• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Cabin in The Woods - April 13th - Best horror film in years?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I need 2 Prequels stat

1 of how the monsters were captured/came to be, almost ghostbusters/monster squad type movie

Then when the industrial complex was set-up and their first try, also show all the other nations that FAIL!, with what they got owned by LOL

These are both horrible ideas.

There's no possible way to make sequels - even though they will - because they covered every possible base that they possibly could with this film. They didn't leave any horror trope unscathed.

Clearly some people want exactly what the movie was satirizing.

Which is why people left my theater so angry.
 

Diseased Yak

Gold Member
Watched it on opening day. As a life-long fan of horror, and a reviewer of obscure/odd horror movies for years now, I loved every freakin' minute of it. I thought I was going to have to have plastic surgery to remove my smile upon leaving the theater. Best movie I've seen in a decade, easily.

My one gripe, and something I was hoping for once I realized what the ending was going to be, is they dropped the ball imo by not having (ending spoilers)
the 'angry god' be Cthulhu popping out at the end, somehow. I was soooo ready for a squid-headed god from beyond time to emerge, instead we get a ashy, fire-streaked hand right out of God of War. It was cool, but not nearly as cool as it could have been. But then, I have a half-sleeve tattoo of Cthulhu, so I may be biased.
 

Sinatar

Official GAF Bottom Feeder
My one gripe, and something I was hoping for once I realized what the ending was going to be, is they dropped the ball imo by not having (ending spoilers)
the 'angry god' be Cthulhu popping out at the end, somehow. I was soooo ready for a squid-headed god from beyond time to emerge, instead we get a ashy, fire-streaked hand right out of God of War. It was cool, but not nearly as cool as it could have been. But then, I have a half-sleeve tattoo of Cthulhu, so I may be biased.

Yea I was expecting like an eyeball covered tentacle or some other eldritch horror.
 

Misfits

Neo Member
Watched it on opening day. As a life-long fan of horror, and a reviewer of obscure/odd horror movies for years now, I loved every freakin' minute of it. I thought I was going to have to have plastic surgery to remove my smile upon leaving the theater. Best movie I've seen in a decade, easily.

My one gripe, and something I was hoping for once I realized what the ending was going to be, is they dropped the ball imo by not having (ending spoilers)
the 'angry god' be Cthulhu popping out at the end, somehow. I was soooo ready for a squid-headed god from beyond time to emerge, instead we get a ashy, fire-streaked hand right out of God of War. It was cool, but not nearly as cool as it could have been. But then, I have a half-sleeve tattoo of Cthulhu, so I may be biased.

i agree with this, it was a brilliant movie. i'm looking forward to whatever next drew goddard puts out next.

i fully agree about the ending too, i was very
letdown they didn't go with cthulhu or snother elder god, to see a giant hand that looked right out of wrath of the titans was disappointing.
 

Parallax

best seen in the classic "Shadow of the Beast"
I need 2 Prequels stat

1 of how the monsters were captured/came to be, almost ghostbusters/monster squad type movie

Then when the industrial complex was set-up and their first try, also show all the other nations that FAIL!, with what they got owned by LOL

so something like 13 ghosts...except not lame.
 

Iceman

Member
Is there a list of all the tropes covered/deconstructed by cabin? I'm not a horror expert and I'm genuinely curious. The audience I was with laughed hard at a couple of scenes and I think they went clear over my head. Loved the rest though. The actual horror bits were pretty strong (to me, I'm a wuss in the theater - hence why I don't see many horror movies).. but it was a really funny movie.
 
i agree with this, it was a brilliant movie. i'm looking forward to whatever next drew goddard puts out next.

i fully agree about the ending too, i was very
letdown they didn't go with cthulhu or snother elder god, to see a giant hand that looked right out of wrath of the titans was disappointing.

This didn't bother me, actually. Lovecraftian horror is a fairly recent invention in the grand scheme of things. The concept of massive, evil humanoids roaming the earth is much older.
 

Misfits

Neo Member
This didn't bother me, actually. Lovecraftian horror is a fairly recent invention in the grand scheme of things. The concept of massive, evil humanoids roaming the earth is much older.

i didn't know that. it makes sense then, but it would have been something else to see it. the whole movie was
about playing up to the cliches of horror movies that i thought they might do something radical at the end and go with something that hasn't been done before.

i hope they do a sequel that picks up a events a few months later or as others mentioned, a prequel would be good too.
 
This didn't bother me, actually. Lovecraftian horror is a fairly recent invention in the grand scheme of things. The concept of massive, evil humanoids roaming the earth is much older.
That and its possible there could be other ancients that look different; the one that lives under North America could just happen to be a big dude.

Either way it didn't bother me, I still thought the ending was bad ass.
 

big ander

Member
i hope they do a sequel that picks up a events a few months later or as others mentioned, a prequel would be good too.

How would this even be possible? Everything, literally EVERYTHING, was annihilated.

Making a sequel to this betrays the entire point of the film. Stop.
 

Misfits

Neo Member
How would this even be possible? Everything, literally EVERYTHING, was annihilated.

Making a sequel to this betrays the entire point of the film. Stop.

i assumed based on what was revealed that
people would eventually stop the gods again and being anew with the sacrifices after the destruction. i do see what you mean though, i just want to see big giant gods wrecking stuff and maybe more of the angry molesting tree.
 

Vagabundo

Member
These are both horrible ideas.

There's no possible way to make sequels - even though they will - because they covered every possible base that they possibly could with this film. They didn't leave any horror trope unscathed.



Which is why people left my theater so angry.

Valiant resistance against the Ancients? Giant monster movie tropes?

Something sent the Ancients to sleep the first time. They could make a sequel about that.
 

Misfits

Neo Member
Valiant resistance against the Ancients? Giant monster movie tropes?

Something sent the Ancients to sleep the first time. They could make a sequel about that.


thats what i thought. they
wasn't there something about them failing to appease the giant gods in 1998 as well? it wasnt referenced more than once, but it sounded like they had failed at least once or twice in the past.
 
thats what i thought. they
wasn't there something about them failing to appease the giant gods in 1998 as well? it wasnt referenced more than once, but it sounded like they had failed at least once or twice in the past.

That was the last time the American office didn't come through, it wasn't a global failure

The fact that it has (supposedly) never happened before is an important aspect of the social commentary
 
Saw this last night. My god.

When that Merman came crawling out of the mist, the movie went from being "great" to "perfect".

My favorite movie in years.
 

Misfits

Neo Member
That was the last time the American office didn't come through, it wasn't a global failure

The fact that it has (supposedly) never happened before is an important aspect of the social commentary

oh right. i really need to see this again as its obvious i didn't pick up on a lot of the subtext and commentary. i was just so into it, it's such an enjoyable movie. it's been a long long time since i enjoyed a movie as much as this.
 
Saw this last night. My god.

When that Merman came crawling out of the mist, the movie went from being "great" to "perfect".

My favorite movie in years.

Best scene in the movie by far

Except maybe the unicorn

oh right. i really need to see this again as its obvious i didn't pick up on a lot of the subtext and commentary. i was just so into it, it's such an enjoyable movie. it's been a long long time since i enjoyed a movie as much as this.

Didn't catch it 'til my second view either ;)

My friend was like "wait what?" But when you know what is going to happen it's transparent.
 

big ander

Member
Look, I'm not saying it's impossible to find a way to write a sequel out of that story. I'm saying doing so would be against the entire point of every single facet of the film.

So: no.
 
Valiant resistance against the Ancients?

Then it's just an action/horror film.

Giant monster movie tropes?

Something sent the Ancients to sleep the first time. They could make a sequel about that.

The entire point of the film was to skewer the current state of horror films as a whole.

How would any of those work?

Seriously, I'm not trying to be an ass here or anything, but the entire point of the movie was to comment on where the horror genre is now. It was not to satirize anything else. They didn't go "hey, let's make a horror film that satirizes other horror films". They were not satirizing one specific subgenre. They had a very clear idea that they wanted to convey:
that the current generation of horror films are shit, and to a lesser extent, we're shit for glorifying death
.

It was a message movie.

I don't see how you can have a sequel to a message movie.
 

MIMIC

Banned
I wasn't all that into the movie until the 2nd half. I kept going,
"Wait a minute....why is everyone being killed off so early?"
 
Best scene in the movie by far

Except maybe the unicorn



Didn't catch it 'til my second view either ;)

My friend was like "wait what?" But when you know what is going to happen it's transparent.

Yes. Yes. The noble, mystical tune that played during the
unicorn mauling
made it all the more special.

It was a message movie.

I don't see how you can have a sequel to a message movie.
I swear to god, if anyone gives this movie a shitty sequel/prequel I'll be inconsolable.
 
Direct-to-DVD, baby. It's going to be one of those things you don't know about until it's been out for two years.

This actually wouldn't bother me because I could just go right on pretending it doesn't exist.

If it gets slasher'd and turns into a big convoluted logical black hole of a back story
...well. That would be different.
 
I might be thinking about the subtext too literally, but
if the gods (us) get angry and destroy the world when their demands are not met, isn't the takeaway that when everything is rebooted, the company (filmmakers) needs to make sure the same demands are met in order to not upset the gods again? If the gods were tired with the current crop of victims, they'd react by getting angry when they keep getting the same thing, not when it fails to happen.
 
I might be thinking about the subtext too literally, but
if the gods (us) get angry and destroy the world when their demands are not met, isn't the takeaway that when everything is rebooted, the company (filmmakers) needs to make sure the same demands are met in order to not upset the gods again? If the gods were tired with the current crop of victims, they'd react by getting angry when they keep getting the same thing, not when it fails to happen.

That's why filmmakers have to keep upping the ante constantly. "Remember when you could just throw a girl in a volcano?" If we believe everything the office crew is telling us (and I'm not sure that we should), these tropes have developed out of a need to keep the gods (the audience?) entertained, and that has translated into bigger, more gruesome spectacles of violence on screen over the years

This works better if you think of the gods as the audience, not the studios.
 
So you guys don't want to see
Cabin in the Woods Origins: Merman
?

They could make 15 and I'd watch them all

Also I would love to know

Exactly what was in the cellar and what it related to, I only caught a couple:

Music box - creepy faceless ballerina
Shell - kickass merman
Mask - strangers people
Diary - redneck zombie torture family
Puzzle ball - hell raiser guy
Necklace - some bride zombie?

Also the painting of the girl that looked like patience do we presume that was also for the rednecks? Reminded me of the creepy kid from a film I saw but couldn't place it, the kid has pyscich powers and makes bad stuff happen is all I remember

Edit: the film is case 39 and holy shit it was the same girl, I thought it was from the painting in the cellar
 
Also the painting of the girl that looked like patience do we presume that was also for the rednecks? Reminded me of the creepy kid from a film I saw but couldn't place it, the kid has pyscich powers and makes bad stuff happen is all I remember

Edit: the film is case 39 and holy shit it was the same girl, I thought it was from the painting in the cellar

There were so many direct references in that film to other horror films.
 
Stupid movie. Not even a horror, more of a comedy. If you have been watching horror's for 40 years and this is a fresh twist on things then I can understand. Otherwise, no.
 
Stupid movie. Not even a horror, more of a comedy. If you have been watching horror's for 40 years and this is a fresh twist on things then I can understand. Otherwise, no.

The film is directly satirizing the current crop of horror that popped up in the late 90s and has only snowballed. You're like one of my hallmates in college that hated Adult Swim because the references were old.

Humor is humor.
 
When I went to bed last night I couldnt stop thinking about it, one more dumb question that I think I missed

Do we know anything about the monsters? Any hints? Are they real or created by the lab?
 
When I went to bed last night I couldnt stop thinking about it, one more dumb question that I think I missed

Do we know anything about the monsters? Any hints? Are they real or created by the lab?

They're real and created by the emanations from the Old Gods. "They're not made from nightmares, nightmares are made from them".
 
Watched it on opening day. As a life-long fan of horror, and a reviewer of obscure/odd horror movies for years now, I loved every freakin' minute of it. I thought I was going to have to have plastic surgery to remove my smile upon leaving the theater. Best movie I've seen in a decade, easily.

My one gripe, and something I was hoping for once I realized what the ending was going to be, is they dropped the ball imo by not having (ending spoilers)
the 'angry god' be Cthulhu popping out at the end, somehow. I was soooo ready for a squid-headed god from beyond time to emerge, instead we get a ashy, fire-streaked hand right out of God of War. It was cool, but not nearly as cool as it could have been. But then, I have a half-sleeve tattoo of Cthulhu, so I may be biased.

My EXACT thoughts when I finished the movie. But LOVED every part of the film. One of the best films I've seen this year, if not the best.
 

big ander

Member
Sequels about
all the different monsters wouldn't make much sense either (and yes I know some of you are joking) because the point was that they're mostly monsters we've seen before. And then, even with stuff like the Merman, the point the film tried to make is that an idea isn't good just because it's never been done. The Merman ended up being hurtful.
Stupid movie. Not even a horror, more of a comedy. If you have been watching horror's for 40 years and this is a fresh twist on things then I can understand. Otherwise, no.
Again: it can be both. Genre hybridity isn't a new thing.

To be fair, TBWP did have an open-ended universe. I'm surprised it didn't have a nod in the film.
That is weird, isn't it? It didn't even need to have a BWP nod, just anything about found footage would have been pretty appropriate.
 

Voidguts

Member
saw this last night and absolutely loved it. I almost want to go see it again, and I never, ever do that. probably my favorite horror movie since Trick 'r Treat.
 
To be fair, TBWP did have an open-ended universe. I'm surprised it didn't have a nod in the film.

I'd say BW's nod comes in the form of the setting. A nod to just about any horror flick set in the deep and scary woods.

You're right, though.
This movie leaves no room for sequels - the world has ended, period
. Really the only route they have would be prequels, which would probably just pull every trick the original pulled and contain no surprises.
 
I'm also a bit surprised, especially given Whedon's involvement, there weren't any
overt torture porn references, like Saw or Hostel. Maybe there was one on the monitors and I missed it. Seems like a missed opportunity. Maybe they wanted to restrict the monsters to sentient creatures.
 
I'd say BW's nod comes in the form of the setting. A nod to just about any horror flick set in the deep and scary woods.

That cabin is confirmed to be a remake of the Evil Dead cabin.

I'm also a bit surprised, especially given Whedon's involvement, there weren't any
overt torture porn references, like Saw or Hostel. Maybe there was one on the monitors and I missed it. Seems like a missed opportunity. Maybe they wanted to restrict the monsters to sentient creatures.

There were the Dolls. In an appropriately ridiculous scenario: with all this horrible killing going around, they are quietly lighting a room on fire.

The movie was very, very, very good at not making anything overt.
 
Eek, you're not that bright, are you?

Let's not be an asshole.

Sure, this thread is dividing between those that "got it" and those that liked it/hated it as a pure, face value horror film.

But let's keep the IQ shit out of the thread.

That belongs in the BioWare and Uncharted threads.
 

Voidguts

Member
There were the Dolls. In an appropriately ridiculous scenario: with all this horrible killing going around, they are quietly lighting a room on fire.

I thought that was a reference to "The Strangers" - especially because they weren't just lighting the room on fire, they had several people tied up and were dousing them in gasoline.
 
That cabin is confirmed to be a remake of the Evil Dead cabin.



There were the Dolls. In an appropriately ridiculous scenario: with all this horrible killing going around, they are quietly lighting a room on fire.

The movie was very, very, very good at not making anything overt.

IMO,
the pain-worshipping hillbillies were the nod towards torture porn, what with the torture dungeon and what not. Could be wrong.

Will buy this DVD for the commentary alone.
 
Saw it this afternoon along with 7 other people in the screening (including the Missus).

Loved it and was grinning all the way through
although for some reason the 'puking' guy / monster (?!) on one of the monitors really disturbed me
lol.gif
.

(Playing safe and putting this in spoilers)
Did anyone catch what was on the interns sign(s) or will I have to wait for home viewing?
 
No, for it to be Torture Porn, it has to be Torture Porn, not just kids having a cat and mouse with monsters.

The movie has to be about the people getting tortured.

A good parody of Torture Porn is Funny Games. It's a parody because the killers break the fourth wall all the time, even going as far as to reverse time with a remote control they pick up from their victim's TV in order to make sure their victims don't fuck the plan up. Even the title of the film itself is a reference to the situation (in fact, I'm 100% certain that the title sequence in Cabin is a direct reference to that film's title sequence).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom