Unfortunately, the example you stated from their video was just one example. And while Benny (right) did say that there have been rip offs, Rafi (left) was still not clear on this entire thing works but at the same time he was saying that they are trademarking reaction videos. And he was lying, they are currently going after people with false DMCA take downs.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Somebody call VH1: "The Fine Bros" are trying to trademark "reaction videos"
- Thread starter Shao Kahn Brewing a Stew
- Start date
- Status
PdotMichael
Banned
Why is there a defence force for that?
I am baffled by it also even the youtube comments with a defence force is making me wonder even people can even think through how bad this all is.
From what I've seen they've gone after random people for what seems to be no discernible reason just because they had videos with react in the title.
I mean, there's also the fact someone posted about in YT comments regarding how they took down a channel that did a show called Seniors React- prior to them ever launching a Elder's React show.
I don't think there's a defense force right now (on GAF at least), but there is a misunderstanding. I'm super glad that some people on GAF are trying to explain this vague bullshit the Fine Bro$ are laying on us.
Proof of them stealing a show and attempting to pretty much erase the one they stole from off of the internet. Btw, this was years ago. These guys were already shady. And if they're still actively getting channels taken down-even ones that just have had videos with the word react in the title, then I find it very hard to believe their Note in the Update video.. If they're genuine here it's very odd that they have a history of getting channels taken down.....and have taken down videos upon videos even months and months ago. And that they somehow haven't 'reacted' til now to these actions.
Shao Kahn Brewing a Stew
Banned
Messofanego
Banned
And yet they've (company is Fullscreen Inc) filed takedowns of videos that haven't copied them.
And as you see above with Seniors React, they've taken their format wholesale from others before.
Not to mention that they've yet to explain what their format is.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3CMS9xnBRkc
This video was so close to whatever their format was that they got their fine bro brand painties in a bunch. Goddamn bros, what else falls under "your" format?
Azure Dream
Member
"But, just because we have, or might get, trademarks, doesn't mean we're going to run around and start taking down videos!"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rmLAj9iIfQk
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rmLAj9iIfQk
TsunamiOfSwagger
Member
I would like to see a video of something funny happening with someone "reacting" in this style they are trying to claim, with a lawyer watching them like this-
so they are essentially keeping a straight face throughout.
so they are essentially keeping a straight face throughout.
Napoleonthechimp
Member
Tyrone also posted a video about it claiming he's unsure as to what he has supposedly done, with the only possible thing being that he reacted to one of GradAUnderA's videos which he subsequently deleted after Akasan (who knows both) told him he didn't like it.
Well then I guess they are pretty shitty. 20k a day wtf
Messofanego
Banned
Look at how takedown-happy they sound if you dare to call your videos "Kids React".
Oh yeah they lost their shit about that Ellen video.
And Buzzfeed.
Oh yeah they lost their shit about that Ellen video.
And Buzzfeed.
Napoleonthechimp
Member
Too late already posted.
And Buzzfeed.
Only thing I find weird is the Tyrone made a video first, without knowing what Grade was going to say. I'm sure it has something to do with Akasan but it doesn't seem like Grade would get too petty over that.
BewareTheBatsie
Member
Buzzfeed do a ton of people react to something videos. More often than not they aren't even reacting to a video, but trying out food from a different country and other things. It's not a rip-off format just because they're a large scale website.
These guys are actively encouraging their subscribers to tell if they see anyone copying their format. Flagging these people could easily result in their channels being taken down.
Napoleonthechimp
Member
I was too eager to gloat in their misfortune as they are especially easy to dislike.
The word schadenfreude was invented specifically for moments like these.
That apology is basically the real life version of: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rDqatJPvOfk
Edit: Lmfao, still won't clarify what their "format" is. "Everything we do is our format". Wat.
Edit: Lmfao, still won't clarify what their "format" is. "Everything we do is our format". Wat.
BANNED
So they're fine with other reaction videos, but they're not okay with people doing it in "their format". What does that mean? What separates their videos from other reaction videos? The Buzzfeed and Ellen examples above don't even use the "Kids/Teens React" name, so what's the problem?
It's incredibly clear they're being intentionally vague :lol.
It seems as if they want to prevent identical video themes e.g Kids react to nineties music , elder react to gta etc, which I can understand but that line is extremely thin
-Plasma Reus-
Service guarantees member status
Apparently, their sub count is going down the drain real fast.
I mean, take or leave PewDiePie's output (and it's certainly not for me) but he seems to have remained pretty level-headed in spite of his massive success and lots of money.
Take their different approaches. A couple of weeks ago PewDiePie launched his own network, Revelmode, where he has cherry-picked a small group of YouTube "talents" to collaborate with focusing on high-quality output (in Youtube terms) and charitable fund-raising.
And he did all that without looking like a mercenary, money-grubbing lizard.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XpOSIjd433Q
And, as far as I'm aware, he doesn't issue DMCA takedowns on other YouTubers who act like idiots while playing videogames.
People are going to Streisand the fuck out of these guys lol. People are going to name their videos "Kids React to x" just to piss them off and dilute their "brand" even further.
If you want to watch it burn in real time, check out http://socialblade.com/youtube/user/thefinebros/realtime
If you want to watch it burn in real time, check out http://socialblade.com/youtube/user/thefinebros/realtime
It's a beautiful thing.
Messofanego
Banned
ayy
Also dem downvotes overseeing the likes it is magical.
Never change youtube comments.
captainnapalm
Member
It seems clear to me they're more interested in going after big fish who are looking to ape their exact formats. Not the random youtuber sitting on his bed reacting to stuff. None of these small time guys can really compete with the professional level of Finebros videos anyway. They're look at big media companies, tv companies etc.
And licensing their shows for use in other countries seems like a totally valid route to go.
The response here seems totally overblown.
And licensing their shows for use in other countries seems like a totally valid route to go.
The response here seems totally overblown.
If you look at the thread, it's clear it doesn't matter what they're interested in.
Fbh
Member
Honestly.... how is this even fucking legal?
Words and names are one thing, but "their format"? What the hell is their format?
I think some of their videos are fun but there is literally nothing unique or creative about the format. It's basically "show something to someone and then ask them questions about it".
They say they are fine with react videos as long as they don't follow the same format, but how the hell are you not going to same format when it's so basic.
It's like someone trying to trademark "interviews" claiming their format is "having a host asking questions to a guest about his profesional and or personal life" or having a game publisher trying to trademark "racing game" claiming their format is "taking part in a car race where the objective is to reach the end line before the other players"
What is their format? Showing things to kids and asking them questions about it? Might as well go and trademark the concept of asking questions on cammera then
Words and names are one thing, but "their format"? What the hell is their format?
I think some of their videos are fun but there is literally nothing unique or creative about the format. It's basically "show something to someone and then ask them questions about it".
They say they are fine with react videos as long as they don't follow the same format, but how the hell are you not going to same format when it's so basic.
It's like someone trying to trademark "interviews" claiming their format is "having a host asking questions to a guest about his profesional and or personal life" or having a game publisher trying to trademark "racing game" claiming their format is "taking part in a car race where the objective is to reach the end line before the other players"
What is their format? Showing things to kids and asking them questions about it? Might as well go and trademark the concept of asking questions on cammera then
He points out the obvious, but in a funny accent. It's why I enjoy his videos
captainnapalm
Member
Format is concept + branding. But the only way to really protect it is through copyright. So the way I see it they can't actually do anything about the Buzzfeed or Ellen examples in this thread, even though they may feel they're being copied. They can only really protect the names of their shows. Which is why they're trademarking the name of their channel, React. That doesn't mean you can't use the word react in the title of your video. I might be wrong though.
It's really funny when you think about how they're using other people's work in their videos and react to it. Now they want to license other people's work which is using other people work as well?! that's a new form of laziness.
There's a defence force for everything in the Internet.
There's a defence force for everything in the Internet.
Recent vid that they took down despite being a parody/fair use vid:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MHhHP_zCch0&ab_channel=LeKevPlays
And they took down a vid/channel a few years ago when that channel did a Elder react vid only for a few weeks later finebros to start doing an elder react vid as well.
https://www.reddit.com/r/videos/comments/43fdw3/seniors_react_originally_posted_apr_3_2012_was/
But they don't they take down vids/channels that do react vids oh wait...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MHhHP_zCch0&ab_channel=LeKevPlays
And they took down a vid/channel a few years ago when that channel did a Elder react vid only for a few weeks later finebros to start doing an elder react vid as well.
https://www.reddit.com/r/videos/comments/43fdw3/seniors_react_originally_posted_apr_3_2012_was/
But they don't they take down vids/channels that do react vids oh wait...
Messofanego
Banned
"You can't call a show 'Kids React' just like you can't call a show 'American Idol'"
PdotMichael
Banned
That's more or less the quintessence of internet humor.
Messofanego
Banned
Then why did they file a takedown of a LeKevPlays video with 8 views whose channel has only 10 subscribers?
People are blowing up one of their latest videos with trademark jokes.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2PHccYowfo4
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2PHccYowfo4
This is what I don't get as well, if they can get away with this, why not just protect prank videos, late night talk shows (or talk shows in general?!), tutorial videos, quiz shows etc. It really depends on the definition of a format, and the category of reaction videos is just way too broad in my opinion.
captainnapalm
Member
That's just a guy who is playing their video and talking over it. That's a totally separate issue. Their actual video is on the screen. As someone points out, it probably got immediately blocked because the Finebros' jingle is being played at the start or whatever.
Yet it's got hundreds of thousands of views now and is supposed to be evidence of what terrible money-grubbing jews these guys are. Go internet.
Really?
PdotMichael
Banned
No one has talked about them being Jewish? But they certainly are money grabbing.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked