Agreed on that they should have been more clear on the deal. Phil Spencer did clearly say it was a deal with a duration and that they didn't buy the franchise or whatever it was that he said. But at the time during and after E3, we didn't know what kind of deal it exactly was, but around that time CD had already received threats. Pathetic really.
Neither did MS, you make it sound like Rise of the TR is not coming to PS4. If i misunderstood you, then it's my bad.
Sure, let's act like it's all bullshit, which it really isn't. Not only talking about this place, many other forums too and people i know in general. There was always clearly more negativity towards MS pulling this kind of stuff compared to Sony. And i guess it depends on what one calls worse. Do correct me on this, but Sony keeping Destiny (not that i give a shit about the game) DLC a year exclusive is probably much worse than any of those deals MS has done. I certainly don;t remember many, if any like that. Except now of course with Tomb Raider.
MS has a deal for GTAIV DLC which was 12 months and some of the other extra GTAIV DLC content took about 14 months to come to the PS3. Plus they are other DLC from MS too. Both companies do it.