-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
COD:Ghosts PS4/XBO Comparisons show the same resolution (720p)?
- Thread starter Oni Jazar
- Start date
Arrowgigantic
Member
Maybe because you have to zoom in on a still shot to notice? It just drives home the point that 1080p vs. 720p doesn't matter enough to really matter. This whole debate just drives home the point that resolution isn't as important as the feature set of your rendering engine.
I'll give you one guess what website questioned there being any real difference.
We'll just say that it's not so popular here.
I assume it is 1080p and there's a mistake somewhere. If not, why did so many sites say there's a difference?
Portugeezer
Member
Well if it's native 1080p what was said about them will still be the case. We don't have the full answers yet.
LittleJohnny
Banned
Here's my theory on what's going on here:
Both console versions may be using the same art assets (at 720p rez), same code base. The PS4 game engine could nonethless be rendering 1080p to the framebuffer. That allows IW to advertise the game as "1080p native." However, it's really just the game engine upscaling the image, rather than the upscaling occurring at the system level on the X1.
Both console versions may be using the same art assets (at 720p rez), same code base. The PS4 game engine could nonethless be rendering 1080p to the framebuffer. That allows IW to advertise the game as "1080p native." However, it's really just the game engine upscaling the image, rather than the upscaling occurring at the system level on the X1.
IGN stated multiple times during their comparison that the ps4 was the clear winner graphically due to the higher resolution :/
They shouldn't, and what's worse is people shouldn't be using Youtube videos to compare fidelity either.
That makes sense. (but also note, COD in previous iterations uses AA which could throw off what one would expect a 1080p game leve of aliasing.)
Chobel
Member
Shit, I totally forget Polygon.
It's obviously their imaginations.
If it was actually native 1080p you wouldn't have to zoom in to notice.
It's a huge difference, but not always the most important difference. I don't mind a resolution hit to achieve even more impressive effects, but on an apples-to-apples comparison, I'll take over twice the pixels, thanks.
I guess we'll find out Friday what the real deal is when I throw in my PS4 copy of Ghosts and will be able to tell instantly
SmoothRunningGun
Member
So you like color blind mode? I should have read your title before your post.
Posted yet?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pyeYnmad5VM&feature=c4-overview&list=UUizuJo-T9_NG926jVz3aTMA
He invites people to try and guess which version is which at one point. I certainly could not.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pyeYnmad5VM&feature=c4-overview&list=UUizuJo-T9_NG926jVz3aTMA
He invites people to try and guess which version is which at one point. I certainly could not.
Chobel
Member
It was posted, it's the first video used to calculate CoD resolution. I guessed right, however it was more luck than telling difference :/
LetoAtreides82
Neo Member
I found some high bitrate png's uploaded by Sixthaxis from their PS4 vs Xbox One comparison:
http://www.thesixthaxis.com/2013/11/12/call-of-duty-ghosts-xbox-one-comparison-video/
Open PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Open-PS4.png
Open Xbox One:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Open-X1.png
Stab PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Stab-PS4.png
Stab Xbox One:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Stab-X1.png
Drop PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Drop-PS4.png
Drop Xbox One:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Drop-X1.png
Explosion PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Explosion-PS4.png
Explosion Xbone:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Explosion-X1.png
Can someone analyse these PS4 screengrabs?
http://www.thesixthaxis.com/2013/11/12/call-of-duty-ghosts-xbox-one-comparison-video/
Open PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Open-PS4.png
Open Xbox One:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Open-X1.png
Stab PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Stab-PS4.png
Stab Xbox One:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Stab-X1.png
Drop PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Drop-PS4.png
Drop Xbox One:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Drop-X1.png
Explosion PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Explosion-PS4.png
Explosion Xbone:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Explosion-X1.png
Can someone analyse these PS4 screengrabs?
PS4 and XBO are both 720p upscaled to 1080p in those screens.
Arrowgigantic
Member
It wouldn't be the first time a reviewer has talked up a bullet point from the PR.
Bleh...game is so rough looking in both cases.
Aliasing appears to be identical.
You don't even need to analyse them to see they are identical, especially in the first one where you can see identical jaggies on the building in the distance.
Arrowgigantic
Member
You sit too close to your TV.
Both look like 720p upscaled.
This whole thing is completely fucked. The difference between 720p and 1080p should be as clear as day, especially if 720p is upscaled. Far Cry 3 is the only thing I have installed at the moment, but some screenshots with 2xAA:
720p Native said:
1080p Scaled to 720p said:
720p Scaled to 1080p said:
1080p Native said:
Iced_Eagle
Member
Interesting. The truth will be known very soon regardless. If it turns out that it's 720p in SP that would be very strange that he wouldn't know.
But did you honestly just take a cell phone screenshot of your computer? lol
plasmawave
Banned
I think there's something going on with the capture or something.
Even the HUD looks upscaled.
Do you honestly believe that anybody in the general public is on the fence as to which version of Ghosts to buy? They're going to buy the one for the system that they have.
The only people that give a shit fall into our category, and that's for the love of the fight rather than as a genuine purchasing guide.
That would be really plausible, it would also explain the ridiculous install size if they consoles have a bunch of 60fps HD video on them.
It's obvious from these that the PS4 version is not native 1080p. No need to analyse.
MaulerX
Member
If both were same resolution, this is going to explode all over the faces of people who clearly could tell the difference of it.
Dat placebo effect.
Interfectum
Member
In some of those comparison shots the Xbone version actually looks better.
Something is very wrong in all this. Never seen Quaz wrong once, but I suppose we shall see. IW would have to be dumb as could be if they think they could get away with it.
phosphor112
Banned
If it's 1080p that doesn't mean Quaz is wrong, all the footage we have seen of PS4 SP has been 720p up-scaled. But just because we haven't seen native 1080p doesn't mean there isn't native 1080p
Is that the new line now? "If you can tell the difference between 1080p and 720p, you're sitting too close to the TV."
Lol.
iceatcs
Junior Member
Yeah also some of those shots the PS4 looks better too.
Anyway seem that 1080p confirmed on MP. Hope it will come SP on both too.
Which one, and how?
AstroNut325
Member
WHOA... cool your jets people. I understand that we are very passionate about games but it seems like we're letting our passion override our judgement by expressing anger/frustration towards developers. I don't think they're intentionally trying to deceive anyone. At least I'm willing to give them the benefit of the doubt.
People do need to calm down I agree. This is getting ridiculous.
resolutiongate: we could all tell the difference ...but then we was wrong
would be hilarious
Lord Error
Insane For Sony
Because they played the multiplayer which is for sure 1080p, and saw the difference. Those who were playing the single player, presumably wouldn't be seeing any difference because there wouldn't be any if PS4 version is really 720p during single player.
LabouredSubterfuge
Member
Eurogamer - Day one patch makes Call of Duty: Ghosts single-player 1080p on PS4
New thread or already posted?
New thread or already posted?
crazygambit
Member
A 720p only display. A lot of people that have those think the resolution rendered by the game doesn't matter since they can't see 1080p anyhow. They are of course mistaken.
Well that's a new twist.
I knew I shouldn't have stealth edited my post :lol. I didn't mean it as a cultural thing. It just... makes me feel old
Especially since the biggest fan of the show we had in our house was my mother who's very not from the USA and was familiar with it before moving there.