Gary Whitta
Member
Yeah. Recently I asked someone in a good position to know what games I should get and his answer was clear: Forza and KI. Ryse, not so much.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Xbox One review embargoes lift Nov 19th (Tuesday 9PM PT/12AM EST)
- Thread starter shinobi602
- Start date
BronsonLee
Member
That sounds about right. I'd put Forza and KI in a dead heat. They're both pretty phenomenal.
Sounds about right from what I played in August.
I have spent a lot of time with KI. About an hour with a tournament player on one of the two stick stations they had. I really enjoyed my time with it.
Canis lupus
Member
Forza a clear 9
Killer Instinct mostly 7-8
DR3 mostly 7
Ryse mostly 6
Killer Instinct mostly 7-8
DR3 mostly 7
Ryse mostly 6
FUNKNOWN iXi
Member
Ryse will have so much more depth than Knack, not to mention longer legs thanks to the co-op arenas.
IdreamofHIME
Member
I don't know how Crytek done fucked up Ryse. The Crysis games are hardly the most groundbreaking in gameplay, but they were pretty solid and quite fun.
StoppedInTracks
Member
I have a feeling Ryse will score between 5 and 6.
shinobi602
Member
True! I'll edit it.
KefkaPalazzo
Member
If we're making predictions for review scores...
Ryse - Upper 60's
Dead Rising 3 - Low to mid 80's
Killer Instinct - Low to mid 80's
Forza - Mid to high 80's
Ryse - Upper 60's
Dead Rising 3 - Low to mid 80's
Killer Instinct - Low to mid 80's
Forza - Mid to high 80's
ps4 lineup lost itself alone..without any need to be fighted....
the launch lineup was "so so" from the start and after been revealed was worst than that "so so" everyone was expecting
Zatoichi's Cane
Member
Polygon gave it 10/10.
BronsonLee
Member
Those are terrible and they should not have put them in. Or at the very least not led their public demos with it.
the thing that seems to kill it, other than the factual shallowness of its combat engine, is the lack of variety. Most previews I've read usually issue scathing indictments over how they literally never mix anything up, it's not like God of War where you're also solving puzzles and traversing massive platforming obstacle courses. It's just being shuttled from one combat arena to the next, with the occasional skint into broader combat scenes involving an army, and since the combat itself is so shallow, it seems it's not enough incentive.
If previews are to be believed, anyway.
LOL if true. Oh man I hope it is true.
Deadly Joker
Member
Ryan from IGN will give it at least an 8.5.
gamechanger87
Member
Goodacre0081
Member
the actual button prompts are gone but now the bodies light up according to the buttons green, red, yellow, blue.
Ray Wonder
Founder of the Wounded Tagless Children
Predictions:
Ryse: Ranging from 5's to Polygon's 9.
DR3: 8.3
Forza: 9
Killer Instinct: 8
Lococycle: 7.4
Power* Golf: 7.7
Ryse: Ranging from 5's to Polygon's 9.
DR3: 8.3
Forza: 9
Killer Instinct: 8
Lococycle: 7.4
Power* Golf: 7.7
Ryse? Played it at Gamescom and thought it sucked.
Is that a new Indie title from MS?
Rice, Rise, Ryse there's no difference. It's like Crytek can't live without that "y" in their gametitles and I refuse to call it R*se! Why are they doing this?! Is this supposed to be funny? AAH!!!
Which one of those will rate higher than Resogun?
ouch
The combat system is terrible.
Resogun cleared that bar pretty easily. So technically if we are comparing they'll need two.
But comparing subjective reviews is pretty pointless isn't it? Either set of earlier adopters don't care about reviews. It's take the gloss off - but we are still going to be buy those pesky beauties are we not? The second and third wave it was really matters. Sony and MS better have good software coming soon.
I'd also suggest that possessing zero indies at launch is a huge oversight. When the dry spell comes - and it will - I'll be looking to indies to fill my needs.
Back to the launch wars:
Killer Instinct may be that second title when I think about it. I saw it yesterday up close and it looks very pretty - I wonder about the depth though seems like a tried and tested brawler. Perhaps that's a good thing.
In the grand scheme I don't think either launch line-up is head and shoulders over the other. I know many gamers who can't stand Forza or racing games. Which leaves very few stand out options - except for Resogun. But then I love that game and so should we all!
(RESOGUN AD ENDS)
Link?
resogun is an indie free game....isnt an aaa....is fun and thats it isnt a "colossal" u cant compare a 9 of forza with a 9 of resogun
I'm comparing it to Crimson Dragon and Zoo Tycoon.
I think DR3 will be mid 70s if the performance is as bad as DF made it sound like.
I think DR3 will be mid 70s if the performance is as bad as DF made it sound like.
It is so they can hype people up who read the review while waiting in line.
Probably
BlackBuzzard
Banned
Press x to awesome the game, Ryse looks like the most shallow game out of both lineups.
King Allant
Member
BloodMoney
Banned
Ryse... with a review embargo like that it's more likely to fall.
Delusibeta
Banned
I suspect that they're going to get hit with complaints about little content, and considering that there's only 14 tracks and the smallest amount of cars available in the series thus far, that would appear to be valid (especially considering GT6 is on the horizon with more than twice the tracks and apparently twice the Premium cars).
Majmun
Member
BloodMoney
Banned
Dude! Next-gen Ben Hur style chariot racing... road rash style... would be epic.god it would had been so great for the game if there was chariot racing in the game
BlackBuzzard
Banned
and at the same time th ebest graphics of both ...this is sad
Yeah... No.
soundscream
Member
See Forza 2