• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Pokemon X & Y sell more than 4 million units worldwide in first two days

liger05

Member
The game sells 4 mil in two days and people are trying to rain on the parade by comparing it to the beastly GTA V sales.
 
Huh? What? :/

Some NPD numbers (3DS(2013) vs PSP(2007))

March
PSP: 180K
3DS: 230K

April
PSP: 183K
3DS: 113K

May:
PSP 221K
3DS 114K

June
PSP: 290K
3DS: 225K

July
PSP: 214K
3DS: 150K

August
PSP: 151K
3DS: 130K

Total:
PSP: 1239K
3DS: 962K

You don't want to see DS numbers...
 

smr00

Banned
Ok I was confused because I thought Xemeas was the cooler looking one and he was saying the contrary or something.
Ok, so yeah X all the way except for that Y megamewtwo who's damn fine
Yeah i actually prefer the Y mega mewtwo look. Burly mewtwo looks like he was force fed steroids.
 

UNCMark

Banned
GTAV and Pokemon X/Y are both videogames. That's where the similarity ends, I think. But hopefully this and the 2DS will do what Diamond/Pearl and the DS Lite did for the original DS, or close to an effect.

LOL not a chance in hell. DS Lite was a brilliant redesign combined with a great line of 20 dollar casual titles. 2DS is a lousy re-design with 30-40 dollar casual titles facing direct competition from mobile devices.

Great numbers for Pokemon though given the install base. The upside is that maybe this can put the silly comparisons to GTA to bed. It never stood a chance of coming close to GTA's numbers.

The game sells 4 mil in two days and people are trying to rain on the parade by comparing it to the beastly GTA V sales.

The odd thing is that it was started by Nintendo fans.
 
Some NPD numbers (3DS(2013) vs PSP(2007))

March
PSP: 180K
3DS: 230K

April
PSP: 183K
3DS: 113K

May:
PSP 221K
3DS 114K

June
PSP: 290K
3DS: 225K

July
PSP: 214K
3DS: 150K

August
PSP: 151K
3DS: 130K

Total:
PSP: 1239K
3DS: 962K

You don't want to see DS numbers...


Just curious, any reason why you left out Jan and Feb?
 
Just curious, any reason why you left out Jan and Feb?

Copied the chart from latest NPD thread and it seems it didn't have january or february numbers. Don't know the reason though. Still 3DS is in no way in any beast mode. Yes it's not dying like Vita but it's not doing that well either. Pokemon will obviously help a bit.
 
LOL not a chance in hell. DS Lite was a brilliant redesign combined with a great line of 20 dollar casual titles. 2DS is a lousy re-design with 30-40 dollar casual titles facing direct competition from mobile devices.

Great numbers for Pokemon though given the install base. The upside is that maybe this can put the silly comparisons to GTA to bed. It never stood a chance of coming close to GTA's numbers.

You only have to look around to see that the 2DS is getting way better reception than it did at first. And you are not the mass market it's designed to appeal to. I'm not being so naive as to state it'll do as good/better than Diamond/DS Lite, but it may have a similar effect.
 
Copied the chart from latest NPD thread and it seems it didn't have january or february numbers. Don't know the reason though. Still 3DS is in no way in any beast mode. Yes it's not dying like Vita but it's not doing that well either. Pokemon will obviously help a bit.

In Japan it is in beast mode. Of course that doesn't tell the full picture since it's doing relatively mediocre elsewhere, but an NPD chart also doesn't.
 
In Japan it is in beast mode. Of course that doesn't tell the full picture since it's doing relatively mediocre elsewhere, but an NPD chart also doesn't.

Well yeah in Japan it's obviously in a beast mode (not in a god mode like DS though lol) but in the west sales have been quite disappointing.
 

DrWong

Member
Exhibit A:

Debunked.

One guy asked if it was possible/conceivable for X/Y to do better than GTA V. He was just wondering you know.

But war contaminates everything.

Who are they though? I'm skimming through the thread that Nirolak posted (http://67.227.255.239/forum/showthread.php?t=694283)

So far I've seen no-one seriously thinking that it will be anywhere near GTA V's day 1 sales, besides the OP (who in fairness is posing it as a question - and later admitting it was pretty dumb).

There are some (I've seen two or three) who say that it's possible that the LTD could be larger though. That's btw also an extremely unlikely/impossible scenario for me.

99 % of the replies seems to be "lol no" to me, and rightly so.

People? As in many? Because all I ever saw was that one poster who decided to make a thread and then later edited the OP to reflect the error of his ways. There was never a chance it would sell more than GTAV and it never was up for debate. Laughing at extremely uninformed people isn't my thing. Because it's not even up to faith if you would believe something as outrageous as that.
 

Ban Puncher

Member
Pokemon X/Y didn't outsell GTAV?


gj4tz.gif
 
Went through the threads. There's quite a few people who thought that Pokemon's LTD could surpass GTAV's. To them I say, it won't even beat GTAV's first week of sales.
 

Yanikun

Banned
I hope Pocket Monsters Ex and Why along with the 2DS will indeed improve 3DS sales in Western regions. I'm not having as much of a problem with sales as I did some time ago though, because back then the lack of interest from third-party publishers was glaring, but then I realized the eShop is getting a healthy number of quality third-party exclusives that would have been full price last gen. VD-dev didn't have to rely on Ubisoft to make their game this time around.

We can see the shift really well, in that in 2011, VD-dev made Driver Renegade, Renegade Kid made Face Racers: Photo Finish and Shin'en made Nano Assault at retail, and now they all turned to the eShop.

I'm still hoping we'll get some good efforts like Need for Speed, Call of Duty or Assassin's Creed if the install base grows significantly, but the situation isn't as bad as it looks on retail shelves.
 
Great numbers, the overall numbers for the holidays should be interesting to see as well. Pokemon is a game that, while it does have a good launch, continues to sell essentially throughout the entire handheld's lifetime. Especially in this first holiday season it'll probably be the go to gift for kids of a 2DS + Pokemon.
 

Celine

Member
In Japan it is in beast mode. Of course that doesn't tell the full picture since it's doing relatively mediocre elsewhere, but an NPD chart also doesn't.
It's doing relatively fine in France IMO.

First Half 2013 YTD + LTD
Rank Plat. YTD LTD
1 3DS 237.950 1.928.838
2 PS3 198.158 4.561.277
3 360 92.405 3.133.692
4 WII 62.470 6.161.310
5 PSP 46.467 3.396.999
6 WiU 38.927 149.434
7 PSV 34.592 233.309

But yeah in general 3DS western sales were disappointing.
 

UNCMark

Banned
Debunked.

The fact remains these comments about GTA5 aren't just coming from nowhere. I'm not saying they're good. I believe the comment I made is that now hopefully they can stop since the entire premise of Pokemon coming anywhere near GTA5 was dumb to begin with. Posting a thread comparing launch lines was just inviting the "haha told you so" responses when the numbers for both were finally released.
 
Went through the threads. There's quite a few people who thought that Pokemon's LTD could surpass GTAV's. To them I say, it won't even beat GTAV's first week of sales.

Yeah but in that thread you said Pokemon's LTD won't beat GTAV's first day sales so glad to see you're moving the goal posts again in light of the recent news. You pulled that shit with Monster Hunter 4 too. So amusing.
 
Great!

Never said it would outsell GTA, but did say it could match it or at least come close down the line, maybe continue to sell as the 3DS/2DS install base grows.
 
Yeah but in that thread you said Pokemon's LTD won't beat GTAV's first day sales so glad to see you're moving the goal posts again in light of the recent news. You pulled that shit with Monster Hunter 4 too. So amusing.

That's because I thought it sold 17M day one. It could still be true though. I don't see how Pokemon can get much more than 11.5M these days.
 
That's because I thought it sold 17M day one. It could still be true though. I don't see how Pokemon can get much more than 11.5M these days.
New generation Pokemon have all sold more than 11.5m, and even remakes of mainline games have (both FR/LG and HG/SS), so I have no idea what you're on about.
 

DrWong

Member
The fact remains these comments about GTA5 aren't just coming from nowhere. I'm not saying they're good. I believe the comment I made is that now hopefully they can stop since the entire premise of Pokemon coming anywhere near GTA5 was dumb to begin with. Posting a thread comparing launch lines was just inviting the "haha told you so" responses when the numbers for both were finally released.

I didn't see anybody here saying this and the few poor souls who said such things in the other thread were, well, in the other thread where most (like 90%) knew it wasn't possible. So what are you fighting for here?
 
I didn't see anybody here saying this and the few poor souls who said such things in the other thread were, well, in the other thread where most (like 90%) knew it wasn't possible. So what are you fighting for here?
Console wars are serious business
 

Lambtron

Unconfirmed Member
My wife and I went out at midnight to get the game on 10/12. I've put 12 hours into it since then and I've been up until like 4 am playing it every night. It's really great and I'm glad it's getting such good sales.
 

Yanikun

Banned
It's doing relatively fine in France IMO.

First Half 2013 YTD + LTD
Rank Plat. YTD LTD
1 3DS 237.950 1.928.838
2 PS3 198.158 4.561.277
3 360 92.405 3.133.692
4 WII 62.470 6.161.310
5 PSP 46.467 3.396.999
6 WiU 38.927 149.434
7 PSV 34.592 233.309

522836_large.jpg
 

MIlky1985

Banned
ANECDOTAL EVIDENCE TIME: Walking round Uni today, StreetPassed 7 people all playing X or Y. I've barely got more than two in a day before now. Which leads me to ask, where the hell is the StreetPass function in this game?

I believe they are classed as passersby in the PSS system along with all the other passerby's you get for connecting to the internet. While not connected to the net in my office i saw one passerby so i assume that's where it came from, I sent him a free heal of his lead Pokemon to be nice.

Reading all the NPD figures above, since when is nearly 1 million in 6 months a BAD thing like people seem to be saying? Nearly 1 million ignoring the new year sales and post Xmas months for no apparent reason as well.
 

UNCMark

Banned
I didn't see anybody here saying this and the few poor souls who said such things in the other thread were, well, in the other thread where most (like 90%) knew it wasn't possible. So what are you fighting for here?

Fighting for? This is the quote that got your knickers in a twist:

Great numbers for Pokemon though given the install base. The upside is that maybe this can put the silly comparisons to GTA to bed. It never stood a chance of coming close to GTA's numbers.

The fact that you took those as fighting words says more about you than me. In case it wasn't clear to you what my innocuous post meant: Great numbers for Pokemon. Really great. I contributed to it by buying X. The threads comparing sales and launch lines were begging for comparisons between the two, and I hope now those can stop. They were misguided and only served to lessen the much deserved Pokemon hype.

If that's looking for a fight, then wow.
 
Top Bottom