D
Deleted member 30609
Unconfirmed Member
Just in case it gets lost on the other page.Rez>You said:
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Resident Evil 5 - Xbox 360 vs PS3 Demos Comparison
- Thread starter Aquanox
- Start date
DangerStepp
Member
In depth PS3 and Xbox comparisons...
Imagine that.
Imagine that.
Private Hoffman
Banned
Very minor differences. Playing both versions one after another you won't notice a difference at all. Can't believe how some people get so worked up over this shit.
I did, however, notice that I greatly preferred the control with the DS3.
I did, however, notice that I greatly preferred the control with the DS3.
Choke on the Magic
Banned
I can't see the difference in either version. What does this mean? 
Always-honest
Banned
image quality between Component and HDMI is not as big as you would think.Zophar said:
Lion Heart
Banned
Guys? Sound quality differences? I bought new (higher end) speakers and sound is a lot more important to me than visuals (minus framerate)
I think the biggest difference is color reproduction. If you check out the burnout paradise comparison on PS3/360 with vga component and hdmi, the colors all look drastically different.Always-honest said:
SixStringPsycho
Member
PS3 has better shadowing
360 has better lighting
360 has better lighting
D
Deleted member 30609
Unconfirmed Member
Well, not necessarily. There are some differences, especially when you look at Dot50's comparison at the top of this page. For people with both consoles, and without a controller preference, it is useful.RpgN said:
Rez>You said:
Ah-ha! Looking at this comparison, and then looking at the OP I've noticed the current PS3 demo suffers from the same exact issues, like disappearing/flickering shadows and whatnot. This is months old code.
Lion Heart said:
I wouldn't be able to tell you, but most assuredly the PS3 version should have better sound quality(pretty much every multiplatform game does), unless Capcom are being dickheads.
D
Deleted member 30609
Unconfirmed Member
There is a high chance this is the same build from way back in September that they built for TGS.jett said:
Always-honest
Banned
Lion Heart said:
i think the difference between HDMI and Component is not that big. (Provided you have good equipment/ cables.. etc..)
Choke on the Magic
Banned
Tiduz said:
Yeah this won't actually happen until the FFXIII comparison thread in 2012.
I seriously cannot see a difference from these screens though. Where are they?
DangerStepp
Member
You see how the HD lighting plays upon Chris's right tricep real subtle-like in that one pic?
In the other picture, his hair isn't as brown as it should be and the wrinkle textures in his shirt seem to sway in an odd direction.
That's makes all of the difference in the world.
In the other picture, his hair isn't as brown as it should be and the wrinkle textures in his shirt seem to sway in an odd direction.
That's makes all of the difference in the world.
D
Deleted member 30609
Unconfirmed Member
Wrong on both counts.Cataferal said:
The 360 has very, very rare tearing if you're playing at 720p, and the PS3 version still averages at 30FPS, even if there are some drops.
RpgN
Junior Member
Rez>You said:Well, not necessarily. There are some differences, especially when you look at Dot50's comparison at the top of this page. For people with both consoles, and without a controller preference, it is useful.
Of course, if all members were civil and didn't use this thread as a fanboy hideout.
But I'm honestly not seeing any difference besides the sharpness, most Xbox 360 games are sharper. I haven't seen any video comparisons, so I don't know how the framerate and screentearing faire between the 2.
Always-honest
Banned
LRB1983 said:This is how it looks for me
that doesn't look right.. is it the camera or your screen that causes these colours?
Choke on the Magic
Banned
DangerStepp said:
They're all in different areas with a snap shot from a camera. Are you being sarcastic?
Rez>You said:
That may be where I'm going wrong then. I'm playing at 1080P on 360, and the tearing was truly something to behold.
As for the PS3 version, I'm not sure which resolution it was set to by default (1080P?), but the screen kept chugging along intermittently. It wasn't pleasant - but it's possible knocking the resolution down to 720P will help the PS3's case as well.
Choke on the Magic
Banned
It's a shame consoles don't have Fraps installed on them.
Baloonatic
Member
Cataferal said:
Yeah, everyone should take note that setting your 360 to 720p practically gets rid of all the tearing. Certainly not noticeable unless you're actively looking for it anyway.
jump_button
Banned
-_- Comparisons are for fanboys they look the same unless you have two tv side by side and was planing to play whem at the same time
but this is neogaf so :/
but this is neogaf so :/
PepsimanVsJoe
Member
Lousy framerates or tearing...Nice.
Wake me when games stop sacrificing framerate and/or image quality for HD graphics(or at least until I can afford a new PC).
(Yeah I played the RE5 demo on an SDTV)
Wake me when games stop sacrificing framerate and/or image quality for HD graphics(or at least until I can afford a new PC).
(Yeah I played the RE5 demo on an SDTV)
Tokyo Rain
Member
borghe said:
Totally agree. Developers keep trying for this "look as real as possible" and failing miserably. Sure skin has more detail or whatever but it just looks over-emphasized and horrible.
DangerStepp
Member
Choke on the Magic said:
Baloonatic said:
Note taken. It's just frustrating that it should come to this. It means we have to constantly change the resolution on a game-to-game basis. FIFA09 and GoW2 look great at 1080p, but for Lost Odyssey and Top Spin 3 (and now RE4), 720p is the only way to go.
They should create display setting profiles for each game.
Synless
Member
I just wanted to point out that it's only sharper because of the AA type used. If you play the second part of the demo with the chainsaw guy there are parts where it stops using Quinicux and the textures lose there blurry appearance. Anyone who doesn't believe me can check it out for themselves.RpgN said:
Felix Lighter
Member
Damn, setting my 360 to 1080p eliminates the input lag on my TV without sacrificing the image quality. In 720p I'll have to use Game mode which really hurts the picture quality and I lose almost all my picture controls. I'll have to test this out when I get home.
MoonsaultSlayer
Member
LOL I find these capture comparison threads to be pretty pathetic. I mean.... I have my PS3 hooked up via HDMI on a 42 inch 1080p sharp aquos and it looks beautiful. Nowhere near the blurry mess posted. I care not to read this thread so someone could have pulled a switcheroo and the joke's on me but just in case, I posted my opinion anyway...
evil costanza
Banned
confirmed again, PS3 blows
however the tearing on the 360 sucks
however the tearing on the 360 sucks
Always-honest
Banned
Tokyo Rain said:
that's very true. in real life you're not staring at textures. lighting is far more important (killzone2/ dutch masters)
dreamer3kx
Member
evil costanza said:
wow.
Choke on the Magic
Banned
evil costanza said:
Double wow.
Similar threads
- Poll