Yes you get more fps from a better gpu, but you also get better fps from a CPU. When I upgraded my CPU from core2quad to i7 my fps doubled with the same cpu. If x1 does have a significant cpu advantage of up to 30% ( big if) then this could place it in the ballpark to compete with ps4.
9% advantage in CPU clock if PS4's CPU is at 1.6GHZ (it's rumoured to be, and it was in january).
The fact is, this gen will be about GPGPU doing a lot of tasks in place of good old CPU. You should count GPGPU in your comparaison, and if you do it's a significant advantage (and not rumoured) for PS4... a very significant one because it's a lot more efficient with hUMA and it doesn't require a choice between compute and graphics as much as on X1 because of 4x the ACEs.
Why i'm answering though? Someone is wrong on the internet it seems.