Nice snark, but I find having full player list out in front of everyone can illuminate blind spots one may have.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Legend of Zelda Mafia |OT| A Lynch to the Past
- Thread starter Sawneeks
- Start date
Player List
1. [f] Sophia
2. [m] StanleyPalmtree1
5. [f] Melonrabbit
6. [m] Ty4on
7. [m] AbsolutBro
8. [m] Natiko
9. [m] CzarTim
10. [m] CCS
11. [m] *Splinter
13. [m] Cabot
14. [m] Kyanrute
15. [m] Kawl_USC
16. [m] Ynnek7
17. [m] Nin1000
18. [m] Bronx-Man
19. [m] Pop-O-Matic -> [m] Terrabyte20xx
20. [m] MagnumBoy20xx
let us all be illuminated then
wow
melonrabbit
Member
Okay. I'm on lunch presently. Has CCS ever posted those full reads? Any sign of Magnum or Ynnek? Terra is still catching up and Nin had his passive agressive drive-by post every few pages.
I see your vote Cabot.
If you want to go down this route we can.
Vote: Cabot
I see your vote Cabot.
If you want to go down this route we can.
Vote: Cabot
I did mine up above. You're welcome to contribute yours as well.
an?
Oh yeah, other reads.
Melon as top scum. Her D1 vote has been discussed and could be innocent but could also have been intentionally planted. There was also the recent slip about her Cabot read which again could be innocent but looked more like we caught her contradicting herself and then she just explained her way out as best she could. I still think her comment to Cabot (that I highlighted earlier) was weird.
Stan I mentioned yesterday felt a little different to usual, some disagreed but I don't think I'm the only one that noticed it. That subtle change combined with his vote earns him a scumread from me.
Tim retains his light scum read from yesterday. His vote doesnt reassure me but there's been nothing today that rang any alarms.
Ty4on is more null than I'd like... Only thing that stands out to me was a weird interaction with Tim on D1. There's been little things linking them in my head all game although I can't think of any other examples. My gut tells me they're both scum, but if Tim is town that would weaken my Ty read.
Lover had me worried early D1 but I'm fairly confident he's town now.
Sophia has been very Sophia, same light town read as yesterday, maybe a little more confident this time.
Kawl I keep flip flopping on, honestly don't know what to think despite him being plenty active. His tunneling on CCS has been extreme to the point of distraction - has he even been commenting on anything else?
Everyone else is varying degrees of null. AB gets a mention for his vote but tbh I'm waiting until CCS flips before I really try and analyse that stuff. Kyan and nin both playing as expected, don't have anything to add there.
Who have I forgotten exists?
Bronx? AWOL, was a town read on D1
Natiko - town read, not sure why I forgot him, probably just because I haven't played with him before. Not a strong town read btw, he's having a good game but it's nothing that makes me think "Nah he's not scum".
Anyone else?
Melon as top scum. Her D1 vote has been discussed and could be innocent but could also have been intentionally planted. There was also the recent slip about her Cabot read which again could be innocent but looked more like we caught her contradicting herself and then she just explained her way out as best she could. I still think her comment to Cabot (that I highlighted earlier) was weird.
Stan I mentioned yesterday felt a little different to usual, some disagreed but I don't think I'm the only one that noticed it. That subtle change combined with his vote earns him a scumread from me.
Tim retains his light scum read from yesterday. His vote doesnt reassure me but there's been nothing today that rang any alarms.
Ty4on is more null than I'd like... Only thing that stands out to me was a weird interaction with Tim on D1. There's been little things linking them in my head all game although I can't think of any other examples. My gut tells me they're both scum, but if Tim is town that would weaken my Ty read.
Lover had me worried early D1 but I'm fairly confident he's town now.
Sophia has been very Sophia, same light town read as yesterday, maybe a little more confident this time.
Kawl I keep flip flopping on, honestly don't know what to think despite him being plenty active. His tunneling on CCS has been extreme to the point of distraction - has he even been commenting on anything else?
Everyone else is varying degrees of null. AB gets a mention for his vote but tbh I'm waiting until CCS flips before I really try and analyse that stuff. Kyan and nin both playing as expected, don't have anything to add there.
Who have I forgotten exists?
Bronx? AWOL, was a town read on D1
Natiko - town read, not sure why I forgot him, probably just because I haven't played with him before. Not a strong town read btw, he's having a good game but it's nothing that makes me think "Nah he's not scum".
Anyone else?
Ab damn you autocorrect
No kyan said this was useless. Don't use that list please.
Apologies, apologies for not posting this last night like I wanted to. Reads:
nin: Going back to D1, I remember now that when Sorian came at me for my joke post, he took it pretty seriously. Everyone else saw it as a joke for what is was, everyone except for nin that is. Sorian turned out to be town, but this and the whole "Bronx is usually playing scared" comment don't sit right with me. If he wasn't trying to start a potential train on me, it feels almost like he's trying to signal it for someone else.
Stanley: No offense, but you're usually a lot more helpful during games like these. All you've done so far is just post fluff. It's fine to do that at the start of D1 like everyone else, but we're almost at the end of D2 now. If you're not scum, then you're definitely playing as bad town right now.
CCS: Again, you were one of the two players I had the strongest reads on at the end of D2. I said myself that the odds of you and acohrs both being scum are unlikely, but I won't rule it out entirely.
Lean town: Sophia, Cabot, Ty
Null on everyone else. Though melon is someone I need to study on for a while.
nin: Going back to D1, I remember now that when Sorian came at me for my joke post, he took it pretty seriously. Everyone else saw it as a joke for what is was, everyone except for nin that is. Sorian turned out to be town, but this and the whole "Bronx is usually playing scared" comment don't sit right with me. If he wasn't trying to start a potential train on me, it feels almost like he's trying to signal it for someone else.
Stanley: No offense, but you're usually a lot more helpful during games like these. All you've done so far is just post fluff. It's fine to do that at the start of D1 like everyone else, but we're almost at the end of D2 now. If you're not scum, then you're definitely playing as bad town right now.
CCS: Again, you were one of the two players I had the strongest reads on at the end of D2. I said myself that the odds of you and acohrs both being scum are unlikely, but I won't rule it out entirely.
Lean town: Sophia, Cabot, Ty
Null on everyone else. Though melon is someone I need to study on for a while.
That's what I thought, but had to make sure. And yeah, I have no feelings on them either, strangely. Hm...
Absolut, Magnum, Terra, ynnek are the ones that I really have no idea about. Could perhaps remove Magnum from the list because of his Absolut vote on day one. I found the reasoning behind the vote illogical and the vote itself was completely detached from the 2/3-way at the end. An illogical vote by an inactive for an inactive. The three others are blanks simply because of low post count, though at least there is something from Absolut.
np kawl posted a useless list in a shitpost, i posted the good correct quality one
feel free to use mine
melonrabbit
Member
What the fuck did you say to me you little bitch
From "fuck i dunno there is so little to think about" into "fuck there is little to think about but that little does seem iffy as hell". In more clearer words, from null into slight scum lean. Would like to hear more certainly because the read is based on very little.
ur silly that was for splinter not for you you silly shitposter
I know you aren't a meme queen like me and Bronx, but yea it's the first line of the navy seal copy pasta. Don't mean any real aggression by that.
we should all hold hands and slowly chant 'magnum, magnum, magnum' and maybe he shall appear.
I refuse to hold Doctor melon's hand, I just doused her with kerosene.
But I would ask for those 4 or 5 posters flying under everyone's radar, please contribute when you can. Just hurting good towns folks otherwise by providing cover for scum. Odds say that there's scum among you, give us something to work with to separate the wheat from the chaff.
melonrabbit
Member
What is happening?
Ew.
Ew.
That scene would really unnerve me if I was a less confident man....join us, Doctor.
before you die.
melonrabbit
Member
join us, Doctor.
before you die.
This thread got all gross and petty lol
never change gafia
you're the guy staring at her aren't you, you cretin.
melonrabbit
Member
Hurts don't it?
Now that you know how it fucking feels you won't be so quick to mock others' hard work.
Lone_Prodigy
Member
Zelda Fact of the Day #4: Did you know that Breath of the Wild is the first Zelda game to feature ACTUAL VOICE ACTING. Now you know!
natiko (0)
cabot 1130 (1234)
bronx-man (1)
czartim 1131
ccs (3)
kawl_usc 1143
bronx-man 1209
*splinter 1546
cabot (0)
nin1000 1152 (1208)
*splinter (0)
cabot 1234 (1260)
ty4on (0)
cabot 1260 (1295)
magnumboy20xx (1)
absolutbro 1282
ynnek7 (0)
cabot 1295 (1476)
kawl_usc (0)
ccs 1301 (1377)
stanleypalmtree (1)
ccs 1410
melonrabbit (1)
cabot 1476
Day 2 ends in:
dat trailer tho
dat release date tho
dat price tag tho
dat release date tho
dat price tag tho
natiko (0)
bronx-man (1)
czartim 1131
ccs (3)
kawl_usc 1143
bronx-man 1209
*splinter 1546
cabot (0)
*splinter (0)
ty4on (0)
magnumboy20xx (1)
absolutbro 1282
ynnek7 (0)
kawl_usc (0)
stanleypalmtree (1)
ccs 1410
melonrabbit (1)
cabot 1476
Day 2 ends in:
remember CCS said he'd be out for a period before end of day, I'm pretty sure we're past that now.
Back to the shitposting.
melonrabbit
Member
I put in work, bro. Unlike Karl.
And also, the people I would like to hear from are all hiding while we all turn against each other.
Name drop them, is it the ones that have been brought up by others?
melonrabbit
Member
He's been elusive. Attempted to get him to flesh out and give context to his reads but no luck there.
Magnum, you remember us right?
whoops wrong gif lol
1. [f] Sophia
acting crazy
2. [m] StanleyPalmtree1
sometimes here sometimes gone
5. [f] Melonrabbit
she tried on d1 but somehow she seems off like. not on.
6. [m] Ty4on
was a presence on D1 now kinda gone
7. [m] AbsolutBro
Who ?
8. [m] Natiko
strong start evaporated lately
9. [m] CzarTim
cant really say a thing about him : (
10. [m] CCS
drawed some attention but now no more. I dont know why
11. [m] *Splinter
stays kinda behind no strong voice
13. [m] Cabot
is touched when someone says he should be lynched
14. [m] Kyanrute
missing
15. [m] Kawl_USC
he is somewhat of a presence but not really enough to stay in my mind
16. [m] Ynnek7
Who ?
17. [m] Nin1000
his focus at the end of the day was remarkable
18. [m] Bronx-Man
poor fellow that just disappeared because of reasons ( he scared )
19. [m] Terrabyte20xx
Arrived but then just vanished
20. [m] MagnumBoy20xx
Who?
@cabot you want to dance ?
Oh you cant.
1. [f] Sophia
acting crazy
2. [m] StanleyPalmtree1
sometimes here sometimes gone
5. [f] Melonrabbit
she tried on d1 but somehow she seems off like. not on.
6. [m] Ty4on
was a presence on D1 now kinda gone
7. [m] AbsolutBro
Who ?
8. [m] Natiko
strong start evaporated lately
9. [m] CzarTim
cant really say a thing about him : (
10. [m] CCS
drawed some attention but now no more. I dont know why
11. [m] *Splinter
stays kinda behind no strong voice
13. [m] Cabot
is touched when someone says he should be lynched
14. [m] Kyanrute
missing
15. [m] Kawl_USC
he is somewhat of a presence but not really enough to stay in my mind
16. [m] Ynnek7
Who ?
17. [m] Nin1000
his focus at the end of the day was remarkable
18. [m] Bronx-Man
poor fellow that just disappeared because of reasons ( he scared )
19. [m] Terrabyte20xx
Arrived but then just vanished
20. [m] MagnumBoy20xx
Who?
@cabot you want to dance ?
Oh you cant.
This is coming from the person who has done nothing substantial the entire game, even by said person's own standards?