Lafiel said:
I just watched the finale and i agree with everything you said. The lack of continuity is my prime complaint about the show at this point. (and it's the main reason why the show will never ever compare to AD) They are certain episodes that show growth in the characters, but they seem to be largely ignored in favor of zany antics, like most of the second half of season 1.
I like that about the show. Not that I object to plot development and character growth, but I'd much rather see it occur along less typical paths, a la AD. Señor Chang's story arc, Abed's social eccentricities, Pierce's attempts to reconnect with a culture that left him behind...these themes were dramatic without becoming clichéd, and managed to be extremely meaningful without having to sacrifice laughs for those tired old 'but let's be serious for a minute' sitcom moments. Community has had many moments that were surprisingly profound, but they never come at the expense of mood, pacing or humour.
I hate the way that almost every sitcom - no matter how off-the-wall - shoehorns in elements of trite romantic comedy, as if it needs the occasional hit of chick-flick in order to keep going. 30 Rock's worst moments are the serious parts, and in my opinion they're the show's only major weakness. Sometimes they're integrated successfully, but they're generally a series of wild emotional and stylistic departures from the the rest of the show. This is one of the many reasons I love AD, Seinfeld, Curb, and Sunny; and one of my favourite things about Community is the fact that its small incursions into rom-com territory are almost always short-lived and ultimately irrelevant to the tone of the show and the meat of its plot. As others have said, you can do great relationship comedy without getting bogged down in the same old schtick.