No, not to me. To the average woman. All girlgaffers have said that. Most guys have said their female friends think the same.
If that's not a good sample to talk about what women on average think (which is what the thread title is asking), then why bother making threads asking women their opinion?
When people bring up bodybuilders here they talk about the extreme examples. Because that's what the thread is asking about.
Small subset (all girlGaffers in this thead and some anecdotal friends) and you don't speak for the average female. But let's play this game as pertaining to the domain that has been reliably set: people on NeoGAF's opinion.
Would you agree that extreme bodybuilders are relatively healthy? We know women that can be classified as anorexic are not.
Women are naturally inclined toward powerful/strong men based on natural imperatives. Bodybuilding is conducive to that end.
Men are attracted to healthy sized women for the same reason, which anorexic women do not satisfy.
These are extremes of course (I mean, if you
must point to Coleman as the example of extremely muscular then you would probably need to counter with an extreme case of anorexia, which is truly frightening shit) and any answers are not really useful outside of a thought experiment, and some social commentary.
According to some men in this thread, all you need to do for FC Pitt is not eat.
Unlike your "average women" spokeperson, kwhit does not speak for the glut of the population of his gender.