• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Respawns Abbie Heppe: "We're not dropping the resolution" of Titanfall for launch

Status
Not open for further replies.
I still think that CBoaT mistook alpha-version textures with alpha blending effects. Maybe somebody said that those are being downgraded, which would make sense, since they are probably the main cause for framerate drops. CBoaT then mistook that for alpha-version textures since those were of low quality in the alpha test.

This would explain everything without the need for crazy conspiracy theories.

No. He was quite clear about it being textures. Even after the beta showed better image quality.
 

danwarb

Member
anyone considered that that are the SAME textures just with added effects / upscaled? It's probably not like they've remade them. Technically, the statement isn't wrong, if they just made them a higher resolution.

You mean like higher quality versions of the "same textures"? :O
 

alr1ght

bish gets all the credit :)
I still think that CBoaT mistook alpha-version textures with alpha blending effects. Maybe somebody said that those are being downgraded, which would make sense, since they are probably the main cause for framerate drops. CBoaT then mistook that for alpha-version textures since those were of low quality in the alpha test.

This would explain everything without the need for crazy conspiracy theories.

Makes sense, seeing as when the titans show up there's a bunch of fire and smoke.
 

Squire

Banned
cboat has/had a agenda to get people not to buy a XB1, I guess the bundle got to him to say crazy stuff.

I don't necessarily disagree, but nothing good will come of this.

CBOAT's the one making claims that can't be substantiated. Let's leave it at that.
 

tfur

Member
CBOAT almost never calls his/her info rumors though, they are presented as "#TRUTHFACTS" and tons of major websites write articles about those "leaks".

This particular bit of information was already discredited by both the developer (Respawn) and the public beta they released, and has now been denied a second time. If there is doubt about something and he/she doubles down on wrong information, he/she absolutely should be banned.

And yet we still have the likes.of Albert.

I guess it's okay for ms employes to come here and lie to our faces. Hiding behind ignorance and just not knowing the plans, even though being the marketing/planing director.
 

Chobel

Member
I still think that CBoaT mistook alpha-version textures with alpha blending effects. Maybe somebody said that those are being downgraded, which would make sense, since they are probably the main cause for framerate drops. CBoaT then mistook that for alpha-version textures since those were of low quality in the alpha test.

This would explain everything without the need for crazy conspiracy theories.

Doesn't explain the resolution talk.
 

Barzul

Member
lol this shit argument makes me laugh everytime I see it.

He really does not want people buying the Xbox One or wants to discourage them from doing so. I forget the thread, but someone posted a pm from cboat saying something like "if what all I've leaked doesn't stop people from buying an Xbox One, I just don't know what else to do".
 

RedAssedApe

Banned
ioDvDp4MQiYln.gif

hehe...only a flesh wound though. cboat will be back to die another day.
 
cboat has/had a agenda to get people not to buy a XB1, I guess the bundle got to him to say crazy stuff.

you can't honestly believe this.

There is not a cotton-picking person on this forum that changed their purchasing choice based on CBOAT rumours, especially as most negative things he said are things that would iron out over time regardless.

You could argue he maybe made a couple a couple people on the fence pause for a few days, but as soon as the right games were shown that flew out the window.
 

alr1ght

bish gets all the credit :)
And yet we still have the likes.of Albert.

I guess it's okay for ms employes to come here and lie to our faces. Hiding behind ignorance and just not knowing the plans, even though being the marketing/planing director.

Good point. Cboat's given years of quality information. If Cboat must die, it shouldn't be a perma.Give him a little vacation to make him check his sources more.
 

EloquentM

aka Mannny
He really does not want people buying the Xbox One. I forget the thread, but someone posted a pm from cboat saying something like "if what all I've leaked doesn't stop people from buying an Xbox One, I just don't know what else to do".

1. proof of said PM?
2. was this before or after microsoft did a 180?
 
For all we know, Titanfall on the Xbox 360 could be a farming simulator, or even look BETTER than the Xbox One version.

There hasn't been ANYTHING shown from it.

Let's be realistic and speculate...

- 30fps when inside a Titan.
- Titan models being smaller and low poly/res compared to XB1
- Large maps being shrunk compared to XB1 counterparts.
- Lots of slowdown encountered as pilots whenever you get near Titans squaring off.
 

Chobel

Member
He really does not want people buying the Xbox One. I forget the thread, but someone posted a pm from cboat saying something like "if what all I've leaked doesn't stop people from buying an Xbox One, I just don't know what else to do".

Whether he has an agenda or not, he usually doesn't bullshit us.
 

Friction

Member
I'm new here, but I've been reading about cboats exploits since the 360 days and s/he comes across as someone smart. It just bothers me that s/he would go ahead and claim something crazy as this 2 weeks before launch. Somethings afoot!
 

chadskin

Member

The Flash

Banned
He really does not want people buying the Xbox One or wants to discourage them from doing so. I forget the thread, but someone posted a pm from cboat saying something like "if what all I've leaked doesn't stop people from buying an Xbox One, I just don't know what else to do".

oh yeah. I remember that one.
 
Good point. Cboat's given years of quality information. If Cboat must die, it shouldn't be a perma.Give him a little vacation to make him check his sources more.

This. He also put his job on risk and put himself in danger by revealing top level stuff just for our consumption. I think he should be given some latitude, especially in something as inconsequential as this.
 

Kinyou

Member
then why would he double down on his prediction. it surely makes no sense. That's why I'm waiting for release until the crucifixion, and even then I think people should take his leaks with a grain of salt instead of the alternative of a perma banning.
Well just saying that all logic speaks against him on this one, which is why I'm inclined to believe Abbie about the resolution over him.
 

antitrop

Member
- Large maps being shrunk compared to XB1 counterparts.

Considering how much the game depends on its map design to allow free-flowing parkour movement, I don't think they'll chop the level sizes. It would be like porting a Tony Hawk game and decreasing the size of the levels, it just wouldn't work. It would deeply affect the balance of the game in a negative way.
 

Yagharek

Member
And yet we still have the likes.of Albert.

I guess it's okay for ms employes to come here and lie to our faces. Hiding behind ignorance and just not knowing the plans, even though being the marketing/planing director.

This. Cboat may be fed bad info or covering his arse if he has been rustled, but Microsoft have a track record for bald faced lies since Peter fucking Moore's denials of rrod.

That hasn't changed since he left either, and perhaps got worse with the drm lies last year.
 
And yet we still have the likes.of Albert.

I guess it's okay for ms employes to come here and lie to our faces. Hiding behind ignorance and just not knowing the plans, even though being the marketing/planing director.

So true. When is he gonna answer his whole not giving up 30% to Sony claim? Cause so far everything is pointing to that and more.
 

statham

Member
you can't honestly believe this.

There is not a cotton-picking person on this forum that changed their purchasing choice based on CBOAT rumours, especially as most negative things he said are things that would iron out over time regardless.

You could argue he maybe made a couple a couple people on the fence pause for a few days, but as soon as the right games were shown that flew out the window.
sorry cboat makes news articles. Yahoo has posted several of thuway tweets as articles.
 

smurfx

get some go again
man they just don't make butts like they used to. seriously though cboat shouldn't be allowed to continue posting if he continues getting things wrong.
 

ElTorro

I wanted to dominate the living room. Then I took an ESRAM in the knee.
No. He was quite clear about it being textures. Even after the beta showed better image quality.

That might be what he believes to have heard. As I said, I think it's a mistake. Things like these being caused by a simple mistake is always a more probable explanation than an explanation that goes against so much of the evidence or assumes malicious intent or a conspiracy.

I don't think someone with that many years of industry experience could get something like that mixed up. It seems like such an amateur mistake.

Not necessarily if you're not a techy.

Doesn't explain the resolution talk.

Sure, but we can look for different explanations for these different statements.
 

EloquentM

aka Mannny
He's just some random person on the internet, so sure?

you seem so blase about someone putting their career and way of life on the line for video game fans. sure him being treated like a God is completely over the top but don't act like his info is inconsequential or of little merit. you are here trying to undermine him afterall so he must be good for something.
 

PBY

Banned
you seem so blase about someone putting their career and way of life on the line for video game fans. sure him being treated like a God is completely over the top but don't act like his info is inconsequential or of little merit. you are here trying to undermine him afterall so he must be good for something.

I don't disagree, but here he's undermined himself.
 

Justified

Member
CBOAT had to kill his account because he was just appointed head of Microsoft's Devices and Studios.

Seriously though. If Titan Fall launches with Alpha textures, but need a "Day One" patch for "Stability and Visual reason" would CBOAT be redeemed?
 

Vanillalite

Ask me about the GAF Notebook
Game isn't gonna run at a smooth 60fps either then unless the "beta" code was mad old. As soon as the Titan part of Titanfall hits so does the frame rate.
 

Squire

Banned
you seem so blase about someone putting their career and way of life on the line for video game fans. sure him being treated like a God is completely over the top but don't act like his info is inconsequential or of little merit. you are here trying to undermine him afterall so he must be good for something.

I don't know him. He's nothing to me. His situation interests me, so I'm here to discuss it. But with no name, no face, no -

His well-being or career matters not to me.
 
This. He also put his job on risk and put himself in danger by revealing top level stuff just for our consumption. I think he should be given some latitude, especially in something as inconsequential as this.

No, he did not do it just for our consumption. Whatever the real reasons were, I can assure you it wasn't selfless.
 
sorry cboat makes news articles. Yahoo has posted several of thuway tweets as articles.

I stand by what I said. I see no evidence that CBOAT had any impact except give talking points for fanboys. Any reduced sales of the Xbox one can be laid at the feet of Microsofts PR, pricing and mismanaged console reveal and launch.

If you wanted a Xbox one you got one, whether you believed cboat or not.
 
Man, I hope CBOAT does not get orbital nuked.

Curious where this information stream is coming from...

sorry cboat makes news articles. Yahoo has posted several of thuway tweets as articles.

Cboat just told us everything MS said, essentially before hand.
 

EloquentM

aka Mannny
I don't disagree, but here he's undermined himself.

with what? I'll shut up when this titan fall stuff finally hits the fan but what in his 8 years of leaking has he put out there that's undermined his credibility? fyi there aren't any 100% correct leakers on this site and cboat has a better and more vast track record than any other leaker which is what got him to this point?
 

PBY

Banned
with what? I'll shut up when this titan fall stuff finally hits the fan but what in his 8 years of leaking has he put out there that's undermined his credibility? fyi there aren't any 100% correct leakers on this site and cboat has a better and more vast track record than any other leaker which is what got him to this point?

Well, he's doubled down on this Titanfall stuff, which I find pretty weird. I also wasn't a fan of the "ass storm"- vague w/o substance.

Some of the stuff he gave us was amazing though, I don't want him banned (nor is it my call obvi).
 
He really does not want people buying the Xbox One or wants to discourage them from doing so. I forget the thread, but someone posted a pm from cboat saying something like "if what all I've leaked doesn't stop people from buying an Xbox One, I just don't know what else to do".

If that is the case then why the determination ? I don't get it. The timing of the accounts TitanFall alpha textures thread right after the Forza Horizon, Crackdown leak was dodgy to say the least and smelled a bit of an agenda but why?

I actually appreciate any genuine info from any trusted source but this situation surely goes beyond console war politics ? If not it's pretty sad.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom