• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

COMICS!!! |OT| September 2017 | 25 Years of wearing a smile to work!

I bought each issue of Secret Empire as they released, knowing I'd want to read it before it came out on paperback, but didn't start actually reading it until yesterday.

It's not that bad! I'm certainly liking it more than I did Civil War II. I'm 4 issues in so far.
 

Aizo

Banned
My friend messaged me saying there was a sale designed to kill me. Indie Slice of Life. Oh no. Sadly (but probably a good thing), a lot of stuff in my wishlist isn't on sale.
No multiversity in the sale, the reread must wait.
I was disappointed by this.
Damn, the second half of 52 new edition isn't on sale. Tempted to look into Morrison's Batman or JLA stuff.
And this.
 

Owzers

Member
Wait, then how did you read it the first time? DID YOU SELL IT FOR LOOT BOXES?
It was back in the floppy days, I was going to buy the hardcover after selling the flops but then I didn't want to spend the money. Super cheap digital sale eventually...

I don't buy loot boxes!
 

VanWinkle

Member
There's got to be a point at which "We fucked up the trade which might sell for years and bring in new readers" becomes a bigger deal than the minor tie-in sales boost. I'm surprised we're not there yet tbh.

I think it's notable when new people come in and ask for recommendations on what to read the recommendations are always around creator runs that don't feature any (or very minimal) crossovers - Wheldon's X-men, Hawkeye etc.

That's why I personally preferred the way they did it with Batman by Snyder and Capullo. They just put out a volume with only the tie-ins and left them out of the main trades. However, they still did something dumb by giving it a volume number. So people who want to have all of the sequential volumes still had to buy that.
 

Messi

Member
It was back in the floppy days, I was going to buy the hardcover after selling the flops but then I didn't want to spend the money. Super cheap digital sale eventually...

I don't buy loot boxes!

I just passed the 1000 box mark!
 
Thought I would change things up and finally turn "one day I will try some Manga" into a reality. Deciding where to start is difficult when you don't really have tastes to build on yet, but a few names came up repeatedly when I was looking at stuff so I grabbed 20th Century Boys by Naoki Urasawa, and two one and done volumes by Inio Asano: Nijigahara Holograph, & Solanin. I'm pretty sure Ty recommended Solanin ages ago so cheers for that. Not comic related I guess, but I haven't picked anything else up lately so that's all I've got.
 
Thought I would change things up and finally turn "one day I will try some Manga" into a reality. Deciding where to start is difficult when you don't really have tastes to build on yet, but a few names came up repeatedly when I was looking at stuff so I grabbed 20th Century Boys by Naoki Urasawa, and two one and done volumes by Inio Asano: Nijigahara Holograph, & Solanin. I'm pretty sure Ty recommended Solanin ages ago so cheers for that. Not comic related I guess, but I haven't picked anything else up lately so that's all I've got.

Solanin is awesome. Couldn't really get into Nijigahara myself though.
 
Solanin is awesome. Couldn't really get into Nijigahara myself though.

Haha I realise that Solanin and Pun Pun would have been the best place to start with Asano in terms of reception but I wanted a mix of books that were a long form series and some stuff that was one and done. Maybe I'll come back with some thoughts. That one actually arrived already and at very least I can say that is one nice HC, really nice high quality thing to own. I don't think I've had a Fantagraphics published book before.
 
Haha I realise that Solanin and Pun Pun would have been the best place to start with Asano in terms of reception but I wanted a mix of books that were a long form series and some stuff that was one and done. Maybe I'll come back with some thoughts. That one actually arrived already and at very least I can say that is one nice HC, really nice high quality thing to own. I don't think I've had a Fantagraphics published book before.

FB have some of the best physical editions around. And there is so much variety too (in design and content).
 

Foofaraw

Member
Thought I would change things up and finally turn "one day I will try some Manga" into a reality. Deciding where to start is difficult when you don't really have tastes to build on yet, but a few names came up repeatedly when I was looking at stuff so I grabbed 20th Century Boys by Naoki Urasawa, and two one and done volumes by Inio Asano: Nijigahara Holograph, & Solanin. I'm pretty sure Ty recommended Solanin ages ago so cheers for that. Not comic related I guess, but I haven't picked anything else up lately so that's all I've got.

Naoki Urasawa is incredible. I read most of manga from the library, but Urasawa is worth owning. Pluto and Monster are both incredible, and the one volume I've read of 20th Century Boys show great promise.
 

dh4niel

Member
Anyone had any issues buying trades on Amazon in the UK recently? I had a third party seller and Amazon themselves revise dispatch dates. Never had that happen before.
 
FB have some of the best physical editions around. And there is so much variety too (in design and content).

I should really look at more of their output. Half the reason I grabbed these books is how bored I've got with some of the comics I'm reading. Half a dozen volumes in to the point of feeling bad about dropping off but also just not feeling it.

Naoki Urasawa is incredible. I read most of manga from the library, but Urasawa is worth owning. Pluto and Monster are both incredible, and the one volume I've read of 20th Century Boys show great promise.

Haha it was close between going for Pluto or 20th Century Boys. I first heard of Urasawa in high school when Pluto started getting published, it always seemed like a really cool thing in concept. If I like these, Pluto will be next!
 
New Bartel print:
DI-qOsxWsAM1esb.jpg:large
 

frye

Member
Haha it was close between going for Pluto or 20th Century Boys. I first heard of Urasawa in high school when Pluto started getting published, it always seemed like a really cool thing in concept. If I like these, Pluto will be next!

Oh man if you asked I'd have recommended Pluto or Monster over 20th Century Boys. The first 2/3 of 20th Century Boys is maybe one of my favourite comics ever but I don't think I've ever fallen out of love with something as quickly or as much as that
 

Foofaraw

Member
Haha it was close between going for Pluto or 20th Century Boys. I first heard of Urasawa in high school when Pluto started getting published, it always seemed like a really cool thing in concept. If I like these, Pluto will be next!

Pluto is great, you should read it even if you don't super love 20th Century Boys. I don't think I've ever been choked up by a comic so frequently.
 
Oh man if you asked I'd have recommended Pluto or Monster over 20th Century Boys. The first 2/3 of 20th Century Boys is maybe one of my favourite comics ever but I don't think I've ever fallen out of love with something as quickly or as much as that

Pluto is great, you should read it even if you don't super love 20th Century Boys. I don't think I've ever been choked up by a comic so frequently.

Thanks for the feedback guys, I'm getting the resounding thumbs up on Pluto haha. Plus, starting with 2/3 of one of Fry'e favourite comics ever with the only place to go being up doesn't sound like a bad foot to start off on :D

Honestly I didn't ask before buying because I kind of just wanted to follow my own nose on it to start off and also, I had no idea you all had opinions on this stuff haha. I wasn't even going to post I'd picked these up
 

Foofaraw

Member
Picked up the Vixen one-shot. Is she essentially Animal Man, power's wise? The art even looks like she is connecting to the Red. Also, Vixen is great!
 

Messi

Member
Oh, is that the same as your commission?

Not my commission, someone else. But yeah it's the same line art... She's very clear when getting a commission she still owns all the print rights ect

Here's the commission


Same happened to me with Takara last year at nycc he coloured my commission and made prints and made it his entire con banner lol
 
Not my commission, someone else. But yeah it's the same line art... She's very clear when getting a commission she still owns all the print rights ect

Here's the commission

Same happened to me with Takara last year at nycc he coloured my commission and made prints and made it his entire con banner lol


oh ok. Is that the norm? I would assume fans might want commissions to be unique?
 

Messi

Member
oh ok. Is that the norm? I would assume fans might want commissions to be unique?

It's not the norm but it does happen. Takara apologised the second he realised it was my commission and I told him it was no biggie. He said if I didn't like or want it he would keep it for himself as it was his favourite rogue drawing he had done (hence the banner ect). He insisted I take a print at the very least. So I took one and tbh the print is fine but it pales in comparison to the original.

Edit : jesus it's still his twitter banner lol. He really seemed like he wanted to keep it.

Print :


Original


That picture isn't doing the original any favours lol
 
Bought the Punisher by Ennis omnibus from IST. Thought about getting the Planet Hulk one, too. But I already have the original hardcover and I think that's a perfectly readable size.

Edit: oh my fuck that Ennis omnibus is 1200 pages lmaolololololbbqwtf
 

Messi

Member
You're absolutely right. And you never will.

What's your problem with Punisher back to work m8?

--

IST is disgusting. It's cheaper to buy from them ship the Harley omni and Dodson HC 1 to Ireland 30$ shipping than buying local.

It ends up being 90$ vs 140$. Disgraceful.

Edit : I can add extremity vol 1 and wicked div HC vol 2 and it's still $20 cheaper than Harleys omni and Dodson Harley locally.
 
IST is disgusting. It's cheaper to buy from them ship the Harley omni and Dodson HC 1 to Ireland 30$ shipping than buying local.

It ends up being 90$ vs 140$. Disgraceful.

Edit : I can add extremity vol 1 and wicked div HC vol 2 and it's still $20 cheaper than Harleys omni and Dodson Harley locally.

Doesn't that actually make your local comic shop disgusting?
 
Top Bottom