These are my very basic impressions I posted in the OT...
So just got back. Great movie. I'll try to keep my impressions brief.
Cap and Tony were great throughout. Bucky was just kinda there. The character was important to the story and had some cool action but didn't quite grab me like he did in TWS. Panther was awesome but didn't serve any more purpose than Wonder Woman in BvS despite much more screentime in comparison. Spider-Man suffered from the same problem. Could have removed him entirely and nothing would have changed. I don't want that to take away from their presentation which was definitely welcome. Some legitimately funny dialogue and great Spidey action that would please any fan.
Which brings me 'round to Stark. His quips here fell flat a lot of the time. There was a lot of good humor but Stark was the weak link there. The audience apparently agreed with me. Very few laughs for him. Bucky and Falcon shined here but my favorites were the Ant and the Spider.
Plot was good. Villain motivation was about as predictable as it gets though. How he accomplished certain tasks were completely handwaved. Wanda may take the crown from Lois Lane for most convenient timing of a character in a CBM.
Action scenes is where the beef of this movie is and they are incredible. I was a huge detractor of the airport scenery for a big fight but that battle delivered in spades. Every other action scene paled in comparison but were pretty damn awesome in their own right.
The score. What score? I can't even remember any music playing let alone what it sounded like. Utterly worthless and that's terrible. The movie deserved so much better.
Performances were great all around. Nothing to complain about here. The conflict between Cap and Stark was done really really well.
My biggest issue I'll have to talk about in the spoiler thread. I'd have to be really really vague if I talked about it in this thread. I enjoyed the 3rd act immensely otherwise.
Overall - 8/10
I think Winter Soldier still slightly edges it out just a tad for being a tighter movie.
...but I wanted to expand on some things here in the spoiler thread.
Going to sound like I'm complaining here but keep in mind I loved the movie. These are just some areas for me I think bring it down from being perfect.
The conflict that Zemo caused between Cap and Stark was great. I have no issue with that. I was Team Cap all the way but completely understood Stark' side of things. My issue was with Zemo's motivations. While not bad exactly it was just common. As in I wish he had a better motivation outside of the same thing we hear all the time. "I lost my family." That's tragic, yes, but gimme something new. I never connected with Zemo at all so his role in the movie came off empty. That motivation worked great with Stark because I was already invested in that character since he'd been around so long. I do appreciate the connectivity between them though. Would have preferred the other Winter Soldiers to be let loose rather than killed. I was super excited for a big fight with all these tough mother fuckers but got nothing. Emphasized only further because they hyped them up a couple of times.
Spider-Man. Love love loved Spider-Man here but I absolutely believe there was a version of the script without him because he didn't matter to the plot in any way, shape or form. As I said in the impressions above he could have been removed entirely and the only difference would be the movie's runtime. Would have preferred a narrative purpose for his appearance other than filling a roster slot.
Vision was basically worthless in the airport battle. Besides the failed attempt to keep Cap and Bucky from the Quinjet, phasing through Giant-Man and accidentally shooting Rhodey down what the hell did he do? He should have been stomping Cap's team like they were punks and instead he was mostly MIA.
What the hell was that bio-weapon stuff about? Cool action scene but if the Battle of New York, the Hyrda stuff in D.C. and the destruction of Sokovia were enough to spawn this idea that the Avengers need to be kept in check that whole scenario at the beginning of the movie was unneeded fluff.
Very minor nitpick but I didn't like the location text taking up the whole screen. Bothered me for some reason.
Anyway, nothing too major. Still a great movie.