I'm sure it looks great, but its not all going to be up to the measure of that tree shot. There's an obvious reason why people who have played the game don't remember it looking as good as that. If it looked that good consistently, it would look just as good, if not better, than anything on next-gen or on PC. And I don't think anybody is going to reasonably try and make that argument.
No he's right the 1% theory is nothing but bullocks. The reason people don't remember it looking that good is because the game didn't have a good IQ, a botched AA implementation, no AF were the prime reason why people don't remember it looking as good. The texture work in Uncharted games have always been sublime and consistency in assets is their strongest point.
Uncharted 3 was the most technically outstanding console tittle released last gen (it was ahead of TLOU in some areas and generally looked better due to prettier artwork) and I find it hard to believe that someone thought that it wasn't even in the top 3 or top 5.