CabbageRed said:
That is my point, though. The same people who would pay for something like DLC, especially when it is for an already lengthy RPG, are the same people who frequent forums; truly101's "paranoid skeptics that frequent GAF and other sites" are a small minority in general, but (I'm betting) a significantly larger minority of those who would consider buying Warden's Keep.
I certainly wouldn't deny that, but our group is not the target for the DA marketing campaign. Our group is seldom the target for any marketing campaign. One reason is us enthusiasts are a fickle and hypocritical bunch. Look no further than the L4D2 boycotters, most of them would buy the sequel, even if Valve didn't fly them to HQ or whatever. Same thing here, there are a lot of people that claim they wont buy the game because they hate the art style or they find it juvenile. Some may stick to that, but I bet a lot of current haters buy it anyway, because a) when we're bored, we're curious and we tend to spend money that way b) November's pickings look a bit slim outside of AC2 and MW2.
EA doesn't care about nerdy enthusiasts, sure we're a great foundation to hopefully build a bigger mainstream success for certain games (dead space or mirror's edge perhaps), but they also couldn't care about offending our fickle sensibilities and bizarre misplaced sense of "indie cred" in an industry that is 100% for profit. EA is hoping DLC resonates with the general game player who doesn't patrol message boards and that they find value in said DLC based on their opinion of the game and what the DLC offers to them in entertainment value. They aren't going to be swayed by mumblings and grumblings on day 1 DLC or speculation on what was cut in game content and what isn't. usually that stuff is painfully obvious (like the TR:U levels) and it gets called out by the general crowd as well.
I just think that this assertion that day 1 DLC is some terrible egregious sin that will somehow doom DA to failure is laughable considering most of the people who buy DA will not give the slightests of fucks.