• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Summer 2012 Anime |OT2| Of Suspended Anime Due To Olympics

Status
Not open for further replies.

madp

The Light of El Cantare
I honestly don't know what response I'm supposed to make to that. :(

Other than to say luffy is a terrible main character. ^^

Yeah, that's the gist of what I was expecting.

Fortunately it doesn't count because I inb4'd, SO THERE.
 

Jex

Member
ivMnJDRPTZ3jF.gif

I was afraid that would be your answer. 00's soundtrack is full of cheap synth, not Kenji Kawai's best work. I can see why you like it, since it's similar to Wing except with a shoestring budget.

I can't really think of that many Gundam works that actually have a good soundtrack.
 

BluWacky

Member
Right. Long weekend.

DVD in the drive. Notepad at the ready. Roses doodled around the edges
except they're not because I can't draw :(
.

Time to finish Utena, over ten years after seeing the first episode. Nine episodes to watch! (watched 30 last night).
Didn't like episode 30 that much, actually. The basketball match was a nice callback, but I'm so thoroughly spoilt for Utena by now that seeing her realise she's fallen for Akio wasn't particularly interesting.

I tried to write something yesterday about why I like episode 7 so much, but I basically got stuck after "I wuv Juri" because I couldn't actually articulate why when she's possibly the most cliched character
noble tragic lesbian
in the show.. The duel is particularly marvellous (the final section where
the camera follows Utena's sword as it skewers Juri's rose and falls through the Juri/Shiori tableau at the same time, followed by the slow descent of Juri's completely intact rose
is brilliant), but I can think of other episodes that are just as good. Might have to rethink that one.

The interview with Mamoru Hosoda in the DVD liner notes is fascinating in that the other episode directors basically tell him that he directed the episode completely differently from Ikuni's instructions for the show and it still turned out great.

icarus-daedalus said:
What could it possibly mean??

(JOKEY SPOILERS!)
Obviously that Akio likes dick, too, although we hardly need ChuChu to tell us that
.

Jexhius said:
The only joke is that I could:

fly from my location to another country and back again

or

travel around a large amount of Europe by rail

for less than it would cost me to reach Scotland (which really isn't that far away and is within the borders of my country).

Conversely, it would cost me less to fly to Scotland in October if I booked it now than it would to visit my family an hour's train journey away tonight. Ah, public transport.
 
No, it's hating bullshit abilities, annoying mannerisms, dumb running jokes, NAKAMA, plot armor, and an annoying character design.

Gomu Gomu no youre confused? Are you sure you arent talking about Usopp? Now that is an terrible ability, annoying personality and awful character design. Luffy's pretty cool and I think he has one of the best outfits for our main shonen heroes.
 
No, it's hating bullshit abilities, annoying mannerisms, dumb running jokes, NAKAMA, plot armor, and an annoying character design.

Plot armor? You might be able to make a case for later when he has to work his ass off to not die, but there's really no need for plot armor at all in what you've seen.
 

Jex

Member
Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood]: 45-46

Remember how I mentioned that the direction and pacing in this series were really improving ever since episode 30 or so? Well these two episodes are an unfortunate reminder of how the show used to be. I'll get into specifics by way of a more detailed post later but at a glance I'd say the biggest problem is how the passage of time is depicted which, incidentally, affects the pacing a great deal.
 

Envelope

sealed with a kiss
Plot armor? You might be able to make a case for later when he has to work his ass off to not die, but there's really no need for plot armor at all in what you've seen.

I'm thinking of the Krieg fight, where he was flattened countless times with an exploding spear, and wasn't affected at all.
 

AAequal

Banned
Paranoia Agent 7

The end of Utena would be a hard act for any episode of any show to follow, but I didn't enjoy this episode very much. It started diving hard into paranormal/supernatural stuff, which didn't feel very coherent a lot of the time.



Shots of radio equipment. A girl on a swing. A magic show. A shrine hidden somewhere in what looks like a sewer system. People against white backgrounds. All this stuff is part of Maniwa's dreamscape, and while it may be true to the nature of dreams, it's also hard for a viewer to follow.

Maniwa is possessed by the idea of a connection between the victims, even if it's a connection that couldn't possibly apply to a real crime. Ikari, on the other hand, continues to do his best to follow up on his present hypothesis about the Shonen Bat case. Even though Maniwa looks rather desperate and a little crazy in this episode, the way Ikari bullies witnesses to fit his narrative reflects poorly on the police, and reminds me of how Japanese cops can hold suspects for 21 days without a lawyer, and how there's a 99% conviction rate in the Japanese justice system. As especially shown by
the resignations at the end of the episode, and by Ikari ignoring Taeko's attack because she's not in his district, the cops as a whole more interested in clearing their responsibility in the case than they are at finding the true answer.



For some reason, it seems like Maniwa is getting some sort of precognition or message through his dreams, and the magic show (going through walls, being in two places at once) directly parallels what Shonen Bat does at the end of the episode. He's a supernatural force, and I suspect that pirate radio broadcast at the end will cause more chaos in the city. I wonder if the old man actually is Shonen Bat somehow.

I've heard the next episode is fantastic. The preview seems rather unusual.
Episode 8 was definitely in top three for me. Episode 8 is straight out filler but it has that certain charm that you gotta like it. After it the show went to directions that I really didn't care for. They still had some great moments but personally I liked the detective aspect of the show and it kinda stopped right after ep7.
 

Ultimadrago

Member
Paranoia Agent 7

nszwi.jpg

Eggs because eggs.

As I had pondered before, the "nice" detective has
changed his overall approach from previous encounters
since the events of the last episode. I have to say that my wish was fulfilled in a pretty underwhelming manner. On one hand, yes, Maniwa is not the man that is present to pull back Keiichi any longer. The problem is, he didn't add anything onto that (besides a devious expression on his face). The man is given a new profile and it adds nothing. He doesn't add anything interesting in his new or perverse reactions from his former ways, instead we get an obsessed man. Additionally, the surreal phases we receive didn't give me any insight or meaningful symbolism. It wasn't the feeling of confusion as much as disconnection with a character, which is a first for me in the series. I can't read what's going on and I really didn't feel it was essential.

OgOFD.png

Geezer because geezer.

On the positive side, Kon's character designs make great work with Maniwa's
obsession face and "Fake Shounen Bat"'s marks of terror.
as usual. Maniwa's search for those
"cornered."
is placing a constricting hold on his own mind. This was definitely a weaker episode, but nothing to make me fear the quality of future ones.
 

Envelope

sealed with a kiss
Q - Please tell how does Chuchu feel to touch in TV series. (reader from Kanagawa prefecture)

Enokido – That’s something I’d like to know too.

Ikuhara – No amount of words can express how wonderful it is.

All – (laugh).

AM – Even so, Utena doesn’t seem to touch Chuchu that often.

Ikuhara – No no, she touches him so much that he gets numb.

Hasegawa – To tell the truth, Chuchu kinda feels like this (this said, he slowly he takes out a certain thing).

AM – Oh, this?

Enokido – I see. This is certainly how Chuchu feels like in TV series.

Ikuhara – Yes, this feels great.

AM – I see, but what is “this” thing?

Enokido – We can’t say it in a magazine, can we?

Ikuhara – It’d be awkward if we did.

Enokido – Because there are also children reading this magazine.

Hasegawa – Those who don’t know what we’re talking about will get to know it when they grow up.


This is better than every chu chu appearance in the show so far.
 

madp

The Light of El Cantare
Q - Please tell how does Chuchu feel to touch in TV series. (reader from Kanagawa prefecture)

Enokido – That’s something I’d like to know too.

Ikuhara – No amount of words can express how wonderful it is.

All – (laugh).

AM – Even so, Utena doesn’t seem to touch Chuchu that often.

Ikuhara – No no, she touches him so much that he gets numb.

Hasegawa – To tell the truth, Chuchu kinda feels like this (this said, he slowly he takes out a certain thing).

AM – Oh, this?

Enokido – I see. This is certainly how Chuchu feels like in TV series.

Ikuhara – Yes, this feels great.

AM – I see, but what is “this” thing?

Enokido – We can’t say it in a magazine, can we?

Ikuhara – It’d be awkward if we did.

Enokido – Because there are also children reading this magazine.

Hasegawa – Those who don’t know what we’re talking about will get to know it when they grow up.

So he feels like bananas.
 

Caesnd

Member
Unicorn may well be getting there, I'll concede that.

It's not the most memorable OST ever, but I seem to recall enjoying it well enough at least.

This makes me wonder, which is/are the best OST(s) of this season? I'm not really watching a whole lot, so I'm sort of curious.
 

Jex

Member
It's not the most memorable OST ever, but I seem to recall enjoying it well enough at least.

This makes me wonder, which is/are the best OST(s) of this season? I'm not really watching a whole lot, so I'm sort of curious.

I can't really think of anything too memorable from this seasons selection of shows. Hyouka has been okay, I suppose, but technically that's just a holdover from Spring.
 

firehawk12

Subete no aware
The power of one man's belief.
The purest of waifus.

As much as I love the Gintama crew, I barely consider them sympathetic characters. And there's room for growth that just doesn't happen. In Binbougami, it took 8 episodes for Ichiko's facade to break and for her to finally start to open up. In Gintama, it took 240 episodes for Katsura and Elizabeth to develop and they STILL reset it.
Whaaa? They're extremely sympathetic and likeable. If anything, the problem comes from the fact that the end game has to be the end game, so the main cast isn't allowed to reveal their hands until the time comes. It'd be nice if they could just move on though, since the type of comedy they do mostly doesn't rely on the status-quo.
 

madp

The Light of El Cantare
I can't really think of anything too memorable from this seasons selection of shows. Hyouka has been okay, I suppose, but technically that's just a holdover from Spring.

I think we can all probably agree that Oda Nobuna no Yabou has the worst OST of the summer season, even if there's no clear best.

One would think that Rinne no Lagrange S2 would inherit the title by default due to its above-average OST in the first season, but I haven't heard a word of praise about this season's music, which must mean that it's either simply reusing old tracks or that the quality of the new tracks, like everything about S2, has unfortunately gone down.
 
It's not the most memorable OST ever, but I seem to recall enjoying it well enough at least.

This makes me wonder, which is/are the best OST(s) of this season? I'm not really watching a whole lot, so I'm sort of curious.

I particularly like the soundtracks to Binbougami ga! (Hamauzu!) and Joshiraku.
 
It's not the most memorable OST ever, but I seem to recall enjoying it well enough at least.

This makes me wonder, which is/are the best OST(s) of this season? I'm not really watching a whole lot, so I'm sort of curious.

Unicorn is quite good, though I have yet to listen to the OST by itself.

Even though it's a continuing show from the spring, Eureka Seven AO is my favorite OST out of what's airing now.
 

Jex

Member
[Fullmetal Alchemist:Brotherhood] - 45

This episode was a series of scenes involving characters from the ensemble cast at various locations performing actions that all tie directly into the main narrative. This means that the episode did not have a 'beginning, middle and end' structure. It didn't feel like anything at all, really because, while the stories were obviously tied together by the story they weren't particularly interesting or satisfying on their own terms.

Each of these scenes involved a particular character, or characters, getting into some some situation and then resolving it. The problem is that all these 'mini-episodes' that went into this episode (The Wrath Fight, The Armstrong Fight, The Movement of Intelligence, Greed & Ed, Riza & Her Friend etc etc) is they were all over extremely quickly and they didn't build on each other because they rarely involved the same characters. Two to three minutes is rarely enough time to tell an interesting story or build repoire with characters or investigate a cool idea. It just ends up feeling like a bunch of truncated sequences strung together.

Strangely enough, if they'd been really short, montage style, scenes it would have worked quite well because they would have been over and done with. However, they're too long for that but too short to be satisfying, so they're just stuck in a weird middle ground where they're ineffective.

Watching characters 'get ready to do something' can, theoretically, be interesting, but I don't think they accomplished anything interesting here.

The Wrath fight, however, was pretty great. Lots of great editing, smooth animation, powerful shading and great camera work. Good stuff!

FMAB-452.png

FMAB-451.png
 

cajunator

Banned
Chocolate 07



Sleeping hijicks.

So I guess we're back to multiple character developments everywhere. Of course it's pretty much for the girls that matter plus the teacher and the yaoi option, though I guess the cat ear girl really hasn't had much development to begin with. Though, I am glad that those many mysteries of this show are slowly getting resolved.

Cat ear girls hardly ever get much development. anime is racist against them :(


This looks like a worthy endeavor.
 
It's not the most memorable OST ever, but I seem to recall enjoying it well enough at least.

This makes me wonder, which is/are the best OST(s) of this season? I'm not really watching a whole lot, so I'm sort of curious.

Eureka Seven AO is the one Ive been listening to the most followed by the Gundam AGE v2. I like the music to Horizon on the Middle of Nowhere 2 when it plays, though I dont think theyve added more to what was introduced last season, but regardless its also a good OST this season, hope the composer does more anime, remember they did Medaka Box.

Accel World OST is also one I like too, lots of good songs. Terrible that Sword Art Online really has no standout musics. I feel like Im cheating if I say Hunter x Hunter 2011 and Phi Brain, since both havent introduced new musics, oh and Saint Seiya Omega...
 

Jex

Member
[Fullmetal Alchemist:Brotherhood] - 46

This episode had a few of the problems that plagued last weeks episode, as well as a number wholly new issuers that are unique to it. As before, the show appears to be spinning it's wheels to some degree while everyone waits for the promised day to arrive. This leads to more scenes where people talk about the coming arrival of the promised day and what it will mean for the country, which is frankly irritating because I don't need to watch people discuss the matter, I'm already aware of the consequences of this event and I just want to see what happens next in the story.

Speaking of exposition, someone really went of the deep end with this episode. For whatever reason Miles feels the need to talk about Alphone's real body, as if we'd forgotten what had happened to him. There's actually quite a few sequences like that, where the characters tell each other the plot of the show so far but it's all completely pointless for the audience because we're already aware of the plot so. This kind of conversation is not uncommon during the course of the episode:

FMAB-463.png


It's utterly pointless to sit through. I guess they felt like they really needed to stall the movement of the plot for another episode so this is the result - more talk about things we already know.

The director of this episode got very lazy with bothering to portray the flow of time, as well. Rather than work out some effective way to display, visually how the seasons have passed or how our heroes have aged he opted to just leave it like this:

FMAB-464.png

FMAB-465.png


Which isn't particularly convincing.
 
I'm thinking of the Krieg fight, where he was flattened countless times with an exploding spear, and wasn't affected at all.

It's been a while, so I would have to watch it again, but IIRC they did wear him down quite a bit. He does have more endurance than most people because he's a rubber man, but he was still bleeding a ton and stuff. He also passed out almost instantly when the fight was over.


Whaaa? They're extremely sympathetic and likeable. If anything, the problem comes from the fact that the end game has to be the end game, so the main cast isn't allowed to reveal their hands until the time comes. It'd be nice if they could just move on though, since the type of comedy they do mostly doesn't rely on the status-quo.

They're a group of asshole misfits, former/current killers, and just all around douchebags. Otae is a much more terrible person than anyone in Binbougami. As hilarious as they are, they're not good people.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom