• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

WWE Mafia |OT| Royal Rumble Superstars of Wrestling MMXVI

Palmer_v1

Member
I mean, that's possible, but it's also selfish. Hider is an investigative role. I guess I'm not sure, but I don't think kalor would have done that. Then again, I thought he would breadcrumb something and I can't see shit in his posts either.
 

Kawl_USC

Member
3804117-1633454510-sit-u.gif


amidoinitright?

Dismissing accusations with a fluffy gif. That's a scum tell you best believe. Let's wrap it up guys. We got em.

By the by in case I do end up getting lynched today I don't think the likes of bats is scum, remember for wrong town to win all that is required is for good scum to do nothing.
 

ultron87

Member
The only thing I'm seeing from Kalor's posts as possible bread crumbs is this one:

I'm going to change my vote from Retro for now. Retro is still suspicious but some of his posts read like a frustrated town member. He'll definitely be someone to look at tomorrow. I'm going to vote for Magnum just due to most of his posts being generally one note. A lot of commenting on the current proceedings without giving their actual thoughts.

Vote: MagnumBoy20xx

Retro could always be this rock

A_Rock!.gif

Said he'd want to look into Retro tomorrow. If Retro was the literal pictured rock he'd be a good hiding spot?
 
I'm not feeling particularly good about Corn myself, though I'm weary of following the opinions of two dead Town on day 1.

The one major thing against him was his absolute certainty that squidy was lying, coupled with him wanting to lead a lynch on him for this lie which didn't make sense for scum to make.

My main worry was that Squidy was lying and trying to draw night protective roles. Which is something scum could conceivably want to do.

And if you look at today, it turns out he was lying even still. Though in this case it seems to have been done to draw scum PR.

Actually reflecting on that, why would scum target squidy with a thief power? Scum gets no use out of stealing a day cop ability. I'm more inclined to believe it was a neutralizer/vanillaizer power. Scum wouldn't want squidy using it more than once.
 

Palmer_v1

Member
Dismissing accusations with a fluffy gif. That's a scum tell you best believe. Let's wrap it up guys. We got em.

By the by in case I do end up getting lynched today I don't think the likes of bats is scum, remember for wrong town to win all that is required is for good scum to do nothing.

Oh, that was a SERIOUS Scum list? I thought you were joking, and my gif was a joke response in turn.

Me, Ultron, Matt Attack, and Scrafty. I mean, that would probably be a decent scum team, though you're quite likely a person short. I know Ultron is a good player in general. Scrafty can be very good town, but I haven't watched a game where she's scum yet. Matt Attack, I have no idea about.

I understand people have trouble reading me. After election, I learned to just ignore it for the most part and continue scum hunting. Proactive is always better than reactive. Also, to be fair, I'm probably the person most responsible for the Seath lynch. On the other hand, this really just feels like an OMGUS.

I mean Ultron? Seriously?

Where did Matt Attack come from as well? I have to admit to having a blindspot there, so I'm legitimately curious why you believe he's scum.

Scrafty is whatever. It's annoying that it doesn't seem like she's posting any differently from yesterday, and if people really want to see her flip, so be it. I'm not going to waste time on that one way or another.
 

batsnacks

Member
uh I made a good post please don't dismiss it like kawl did.

These are kawl votes in chronological order:

1.
Vote: ScraftyDevil

I'd rather use day 1 to cut through some of the confusion and murkiness brought up by these semi conflicting claim. Just because scum would have been provided fake claims doesn't mean they won't go off the reservation (cough*Darryl*cough). Neither of the two parties have inspired a great deal of confidence (yes including Retro despite the interpretation of me trying to take a bullet in his defense yesterday) so let's get two birds stoned at once.
I don't believe Squidy at all at this point but I'll switch this vote to Retro if he claims that he wants to publicly investigate Retro.
2.
Vote: RetroMG

For the check. My actual lynch vote will return to Scrafty if Squidy is a lying sack.
3.
Seeing as YN was kind enough to show how massively I botched that attempt at untying...


Vote: MagnumBoy20xx

Will return to probably change this vote tomorrow, barring oversleeping.

Kawl thinks scrafty is mafia,
votes scrafty,
votes retro and says he will switch back to scrafty,
then he votes magnum who he didn't even mention day 1.
This is not a logical read progression.
 

Kawl_USC

Member
Oh, that was a SERIOUS Scum list? I thought you were joking, and my gif was a joke response in turn.

Me, Ultron, Matt Attack, and Scrafty. I mean, that would probably be a decent scum team, though you're quite likely a person short. I know Ultron is a good player in general. Scrafty can be very good town, but I haven't watched a game where she's scum yet. Matt Attack, I have no idea about.

I understand people have trouble reading me. After election, I learned to just ignore it for the most part and continue scum hunting. Proactive is always better than reactive. Also, to be fair, I'm probably the person most responsible for the Seath lynch. On the other hand, this really just feels like an OMGUS.

I mean Ultron? Seriously?

Where did Matt Attack come from as well? I have to admit to having a blindspot there, so I'm legitimately curious why you believe he's scum.

Scrafty is whatever. It's annoying that it doesn't seem like she's posting any differently from yesterday, and if people really want to see her flip, so be it. I'm not going to waste time on that one way or another.
Ha jokes on you it was a joke list after all. Played right into my hands.
 

Kawl_USC

Member
uh I made a good post please don't dismiss it like kawl did.

These are kawl votes in chronological order:

1.

2.

3.


Kawl thinks scrafty is mafia,
votes scrafty,
votes retro and says he will switch back to scrafty,
then he votes magnum who he didn't even mention day 1.
This is not a logical read progression.
Ssssshhhh baby don't be like that. Logic ain't no thing.
 

Kawl_USC

Member
I mean if I was scum I could come up with some better reasoning, ex post facto. But I'm not so might as well be honest. Guess I don't treat day 1 with the appropriate respect. Sorry for letting town down guys.

This mess is on me.
 

batsnacks

Member
I don't think you could come up with better reasoning if you were mafia. You are mafia and you either:

didn't want to lynch your mafia mate scrafty or
you didn't care which townie, scrafty or magnum, got lynched and you were careless about which one you picked

Town votes for reasons even if they're bad or wrong reasons. You didn't have a reason to vote magnum when scrafty was who you gave the most reasons for voting and who you said you were going to vote.

Double: Kawl_USC
 
Top Bottom