• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Video game art/designs that just upset you.

dancer1-610x786dpsm1.jpg

typical bad JRPG design.

Design wise, there's nothing wrong here, it's actually quite good. It's just jarring because they put it on someone who is clearly 12.

I mean this isn't chibi style where the proportions of a woman are reduced in scale for the sake of a consistent style, this girl is just 12, the purpose of this outfit is to ogle a 12 year old.

But that outfit on an adult though...yeah, I'm with it.
 
Perhaps the worst character design I've seen in a Final Fantasy game.

Definitely agree with Vaan.
That Final Fantasy was the only I've played that I enjoyed though.



Like others in this thread have said, really not a fan of the generic Gears of War-esque western character design.
 
Lol, what is she supposed to put in those tiny pouches? Her nipple piercings?

I know man, nothing makes sense in this Sonya design. A policewoman costume that is wide open in the chest? Not even bulletproof implants would save her from being shot in the middle of the chest. This, the pockets, the too many bangs, the mouth, the physics on the collar/dog tags (shouldn't they be tending towards the side she is?)... it's just a fucking mess.
 
Quiet from the MGS game that is coming out eventually. To tell the truth though, she doesn't bug me near as much as people's reactions when you pointed out how ridiculous her outfit was and that it's a little annoying it's so obviously done for fan service. The fan reactions to daring to say anything bad plus the fact I just couldn't get into MGS 2 has really turned me off of the series entirely honestly. I know it's a little unfair to have fan reaction turn me off a game (cause it can't help that really) but it just left a bad taste in my mouth.

Also, I cannot get into a lot of character designs from Dragon's Crown. It almost turned me off from getting the game. It's a fun game but some of the designs still bug me. I honestly can't even play the sorcerer cause her huge and exagerated boobs that look like they hang from one little piece of flesh look disgusting and I hate looking at her when playing so I avoid any sorcerer characters entirely. I also really don't like the female barbarian design either. I know the game has exaggerated art design, I just really can't get into the art design.

Edit: Hey look, the post below illustrates exactly what I mean (if they made her like that servant girl it wouldn't be near as bad and I could be ok with it though honestly if you can't tell it does bug me when they treat female characters as just objects to ogle at. But at least it would be visually appealing. The sorcerer's boobs look like they want to just pop off cause barely anything is holding them to her body, it's gross).
 
Eugh Kill me now, furry anime shit. And JRPG character design in general.

WHATISTHAT-570x320.jpg


The voices were even worse.

Also every character in Mass Effect looks terrible and never improved over the games.
 
This Last of Us infected design. Good thing it didn't make it into the full game.
http://www.kotaku.co.uk/2014/05/23/last-us-nearly-went-full-thing

Blob-Monster-1200-620x349.jpg

I've never seen this before. It's terrifying. In a good way.

To me, not using this design is now one of the the worst creative decisions in modern gaming.


I think it was smart to drop it, especially since the infected weren't the focus of the story but a means to an end. It wasn't a creature feature, and they kept it a bit more focused by not creating all these weird beasts.

Which is surprising seeing how Uncharted wasn't as reserved and threw some curve balls to their worlds believability in the final chapters.
 
I can't see Vaan has the worst Final Fantasy character design, especially when we have freaking Nooj:
Nooj.jpg


God, that is the most embarrassing design I've ever seen in a video game.

Absolutely. None of the FFXII designs strike me as terrible, at the very least they all look homogenous and consistent – they work in their environment.

This Nooj guy though? Easily one of Nomura's worst (and I say this as a Nomura fan).
 
My personal choice is:
tumblr_inline_mg4csdH56U1r81par.gif

His lips bothered me the entire game. His pale face and eyes remind me of Michael Jackson. Why Nintendo?
tumblr_inline_mg4cvrtMLB1r81par.gif

That stupid face.
tumblr_magrohAgcy1rtkss6o1_500.gif

WHHHY!?
Nintendo employ 1: How do we make Zelda relevant in Japan?

Nintendo employ 2: Animu!

Nintendo employ 3: Yes, but what about our target-audience in the west?

Nintendo employ 4: Justin Bieber!
 
That ankle funnel guy is seriously the absolute worst. Holy shit, I'm at a loss of words at how overdesigned that crap is.



This stuff is obviously also beyond garbage. Worse though, this one in particular reminds me of that anime Suisei no Gargantia which I felt pretty meh about overall anyways but I couldn't believe how blatant the fucking fan service in there was.



The main female character (and her friends for that matter) even did some ridiculous belly dancing in one episode and damn, the whole art style is so... urgh. This kind of red glow on their shoulders and checks which is like some kind of perma-rouge. Even if I felt like the anime executed well on the kind of story it tried to tell (which had some very serious and somewhat interesting ideas) I couldn't take it seriously when you constantly get huge tits or half-naked characters shoved in your face and they even do 1-2 fanservice episodes right in the middle. Just what the fuck.

Seriously, search for the belly dancing scene and tell me that's not just creepy considering they're like 15 or sth, belly dancing for an audience consisting to a large degree of grown up men.

Naruko Hanaharu, the main character designer of Suisei no Gargantia is a famous (maybe notorious for you) hentai manga artist, what else do you want from him? This is how Japanese anime industry working in reality, they really have a decent job for a hentai manga artist, and his name could attract more otaku audience.

Things like "Mature audience will never accept Japanese artists sexualize little girls/underage/youngsters/female characters" is a very weak social justice agenda. If our communist government taught me anything about social justice, it's about social justice is the worst thing on this planet, it's basically nothing but admit how weak your culture/law/national strength is. If you want to achieve social justice, you make a law to forbid, you take the dispute land by force, you arrest hentai manga artists across national boundaries and put them in your jail, in this way you can tell the world "this is fucking bad and should go to hell", this is how social justice being served, not using agendas to encourage censorship or witch hunt.

If America can make laws to anti such sexualiztion in ACG world, that will be respected, and there will be no Japanese game dev/anime artist dare to show these to their honorable foreign audience again. Kojima will change Quite's design, Kamitani could never make that fanservice, and Suisei no Gargantia won't give Naruko Hanaharu any job. If this is what you want, that's how to achieve it, acting like "I am such a sane mature human being, I know how bad this is, you guys who enjoy and support this are silly perverts" won't help at all.
 
i would actually, gotta get me some of that hunky snake yo

as for the thread um

0aff1ffdb25ef1f3104bf8a685330356.png


new wolfenstein looks good as a game but i don't like the character designs at all especially the male ones, awfully generic and "sculpted"

You do realize that the entire point of his being perfectly sculpted and handsome and stuff is because he's supposed to be the perfect Aryan type of individual that the Nazis are looking for, and yet he hates the Nazis. It plays into the story, actually, and characters comment on his distinctly Aryan features (solid build, blonde hair, blue eyes, muscular physic, solid deep voice). It has a purpose in the story.
 
Yuji Himukai is a good artist.
He can draw feet just fine, this isn't Liefeld we're talking about here.
The thing is, since the characters in EO are just static portraits, he tends to warp their anatomy to make them more dynamic:

Anyway, 6 pages without this monstrosity, GAF is slipping.
Legitimately greatest downgrade in art/design in the entire history of video games.
 
Eugh Kill me now, furry anime shit. And JRPG character design in general.

WHATISTHAT-570x320.jpg


The voices were even worse.

Also every character in Mass Effect looks terrible and never improved over the games.

Dude, stop with the bolded shit. It's not furry. Furry is sexual. I hate furry, and other than random stuff I see some of the time, I hate anime. But that is not furry.

The voices could have been better, but they could have been a lot worse.
 
To be fair, some kind of belly dance dresses are suppose to be like this.

There's also some one live in Iran think this is bad and should be prohibited.

http://www.globalpost.com/sites/default/files/imagecache/gp3_slideshow_large/iran_female_ninjas.jpg
And this is the result.

hey man, I'm not saying this should be banned, I'm saying it's stupid and pointless. The only reason its exposed is because it can be, thats just shoddy workmanship. But i guess if naked 12 year olds float your boat who am I to judge.
 
Yuji Himukai is a good artist.

He can draw feet just fine, this isn't Liefeld we're talking about here.

The thing is, since the characters in EO are just static portraits, he tends to warp their anatomy to make them more dynamic:

I own several of his artbooks and when I hear someone complaining about Yuji Himukai, I just can't.

He's so good:

Also with Castlevania, I agree... the art was so beautiful before.
 
Dude, stop with the bolded shit. It's not furry. Furry is sexual. I hate furry, and other than random stuff I see some of the time, I hate anime. But that is not furry.

The voices could have been better, but they could have been a lot worse.

Looks the same to me, no need to get so bent out of shape over furry animals human things that look shit.
 
hey man, I'm not saying this should be banned, I'm saying it's stupid and pointless. The only reason its exposed is because it can be, thats just shoddy workmanship. But i guess if naked 12 year olds float your boat who am I to judge.

I don't think you understand what this means.

Whether you personally like something or not has little to no bearing on its "workmanship". You can say "I don't like this naked belly dancying 12 year old loli and object to it from a moral standpoint", but you can't extrapolate that to "he's a bad/shoddy artist". That's not how it works, or else any artist can be "shoddy" from the perspective of a certain person, which is just ridiculous and dilutes the meaning of "shoddy".
 
I don't think you understand what this means.

Whether you personally like something or not has little to no bearing on its "workmanship". You can say "I don't like this naked belly dancying 12 year old loli and object to it from a moral standpoint", but you can't extrapolate that to "he's a bad/shoddy artist". That's not how it works, or else any artist can be "shoddy" from the perspective of a certain person, which is just ridiculous and dilutes the meaning of "shoddy".

it's shoddy because it doesn't fit with any traditional garb, it's shoddy because that type of clothing exposes the leg, and it makes the clothing less fit, which, if you're using a sword, would be problematic, it's shoddy because it's unnecessary, it's shoddy because it produces needless amount of work, requiring you to make extra art for underwear, it's shoddy because it looks bad and is unflattering for any character. Thats why its shoddy. It's bad design direction, plain and simple. You can disagree with my opinion all you want, but I stand by the fact that it's poor design work. He might be a great artist, i have no idea, I never said he was bad or good, but that this work in particular is shoddy workmanship.

Also as a gay man, i dont like having pussy shoved in my face, loli or not.
 
Dude, stop with the bolded shit. It's not furry. Furry is sexual. I hate furry, and other than random stuff I see some of the time, I hate anime. But that is not furry.

The voices could have been better, but they could have been a lot worse.

Furry is not sexual. Those designs count as furry, but that doesn't mean they are bad.
 
I own several of his artbooks and when I hear someone complaining about Yuji Himukai, I just can't.

He's so good:


Also with Castlevania, I agree... the art was so beautiful before.

how is that good? It's incredibly difficult to read, visual noise with little to no depth, high contrast art with lines constantly crossing planes in various manners. I get that its probably from an action scene so the artist is trying to evoke some sense of chaos but restraint is also necessary to ensure visible fidelity and readability.
 
Every JRPG getup ever.
It's either one of 3 things that bother me:
1. Chibi art design
2. Little kids that wearing rather revealing crap (Creepy as hell too)
3. Pineapple hair shit like this:
9-270px-SOM_Randi.jpg

(granted, this is not a bad design, but I just can't stand it)
 
I'm glad people posted Nooj and the Gears of War guys. Just awful designs that never fail to make me sigh and shake my head. IMO, they're perfect examples of their respective camps (and why designs like them need to be avoided like the plague).

One character design I'd like to call out is Bayonetta. She looks dreadful. I've read that her designer based her off of fashion sketches, but that does little to change my opinion of the work she did. Bayonetta is ridiculously gangly, and this is especially obvious in promotional material where she strikes a wide-legged stance with a katana. What makes matters worse is that her hips and torso are relatively wide, while her head is tiny (and the cone of hair makes it seem even smaller).

After that there's a host of smaller things that bug me about the design: The crescent moon-shaped boob window, the flowers and other embellishments in the skintight outfit, the hair sleeves, etc...

I have no problem with the character herself, but her design is overwrought and tacky.
 
Top Bottom