-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Quarantine Mafia |OT| The Contagion is spreading.
- Thread starter Dusk Soldier
- Start date
Seems like a bad play considering we have no idea if there is someone that can cure. If there is, based on what you just said I would guess they cannot cure someone fully converted. If that were the case they would just come back to town and tell us who all the scum players are. I'm not sure if you just goofed really bad and doomed yourself or if this is some high level gambit. Either way there's no chance I'm voting for you since your plan doesn't actually seem to hinge on you gaining the director role. It in fact seems completely unnecessary to it.
Why we NEED to make you director if you are the infected? I don't understand that. We can do all of that even if you are not the director. I'm leaning more to something like a neutral. You need the Director role to complete a condition or something.
Infected are all recruiters, so the game doesn't break. I will blind-recruit tonight, and then they will recruit, and so on. I can bail out now, but the chain of infected will continue just because of the delay in knowing who gets infected.
This day 1 itself is a bit antithetical to how the game works, too. I think I'm not really given all the info to protect the game. Likewise, I think anybody petitioning to get cured is just gonna be Infected's target (since their goal is to Infect, period). This is why I have to do this NOW before I get involved with other Infected.
Die, lol
Yeah, this is where I lay.
You are claiming in hopes of getting cured, but why do you need to be Director?
Yeah. If you can really be cured then you don't need the to be the director to be cured. I would rather we vote for someone who didn't just claim to be infected member.
I'm ok with this plan.
A) If there is someone that can "cure" Karkador, then we have a townie. If for some reason Kark had a partner(s) then we can get their names. This is insane and as a moderator I would never allow it, but still.
B) Kark is lying. If he survives until D3 I would lynch him on principle.
C) Kark has no partners, but we now have a townie that is Director and can be protected.
fucking NX
A) If there is someone that can "cure" Karkador, then we have a townie. If for some reason Kark had a partner(s) then we can get their names. This is insane and as a moderator I would never allow it, but still.
B) Kark is lying. If he survives until D3 I would lynch him on principle.
C) Kark has no partners, but we now have a townie that is Director and can be protected.
fucking NX
Higher chance of being cured, and I'm pretty sure if I'm cured I can't go back to Infected.
Ok, adding on to that, yeah - I misnderstood his Director/healing claim.
I'm a little wary of this now. Kark has done ridiculous gambits before, and while I'm not sure I doubt his Infected claim (because I can see absolutely ZERO reason to do this as Town), this is interesting.
My vote is to make someone else Director and then heal Kark. Or the Director. One of those two.
If Kark is telling the truth we don't have a say in who scum "targets," so why not roll the dice.
I'm a little wary of this now. Kark has done ridiculous gambits before, and while I'm not sure I doubt his Infected claim (because I can see absolutely ZERO reason to do this as Town), this is interesting.
My vote is to make someone else Director and then heal Kark. Or the Director. One of those two.
If Kark is telling the truth we don't have a say in who scum "targets," so why not roll the dice.
This is something I can't believe. If all the infected are recruiters the game ends by night 4 and it would be really broken. I think you are lying but still don't know what you gain with that. Why the bold claim.
"we" as in "scum." Yes, I know that looks scummy. Get over it.
A) We do not know if someone can be cured or at what level they can be cured. Also, why would we not just give it to someone else who in this hypothetical situation is most likely already town as Kark just claimed lone scum? If they were ever flipped they could still then be cured.
B) How does giving him the director role help us in any way given this? You yourself argued you wanted to give it to someone that could be analytical and make good moves for town early on. Giving it to scum seems like the complete opposite of that.
C) How did he get to a townie in this situation? Isn't this just A except you assumed he would be cured?
What even am I reading? Definitely not voting for Kark or Ouro at this point lol
A) I am making an assumption here about "curing." Obviously I don't know on D1 how it works.
B) Kark, if Town, I think can be a good asset.
C) My assumption here was that he became Town after being "cured," if that is a thing.
I suppose so, since they'll join the chat. I guess that makes a limited window of opportunity for getting cured
It makes that Level 2 infected being cured later in the game would more or less break the game. They could out most of the other infected then.
This is a bullshit plan, if you are Level 2 already.
If what you are saying it's true the game would be over in 2 weeks. If the infected grow exponentially that would be that the game is unwinnable by night 3:
Night 1 you infect someone else so 2 scum.
Night 2 both infect 2 more so 4 scum.
Night 3 there would be 8 scum and game over as there is no way to win.
If that's true it would be really easy to the infected to win the game, so why the risk to make the claim. You could win really easily without claiming in a couple of nights.
I started "feral" and Cabot died. Tonight I'll be Level 2 and that's when I randomly recruit
yet you say you can be cured?
So that means by the time you hope to be cured, you are already Level 2. Aka. uncurable, unless Dusk designed a game broken from start.
Tell me why we shouldn't lynch you tomorrow, again?
B) So you think Kark, who you do not know can become Town and currently have been told by Kark himself is not Town is the best choice for us today? Over anyone else?
I don't recall ever saying that. I just said I have no interest in voting for either of you. Regardless of which if either of you is telling the truth both of you have shown enough for me to not put my trust there.
I don't think it's gonna be that easy. I suspect there's gonna be a lot of turn-around in Infected. If I'm gonna die anyway, I'm trying to use this small opportunity to switch sides.
This is a good point. What's the reason for you to switch off to town Kark when being infected according to you sounds pretty good for a win con.
well, then I doubt there's a way to cure during the day.
No, before the next day starts
I'm saying that if Kark is running some dumbass gambit (which he has done before), but is Town, can be useful as a player. Whether he IS Town or not is up for discussion.
And if you don't want to vote for me, that's ok.
If what you are saying is true we could lose in Night 4 instead of Night 3 so, Why would you change a really easy win for a almost sure lost? I just don't see it. I think you really want the Director role and it must really pay off if you are taking such a risk move to get it.
I say we give the Director role to someone else and simply lynch Kark day 2. That would be the best outcome.
Giving Kark the Director would be the worst choice. Kark has to die as we need to read his role PM to better understand the game if he is not lying.
There's the delay in the random recruit. I don't learn who it is until the night after.
Hey, I'm not gonna start judging the game as "broken", that's ridiculous without knowing everything at play. I'm simply acting with the information I have, and making a risky play that is not too surprising from me now.
Look, what alternatives does Town have right now?
- If Town elects a Town Director, in all likelihood they will either be killed or eventually end up on Infected - especially worse later in the game, near LyLo or whatever the equivalent in this game is.
You can go with people promising a bunch of nothing with those 3 votes, or someone who is at least making himself a known quantity. You can track the status of my "curedness" by looking at the counter. If I'm not cured, Town knows they can axe me.
Similar threads
- Locked