else, like the brand attachment (marvel) or the quality of the entertainment (Lucy).
His bro evens it out
3N16MA's Liam joke is that all of those figures come from the Hunger Games, where he is basically supporting character eye candy. See this very serious review: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kyx1U9QjWVQ
Zoe
Member
They've already finished filming.
SolidusDave
Member
At least Hollywood/high budget ones.
I'm glad they made GitS before this realization as they would never have pumped in so much money and I get to reap the results in form of the best depicting of a cyperpunk city.
CGI everywhere haha even the road markings were animated hologram.
To be fair when he wants to be Chris can be a funny dude
His bro evens it out
Liam is great when he has a much more famous female lead carrying him to box office success.
EdibleKnife
Member
Yep. Asian Americans have been vocal about white washing on several occasions but the only ones that are listened to seemingly are the ones who aren't "outraged"
neverknowsbest
Member
For all the furor about "white-washing," the movie would have done even worse with an Asian actress instead of Johansson in the lead.
And for the record, I'm an Asian-American, and I think Johansson was a good choice for the role, and I would have gone to see the movie if the reviews hadn't been terrible.
And for the record, I'm an Asian-American, and I think Johansson was a good choice for the role, and I would have gone to see the movie if the reviews hadn't been terrible.
#givechrisachance
and my first response was strictly countering someone saying she didn't earn her paycheck. sorry if others decided to go off the rails with it. I can't really control that.
I know, I just wanted to point out Chris has more bombs than the original Civil War comic
Frozenprince
Banned
Black Republican
Member
It also wouldn't have had as high of a budget if it didn't have Scarlet Johansson though.
got it
2Smashed4U
Banned
I remember her breaking out in Lost in Translation, seemingly disappearing for a long time from anything high profile, and then randomly exploding back into prominence in the Marvel movies.
Still not sure how that happened.
TheBryanJZX90
Member
Really those numbers just mean that Asians DIDN'T like the movie at the same rate as everyone else. As a whole, no one liked the movie, because it bombed.
Vicetrailia
Member
Yeah, they fucked up on every level in this movie.
She was married to Ryan Reynolds, she had to catch Ls by osmosis
Dash_Riprock
Member
Discotheque
Banned
L? dude's the best comic book leading man now that Jackman is gone.
got it
Green Lantern was a hefty type of growing pain though. hell, OG film Deadpool was a hefty one too.
And he better hope that Deadpool train never stops. Cause the last few weeks prove Life will not find a way
Her most famous claim to fame was and still is Lost in Translation.
Chadwick Boseman will take the crown.
maybe it'll end up like Prometheus then. go back and watch and ignore the story.
And Deadpool is more annoying now than he ever was in 2010!
All hail the king
Monocle
Member
So much hostility for a movie that was average at worst.
Obviously this will make studios more risk averse. What other outcome is this likely to have, seriously?
airmangataosenai
Member
Any word on Chinese presales? I am curious if that can save it like they did xXx.
She was a bit of an art-film darling for a while between Ghost World, Lost in Translation, The Girl with the Pearl Earring, and Love Song for Bobby Long. Then she had that period where she was in a bunch of Woody Allen films, and bombed her first big action role in The Island. There were a few more small budget films in there, The Prestige, and The Spirit (Bobby Roberts' favourite movie), before she started her Marvel contract.
Massive Duck. C.M.
Banned
I honestly don't get why anyone wants a live action movie for anything like this. There's a reason something may succeed in a certain medium. I get financially why a studio might attempt it, but from a fan's point of view, why would you want it?
I know there's a live action JoJo movie coming but how would that work outside of manga and anime is beyond me. Just getting a great anime production of the manga is service enough.
I know there's a live action JoJo movie coming but how would that work outside of manga and anime is beyond me. Just getting a great anime production of the manga is service enough.
the hostility is rightfully paired with the white-washing. I'm sure that provided a direct hit on it's reception as well.
2Smashed4U
Banned
Yeah I just looked up filmography again, I forgot how many movies she was in from the mid to late 2000s.
The cast is crazy good, Coogler is top notch, Boseman was solid in Civil War.
I think they hit it out of the park.
BlueTsunami
there is joy in sucking dick
That bit about the film being a 30m art house film instead. Fuck. What could have been.
2Smashed4U
Banned
People look at comic book movies and hope anime/games can achieve a similar fate.
What people forget is beyond Marvel, who have the major backing of Disney, and The Dark Knight trilogy, a major outlier that was produced under a talented major director, comic book movies have also been trash.
BocoDragon
or, How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Realize This Assgrab is Delicious
I mean look around you. You're living in world dominated by super hero films. And my friends who grew up on comic books seem to be happier than pigs in shit. Lots of people want to see their favorite stories in world-class live action movies.
Not all of us anime fans are like "don't try, leave it as anime". I want them to try. Sometimes they'll mess it up, and sometimes they might do something spectacular with it. And maybe some of the best anime stories deserve to be shared with wider audiences. But with bombs like GITS I don't think you have to worry about the Hollywood ruining your anime for a long time...
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked