Support NeoGAF

[BlackBuzzard]

I WASNT EVEN DRUNK THIS TIME

I SUCK AT MAFIA IM NEVER PLAYING AGAIN

Same here im done. I suspected you the entire game atleast im not on the last bandwagon.

 

[Haly]

Golfclap

 

[TheExodu5]

I'll go on the record and say I wanted to NK Swamped from the start. Damn you Swamped! Never had you pegged as the neutral. Well played.

 

[hey_monkey]

ALAS, POOR TOWN

 

[cabot]

I WASNT EVEN DRUNK THIS TIME

I SUCK AT MAFIA IM NEVER PLAYING AGAIN

Same here im done. I suspected you the entire game atleast im not on the last bandwagon.

You're both good players.


You're going to be wrong as Town, a lot. I am mostly wrong, it doesn't stop me.


Please keep playing.

 

[Natiko]

The town losses just keep piling up lol GG scum!

 

[Kevyt]

Am I a good player too Cabot-Senpai??

 

[BlackBuzzard]

You're both good players.


You're going to be wrong as Town, a lot. I am mostly wrong, it doesn't stop me.


Please keep playing.

If i do play again your my day 1 lynch vote just as policy.

 

[cabot]

If i do play again your my day 1 lynch vote just as policy.

Now that's just wrong.

 

[SkyOdin]

Now that's just wrong.

I don't know, I can support BB's decision.

 

[BlackBuzzard]

I don't know, I can support BB's decision.

Sky hold me

 

[WhereAreMahDragonz]

You're both good players.


You're going to be wrong as Town, a lot. I am mostly wrong, it doesn't stop me.


Please keep playing.

Nah I'm just being dramatic I'm definitely gonna keep playing, I love this game and the community. I am gonna take some time off to work on my own game though


Great game to all! I had a lot of fun this time and the RP aspect gave me a few IRL chuckles.

If I had to offer one piece of feedback...I can't help but feel like town is always significantly underpowered. Yeah we get protective roles, but scum was stacked this game. They had a cop, strongman, and a bunch of other good roles. Town had no investigative, really, and had no way to confirm townies. It doesn't just happen here, though. It's prevalent in other games, as well.

^.^

 

[cabot]

I don't know, I can support BB's decision.

you seek so much vengeance. I can't even blame you.

 

[SkyOdin]

Sky hold me

Don't feel bad, you lasted a lot longer than I did. Wrong reads happen. I was trusting the wrong people and doubting the wrong people Day 1 too.

 

[Burbeting]

I don't like roles that perfectly clear town members. It makes the game too swingy.

 

[oreomunsta]

Good game everyone!

Enjoyed this a lot

 

[Dusk Soldier]

Scum MVP: Dusk.

Round of applause!

We definitely had a lot of luck on our side...but town really should have picked up on the fact that we were killing off the most vocal players. We were able to drive the conversation a little too well.

Oh, and hatmoza was a clever bastard...had a pretty awesome gossip gambit. I have to admit, the offer was tempting.

I feel like i played my role perfectly the first 3 days, but then fucked it up D4.

 

[cabot]

If I had to offer one piece of feedback...I can't help but feel like town is always significantly underpowered. Yeah we get protective roles, but scum was stacked this game. They had a cop, strongman, and a bunch of other good roles. Town had no investigative, really, and had no way to confirm townies. It doesn't just happen here, though. It's prevalent in other games, as well.

^.^

I don't like roles that perfectly clear town members. It makes the game too swingy.

I agree with Bear. If I'm moderating, It's unlikely you'll find a normal cop. I think they're too easy.

I want this community to get better at reading what is scum and what is Town based on playstyles and instincts.

I have a game in the pipeline, so that's all I will say.

 

[WhereAreMahDragonz]

I don't like roles that perfectly clear town members. It makes the game too swingy.

In this instance I feel it was too much. Just look at your scum roster: a cop, a strongman, a ninja, a vote preventer, and whatever Blarg was. Town didn't have nearly as many powers that could influence the game as much as the scum team could.

I'm only saying this not as a butthurt townie who lost, but the endgame is usually reserved for feedback, and I'm trying to give that as best I can without sounding rude. Sorry if I am, that's not my intent at all.

 

[Dusk Soldier]

Nah I'm just being dramatic I'm definitely gonna keep playing, I love this game and the community. I am gonna take some time off to work on my own game though


Great game to all! I had a lot of fun this time and the RP aspect gave me a few IRL chuckles.

If I had to offer one piece of feedback...I can't help but feel like town is always significantly underpowered. Yeah we get protective roles, but scum was stacked this game. They had a cop, strongman, and a bunch of other good roles. Town had no investigative, really, and had no way to confirm townies. It doesn't just happen here, though. It's prevalent in other games, as well.

^.^

Yeah to be honest, too many games have ended with the scum team getting to LYLO with full team intact.

 

[cabot]

In this instance I feel it was too much. Just look at your scum roster: a cop, a strongman, a ninja, a vote preventer, and whatever Blarg was. Town didn't have nearly as many powers that could influence the game as much as the scum team could.

I'm only saying this not as a butthurt townie who lost, but the endgame is usually reserved for feedback, and I'm trying to give that as best I can without sounding rude. Sorry if I am, that's not my intent at all.

Well kyan did block the strongman shot we had.

 

[Burbeting]

All Feedback is appreciated, of course ^.^

 

[TheExodu5]

I feel like i played my role perfectly the first 3 days, but then fucked it up D4.

Your gambit was fine...it got things moving and forced votes. But I do think you should have fessed up sooner.

Kyan blocked our kill N2 and his role claim should have led you to believe him. You pushed a bit too hard there.

 

[WhereAreMahDragonz]

Well kyan did block the strongman shot we had.

That's about all town was able to do, though. We had no "take the fight to them" roles other than a vig, which turned out well, but it wasn't enough.

 

[TheExodu5]

The roles were not the reason for the town loss though. Scum was simply never under any lynch pressure all game. Not once was one of our players under threat.

I even pointed it out several times: votes were never swinging. This was an indication that scum is happy with the votes.

Problem was there was a lot of scummy behavior from some townsfolk and it was easy for us to paint them as lynch targets. E.g. rac's votes, palmer's tunelling on monkey, or squidy's refusal to claim harem.

 

[Ourobolus]

Town pretty much tunneled their way to a loss. So many of the suspicions stemmed from "I think this guy is scum, let me find reasons to back that up" instead of "hey this guy did something scummy, let me look into that."

It's ok to change your mind and reconsider your accusations. Scum wants you to be focused on someone to a fault.

 

[squidyj]

i want to give a big round of applause to dusk, cewyn, and dragonz.
your honorary scum badges should be coming in the mail.

 

[BlackBuzzard]

i want to give a big round of applause to dusk, cewyn, and dragonz.
your honorary scum badges should be coming in the mail.

 

[squidyj]

also every time i go afk. every fucking time.

 

[BlackBuzzard]

also every time i go afk. every fucking time.

What could you have done? Your vote wasnt on Rac.

 

[squidyj]

i could have pointed and made a disapproving face. I lost that opportunity.

 

[WhereAreMahDragonz]

i want to give a big round of applause to dusk, cewyn, and dragonz.
your honorary scum badges should be coming in the mail.

as if you didn't do anything scummy

 

[BlackBuzzard]

i could have pointed and made a disapproving face. I lost that opportunity.

True i was watching the thread but the one time im in the middle of a Hearthstone game shit goes down. Lets just point fingers at Cewyn and make ourselves feel better.

 

[Burbeting]

You should have listened when Palmer was screaming about Bowlie .

 

[BlackBuzzard]

You should have listened when Palmer was screaming about Bowlie .

The Corgi was right

 

[rac]

was asleep when the final votes came in

feel like i fucked up the game sorry

 

[squidyj]

scum seems to have a lot of PR there, doesn't matter because the better team won, Cabot in particular. He put in the effort for the win. I mean by the end he was either the worst town leader ever or scum but still.

 

[squidyj]

was asleep when the final votes came in

feel like i fucked up the game sorry

nah you did alright.

 

[BlackBuzzard]

was asleep when the final votes came in

feel like i fucked up the game sorry

I believed you man there there.

 

[squidyj]

So the funny thing is Day 1 I thought Haly was scum but I was trying not to abuse the poor corgi.

#regrets.

 

[Dusk Soldier]

The roles were not the reason for the town loss though. Scum was simply never under any lynch pressure all game. Not once was one of our players under threat.

I even pointed it out several times: votes were never swinging. This was an indication that scum is happy with the votes.

Problem was there was a lot of scummy behavior from some townsfolk and it was easy for us to paint them as lynch targets. E.g. rac's votes, palmer's tunelling on monkey, or squidy's refusal to claim harem.

I agree with you in principle, but sometimes you have to take your player base's meta in mind when you're​ balancing the game.

i want to give a big round of applause to dusk, cewyn, and dragonz.
your honorary scum badges should be coming in the mail.

Yup. Lol. Everyone's fault but ​yours.

 

[squidyj]

I agree with you in principle, but sometimes you have to take your player base's meta in mind when you're​ balancing the game.


Yup. Lol. Everyone's fault but ​yours.

I only listed 3 names, not the entire town team.

 

[WhereAreMahDragonz]

I only listed 3 names, not the entire town team.

and how is that any fucking better?

 

[squidyj]

and how is that any fucking better?

because I'm as responsible for the town loss as the names I didn't list. perhaps a little moreso.

 

[WhereAreMahDragonz]

because I'm as responsible for the town loss as the names I didn't list.

so the people you listed are somehow more responsible for a town loss? grow the fuck up dude, this is some petty high school level bullshit

 

[BlackBuzzard]

Lets just be honest

By everyone in town(cept Sky) no need to start pointing fingers on who messed up more.

 

[Natiko]

I think we need a parent to intervene.

 

[Ourobolus]

Chill the fuck out people.

It was a team effort, and it took every townie, working together, to fuck this up.

 

[RetroMG]

Children, play nicely, please.

 

[OceanicAir]

I feel like the games that I've played with cops haven't really done a whole to break the game although they tend to go out in a spectacular blaze of useless glory (SW and DR3).

Even still, not only do people have to investigate, they also need to not get lynched/NK long to release useful info that's not even including the fact that they still need to be believed by the rest of town, along with concerns about millers/godfathers. Although those could be considered to be more bastard. But I don't really remember seeing a cop swing a game here.