NPD Sales Results for February 2015 [Nintendo Numbers, Majora's, MH4, ~XB1]

May 23, 2013
5,915
0
0
twitter.com
Apparently it is outrageous to think it could sell 3 million lifetime.
No it's not.

However, It is outrageous to base first month/lifetime sales on an Amazon ranking.

Like I've said multiple times in this thread, no one is doubting that Bloodborne will do well, but to use one retailer as a way to say sales will be explosive etc... doesn't really mean much.

(This post isn't aimed at you btw, just the comment in general)
 
Jun 12, 2013
21,443
0
440
No it's not.

However, It is outrageous to base first month/lifetime sales on an Amazon ranking.
Pretty much.

I'd go so far to say that Amazon, from a software perspective, is only good as a positive reinforcement in one perspective, in that a game that charts well is less likely to flop badly at launch. And I use the term badly very liberally.

But it's not even good as a negative reinforcement, because games that chart low doesn't mean it'll do badly.
 
Nov 30, 2014
6,851
0
0
Ipoh, Malaysia
Apparently it is outrageous to think it could sell 3 million lifetime.
Then there are people who underestimate its sales as well ;) 3 million lifetime is totally achievable IMO, considering Souls games have really long legs and Sony might bundle Bloodborne for the holidays.

BruceLeeRoy said that we gonna be impressed with Bloodborne sales, whatever that means.
Not sure where he got that info. He's no retailer or anything.
 
Dec 12, 2013
5,143
0
0
I see some are still harping on Amazon being a small percent of the market for NPD. Amazon is a huge retailer. Whatever is popular there you can predict is popular everywhere else. And vice versa. Check for yourselves. Other retailers charts are available. What you shouldn't be doing is predicting exact sales.

Also BB doing 300K in the U S. would be a success. Didn't it sell 157K in Japan? Why is it hard to believe it can't do 300K in a much bigger market?
 
Jul 24, 2014
3,433
0
0
I see some are still harping on Amazon being a small percent of the market for NPD. Amazon is a huge retailer. Whatever is popular there you can predict is popular everywhere else. And vice versa.
Not true as Evolve proved last month and Hardline will show this month.

Amazon is not very representative of the software market at large at all, especially for first month sales data. Their market share for new games at launch is fairly miniscule.

Bloodborne IS successful. I'm certain Sony and From are plenty happy with its sales. But there's some crazy predictions in here. 600k? Not even close. If they can manage to do over 300k it will be a huge success imo and I fo feel that's doable at this point. It being a 5 week period I'd guess its top end could be maybe 350k.

* everything stated is my own opinion and not representative of any business or its data
 
Dec 23, 2008
6,565
0
0
I see some are still harping on Amazon being a small percent of the market for NPD. Amazon is a huge retailer. Whatever is popular there you can predict is popular everywhere else. And vice versa. Check for yourselves. Other retailers charts are available. What you shouldn't be doing is predicting exact sales.

Also BB doing 300K in the U S. would be a success. Didn't it sell 157K in Japan? Why is it hard to believe it can't do 300K in a much bigger market?
I know people don't like to bring up userbase but that JP number is from a 1.4 million userbase. What's the U.S. userbase? 6 million? I hope it at least does 300K in the U.S.
 
Nov 29, 2014
1,247
0
0
I feel bad for that iamrandom guy, dude's kinda asking for a shout out when Bloodborne sales release. It's a great game (loving it) but not the kind of game which is going to sell a huge amount, a number in the region of 250k would be great. Amazon, gaming forums etc are not a good barometer of what actual sales will look like, it does not take a genius to know that Hardline will have wiped the floor with Bloorborne, wouldn't at all be surprised is PS4 sales alone are higher for Hardline than Bloodborne.

Would love to be wrong but very much doubt it .
 
Feb 9, 2006
8,501
0
0
I feel bad for that iamrandom guy, dude's kinda asking for a shout out when Bloodborne sales release. It's a great game (loving it) but not the kind of game which is going to sell a huge amount, a number in the region of 250k would be great. Amazon, gaming forums etc are not a good barometer of what actual sales will look like, it does not take a genius to know that Hardline will have wiped the floor with Bloorborne, wouldn't at all be surprised is PS4 sales alone are higher for Hardline than Bloodborne.

Would love to be wrong but very much doubt it .
Bloodborne had a great debut in the UK, better than any Souls game and number one in the single format charts. Most people on my friend list are playing it. It'll do very well, pretty sure of that.

Deserved as well. Amazing game.
 
Dec 12, 2013
5,143
0
0
Not true as Evolve proved last month and Hardline will show this month.

Amazon is not very representative of the software market at large at all, especially for first month sales data. Their market share for new games at launch is fairly miniscule.

Bloodborne IS successful. I'm certain Sony and From are plenty happy with its sales. But there's some crazy predictions in here. 600k? Not even close. If they can manage to do over 300k it will be a huge success imo and I fo feel that's doable at this point. It being a 5 week period I'd guess its top end could be maybe 350k.

* everything stated is my own opinion and not representative of any business or its data
Like i said you can't use it and guess how much something is going to sell. But i mean if you see a product also charting at all major retailers for the duration of a month you can say it's doing pretty well. Amazon is usually iffy with software though i agree.

I don't think BB will do 600K. It only has one week and a couple days of NPD tracking. 300K is the max i can see it doing. It's definitely selling more than The Order.
 
Aug 3, 2009
19,285
0
0
Moga Village
290k and that includes digital which NPD does not track so when people say 300k its without digital.

Your logic makes little sense but thats expected.
Well, lower my prediction to 500k then, not that much of a difference.

The fact is, Monster Hunter is a handheld exclusive, in the west, and with close to non-existent promo. While Bloodborne is the new Souls game, marketed by Sony and on the most popular home console of the generation.

It should sell more than Monster Hunter, easily. What is your prediction?
 
Apr 2, 2013
4,934
0
0
Not true as Evolve proved last month and Hardline will show this month.

Amazon is not very representative of the software market at large at all, especially for first month sales data. Their market share for new games at launch is fairly miniscule.

Bloodborne IS successful. I'm certain Sony and From are plenty happy with its sales. But there's some crazy predictions in here. 600k? Not even close. If they can manage to do over 300k it will be a huge success imo and I fo feel that's doable at this point. It being a 5 week period I'd guess its top end could be maybe 350k.

* everything stated is my own opinion and not representative of any business or its data
Indeed, which is why having Bloodborne almost equal to the Xb1 AC bundle on the year is a fair comparison point. We know what the Xbox has been doing and we know Amazon is fairly in line with the overall market on hardware sales, predicting the winner each month except December of 2013. Wish I hadn't floated the 10% number coming up with crazy numbers at first. The 360k is actually somewhat plausible.
 
Jan 16, 2009
16,846
0
0
Like i said you can't use it and guess how much something is going to sell. But i mean if you see a product also charting at all major retailers for the duration of a month you can say it's doing pretty well. Amazon is usually iffy with software though i agree.

I don't think BB will do 600K. It only has one week and a couple days of NPD tracking. 300K is the max i can see it doing. It's definitely selling more than The Order.
Close to 300k in two weeks is pretty much what The Order did.
 
Dec 29, 2008
430
0
0
Here's my question, for those of you that think Bloodborne is going to put up 500k or more on NPD what on earth are you projecting Hardline to do?



The Order was much closer to 200k than 300k in NPD last month.
Are you sure since it was ranked ahead of MH4U which did 290K with digital. I wouldn't imagine MH4 digitals sales would be much over 10%.
 
Jun 3, 2014
7,705
1
0
Here's my question, for those of you that think Bloodborne is going to put up 500k or more on NPD what on earth are you projecting Hardline to do?
I don't think that's really a fair comparison though, Bloodborne is PS4's first killer exclusive and is the highest rated next gen exclusive so far, so a lot of people will be picking it up just to check it out etc while hardline is a crappy battlefield that people will avoid.


I'm not saying Bloodborne will do over 500k, ~400k ish is my guess... Just pointing that out.
 
Feb 24, 2014
14,512
0
370
I don't think that's really a fair comparison though, Bloodborne is PS4's first killer exclusive and is the highest rated next gen exclusive so far, so a lot of people will be picking it up just to check it out etc while hardline is a crappy battlefield that people will avoid.


I'm not saying Bloodborne will do over 500k, ~400k ish is my guess... Just pointing that out.
So do you think Hardline will do worse? Better?
 
Jul 24, 2014
3,433
0
0
Are you sure since it was ranked ahead of MH4U which did 290K with digital. I wouldn't imagine MH4 digitals sales would be much over 10%.
Hm entirely possible. I was just basing that on the way cream writes his leaks.

He put 200k < The Order

He usually puts games closer to the number that they sell. If it was closer to 300k it would usually be more his style to put it like this

300k > The Order

Or

250k < The Order
 
Mar 26, 2013
15,673
3
0
Nothing wrong with The Shogun post, Cream said The Order did >200K, which means it's very close to 200K. Plus The Shogun works at a big retailer so he knows the general trends.
 
Aug 25, 2013
24,331
0
0
The Monster Hunter did 290k ( digital included ). Chill out, man.
digital+bundles, also we can only really compare retail-only sales unless Sony decides to spill total numbers (yeah right)

and since creamsugar's post was The Order>200k, it was probably 200-225k (otherwise he would have probably put The Order<250k or something)
 
Aug 5, 2012
13,025
0
0
Nothing wrong with The Shogun post, Cream said The Order did >200K, which means it's very close to 200K. Plus The Shogun works at a big retailer so he knows the general trends.
Does the NPD record digital sales with retailer? If The Order charted on the NPD above MH4U at 290K then it's possible The Order was above that, but under 300K. If Cream was giving numbers without digital then his original post of The Order > 200K would make more sense.
 
Mar 26, 2013
15,673
3
0
Does the NPD record digital sales with retailer? If The Order charted on the NPD above MH4U at 290K then it's possible The Order was above that, but under 300K. If Cream was giving numbers without digital then his original post of The Order > 200K would make more sense.
No, just retail sales.
 
Jun 3, 2014
7,705
1
0
So do you think Hardline will do worse? Better?
On the PS4 only? I'd guess roughly the same as bloodborne, maybe even a bit less. I'm not expecting much from that at all.

I'm not sure how much BF sells normally though so that could just be a guess from my ass, I'm just going off that BF4 sold 825-850k in total on launch month and nothing else, but that came out only weeks before the next gen consoles and the game was broken which gave it a bad word of mouth around launch... So with that in mind, and that it's not a mainline battlefield game I'm guessing we'll probably see similar total results for hardline.
 
Jun 22, 2011
11,588
0
520
Norway
digital+bundles, also we can only really compare retail-only sales unless Sony decides to spill total numbers (yeah right)

and since creamsugar's post was The Order>200k, it was probably 200-225k (otherwise he would have probably put The Order<250k or something)
I have no hard numbers to back it up with, but MH4 also seems like a game most known to the hardcore which knows about the Japanese market and its popularity there. They seem to me to be more likely to buy it digitally.
 
Feb 24, 2014
14,512
0
370
I was close with my 6%. Amazon is actually around 5% of the US market as said by Aqua.

I hope after the next NPD we put far less credence on Amazon software placements as we do hardware.
 
Jul 28, 2012
26,651
0
0
Well, lower my prediction to 500k then, not that much of a difference.

The fact is, Monster Hunter is a handheld exclusive, in the west, and with close to non-existent promo. While Bloodborne is the new Souls game, marketed by Sony and on the most popular home console of the generation.

It should sell more than Monster Hunter, easily. What is your prediction?
Different platform with a larger user base, different audiences, MH4 was advertised and the new hardware launch would of helped as well.

Considering DS2 sold <350k on PS360 in 3.5 weeks, I'm guessing Bloodborne will sell 300-400k. These games tend to have quite long legs as well.