AniHawk said:That actually sounds pretty fair.
Dabookerman: please tell me this isn't their mistake.
Nirolak said:Does it look like this?
RandomVince said:Moral choices in vapid, peurile games? Ive always considered "moral choices" in games as nothing more than a marketing bullet point, and a superficial attempt at conveying depth that we all know does not exist in any game to date.
Looks like they fell for the hype.
Haruspex said:Um... that's what I was getting at. This whole 'moral choice' crap is getting tedious already but its currenty the poster-child for those who want to present games as being a bit arty or having their own merits because of interactivity.
AniHawk said:That actually sounds pretty fair.
!!!!!!!Dabookerman said:Yup, looks like a perfect match, well done.
Dabookerman said:I don't know which review you're talking about, but bare in mind, the excerpt about multiplayer and controls are the only positives in that review. The rest of the review was hugely negative, and quite fun to read. Will post quotes if anyone's interested.
Nirolak said:Does it look like this?
nny said:Only a 4 for Another Code? Oh well, I'm enjoying it a lot.
Me too, even more so than the DS version. A 4 means there's not much he liked in this game. Oh well.nny said:Only a 4 for Another Code? Oh well, I'm enjoying it a lot.
Awntawn said:EDGE uses the whole damn scale!
:lol I was being sarcastic. EDGE apologists say that all the time to try to add merit to their reviews, when the truth is their scores are usually just bogus and often way off the general consensus with no hint of consistency whatsoever.Aaron said:I'm pointing out the game they obviously didn't do that for. Prototype is a short, single player only mess cobbled together by hobos. A six would be generous.
Dabookerman said:On Protoype, last paragraph :
Awntawn said::lol I was being sarcastic. EDGE apologists say that all the time to try to add merit to their reviews, when the truth is their scores are usually just bogus and often way off the general consensus with no hint of consistency whatsoever.
Like I said.shagg_187 said:What a fucking Oxymoron review. So they complain about shit and gave it an 8? I can't imagine how they reviewed games like The Conduit with a 4 :lol
agm2502 said:Prototype - 8
Dabookerman said:On Protoype, last paragraph :
Prototype won't win any awards for its story, which for all its micro-cutscenes and intrigue nodes leaves you wondering just how anti- its hero really is, and not always in a good way. Not do its objectives come as any real surprise once the pattern's set, most involving one almighty scrum between countless enemies and vehicles. When you're not evading strike teams by dashing into cover and walking casually back out, the disguise system seems more about playful murder than rewarding stealth. But which would you rather have: a game that tries everything or a game that doesn't have to? Prototype does what it does, and does it with distinction.
TheGreatDave said:Prototype is fun, what's the problem?
Vorador said:EDGE should just stick to do reviews without scores.
PSGames said:Butt hurt fanboys upset it outscored a certain PS3 exclusive.
Boerseun said:edge
As irrelevant today as they were yesterday and will be tomorrow.
Be sure to post next monthPeter Molyneux on Milo reviews said:Edge is an extremely important score to any developer, and wanting to get the perfect score is a motivator for many people...
THEY COMPLAINED AND GAVE IT AN 8?!shagg_187 said:What a fucking Oxymoron review. So they complain about shit and gave it an 8?
PSGames said:Butt hurt fanboys upset it outscored a certain PS3 exclusive.
Odd question, and it depends on the DW game in question... but no.Scribble said:Is Prototype better than Dynasty Warriors (If you're a DW fan)
Dunlop said:I won't compare it to infamous as they are completely different games, but while I am finding Protype fun atm, there are so many flaws and bugs that the games should definately not be anywhere above a 6.5 imho
glaurung said:Incredible that EDGE would give PROTOTYPE an eight.
Can't wait to read that review.
RFG grade is about right, shame about Prinny.
Alex said:Well, not average, at least above average, because the posterchild for as average it gets just came out, and its name is Any Non-Valve FPS
PSGames said:Butt hurt fanboys upset it outscored a certain PS3 exclusive.
agm2502 said:Just got it in the post this morning:
The Conduit - 4
Indiana Jones and the staff of kings - 3
Another code R - 4
Did a search and couldn't see if these have been posted already. The also have an intervie.
Sadist said:Sometimes, EDGE is a weird magazine.
SecretBonusPoint said:8 for Prototype is ridiculous compared to the shit scores Edge has given other great games this year.
ShockingAlberto said:THEY COMPLAINED AND GAVE IT AN 8?!
BUT AN 8'S THE HIGHEST SCORE YOU CAN GIVE!
HUARGHAGRAFFLEDAMN
FFChris said:Which PS3 exclusive did it get higher than?