• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

58.3% Plan To Buy A PS5 VS. 38.5% For XBX, According To IGN Poll

Which of the two do you plan on buying?

  • PS5 Only

    Votes: 309 60.2%
  • XBX Only

    Votes: 87 17.0%
  • Both

    Votes: 95 18.5%
  • Sticking To Switch

    Votes: 16 3.1%
  • Sticking To PS4/XBO

    Votes: 6 1.2%

  • Total voters
    513

yurinka

Member
I think the percentage in IGN is very skewed to the MS side, probably because IGN is from US and that market is traditionally more MS friendly than the rest of the world.

I think PS5 will continue selling more than the double of the Xbox units as PS4 did this generation. I think most of their announced selling points are their versions of already existing PS features (like PS Now, Cross Buy or Remote Play), MS bought some cool studios but nothing that can compete with the big Sony studios, since excluding Ninja Theory most of the other 'big' ones seems to target more a PC audience, and if the difference in horsepower won't be enough because in X wasn't enough and that difference was more clear, and more than the double of now. Regarding BC, I think it will be more complete in MS by supporting 360 and OG Xbox, but will be more important in PS4 due to >100M sold + PS4 exclusives.
 
I repeat, if the gap between MS and Sony is smaller next-gen than this gen it's a fail for Sony. Losing market share is never a win. Just like going from 120M+ sold with PS2 to 85m sold with PS3 is a fail.

Read the 1st 2 sentences of your post and stopped there. I highly doubt I missed out on anything interesting.

lol Nice spin. I was going to put you on ignore, but seeing the asininity of your comments changed my mind. I could use some delusional humor to get me through the quarantine.
 

Filippos

Banned
Nah. More important reasons include:
- it was cheaper
- brand loyalty built up over three previous generations
- better first party games
- marketing that recognises life outside of North America
- focus on games

Nah. Brand loyalty is not a thing. Why do people believe that? Lol if brand loyalty was a thing, then people wouldn’t have bought Xbox 360 and only bought PS3... yeah we have seen what happened.
And better first party games?

uuh, did you see the PS4 launch lineup? It was absolutely horrible. No doubt there. there were mostly indies or Desasters like the order, boring gameplay, huge bars on the screens.
Or driveclub. Remember the broken multiplayer? http://geekparty.com/broken-servers-are-not-the-only-issue-with-driveclubs-multiplayer/

People always say games games games, but it took sony 3-4 YEARS to get the exclusive catalogs for the PS4. There was NO system seller available at launch.
And I’m afraid PS5 won’t be different. The first two PS5 games we have seen don’t look promising at all.
Im hoping Sony will reveal more details.
 
Last edited:

CJY

Banned
What we can learn from these polls is that emotional attachment to a brand is stronger than facts.
The poll doesn't represent this whatsoever. Are you actually suggesting that most people should purchase XSX just because of the fact that's it's marginally more powerful? That's so damn delusional and it's interesting seeing so many Xbox fans slowly but surely coming to the realisation that TFlops don't mean jack.
 

wintersouls

Member
It is not surprising. If you read polls from forums in different countries, PS5 always comes out, almost doubling the xbox votes. Sony has done very well this generation. It has gained a loyal following, on the contrary MS has the job of winning back the players it had in the xbox 360 era. It will be hard work.
 

CJY

Banned
It is not surprising. If you read polls from forums in different countries, PS5 always comes out, almost doubling the xbox votes. Sony has done very well this generation. It has gained a loyal following, on the contrary MS has the job of winning back the players it had in the xbox 360 era. It will be hard work.
This.

When Sony had their backs against the wall, they fought and fought and eventually became sales leader with PS3.

Xbox just capitulated and are now chasing those 2 billion gamers and marginalising their staunchest supporters.
 

CJY

Banned
There are lots of us that arent bothered by any power gap and just want to play the next HZD, Spiderman, etc..
Some people seem to think there are lots who will forego being able to play Spider-Man, God of War, Horizon, Ghosts of Tsushima, Days Gone, Kojima games, Gran Turismo, Last of Us, FF7, Uncharted, VR, Dreams, Tons of Japanese exclusives and stop supporting a company they've been supporting probably for close to 2 decades because of slightly more TFlops. The delusion is real.
 
It’s a Nintendo handheld that sells like a Nintendo handheld.

Nintendo doesn’t belong in this discussion.
It's a hybrid home console and handheld. Of course it belongs in this discussion.
Power is not everything. That has been evident for the last 30 years. It seems some of you have shot term memory.

The Sega Saturn shat on PS1 in terms of power
The Gamecube and Xbox shat on the PS2 in terms of power
The Xbox 360 shat on the PS3 in terms of ease of development and arguably power as well

MS was a walking disaster with Xbox One's marketing and messaging and policy practices with a console designed for the US audience only. Coupled with the fact PS4 was cheaper with better specs it was an easy win for Sony.
 
Last edited:

RayHell

Member
Nah. Brand loyalty is not a thing. Why do people believe that? Lol if brand loyalty was a thing, then people wouldn’t have bought Xbox 360 and only bought PS3... yeah we have seen what happened.
And better first party games?

uuh, did you see the PS4 launch lineup? It was absolutely horrible. No doubt there. there were mostly indies or Desasters like the order, boring gameplay, huge bars on the screens.
Or driveclub. Remember the broken multiplayer? http://geekparty.com/broken-servers-are-not-the-only-issue-with-driveclubs-multiplayer/

People always say games games games, but it took sony 3-4 YEARS to get the exclusive catalogs for the PS4. There was NO system seller available at launch.
And I’m afraid PS5 won’t be different. The first two PS5 games we have seen don’t look promising at all.
Im hoping Sony will reveal more details.

-Brand loyality isnt a thing.
-There was NO system seller available at launch
-Sony 3-4 YEARS to get the exclusive catalogs

Are you Trump ?
 

Stuart360

Member
It's a hybrid home console and handheld. Of course it belongs in this discussion.
Power is not everything. That has been evident for the last 30 years. It seems some of you have shot term memory.

The Sega Saturn shat on PS1 in terms of power
The Gamecube and Xbox shat on the PS2 in terms of power
The Xbox 360 shat on the PS3 in terms of ease of development and arguably power as well

MS was a walking disaster with Xbox One's marketing and messaging and policy practices with a console designed for the US audience only. Coupled with the fact PS4 was cheaper with better specs it was an easy win for Sony.
Thats not true.
 
Nah. Brand loyalty is not a thing. Why do people believe that? Lol if brand loyalty was a thing, then people wouldn’t have bought Xbox 360 and only bought PS3... yeah we have seen what happened.
And better first party games?

uuh, did you see the PS4 launch lineup? It was absolutely horrible. No doubt there. there were mostly indies or Desasters like the order, boring gameplay, huge bars on the screens.
Or driveclub. Remember the broken multiplayer? http://geekparty.com/broken-servers-are-not-the-only-issue-with-driveclubs-multiplayer/

People always say games games games, but it took sony 3-4 YEARS to get the exclusive catalogs for the PS4. There was NO system seller available at launch.
And I’m afraid PS5 won’t be different. The first two PS5 games we have seen don’t look promising at all.
Im hoping Sony will reveal more details.

How can anyone believe there is no such thing as brand loyalty? It's the reason people go out and buy the new iPhone every year, when they could get an Android for half the price with, more than likely, similar features/performance. They like the brand and experience more than the extra money. Of course, brand loyalty can questioned when there is a recession and someone is asking you to pay $200 more for a console that has worse looking multiplats. There's no wonder some people switch. Still, a lot stayed because of brand loyalty, while others were won over, again, which is why the PS3 went on to beat the 360 in the end, even though it was on the market for a year less.

Everyone's launch is somewhat bare, including MS's. That's why the Big 3 always announce games that are still a 2-3 years out, to get people pumped for what's to come. Sony was also smart in padding out its lineup with indies, with their more indie friendly policies. Still, within year of launch, PS4 had Killzone:SF, Knack, Infamous:SS, FF XIV, TLOU: Remastered, Driveclub, and LBP3. Add in the indies and multiplats and there was something for everyone to play.

As for the PS5 games, they are games from small dev teams. They aren't going to blow people away graphically. Godfall still looks pretty good, though. Still, don't dismiss even those smaller games at helping flesh out the launch lineup and beyond. It's what Xbox fans this gen did when the PS4 was launching, saying indies titles didn't count/help. Didn't turn out so great, as they had to eat crow when MS reversed its indie policies to try and get more on their own system. In other words, smaller games count, too.
 
Last edited:

Stuart360

Member
Would be nice to know what is not true about my post and provide proof if possible.
Sega Saturn was more powerful but was incredibly difficult to program for so it was hard to extract the performance.
But yeah still happy to hear why its not true.
Because its not true, as the games show. It was better at 2D though, although sometimes PS1 even had the better version of a 2D game. Saturn was terrible for 3D though, which is why Sega threw in the extra chip last minute, as they knew the world was going 3D and Saturn wasnt up to the task.
 
Because its not true, as the games show. It was better at 2D though, although sometimes PS1 even had the better version of a 2D game. Saturn was terrible for 3D though, which is why Sega threw in the extra chip last minute, as they knew the world was going 3D and Saturn wasnt up to the task.
The Saturn had more processing power than PS1 but the incredibly hard nature of developing games for it meant that developers was able to extract more out of the PS1 versus the Saturn.
All you have to do is google. There is information everywhere. ts really not that hard.

Its the same with Xbox 360 vs PS3. PS3 was a nightmare to develop games for which is why 360 games looked better than PS3 games especially early on in that generation.

People really like to under estimate ease of development. This is the reason since PS3 shipped that Sony focused their efforts of designing home consoles around developer input. It's also the same reason they have double down on that focus with PS5 by designing a console to make developers happy in what they need and want in a console.
 
Last edited:

TheStruggler

Report me for trolling ND/TLoU2 threads
It's a hybrid home console and handheld. Of course it belongs in this discussion.
Power is not everything. That has been evident for the last 30 years. It seems some of you have shot term memory.

The Sega Saturn shat on PS1 in terms of power
The Gamecube and Xbox shat on the PS2 in terms of power
The Xbox 360 shat on the PS3 in terms of ease of development and arguably power as well

MS was a walking disaster with Xbox One's marketing and messaging and policy practices with a console designed for the US audience only. Coupled with the fact PS4 was cheaper with better specs it was an easy win for Sony.
THANKYOU.gif

someone much like me remembers history and that the console who had the power advantage didnt always = higher sales
 
Last edited:

replicant-

Member
I'm sticking with PC. Xbox is 100% pointless if you have a gaming PC and I doubt there will be very many PS5 exclusives this gen. I'll only consider getting the PS5 if there will be a good number of exclusives I wouldn't want to miss.

I disagree. I’ve got a X and a pretty high end PC (ryzen 3800 with 2080 Super).

I’m on the X more than the PC.
 
i think M is okay with a split ratio of 60-40 tbh.

SSD5 and a 3080 here.
I have a Ryzen 1700 + 1660 ti + 1TB nvme and I think I'll be fine

I think it's too early to have a definite call on what console will outsell the other in medium or long therm... However MS has the better communications around their launch, I suspect it will help them greatly.. Assuming their software lineup is worthwhile this time around.
 
For the moment will stay on PC/Steam.
If more PS exclusives come to Steam then its a no brainer in terms of which platform you play on. Depends on affordability too of course.

After I finish my crazy backlog I'm getting both
Nowhere near finishing my 120+ PS4 games backlog but it won't stop me from getting PS5 first and eventually Series X after the first year.

Both will be awesome machines. Just in love with the Series X form factor. Will be perfect fit for my entertainment unit.
 
Last edited:

dolabla

Member
Getting both.

I think PS5 will outsell XSX worldwide (due to bigger brand worldwide), but I think this gen will be more like 360/PS3 gen.

Shoot, I loved the 360/PS3 gen (even though Sony pooped the bed out of the gate) so I'll be pretty ecstatic if it turns out that way. Even after the disastrous start, PS3 eventually became an awesome machine.
 

replicant-

Member
I’m definitely getting both machines. My time is split between my X and Pro. Although since the X I’d say XO has taken the lion share of my time.

I do prefer Trophies over Achievement Points.
 

Ascend

Member
The poll doesn't represent this whatsoever. Are you actually suggesting that most people should purchase XSX just because of the fact that's it's marginally more powerful? That's so damn delusional and it's interesting seeing so many Xbox fans slowly but surely coming to the realisation that TFlops don't mean jack.
I didn't suggest that at all. What I am suggesting is that it is really kind of a stretch to root for the PS5 right now when we haven't really seen ANYTHING run on it. We have a spec sheet. We don't even have a picture or a design model of the console. All we know about it is the specs and the brand name.

The XSX on the other hand has already shown what can be done with it, which includes faster loading of older games, more than playable framerates at 4K, the ability to basically immediately resume games that were put on hold, and the ability to 'magically' add HDR to basically any older game. We know the BC is top notch from the start. And I'm pretty sure I forgot a few things.

How anyone can already say they are going for the PS5 is beyond me. As of now, everything we have to compare shows the PS5 is inferior. BC is inferior, specs are inferior aside from SSD speed, and the whole variable performance is a hint towards heat issues. Can it end up better? Sure. But as of now there is zero indication for this.

So I stand by my statement that these poll results show that emotional attachment to a brand is stronger than facts.
 
Last edited:

SaucyJack

Member
Nah. Brand loyalty is not a thing. Why do people believe that? Lol if brand loyalty was a thing, then people wouldn’t have bought Xbox 360 and only bought PS3... yeah we have seen what happened.
And better first party games?

uuh, did you see the PS4 launch lineup? It was absolutely horrible. No doubt there. there were mostly indies or Desasters like the order, boring gameplay, huge bars on the screens.
Or driveclub. Remember the broken multiplayer? http://geekparty.com/broken-servers-are-not-the-only-issue-with-driveclubs-multiplayer/

People always say games games games, but it took sony 3-4 YEARS to get the exclusive catalogs for the PS4. There was NO system seller available at launch.
And I’m afraid PS5 won’t be different. The first two PS5 games we have seen don’t look promising at all.
Im hoping Sony will reveal more details.

It's better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to speak and remove all doubt.
 
Last edited:
My option isn't there: Undecided. Still need more info on the consoles and games coming. But Microsoft definitely has a big opportunity to sway me over to Xbox Series X, even though I've been a Playstation console and Playstation handheld owner since the original Playstation. It's honestly all Sony's own fault as well. PS3 was peak Sony, even though the console cost a lot. At least my launch PS3 allowed me to play most of my old games and it even supported games being usable across both Sony handheld and home console, like the Playstation Classics and other titles.
Playstation 4 was great feature wise with a lot of modern technology, expanding remote play, adding streaming and recording capabilities, shareplay, PSVR and overall being a beast of a machine at launch. However, in return it gave away the idea of one machine (though to be fair, that happened during the PS3 era, but my investment into PS3 happened before that step backwards), PS Classics/crossplatform games and limited online usage.
If Microsoft under Don Mattrick had delivered a good vision for the Xbox One, I might've bought that instead of PS4. However, with only bad option for a "one machine", I obviously ended up with a PS4. I was honestly completely ready to buy whichever of the consoles were the best back in 2013 and bought the PS4. Playstation generally having a wider library also helped much, having a bigger genre production and a Japan presence. Sony generally also let more unique and niche projects live, which is something I appreciate. Also I had the Vita, so that made it much easier to buy the PS4, because I imagined I'd use remote play a lot (though it's still too unstable to be of much use).

Honestly, had they done as with Xbox 360 (having a great varied list of exclusives in the pre-Kinect era) and follow the mindset they have had under Phil Spencer with Xbox One X and now Series X, while coming up with great features for the console to make it the best "one machine" I can get. Then I'd be an Xbox owner easily.
Regarding IPs Microsoft has a lot of potential draw power in terms of exclusives. Microsoft Flight Simulator, Banjo-Kazooie, Perfect Dark, Battletoads, Age of Empires, Conker, Black & White, Lost Odyssey, Monster Truck Madness, Forza and Halo. Those are all interesting IPs I believe Microsoft owns and could take advantage of. However, establishing new IPs is also important, which is why there needs to be a balance there, otherwise sequels will often dry things up.
If Microsoft released Banjo-Threeie I'd have a hard time not buying the Xbox Series X. Only thing stronger from the Sony side would be Demon's Souls 2 or Bloodborne 2. Possibly also a new and ambitious Wild Arms. Of course, both have other IPs that have some pull, but generally a lot of their exclusives are "good, but I don't need to play it". Historically Sony has depended on japanese publishers to fill up their catalogue, along with first party production of a wide range of genres. Since most games from third party publishers tend to be released on multiple consoles nowadays, first party has become more important. Though I'd say that there's very few IPs from the console manufacturers that have a hard draw for me, outside of those mentioned.

My advice for Microsoft is get some RPG exclusives (both western style and japanese style), a third person action/adventure game, make a good Halo game and a platformer. Probably should've made a deal for a game with FromSoftware for a sci-fi horror souls game. Other than that, just trying to make deals with various developers or publishers for promising titles that would have the promise to sell consoles.
 

MayauMiao

Member
I'll go PS5 only that's for sure.

If I wanted Xbox, I would just upgrade PC, so at least I'll have a good PC gaming as well as the Xbox.
 

Kerlesly

Neo Member
Nah. More important reasons include:
- it was cheaper
- brand loyalty built up over three previous generations
- better first party games
- marketing that recognises life outside of North America
- focus on games



Correlation =/= causation

This here my friend.. Since it was anounced MS nevercared about this small country, so no support no accesories no warranty no nothing. PS4 was it and most likely will continue on like that with the next gen
 
Top Bottom