• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Team Fortress 2 PC: GAF Tournament of Victory

F

Firestorm

Member
Wouldn't warpath be better for the final round that round 1?

Dustbowl + Gravelpit + Granary + Warpath might take a looong time.
 
O

omgimaninja

Member
Firestorm said:
Wouldn't warpath be better for the final round that round 1?

Dustbowl + Gravelpit + Granary + Warpath might take a looong time.
Click to expand...

Yeah, warpath is for final round.

ROUND ONE:

1) Granary (first team to 3 points)
2) Dustbowl (each team attacks/defends each stage; 6 total stages)
3) Gravelpit (each team attacks/defends twice; 4 total rounds)


FINAL ROUND:

1) Map of choice by Team with highest stage points from ROUND ONE
2) Warpath (w/30 min timer)
 
J

Javaman

Member
omgimaninja said:
Yeah, warpath is for final round.

ROUND ONE:

1) Granary (first team to 3 points)
2) Dustbowl (each team attacks/defends each stage; 6 total stages)
3) Gravelpit (each team attacks/defends twice; 4 total rounds)


FINAL ROUND:

1) Map of choice by Team with highest stage points from ROUND ONE
2) Warpath (w/30 min timer)
Click to expand...

That looks good to me apart from the length of the total match... We're talking a couple of hours probably. :eek:P

We'll need to figure out a way to keep people off of the server (password?) and how to record the matches.
I can join the Thursday and Saturday game in order to shuffle people around, but I don't have password setting access, or a way to turn off auto team balance.
 
Y

YakiSOBA

Member
Javaman said:
That looks good to me apart from the length of the total match... We're talking a couple of hours probably. :eek:P

We'll need to figure out a way to keep people off of the server (password?) and how to record the matches.
I can join the Thursday and Saturday game in order to shuffle people around, but I don't have password setting access, or a way to turn off auto team balance.
Click to expand...

I think Icy said he was going to get with you to pass you admin access or some such?
 
O

omgimaninja

Member
If Dustbowl stages run too long, Gravelpit will be cut down to 1 attack/defend for each team.

Server will hopefully be locked w/new password for Saturday, and different password for Sunday match to prevent idiots from joining.
 
Z

Zaraki_Kenpachi

Member
"Don't think they made a group on Steam yet."


Nope we haven't. You can just tell him to friends request some of us on the team so we can keep him posted if we ever do make a group.
 
N

n0b

Member
omgimaninja said:
If Dustbowl stages run too long, Gravelpit will be cut down to 1 attack/defend for each team.

Server will hopefully be locked w/new password for Saturday, and different password for Sunday match to prevent idiots from joining.
Click to expand...
Why not just stick to one map per match and you play the map out fully, I don't see why we're trying to pack in so much into this first weekend. A one hour match is easy for everybody to be there for, but its a bit more difficult to make people keep 2-3 hours open for a match in the middle of the day. We don't have to be on to final match after this weekend, we could have each team play each other once, a couple weekends in a row, and the teams that won the most would go to the final match.
 
O

omgimaninja

Member
n0b said:
Why not just stick to one map per match and you play the map out fully, I don't see why we're trying to pack in so much into this first weekend. A one hour match is easy for everybody to be there for, but its a bit more difficult to make people keep 2-3 hours open for a match in the middle of the day. We don't have to be on to final match after this weekend, we could have each team play each other once, a couple weekends in a row, and the teams that won the most would go to the final match.
Click to expand...

I don't want to drag it on forever since we don't know the status of the server past January.

If yall like the idea of just doing one map or so, that's fine. CUBEs and EAD decide what you like best and we can run with it Saturday :)
 
I

Icy

Banned
omgimaninja said:
I don't want to drag it on forever since we don't know the status of the server past January.

If yall like the idea of just doing one map or so, that's fine. CUBEs and EAD decide what you like best and we can run with it Saturday :)
Click to expand...

its staying.
 
1

1-D_FTW

Member
Confidence Man said:
2 maps with a 30 minute timelimit each would be good.
Click to expand...

You can't have time limits. Dustbowl and Gravel Pit aren't fair if both sides don't do things an equal number of times. I'm not a proponent of marathons, but we can't be arbitrarily killing a map 3 minutes before something is gonna finish (If it's attack/defend.)
 
C

Confidence Man

Member
1-D_FTW said:
You can't have time limits. Dustbowl and Gravel Pit aren't fair if both sides don't do things an equal number of times. I'm not a proponent of marathons, but we can't be arbitrarily killing a map 3 minutes before something is gonna finish (If it's attack/defend.)
Click to expand...

Ah, you're right. One map is fine, then.
 
F

Firestorm

Member
b-b-but dustbowl! :(

sorry we must be so hard to please puyo.

Would Dustbowl + Gravelpit be too similar? Nobody likes Granary do they?
 
I

Icy

Banned
1-D_FTW said:
You can't have time limits. Dustbowl and Gravel Pit aren't fair if both sides don't do things an equal number of times. I'm not a proponent of marathons, but we can't be arbitrarily killing a map 3 minutes before something is gonna finish (If it's attack/defend.)
Click to expand...

and then what if we have a stale mate for 3 hours? Thats why time limits exist. I agree 30 minutes is kinda meh for those maps. 45-60 minutes is fine imo.
 
O

omgimaninja

Member
I think having a Well/Granary (5pt capture) and a Gravelpit/Dustbowl (attack-defend 3 points) is a nice mix because they require different techniques.
 
1

1-D_FTW

Member
Icy said:
and then what if we have a stale mate for 3 hours? Thats why time limits exist. I agree 30 minutes is kinda meh for those maps. 45-60 minutes is fine imo.
Click to expand...

Then Dustbowl should probably be discarded. Dustbowl never seems to linger for me, but maybe that's because I have so much fun and time flies. I've never actually stopwatched it.

But if the attacking team is constantly capturing the CP at the last moment and wins all three stages and the next team gets to capture Stage 1 before the timer expires, how is a 3-1 score of any relevance?

Or even if they get stopped on Stage 3 and the next team captures Stage one when it ends (2-2). Who would be declared the winner in that? It's entirely possible the 1st team is superior and would have stopped them on Stage 2 for a 3-2 win. Or they could have gotten rolled 4-2.

I guess that's why Dustbowl isn't a competitive map. Though I don't think we're gonna have a full house and the less people there are, the harder it is to defend and the quicker it's gonna go.

omgimaninja said:
I think having a Well/Granary (5pt capture) and a Gravelpit/Dustbowl (attack-defend 3 points) is a nice mix because they require different techniques.
Click to expand...

As much as I hate Granary the map and think Well is a lot funner, it's a good indicator of who the better team at that style is. It's seems like one team always dominates and dominates quickly.
 
C

Confidence Man

Member
1-D_FTW said:
Then Dustbowl should probably be discarded. Dustbowl never seems to linger for me, but maybe that's because I have so much fun and time flies. I've never actually stopwatched it.

But if the attacking team is constantly capturing the CP at the last moment and wins all three stages and the next team gets to capture Stage 1 before the timer expires, how is a 3-1 score of any relevance?

Or even if they get stopped on Stage 3 and the next team captures Stage one when it ends (2-2). Who would be declared the winner in that? It's entirely possible the 1st team is superior and would have stopped them on Stage 2 for a 3-2 win. Or they could have gotten rolled 4-2.

I guess that's why Dustbowl isn't a competitive map. Though I don't think we're gonna have a full house and the less people there are, the harder it is to defend and the quicker it's gonna go.
Click to expand...

Maps only change between rounds. That's why Warpath would go on forever, even after the timelimit expired.
 
C

Capndrake

Member
Could we maybe start scrimmages an hour earlier for Europeans and anybody else who's on? Everybody else can just join whenever they get on but at least it allows us to get some practice in.
 
T

The Storyteller

Member
I don't think I'll be able to play. Way to busy right now, the entire weekend is no good for me. I wont be able to join until well after the matches have finished.
 
Z

Zaraki_Kenpachi

Member
"I don't think I'll be able to play. Way to busy right now, the entire weekend is no good for me. I wont be able to join until well after the matches have finished."


Can you play a night during the week or sunday night? Our match is getting postponed slightly due to icy being gone for the weekend anyhow.
 
K

Kade

Member
How about we get some substitutes for the matches before hand?

Seems like a lot of people can't make it.
 
Z

Zaraki_Kenpachi

Member
"How about we get some substitutes for the matches before hand?

Seems like a lot of people can't make it."


Well it's already been argreed that Kirby Allstars match will be pushed back and besides we can't substitute half the team or that defeats the purpose. :/
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Let's appreciate... PC KID / BONK series!
25
6K
NeoZeedeater replied
NeoGAF's Official Game Soundtracks of the Year 2016: Voting Ends January 15th
6 7 8 9 10
482
91K
Ekai replied
Fighting Games Weekly | Feb 2-8 | The Great Cave-In Offensive
29 30 31 32 33
2K
140K
Westlo replied
Fighting Games Weekly | Dec 1-7 | Guest characters are banned
66 67 68 69 70
3K
197K
isamu replied
Fighting Games Weekly | Jan 5-11 | A World Warrior Demographic
44 45 46 47 48
2K
167K
enzo_gt replied
Top Bottom