Not arguing remasters. Which is what the PS4 version of TLOU is, I have it. Can't remember who, but that person said Sony doesn't waste time and resources with last gen games because they focus only on current. Regardless of when, where, and why it was made, in my opinion it's a form of making a game multiple console compatible and accessible.
I've somewhat followed the discussion and it's about crossgen games, right?
I don't see why we suddenly should claim "anti-consumer" for standard practice. Not releasing cross-gen games at the launch of a new gen isn't something new.
The only difference this time is that MS is forced to do it and is running a "pro-consumer" narrative, while they have to release crossgen titles as they've lost about 50% of their userbase this gen.
They're also likely to lose even more, especially by not having their games ready for launch.
New gens need early adoption, that's why companies shouldn't focus on crossgen.
Whether or not it's mostly marketing is irrelevant.
People who are opposed to this can easily hold off from buying until next-gen consoles drop in price and those games go on sale.