• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

CNN dives into Japan's School Girl culture, examines "the dark truth"

Status
Not open for further replies.
Fascination with Japanese schoolgirl culture hiding a darker side?
Tokyo (CNN) On a cold, rainy night in Tokyo -- Japanese schoolgirls line the streets.

Shivering in short skirts they pass out fliers for "JK" or "joshi-kosei," cafes in which adult males pay for the company of girls as young as 16.

"Most are in their 30s, 40s and 50s," says 18-year-old Honoka.

The girls, all dressed in their actual high school uniforms, earn about $8 dollars an hour to socialize and serve food and drink to men often more than twice their age.


Sometimes however, the men want more than talk.

16-year-old Eli says that customers ask the girls out on dates "all the time."
151221102429-japan-schoolgirls-ripley-1-exlarge-169.jpeg

The dark side

While some cafes, like the one in which Eli and Honoka work, strictly prohibit dating or interacting with customers outside the business, there is a much seedier and disturbing side of JK.

CNN found businesses selling school girl massages, uniforms and even supposedly "used" underwear.

Other girls are made available for dates, which the authorities and advocates for victims of sexual exploitation warn are often a barely concealed front for child rape.

"Once you're out of the shop, even by a step, you can do whatever you want," one victims' advocate told CNN.

In its most recent report on human trafficking, the U.S. State Department warned that "sophisticated and organized prostitution networks target vulnerable Japanese women and girls."

"Enjo Kosai," or "compensated dating," the report said, "continues to facilitate the prostitution of Japanese children."


An abiding sense of shame and victim-blaming within Japanese culture prevents many girls from coming forward, says Shihoko Fujiwara, director of the Lighthouse Center for Human Trafficking Victims.
151221102556-japan-schoolgirls-ripley-3-exlarge-169.jpeg

Child pornography

Japan has long had an uneasy relationship with the sexualization of children. It was only in June 2014 that the government finally outlawed the ownership of child pornography.

Activists criticized the bill for excluding anime and manga -- Japanese styled animations and comic books -- that feature child sex abuse, which industry representatives justified on the grounds of freedom of expression.

"Rich, deep culture is born from something that might not be accepted by all. We need to allow the gray zone to exist as a necessary evil," said Hiroshi Chiba, manager of manga production house Chiba Tetsuya Production. With that, he admitted that some products of the industry leave him and his colleagues "disgusted."

In one Tokyo manga store, in an area marked "adults only," CNN observed content which depicted female characters wearing school uniforms, hair clips and innocent expressions as they engaged in sometimes violent sex acts with dominant characters.


While no link has been made between anime, manga and child abuse, a 2014 White Paper issued by the Japanese National Police Agency said that the number of child abuse victims jumped 20% between 2011 and 2012.
151221102638-japan-schoolgirls-ripley-4-exlarge-169.jpeg

In October, organizations and activists fighting child pornography called on the government to do more to protect young victims and crack down on the producers and consumers of child porn.

"There is no denying that Japan remains a country tolerant of child pornography," they said in a petition signed by a number of leading NGOs, including Lighthouse.

The petition calls for the law to be revised to outlaw much of the "JK" trade, including underage massages and "walking dates."

The age of consent in Japan is 13, though individual prefectures and cities often have their own legislation governing this area, meaning it varies between 13 and 17.
Customers see no problem

Male customers at the Tokyo "JK" cafe said they didn't see anything inappropriate about the business.

One man, a married university professor in his 40s, told CNN he was doing "research on the younger generation."

He was unsure whether he'd feel comfortable having his now 12-year-old daughter work in a "JK" cafe, though he insisted that nothing inappropriate happened there.

"If (my daughter) was here, I could at least supervise her," he said.

Another man, in his 30s, said he managed a similar "JK" business and comes to the cafe CNN visited every week "because it's fun."

He acknowledged that there was a level of sexual "stigma" around the practice, but said that critics should "come just once and try it."
Click the link for full article including a video of the CNN report.
 

studyguy

Member
One man, a married university professor in his 40s, told CNN he was doing "research on the younger generation."

Right, right... for science.

Personally I don't see what there is to discuss between a middle aged man and a girl as young as 16. Like the only dudes out here looking to talk it up with someone that young have to be dudes that never talked to them at that age in the first place. Like make up for it with women at least around college if not older, at least they have interest worth discussing. But I mean, you know why you're there breh.
 

Shadybiz

Member
Now, are we CERTAIN that these girls aren't actually 10,000 year old dragons? Because then it would be okay, right???

It's awful, and I hope something is done about it.
 

The Technomancer

card-carrying scientician
"Cultural differences" only goes so far, when it comes to relations between older adults and teenagers that's a line I can't really overlook, no matter how rooted it is in Japan's "culture of youth" or how much about it is because of their depressing work culture or whatever
 

liquidtmd

Banned
It is a social issue BUT there is nothing new here.

Id counter the 'depth' of CNN's diving here is as exploitative as its content
 

maxcriden

Member
Disgusting. I want to know how common this really is in Japan, though. My understanding is that it's a seedy subculture that does not represent the predilections of most men (or women) in the country. That doesn't excuse it of course, it's still absolutely vile, I just want a better understanding of how pervasive of an issue it is.
 

kswiston

Member
"Cultural differences" only goes so far, when it comes to relations between older adults and teenagers that's a line I can't really overlook

If we are talking about adults having relationships with teenagers 16 and up, this happens pretty much everywhere (and is often legal). Everyone knew a few girls in high school who were dating guys over 25. Sometimes over 30.

The major difference is that Japan celebrates it.
 

The Technomancer

card-carrying scientician
While no link has been made between anime, manga and child abuse, a 2014 White Paper issued by the Japanese National Police Agency said that the number of child abuse victims jumped 20% between 2011 and 2012.
This is the sort of statistic that strikes me as bullshit on its face (a 20% jump in one year is basically impossible if its accurate) but I do wonder how much of an underreporting and under-prosecuting issue there's been that has skewed data historically and if that's undergoing any change
 

Aeana

Member
This really is all that needs to be said about how backwards Japan is in some areas.
Well, more needs to be said, because while that's true, the actual age of consent varies by location, and in a lot of places it's 17 or 18, like in Tokyo.

But they absolutely should raise it across the country.
 

The Technomancer

card-carrying scientician
This isn't the sort of thing you can delve into without looking at how it manifests across the culture, from idol culture to the schoolgirl cafes to, yes, entertainment media. I don't know if anyone (in the "West" at least) who's informed enough to really do a deep dive piece (or set of pieces) on that has the nerve to actually do it though
 

frontovik

Banned
Disturbing. I'm sure it's difficult to make a living in Japan, but the girls/women in this "industry" should have more/better opportunities to get out of it ASAP.
 
This isn't the sort of thing you can delve into without looking at how it manifests across the culture, from idol culture to the schoolgirl cafes to, yes, entertainment media. I don't know if anyone (in the "West" at least) who's informed enough to really do a deep dive piece (or set of pieces) on that has the nerve to actually do it though

To a lot of people Japan is something that's out of reach so protesting, challenging, or writing about it is meaningless for certain topics. Try having people question certain entertainment forms and most will be passive about it because, "I can't do anything". It's a difficult hill.
 
I'm never going to Japan

I'd love to go. Every society has a disgusting dark side. You have every reason not to go to Japan. Or anywhere else.

America has plenty of dark truths. As do Europe. Geographical positioning and customs has little to do with validity of a space on this floating rock.
 
I try to be open about a lot of things, no point making a stink about the other side of the fence 'til you actually know what's there etc.

But yea, it's gross, no other way around it. Look, if having young girls do lewd shit in manga or anime counts as artistic expression, that's fine. When real-life men try to take upskirts or fondle girls in the subway or harass them on the street, that's fucking illegal.
 

kswiston

Member
Disturbing. I'm sure it's difficult to make a living in Japan, but the girls/women in this "industry" should have more opportunities to get out of it ASAP.

They are teenagers. Jobs for teenagers tend to be minimum wage or close to it. Girls get drawn to this for the same reason that some high school students get drawn to dealing drugs. They can make a lot of money (relatively), which buys a lot of status items.

The government has the option to crack down on these sorts of cafes, but they choose to ignore it.
 

maxcriden

Member
In Japan, when you turn 25, you're already past your prime.

Unfortunately, this is what I've been told by women in Japan. That they're considered "over the hill" and less likely marriage material at that point. I've told them America is a whole different story...crazy to think at 25+ you're an "old maid."
 

Dennis

Banned
In Japan, when you turn 25, you're already past your prime.

In Japan life is something that happens when you are in high school.

What has gone before and will come after are great unknowns.

I know this because anime, manga and games have made me aware of Japanese culture (I am an expert).
 

frontovik

Banned
They are teenagers. Jobs for teenagers tend to be minimum wage or close to it. Girls get drawn to this for the same reason that some high school students get drawn to dealing drugs. They can make a lot of money (relatively), which buys a lot of status items.

The government has the option to crack down on these sorts of cafes, but they choose to ignore it.

That makes sense. Unfortunately, I'm sure the government would only intervene if the industry gets increased media or international scrutiny, or if something perversely grotesque makes the major headlines.
 

Infinite

Member
To a lot of people Japan is something that's out of reach so protesting, challenging, or writing about it is meaningless for certain topics. Try having people question certain entertainment forms and most will be passive about it because, "I can't do anything". It's a difficult hill.

That's interesting because I see a lot of "what's up/wrong with wacky Japan" articles from western media
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
This is the sort of statistic that strikes me as bullshit on its face (a 20% jump in one year is basically impossible if its accurate) but I do wonder how much of an underreporting and under-prosecuting issue there's been that has skewed data historically and if that's undergoing any change

The entire sentence is weird to me. What does anime/manga have to do with an incredibly unrealistic jump in a specific crime rate?
 
That's interesting because I see a lot of "what's up/wrong with wacky Japan" articles from western media

The goal is to try to promote change and, unfortunately, unless the story is big like political, economical, china-japan, or just straight up crazy it won't make people talk about it. Loads of people probably believe it's a lost cause. It's why so many well-rounded individuals are pretty passive about certain repulsive animes or how this won't be anything than a headline even though it's a big issue.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom