• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Hideki Kamiya on PlayStation All-Stars Battle Royale: "It's just a ripoff."

Status
Not open for further replies.

Forever

Banned
Jul 7, 2010
6,717
0
0


This got quite the reaction in the other thread. Some people were quick to jump on Kamiya for attacking the game without playing it, but I think it's clear here that he has problems with the game from a conceptual standpoint, the execution being irrelevant.

Food for thought:

:lol

More Kamiya being awesome:

The dude in the above tweets deleted his Twitter account. Come at the King, you best not miss!

Kamiya doesn't give a fuck about GAF:


...or about the game:
Fun is over for today:

A friend asked me to post this:

 

The_Hitcher89

Member
Apr 28, 2011
52,480
0
0
Maidenhead, England
At the end of the day for me, its a conceptual rip-off of a game that is one-of-a-kind, and doesn't have many willing competitors with a rostor to make it worth copying. But they seem to have done more than just copy it. They've taken the simple framework and put their own spin on it from the first floor up judging from the changes and impressions, and its basically ignorance to not even give it a chance because it has the audacity to be a 4-player mascot brawler.
 

Loudninja

Member
Jul 30, 2007
53,089
0
0
31
Chicago
Sorry I atleast expect someone to play a game before they try to make such claims.

I dont think that's unreasonable.
 

Schobeleth

Member
Nov 27, 2011
3,294
0
0
USA
I have immense respect for that man but I don't like that he calls it a rip off. I'll politely agree to disagree with him. Just because something is in the same vein as something else doesn't mean it is a rip off.. It's different enough to make it awesome and fun, while All-Stars is its own unique thing.
 
Well, that rules out Bayonetta/Jack for PSASBR
Sega has thrown Platinum off a cliff at this point so I don't think Platinum has much influence on the IPs anymore. :p

That said the games didn't do well so I don't expect us to ever see the IPs again.

Edit:

Though contemplating this, it does make the inclusion of Dante and Raiden from Rising rather amusing.
 

Beth Cyra

Member
Nov 7, 2009
16,041
0
0
Oregon
Wow.

Honestly thought this would be contained to the Twitter thread. Just one dude giving his opinion on the game and now is going to be used as a flame war.
 

Meccanical

Member
Oct 14, 2011
11,962
0
0
It is a rip off.

Anyone who says otherwise is seriously a fanboy.

Granted that doesn't mean it can't be a fun rip off.
 

AAK

Member
Sep 30, 2006
19,614
4
1,235
32
Ottawa, ON
Not a fan of PSBAR either. Playstation was immoratlized by all the games which pioneered 3D gaming. Then they go on to make it a 2D game.

SHOULD HAVE BEEN A 3D GAME!!!
 

JABEE

Member
May 19, 2010
44,037
0
645
It's a mascot brawler. I've played both and they don't really feel the same at all. Fighting games are very similar, but differentiate themselves in their systems and the way the game is played. All Stars is no rip-off.
 

Cade

Member
Mar 1, 2012
4,803
2
0
This won't happen. The first, that is. Kamiya's word is bond.
Don't know much about the guy, just seems like every time something like this happens it's only a day or two (sometimes only a few hours!) before we get PR statements and claims of mis-wording. :p
 

Duffyside

Banned
Sep 8, 2010
5,526
0
0
Sorry I atleast expect someone to play a game before they try to make such claims.

I dont think that's unreasonable.
I think it's totally unreasonable to say people have to play games to decide they're not interested, or that they are. Yes, he might think differently once he played it, but that doesn't mean he can't have an opinion now, nor that it might not be true in the end.

And I'm really looking forward to PSBR; but I get the harsh criticisms.
 

Anteater

Member
May 22, 2010
27,731
1
845
39


Btw he said Streets of Rage is a ripoff of Final Fight too, just for reference regarding his definition of rip-off
 

GDGF

Soothsayer
Jun 6, 2004
23,925
1
0
43
Savannah, GA
Kamiya is pretty good friends with Sakurai, correct?

(of course you could probably say that about the majority of the japanese games industry)
 

ponpo

( ≖‿≖)
Aug 22, 2011
19,680
8
0
Tsukuba, Japan
Don't know much about the guy, just seems like every time something like this happens it's only a day or two (sometimes only a few hours!) before we get PR statements and claims of mis-wording. :p
No, you definitely don't know much about Kamiya :(
 

KillerTravis

Banned
Mar 25, 2012
4,730
0
0
Come on guys, how can you say it's not a concept ripoff? Did you honestly think Superbot came up with the idea on their own? Being a ripoff and being a fun game are two different things. Seems Kamiya just dislikes unoriginal ideas.
 
Sep 2, 2007
17,992
3
0
But you know, he is totally right.
Its a rip off, even sony knows that by putting the name super smash bros on their youtube tag videos.
 

chertipros

Member
Apr 15, 2012
3,863
0
0
I wouldn't say it's a ripoff, but it definitely was inspired heavily by super smash brothers. And there is no denying that. And just to play devils advocate, viewtiful joe red hot rumble was a "super smash bros ripoff" too. Was he involved in that?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.