I finished the demo and thought it was very good.
Not tried the combat trials yet but the prologue combat seemed good. I can see that people are doing crazy combos but I didn't see a need as the perfect evade timing is very generous at least on normal difficulty. Could definitely see myself enjoying this kind of casual DMC combat though.
The story seemed interesting and certainly already better than what I saw in FF15.
I'm not buying it on PS5 at least unless they have really ramped up the quality and performance of the final game but I know that kind of stuff doesn't bother most people so I can see why the majority are excited.
Some critiques:
For me personally some of the English VA really made me laugh at events I'm sure were supposed to be emotional - Clive's acting in the Phoenix bit was like a spoof and sounded very amateurish.
Neither graphics mode was acceptable for me. Graphics mode feels bad and looks bad thanks to the horrible motion blur. Performance mode looks blurry as hell without even considering the motion blur and the performance is all over the place. Like why am I getting less than 48 FPS standing in this tiny empty room? Not to mention the 15fps Panzer Dragoon fight that should just have been pre-rendered. Old build I know so maybe it will improve.
The graphics are a real mixed bag - the cutscenes can look like CGI (at least the characters) and the motion blur and depth of field they use is really high quality but the gameplay can look kind of shit.
What's going on with the ground here for instance? Some really weird artifacts that were even more obvious on a TV. Maybe just a bug?
The AF looked really bad throughout leading to really blurry ground textures.
Some parts were like a damp squib and felt like placeholders. 2015 v 2023. I know not exactly fair as you can go to the Witcher 3 area later on but you have to admit the FF16 scene looks really crap.