Sure he's an ugly dude, but the framing or whatever artists call it is uninspired. We have the protagonist from the waist-up with side-characters floating beside him and bad-guys in the background, it doesn't really give us a sense of what the game is going to be about aside from 'this is an action game.' They could have shown the father with Yonah which establishes the driving force behind the game without even having to look at the blurb. Or even better, juxtapose his rugged ugliness with her childish innocence. Ugh, I need to stop talking about this game and just play it lol.Nier's cover is fine IMO. Father Nier is a hideous dude, but there's no fixing that aside from a paper bag over the face.
I think it makes him more relatable/humanized as a character. I play plenty of JRPGs and I've had my fill of bishonen protagonists.
The game itself is Best of the Generation for me.