• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Persona Mafia |OT| Memento Mori

N

Natiko

Banned
I don't think anyone is going for a lynch that isn't Style. Just discussing how things have unfolded so far and what that could mean as far as his role and any other potential roles.
 
S

Sophia

Member
style (6)
plop 997
exmachina64 1160
fluxwavez 1259
11037 1266
pk gaming 1274
ii-vanguard-ii 1299

starsketch (0)
flatearthpandas 1121 (1297)

franconp (0)
hyperactivity 1149 (1251)

Majority is 9

Day 2 ends in

blu_1480194000.png
 
F

FluxWaveZ

Member
flatearthpandas said:
We've got 6 on Style now, majority at 9. We've got almost a day left to talk so let's be careful.
Click to expand...

Eh. Does it matter? The only one I'd like to hear more from is Style himself, but I doubt that'd even matter much at this point.

I'd be totally fine with a turbo at this point when discussion's pretty much completely halted and when it'll stay that way until this Day's over. Unless another Townie feels like role claiming ala StarSketch.
 
E

exmachina64

Banned
I'm not necessarily disagreeing with Fran and FEP's discussion, but a far simpler explanation is that Style is a Shadow. He lied about his role, the Shadows lynched Sorian and Ty4on died because he investigated Style or another Shadow.

Sure, the convoluted theory that Style's not lying and everything happened that way (or he's a neutral PR) could be true, it's just less plausible until we lynch him and find out.

When the dust clears after Night 2, we'll have a better idea whether two or more people are being killed each night and a SK is on the loose.
 
E

exmachina64

Banned
I'll reiterate that nothing productive is happening if we don't lynch Style, he keeps saving himself, and doesn't participate in discussion -- assuming his claims are true.
 
F

franconp

Member
exmachina64 said:
I'm not necessarily disagreeing with Fran and FEP's discussion, but a far simpler explanation is that Style is a Shadow. He lied about his role, the Shadows lynched Sorian and Ty4on died because he investigated Style or another Shadow.

Sure, the convoluted theory that Style's not lying and everything happened that way (or he's a neutral PR) could be true, it's just less plausible until we lynch him and find out.

When the dust clears after Night 2, we'll have a better idea whether two or more people are being killed each night and a SK is on the loose.
Click to expand...

If Style is shadow I don't think Ty was killed by an investigation. If Style flips scum that means he was lying, even when he said that Ty wasn't an option to save. So that would mean he was following an agenda when he said that.
 
F

flatearthpandas

Member
Almost to work so can't post but will be reading. Can help a turbo along toward the end of most hours if that's what we want to do. Otherwise back at lunch if we get a topic going.
 
F

flatearthpandas

Member
franconp said:
If Style is shadow I don't think Ty was killed by an investigation. If Style flips scum that means he was lying, even when he said that Ty wasn't an option to save. So that would mean he was following an agenda when he said that.
Click to expand...
This is what I've kind of been feeling. Feel like ty was convenient. Would be inclined to expect Style to be an extra scum kill if he flips scum. The only word thing is him not being here now. If the plan was to save the extra kill n1 and give up why bother with the stuff from sorian today? Mission already accomplished.
 
F

franconp

Member
flatearthpandas said:
This is what I've kind of been feeling. Feel like ty was convenient. Would be inclined to expect Style to be an extra scum kill if he flips scum. The only word thing is him not being here now. If the plan was to save the extra kill n1 and give up why bother with the stuff from sorian today? Mission already accomplished.
Click to expand...

I find it weird that Sorian targeted Style. I still don't understand why would he. Style was either scum or a main target last night so what could Sorian gain from that. Maybe Sorian wanted to get Style's reads before he was killed, but if Style is scum maybe Sorian didn't targeted him but one of his partners. They let Style claim that was visited by Sorian to gain credit and to modify Sorian reads to their benefit.

Until Style flips we shouldn't trust anything that he said.
 
F

flatearthpandas

Member
franconp said:
I find it weird that Sorian targeted Style. I still don't understand why would he. Style was either scum or a main target last night so what could Sorian gain from that. Maybe Sorian wanted to get Style's reads before he was killed, but if Style is scum maybe Sorian didn't targeted him but one of his partners. They let Style claim that was visited by Sorian to gain credit and to modify Sorian reads to their benefit.

Until Style flips we shouldn't trust anything that he said.
Click to expand...
Yeah, it's possible. If he doesn't target Style, I think it's safe to assume it was another scum. Doesn't matter too much at this point.
 
E

exmachina64

Banned
I'm not in favor of turboing Style because I want to see who comes rushing in to vote before the deadline. I don't think the Shadows are going to rush in to save potential-teammate Style, but rather push his lynching through. Might only be one or two of them if that's what they need.

Might as well make it harder for them.

UNVOTE
 
S

Sophia

Member
franconp said:
Sophia, I don't think Hyper unvoted me. Maybe something went wrong with the script but I can't find the Unvote in that post (#1251).
Click to expand...

Ahh, I see what happened. He was using the highlight command to draw attention to his comments, and it picked up on "Unvote" because nothing else in that command was valid.

As a reminder, please do not use the highlight command for non-command related purposes. Hyper, as this was your mistake, I'm treating that unvote as valid to save myself a headache. So make sure you revote if you need to.
 
N

Natiko

Banned
I would rather hold off on the turbo but that's mainly me being selfish and preferring the day end be on Saturday.
franconp said:
If Style is shadow I don't think Ty was killed by an investigation. If Style flips scum that means he was lying, even when he said that Ty wasn't an option to save. So that would mean he was following an agenda when he said that.
Click to expand...
I'm not sure I agree with this logic. If Style flips scum everything he said about his role will be thrown out. There would have been no choice about who to save, etc. That doesn't change that Ty may still have been killed investigating someone. There's frankly too many unknowns to really say. If two Town die tonight after a Style as scum lynch then we can probably say Ty was just killed by scum outright. Even that could be argued against depending on who the two are if say one of them was suspected by several of us as being scum.
franconp said:
I find it weird that Sorian targeted Style. I still don't understand why would he. Style was either scum or a main target last night so what could Sorian gain from that. Maybe Sorian wanted to get Style's reads before he was killed, but if Style is scum maybe Sorian didn't targeted him but one of his partners. They let Style claim that was visited by Sorian to gain credit and to modify Sorian reads to their benefit.

Until Style flips we shouldn't trust anything that he said.
Click to expand...
This is a really good point though and something I hadn't considered at all. However this does bring up another point..

You were given a Town read from Sorian. He once even referred to you as co-leader of Town with him I believe. It might be entirely too convenient that you were the first to think of and suggest this possibility. Perhaps because you didn't have to think too hard to come up with it.
 
F

franconp

Member
Natiko said:
I would rather hold off on the turbo but that's mainly me being selfish and preferring the day end be on Saturday.

I'm not sure I agree with this logic. If Style flips scum everything he said about his role will be thrown out. There would have been no choice about who to save, etc. That doesn't change that Ty may still have been killed investigating someone. There's frankly too many unknowns to really say. If two Town die tonight after a Style as scum lynch then we can probably say Ty was just killed by scum outright. Even that could be argued against depending on who the two are if say one of them was suspected by several of us as being scum.

This is a really good point though and something I hadn't considered at all. However this does bring up another point..

You were given a Town read from Sorian. He once even referred to you as co-leader of Town with him I believe. It might be entirely too convenient that you were the first to think of and suggest this possibility. Perhaps because you didn't have to think too hard to come up with it.
Click to expand...

What point? That we should believe Style until he flips? It's obvious to me.
 
N

Natiko

Banned
franconp said:
What point? That we should believe Style until he flips? It's obvious to me.
Click to expand...
More that the idea of Sorian picking someone he suspected was town but was really scum and that this scum then fed the info to Style. Sorian referenced you as co-town leader. Sorian believed you were likely Town. Hyper now very much believes you are scum. It's just curious to me is all. Not enough to make me reach a conclusion but could tip the scales given enough evidence.
 
F

franconp

Member
Natiko said:
More that the idea of Sorian picking someone he suspected was town but was really scum and that this scum then fed the info to Style. Sorian referenced you as co-town leader. Sorian believed you were likely Town. Hyper now very much believes you are scum. It's just curious to me is all. Not enough to make me reach a conclusion but could tip the scales given enough evidence.
Click to expand...

Sorian was just another player. I'm more interested in who Style tried to protect if he is scum.
 
N

Natiko

Banned
franconp said:
Sorian was just another player. I'm more interested in who Style tried to protect if he is scum.
Click to expand...
Yes I get this. I'm just saying the argument could be made that Sorian may have been likely to pick you. I could have missed it but I don't recall this particular theory being discussed much so seeing it suggested by someone that had a better than average chance of being picked who has already been accused of being scum by another player gives me pause is all.
 
V

Verelios

Member
Natiko said:
Yes I get this. I'm just saying the argument could be made that Sorian may have been likely to pick you. I could have missed it but I don't recall this particular theory being discussed much so seeing it suggested by someone that had a better than average chance of being picked who has already been accused of being scum by another player gives me pause is all.
Click to expand...
I understand where you're coming from, but if I were Sorian I wouldn't pick Fran. Instead I'd pick someone liable to give me information or someone that would help consolidate my vote base, not someone that probably wouldn't do both. Chat is a very obscure power role after all.
 
N

Natiko

Banned
Verelios said:
I understand where you're coming from, but if I were Sorian I wouldn't pick Fran. Instead I'd pick someone liable to give me information or someone that would help consolidate my vote base, not someone that probably wouldn't do both. Chat is a very obscure power role after all.
Click to expand...
Yeah, I will say I don't particularly understand the benefit of such a role. The only thought I had about it was the ability to discuss opinions in private but I don't see how that would be applied super well.
 
H

Hyperactivity

Banned
Sophia said:
Ahh, I see what happened. He was using the highlight command to draw attention to his comments, and it picked up on "Unvote" because nothing else in that command was valid.

As a reminder, please do not use the highlight command for non-command related purposes. Hyper, as this was your mistake, I'm treating that unvote as valid to save myself a headache. So make sure you revote if you need to.
Click to expand...

Ah, sorry

Wish this was outer gafia, could have used another colour witgout the highlight command
 
V

Verelios

Member
Natiko said:
Yeah, I will say I don't particularly understand the benefit of such a role. The only thought I had about it was the ability to discuss opinions in private but I don't see how that would be applied super well.
Click to expand...
Yeah, it's tough to utilize. It's mostly making divisions in town though (Basketball or Soccer) to help you maybe not get lynched or shot.
 
Y

YesNOnoNOYes

Member
CURRENT VOTE TALLY:

Style (6)
plop .997
exmachina64 .1160 .1313
FluxWaveZ .1259
11037 .1266
PK Gaming .1274
II-Vanguard-II .1299
BlackBuzzard .1325

franconp (1)
Hyperactivity .1149

StarSketch (0)
flatearthpandas .1121 .1297


No active vote for Day 2:
exmachina64 (has previously voted)
flatearthpandas (has previously voted)
franconp
Matt Attack
Natiko
StarSketch
Style
Verelios
WhereAreMahDragonz
Zippedpinhead



Day 2 ends:
blu_1480194000.png

Automated vote tally here

9 votes for majority
 
V

Verelios

Member
Vote:Style

I'll probably be around by day end but setting my vote down just in case. Don't trust you Style, sorry, them's the breaks.
 
E

exmachina64

Banned
YesNOnoNOYes said:
CURRENT VOTE TALLY:

Style (5)
plop .997
exmachina64 .1160 .1313
FluxWaveZ .1259
11037 .1266
II-Vanguard-II .1299
BlackBuzzard .1325

franconp (1)
Hyperactivity .1149

StarSketch (0)
flatearthpandas .1121 .1297


No active vote for Day 2:
exmachina64 (has previously voted)
flatearthpandas (has previously voted)
franconp
Matt Attack
Natiko
PK Gaming
StarSketch
Style
Verelios
WhereAreMahDragonz
Zippedpinhead



Day 2 ends:
blu_1480194000.png

Automated vote tally here

9 votes for majority
Click to expand...

Are you sure that's correct? Sophia's previous tally has PK Gaming voting for Style, looks like Style should be at 7 now with Verelios's vote.
 
F

flatearthpandas

Member
Unless I'm here for day end, not voting today. Just to make clear where I'm at since I'm personally a vote bot in that's how I primarily hunt scum, my vote would probably be on black Buzzard if there was a point. Second in zipped or sketch but there's too much information missing. Vanguard would also be a possibility. Hopefully I'm around later to keep track. Never explained last day end but i set my alarm for the wrong day and slept through. Was content with results though.
 
N

Natiko

Banned
I'll put a vote on Style later if it won't result in a turbo but the tally is already so close I'm going to let it sit for now.

I believe I've also already stated if it wasn't for Style I would be voting for BlackBuzzard or Vanguard.
 
M

Michael F. Assbender

Banned
I still need to head back and read everything that happened yesterday evening (real time, not game time), but did Star ever say what her power role is?

If not, why not? I get that she says it's dangerous for town somehow, but if she's telling the truth about being a PR townie, she's likely going to be a target for a scum lynch at night, right? And in that case, we'd see her role PM at the beginning of day three anyway, right?

So why not just share what she's claiming to be?
 
W

WhereAreMahDragonz

Banned
flatearthpandas said:
Unless I'm here for day end, not voting today. Just to make clear where I'm at since I'm personally a vote bot in that's how I primarily hunt scum, my vote would probably be on black Buzzard if there was a point. Second in zipped or sketch but there's too much information missing. Vanguard would also be a possibility. Hopefully I'm around later to keep track. Never explained last day end but i set my alarm for the wrong day and slept through. Was content with results though.
Click to expand...

Wait why?
 
N

Natiko

Banned
plop said:
I still need to head back and read everything that happened yesterday evening (real time, not game time), but did Star ever say what her power role is?

If not, why not? I get that she says it's dangerous for town somehow, but if she's telling the truth about being a PR townie, she's likely going to be a target for a scum lynch at night, right? And in that case, we'd see her role PM at the beginning of day three anyway, right?

So why not just share what she's claiming to be?
Click to expand...
She did not, she felt it could be detrimental to Town and her odds to live. Maybe her role offers her some form of protection.
 
Z

Zippedpinhead

Member
vote: style

I'be been working on a theory, but I think all it will do is get me killed today. Day 1 when we come back I will post my theory. Style being scum doesn't impact The theory, but I do feel his Lynch is the most likely for thto day.
 
M

Michael F. Assbender

Banned
Natiko said:
She did not, she felt it could be detrimental to Town and her odds to live. Maybe her role offers her some form of protection.
Click to expand...

Yeah, I suppose.

But then how would that be detrimental to town? I know there are tons of roles that could be in the game, but the healer types I've heard of (doctor and nurse) don't hurt townies if discussed.

To be clear, I'm not fishing. She's already exposed herself (or is trying to lead town to believe she did). I'm just looking to understand, and mostly thinking out loud.
 
W

WhereAreMahDragonz

Banned
plop said:
Yeah, I suppose.

But then how would that be detrimental to town? I know there are tons of roles that could be in the game, but the healer types I've heard of (doctor and nurse) don't hurt townies if discussed.

To be clear, I'm not fishing. She's already exposed herself (or is trying to lead town to believe she did). I'm just looking to understand, and mostly thinking out loud.
Click to expand...

Because her role maybe only works if she remains anonymous? Something like a bodyguard. If scum knows who she is they will target her first and then she will be of no use to town.
 
F

FluxWaveZ

Member
plop said:
Yeah, I suppose.

But then how would that be detrimental to town? I know there are tons of roles that could be in the game, but the healer types I've heard of (doctor and nurse) don't hurt townies if discussed.

To be clear, I'm not fishing. She's already exposed herself (or is trying to lead town to believe she did). I'm just looking to understand, and mostly thinking out loud.
Click to expand...

Townies aren't the only ones reading and discussing in this thread.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Persona Collection Bundle Released on PS4, PS5, Xbox, Nintendo Switch and Steam
News
20
2K
Paltheos replied
Persona 3 Reload | Review Thread
Analysis Review Hype 2 3
107
8K
Grildon Tundy replied
Ok, let's talk about this Persona 3 scene...
Cringe
25
3K
Shut0wen replied
Persona 3 Reload launches February 2, 2024 - Pre Orders Available
News 2
89
6K
Chittagong replied
Elden Ring closed beta times/dates and 'I got a key' thread
2 3 4
192
12K
Northeastmonk replied
Top Bottom