• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

The Last of Us Pt II |OT| Oh Ellie...I think they should be terrified of you

Kagero

Member
Should I feel guilty about loving this game's story mostly? Some scenes are badly handled and writing can be mixed but overall I'm loving this game so much, more than I ever thought I would.
Why should you feel bad? Because some guys with an agenda of their own want you to? It’s an amazing game that should be celebrated for what it’s doing. It’s pushing the medium forward in all aspects.
 

DonJorginho

Banned
Why should you feel guilty? I feel the same as you pretty much.
Just I see so many people hating this game to kingdom come and people who love it on many public forums or comment sections and social media sites are getting hounded for it.

I very much feel like the minority, of course some scenes aren't well handled but overall the story still flows well enough and I'm liking the new characters, even Abby in some ways.
 

makaveli60

Member
so if being gay can only be a side note of a character does that mean they're not allowed a gay relationship in the game? I mean this is completely ignoring the idea that it's kind of offensive to imply a character being gay should only be a side note but even taking that in stride what's the conclusion if the main character is gay?
This is a very complex topic and I don't have the time or energy to properly answer you now and this is not the place for it either, but what I see is, the modern left is not about bringing us together and living in peace (though they hide behind this idea) with each other but rather about dividing us more and more based on certain aspects of people. And this game is following this destructive ideology, that is my problem.
 

Horatius

Member
Should I feel guilty about loving this game's story mostly? Some scenes are badly handled and writing can be mixed but overall I'm loving this game so much, more than I ever thought I would.
something having objective shortcomings doesn't mean people can't still like the thing

(just means you like trash :3)
 
This is a very complex topic and I don't have the time or energy to properly answer you now and this is not the place for it either, but what I see is, the modern left is not about bringing us together and living in peace (though they hide behind this idea) with each other but rather about dividing us more and more based on certain aspects of people. And this game is following this destructive ideology, that is my problem.
I mean I agree with that but I don't agree with the idea that someone's sexuality has to be a minimal part of their character.
 

DonJorginho

Banned
something having objective shortcomings doesn't mean people can't still like the thing

(just means you like trash :3)
That's just an opinion. I'm acknowledging serious shortcomings but this game as a complete product is still very good, even some of the biggest haters respect the gameplay, visuals, music, combat, level design, animations etc.

The story is still the biggest issue and that I agree on 100%, but for me aside from some scenes it is a good enough revenge plot, whether or not the end will deflate my good feelings for it will be seen.
 

makaveli60

Member
I mean I agree with that but I don't agree with the idea that someone's sexuality has to be a minimal part of their character.
But if you approach this thing from a Christian or Muslim or other religious background then promoting gayness is blasphemious. I mean, I accept if someone is gay and this is just a certain aspect of the person's character and otherwise is a decent person. Who cares then? But gayness is promoted in such in to your face blatant way nowadays in mainstream media that soon hetero people will be persecuted. I'm exaggerating of course but you get the point. And this makes me think, what's the point? If someone hates gays just for being gay this won't change it. So what I feel is, in reality this is a big fuck you to religious people and religion. And this is my problem with it. But as I said this is a much, much more complex topic so I just wanted to give you some idea.
 

sobaka770

Banned
This is a very complex topic and I don't have the time or energy to properly answer you now and this is not the place for it either, but what I see is, the modern left is not about bringing us together and living in peace (though they hide behind this idea) with each other but rather about dividing us more and more based on certain aspects of people. And this game is following this destructive ideology, that is my problem.

If you play the whole game you should be able to see quite clearly that the main overarching theme of this game is the exact opposite of what you claim left is preaching, it is in fact a questioning quite alongside yours. All SJW things in this game are not part of core themes, they are just things that exist in Western society and are depicted as such.
 
But if you approach this thing from a Christian or Muslim or other religious background then promoting gayness is blasphemious. I mean, I accept if someone is gay and this is just a certain aspect of the person's character and otherwise is a decent person. Who cares then? But gayness is promoted in such in to your face blatant way nowadays in mainstream media that soon hetero people will be persecuted. I'm exaggerating of course but you get the point. And this makes me think, what's the point? If someone hates gays just for being gay this won't change it. So what I feel is, in reality this is a big fuck you to religious people and religion. And this is my problem with it. But as I said this is a much, much more complex topic so I just wanted to give you some idea.
But what if it's not a message at all what if someone just genuinely wanted to write a story where the main characters were lesbians. I mean in China it's taboo to believe in ghosts and they won't put out movies that have ghosts in them does that mean any movie with a ghost is a big f*** you to China?
 

makaveli60

Member
If you play the whole game you should be able to see quite clearly that the main overarching theme of this game is the exact opposite of what you claim left is preaching, it is in fact a questioning quite alongside yours. All SJW things in this game are not part of core themes, they are just things that exist in Western society and are depicted as such.
Great, looking forward to see the whole picture. Though it will take some time because otherwise I'm astonished by the game and I'm checking out every last pixel of it :)
 

REE Machine

Banned
Non of those look like abby.

Do you notice how even those super muscular women still have breasts? Do you notice how their figure is still female? Men and women have different body proportions, abby has a completely male body.

It's weird.
Because they could be implants to look more symmetrical with the rest of their body, all those women are still buff as fuck so saying it cant happen is false
 

makaveli60

Member
But what if it's not a message at all what if someone just genuinely wanted to write a story where the main characters were lesbians. I mean in China it's taboo to believe in ghosts and they won't put out movies that have ghosts in them does that mean any movie with a ghost is a big f*** you to China?
No, that in itself is not the problem. And Ellie being gay is the least of the problems anyway, that in itself isn't a problem either actually. I hoped you might get my point but it seems I was unable to properly convey my message. That's why I said it's too complex to talk about this here and now.

Btw, it is so nice to see Ellie constantly smiling at a certain part of the game where I am now after a lot of pain, sadness and anger on her face.
 
Last edited:

shaddam

Member
Just finished the game. Really liked it. Tomorrow I will read the leaked spoilers because I dont understand the buthurtness. I will need some break, but after that I will try the new game+
 

Gamernyc78

Banned
This fucking story got me feeling all types of ways I was angry and sad not to long ago smh. I am really engulfed and loving the combat and story so far. This game is sublime. Those graphics 👀💦💦🔥
 

Gamernyc78

Banned
Just I see so many people hating this game to kingdom come and people who love it on many public forums or comment sections and social media sites are getting hounded for it.

I very much feel like the minority, of course some scenes aren't well handled but overall the story still flows well enough and I'm liking the new characters, even Abby in some ways.

I see the ass hats and pseudo political snowflakes but they are actually the minority. All I'm reading is mostly gushing and positivity about this game. This game is sooooo good and I'm loving the story so far.
 
Last edited:

REE Machine

Banned
This fucking story got me feeling all types of ways I was angry and sad not to long ago smh. I am really engulfed and loving the combat and story so far. This game is sublime. Those graphics 👀💦💦🔥
The combat isnt a step up i feel this is a fuckin leap up, to me this is what mgsv should have been. Fuck the massive open world, give a linesr story with some wide enrionments and god the dodge and prone in this game is so good, giving me those mgs feels, making me wish they made a the boss mgs game, because fuck this would be it
 

REE Machine

Banned
You shouldn’t feel bad about liking this piece of high literature that literally wants to end civilization by pushing its leftist progressive SJW agenda, no.
......
giphy.gif
 

PanzerAzel

Member
No. You craft the upgrades yourself at workbenches with the tool bits you find and literally watch them put together the piece or adjustment at the workbench.

It looks great and is super cool. The visual update stays on your person. Real similar to Tomb Raider.
Game’s legit gun porn. Love upgrading due to it, I only wish the gun models were in the model viewer and interactive.
Still early on in the game and I don’t think Abby is that unattractive at least face wise.

Dina on the other hand is all types of hideous. Who ok’d that design?
Dina’s borderline thicc, I’d hit that shit in a heartbeat though I’ve a thing for average looking women, so...

Abby is 💯 repugnant, though I think that’s mostly due to her male physique and tree trunk arms.
 

tassletine

Member
The problem with the theme of this game --that violence is bad -- is not that, that theme has been used a lot in videogames in the last five years, but that this is the wrong genre to do so.
The game is basically trying to justify how much violence is on screen by simultaneously showing it, and they trying to make you feel guilty about that.

When it was done before, Hotline Miami, Spec op and to some extent COD. These were purely first person shooters -- so you made some sort of pact with the developer: You want to shoot? Well this is what shooting entails.

But with the Last of Us 2, a lot of people didn't come here for the gore (I partly did admittedly) they came for the story. So to then twist that into a shallow moral lesson, which forces you to go on a revenge mission whether you like it or not, seems excessively cheap, not to say hectoring. It reminds me of the film Funny Games, purely because it takes such a moral high ground.
It seems like Naughty Dog have quite a bit of contempt for it's audience, and feel like they have to lecture them in some way, like they're actually not aware they're playing a videogame or can distance themselves from it.

So I'm left with the feeling that the developers, whilst trying to lecture us, actually lost sight of the target -- Not only are they not aware this anti war message is trite, but also they were dumb enough to not understand what made the original game so special.
Why, would you spend 7 years making a game that revels in violence if you thought violence was this bad?
Only if you were sanctimonious enough, and thought you were intellectually above others, would you have the gall to do such a thing. That's what I think.

It's such a superb game in so many ways, but it's message is so shallow, dumb and confused.
 

Gamernyc78

Banned
The combat isnt a step up i feel this is a fuckin leap up, to me this is what mgsv should have been. Fuck the massive open world, give a linesr story with some wide enrionments and god the dodge and prone in this game is so good, giving me those mgs feels, making me wish they made a the boss mgs game, because fuck this would be it
I enjoyed tlou 1 combat this as it was but this is evolved and better though. Even the movement feels good not some walking in quick sand bs. Didn't enjoy RDR2 before this game but even after this is just so much better imo.

I still can't believe I'm controlling my character in this gorgeous world. And I hvnt finished the game but again the story is gripping so fuck the Haters 💯😊
 

REE Machine

Banned
I enjoyed tlou 1 combat this as it was but this is evolved and better though. Even the movement feels good not some walking in quick sand bs. Didn't enjoy RDR2 before this game but even after this is just so much better imo.

I still can't believe I'm controlling my character in this gorgeous world. And I hvnt finished the game but again the story is gripping so fuck the Haters 💯😊
God dont get me started on those rdr2 defenders, ill need to take a golf club to my own head
 

tassletine

Member
Uh oh...

Didn't like the 2nd flashback with Joel & Ellie. To me, that was the time when Joel would tell Ellie the truth. She's a bit older, was always smart for her age & is asking the question. He would sit down & tell her. But the writers didn't want that & I can't help but wonder why. I've got a bad feeling about this.



Oh dear. This game is all kinds of ups & downs by the look of it. I just played through the first encounters with the WLF & it was fantastic.
The encounters are superb. I save at every turn just so I can go back and mess around.
 

rofif

Can’t Git Gud
The combat is very visceral and high tension. A little simple and cinematic to control but shooting someone in the face in the last moment from prone position is exhilarating.
The graphics are fantastic but the variety is lacking. Audio is amazing as expected.

The story is kinda forced and blatant about is statement. No, the bad guys are still bad no matter how much they retcon or humane then. The game still movies way to slow. Some cinematics say very little over extreme long, stretched runtime... It almost puts me to sleep. I like the game but just barely. It's just drawn out so far.
 

MiguelItUp

Member
My thoughts exactly if it had this games controls holy fuck!
I adored RDR2, personally. Had an issue with the pacing and controls, but everything else was amazing. I remember almost giving up on the game, pushed through and was beyond glad I did. But if the pacing and control issues weren't there, that would've been tight.
 

RedVIper

Banned
Why should you feel bad? Because some guys with an agenda of their own want you to? It’s an amazing game that should be celebrated for what it’s doing. It’s pushing the medium forward in all aspects.

The only thing it's pushing forward is graphics. And even then we've had very impressive games like RDR and Horizon.
 

Bartski

Gold Member
Watching the credits roll...
I really feel like I need a moment to collect myself.
Let me just say this: TLOU2 is an astonishing achievement of the gaming medium and will go down in history as nothing less.
A new benchmark for the action-adventure genre and interactive storytelling in general and it exceeded all my expectations for what the next game in the series could be.
Absolutely fucking jaw-dropping. I love my hobby.
 

Yoshichan

And they made him a Lord of Cinder. Not for virtue, but for might. Such is a lord, I suppose. But here I ask. Do we have a sodding chance?
What is even going on in this game... I’m 36 hours in and something happened that I think will expand the game with AT LEAST an additional 5 hours, wtf?!
 

RedVIper

Banned
What is even going on in this game... I’m 36 hours in and something happened that I think will expand the game with AT LEAST an additional 5 hours, wtf?!

How did you play a 20 hour game for 36 hours.

And if it is what I'm thinking about, no, it's dealt with surprisingly quickly.
 
Last edited:

Yoshichan

And they made him a Lord of Cinder. Not for virtue, but for might. Such is a lord, I suppose. But here I ask. Do we have a sodding chance?
How did you play a 20 hour game for 36 hours.

And if it is what I'm thinking about, no, it's dealt with surprisingly quickly.
I really have no idea, I’m exploring everything I can but I imagine many are doing the same... in 20 hours.
 

TissueBox

Member
Reached the second half, finalleh. With it proving some spoilers I thought were wrong as correct, I now am cry. Not because I don't like the direction the story's taking, but because I actually do, and would have not only liked it, but been verily mystified, if it were all a surprise coming at me for the first time here.

Where's the amnesia when ya need it..??

In any case, while the story may or may not buckle down on itself, as of right now, this second half far exceeds the first in terms of investment and 'feel'.

Writing is more colorful, and the story is moving in a more dense sequencing of events., as if it has actual footing. But, then again, the opening of the first had pretty much the same exact pressure points before turning a little thinned out.

Let's see if this holds down the fort.
 
I really have no idea, I’m exploring everything I can but I imagine many are doing the same... in 20 hours.

That's how you play that many hours. It took me like 6 hours to complete a single freaking day. I still missed some cards on that day. Viper doesn't know what he's talking about and is just going by what he reads elsewhere. Obvious troll baiting everyone in the thread.

Real talk this Platinum will easily take 60-70 hrs.
 
Last edited:

scalman

Member
And doing another round skipping some cinematics that could be sad at beggining and enjoying my upgraded guns and made slow mo on aiming this time,wanna see how it feels. Yes gameplay very enjoyable even to play it again.
 

Cha

Member
I've played for about 8 hours now. I'm in Seattle. Taking it slow. Here are some thoughts:
Not a fan of the writing so far. Feels like Left behind dlc with a big dramatic event to set a plot in motion. It's still early though, and I hope there is more depth and focus later on.
The gameplay feels smoother than the original. Simple additions like a dodge, and better platforming makes areas fun to explore.
The new clicker sounds almost made me sh#t my pants. Was NOT expecting that velociraptor shit.
Actually showing how your guns get modified blew my mind a little.
The Dr. Uckmann card made me cringe.
Playing on base ps4, but it looks great.

Unfortunately, I think I got spoiled about something to do with the main villian (a youtuber just blurted out a detail about them like it wasn't gonna affect anything - but it was a pretty "unusual" detail imo). So, as much as I am enjoying the gameplay, my mind is constantly forcing what I already know into the plot and trying to piece things together. I can only hope that the actual story and writing delivers enough depth to make what I know irrelevant.
Overall, a good experience so far though.
 

Shrap

Member
I'm a few hours in now and I've seen a few other people say if RDR2 controlled like this it would've been much better - I completely agree. The difference in responsiveness and accuracy is night and day. Even basic interaction are so much easier and faster. The controls never inhibit you or slow you down unlike RDR2. It also looks better in motion since you aren't stumbling around your campfire to drink some coffee or circling a hitching pole on your horse like a dumbass.

Really enjoying the game. The way areas open up and allow for more exploration is a huge improvement over the first game. I love exploring in games but hate getting bogged down with filler and emptiness so this is the perfect middle ground for me.
 
Last edited:

Dr. Claus

Vincit qui se vincit
That's how you play that many hours. It took me like 6 hours to complete a single freaking day. I still missed some cards on that day. Viper doesn't know what he's talking about and is just going by what he reads elsewhere. Obvious troll baiting everyone in the thread.

Real talk this Platinum will easily take 60-70 hrs.

No. It takes about 25-30 hours. There are a number of guides out there that will make it even faster than that.

I missed a few collectibles in my first playthrough which took about 20-ish hours. Grabbed them in about 2 hours and all I have to do now is grind half the game for the few upgrades that I didn't get (as you can't upgrade everything in a single run). If you have a manual save before the final chapter you can go back to any chapter and grab the missing collectibles.
 
Top Bottom