• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

2015 Fantasy Football Discussion/Advice Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
So, interesting yet totally unintuitive fantasy scoring quirk:

1. If you play a WR and they fail to catch the punt? Fumble (despite the player never establishing control of the football, the Leon Lett rule applies)

2. In the above situation, the DST is *not* penalized for the fumble. (Whereas, say, the returner scores, the DST gets credit.)

Not that it would have changed my week, but interesting turns.
 
Had a very comfortable 13 point lead and stopped paying attention because my opponents only player left was DE Ezekial Ansah. When it comes to individual defensive players, defensive linemen and defensive backs are boom or bust, but mainly bust. So I just didn't worry at all about it. Then I realized he was the same guy who forced the fumble and recovered it(this is 8 points alone in my league). Now I'm sitting here with a 1.1 point lead and I'm terrified as hell that stat correction will cause me to lose because stat correction already gave me 3 points after the Sunday games. If at least two of those are taken back then I lose, or maybe my opponent gets one and I lose one I'd lose. Oh boy....
 

Apath

Member
Holy hell, I won by less than two points after coming in today with an 18 point lead up against just Russel Wilson. Those two fumbles + Calvin Johnson blowing the game saved my ass. Third lowest scoring team of the week and beat out second lowest scoring team. This was my lowest scoring week by 30 points.

4-0 baby!
 

Hazelhurst

Member
Won in my Yahoo league.

Lost in my ESPN league. I just needed seven points to win and had Calvin Johnson playing. I screamed with glee when Megatron was about to score. Then the fumble happened. Ended up losing by three points. So sad when Megatron can't even get seven points for the whole game. How the mighty have fallen.
 

MikeRahl

Member
What is everyones thoughts on defense?

I always draft 1 defense, but always struggle on what to do on byes. Sometimes there is clearly a player that I can cut loose, and maybe run with 2.

In one league I have

Rivers,
Morris,
Gordon,
Decker,
M Bryant
Steve Smith

On the bench.

My Starting WRs are pretty set with OBJ, D Thomas and K Allen so maybe I can cut loose one of the Receivers. RBs are less set, Murray and Freeman starting, Woodhead, Lewis and CJ2K are all on the waiver wire so I was thinking of swapping Morris for Dion Lewis but haven't decided yet.

The two options I am leaning towards right now is a straight swap Carolina for NYG, and just play matchups for the rest of the year, or Bradys Bye is done and just drop Rivers and hope nothing terrible happens.
 

gutshot

Member
I always stream defenses since they are so matchup-dependent. The only time I'd keep a defense on a bye week is if I had an elite D that is matchup-immune. The only defense like that this season looks to be Denver.

I would also pick up Dion Lewis immediately. You could probably drop Martavis Bryant who isn't the first option on his team and has to be further downgraded with Big Ben out. You could also try to package a couple of your WRs for an upgrade at RB. Selling high on Freeman may also be a wise move. Your team is really deep at WR though and pretty thin at RB, so I'd definitely be looking to shore things up there.
 
What is everyones thoughts on defense?

I always draft 1 defense, but always struggle on what to do on byes. Sometimes there is clearly a player that I can cut loose, and maybe run with 2.

In one league I have

Rivers,
Morris,
Gordon,
Decker,
M Bryant
Steve Smith

On the bench.

My Starting WRs are pretty set with OBJ, D Thomas and K Allen so maybe I can cut loose one of the Receivers. RBs are less set, Murray and Freeman starting, Woodhead, Lewis and CJ2K are all on the waiver wire so I was thinking of swapping Morris for Dion Lewis but haven't decided yet.

The two options I am leaning towards right now is a straight swap Carolina for NYG, and just play matchups for the rest of the year, or Bradys Bye is done and just drop Rivers and hope nothing terrible happens.

Id swap Lewis for Morris ASAP
Drop Rivers and pickup NYG D

Id keep your WR assets and dangle them in trades
 
Yeah, I have the same issue with DST coming up. Think I'm going to drop Seattle's D when the Bye happens and stream for the rest of the season. They got me 5 pts last night and I almost lost because of it - not exactly earth shattering.
 
Yeah, I have the same issue with DST coming up. Think I'm going to drop Seattle's D when the Bye happens and stream for the rest of the season. They got me 5 pts last night and I almost lost because of it - not exactly earth shattering.

As someone who got bitten by this exact line of action last year, allow me to caution you - Seattle's D seems to get better as the year progresses. Last year they were horrible the first 4 or 5 games or so, I dropped them, and then they went on a tear after that. That's not to say the same thing will happen again but they may require patience.
 
Which D/ST you guys think? Packers v Rams or Giants v 49ers?

Go with NYG

Im a giants fan and we are as stout against the run as any team so far this year which will force Kap to throw a lot of passes which has a good chance in resulting in at least a pick or two.

The rams seem to be figuring out their offense the past few weeks and Foles isnt very prone to throwing picks so the ceiling isnt as high for GB in this matchup.
 
As someone who got bitten by this exact line of action last year, allow me to caution you - Seattle's D seems to get better as the year progresses. Last year they were horrible the first 4 or 5 games or so, I dropped them, and then they went on a tear after that. That's not to say the same thing will happen again but they may require patience.

Ugh, OK, thanks. They don't have a bye for a couple of weeks so I have time to see if things change.
 
Well, lost my first game after last night. My whole team was so-so to mediocre, but on to this week. I have Jonathan Stewart and Greg Olsen out. I'm trying to pick up another running-back, but I need another tight end. I think Maxx Williams and Gary Barnbridge are on the waiver wire so I might pick up one of them, but I need to make space. Do I finally give up on Victor Cruz making an impact on my team and drop him?
 

TylerD

Member
Holy hell, I won by less than two points after coming in today with an 18 point lead up against just Russel Wilson. Those two fumbles + Calvin Johnson blowing the game saved my ass. Third lowest scoring team of the week and beat out second lowest scoring team. This was my lowest scoring week by 30 points.

4-0 baby!


I was up by 24 and survived Abdullah, Megatron,
and Ebron. Also 3rd lowest score and beat the 2nd lowest score this week in our league. 4-0 for me too!

Need a TE this week with Jordan Reed likely out and Heath Miller my only other option.

Going to try to get Ronnie Hillman to replace David Johnson (pick 5 waiver) and swap Isaiah Crowell for Duke Johnson Jr

also... what the hell to do about Demarco Murray?
 

UberTag

Member
Well, lost my first game after last night. My whole team was so-so to mediocre, but on to this week. I have Jonathan Stewart and Greg Olsen out. I'm trying to pick up another running-back, but I need another tight end. I think Maxx Williams and Gary Barnbridge are on the waiver wire so I might pick up one of them, but I need to make space. Do I finally give up on Victor Cruz making an impact on my team and drop him?
You can drop Victor Cruz.
He's fantasy fool's gold.
 
Cam is on a bye (and Big Ben is injured) so i'm in need of a one time pick up at QB, the most appealing available options on FA are Foles and Bradford..any thoughts?
 

nillapuddin

Member
The Houston Defense is by far the most disappointing Draft Pick of my season, good god what happened.

(being envious about not drafting the Broncos instead)
 

Sumidor

Member
Cam is on a bye (and Big Ben is injured) so i'm in need of a one time pick up at QB, the most appealing available options on FA are Foles and Bradford..any thoughts?

Take Bradford. Playing against the Saints, he SHOULD do well. But then again, the Eagles suck, so who knows.
 
Dropping kniles davis considering if charles gets injured its been stated theyd go with a committee. #1 waiver seed tom... Picking up leonard hankerson. Pretty stoked.#2 wr in atl.

Aiming to grab gmen and catanzaro for streams this week.

Lost this week in the final minute of SNF... I had the 2nd highest score of the week, he had the highest. Really burns me.


I could use advice on a trade... whats ellingtons worth in a 1/2 ppr league. Close to Jordan mattews?
 

necrosis

Member
ugh i got fucked this last week by starting flacco over andy dalton & thinking arian foster would get a bigger share of carries than he did (and in turn benching chris ivory)

fuck football
 
This has been my first year playing FF and so far I'm 4-0, 2nd in my league, and top of my division. I go up against the #1 guy this week.

I was drunk when I made all my picks and I still have very little clue as to whats going on.
 
This has been my first year playing FF and so far I'm 4-0, 2nd in my league, and top of my division. I go up against the #1 guy this week.

I was drunk when I made all my picks and I still have very little clue as to whats going on.
You need to step it up to the next level... Drunk Fantasy Football Trades


i-dont-always-make-drunk-fantasy-football-trades-but-when-i-do-i-make-sure-to-trade-away-arian-foster.jpg
 
Dropping Lance Dunbar was such a wrench this morning :(
in my ppr I've had...

-Romo
-Dez
-Dunbar

I'll do cowboy fans a favor and not grab anymore players off their team.
This has been my first year playing FF and so far I'm 4-0, 2nd in my league, and top of my division. I go up against the #1 guy this week.

I was drunk when I made all my picks and I still have very little clue as to whats going on.
the magic and mystery of fantasy! The guy #1 in my league auto drafted his first 5 picks. Meanwhile I'm slumming at 1-3 and have the second most points scored against me. Faced the top scorer of the week twice.
 

gimmmick

Member
Just traded away Dalton for Chris Irovy. Dalton was just a back up and I needed a running back. I like my chances of jets making him the center point of their ofense.
 
Just traded away Dalton for Chris Irovy. Dalton was just a back up and I needed a running back. I like my chances of jets making him the center point of their ofense.
Highway robbery from a position scarcity perspective. Ivory has been the focal point of the offense and at the core, Jets are still a smashmouth pound the rock team. Ivory is a workhorse RB2 putting up RB1 numbers, and with Bilal Powell hurt he may see some receptions in the passing game now.
 

gimmmick

Member
Highway robbery from a position scarcity perspective. Ivory has been the focal point of the offense and at the core, Jets are still a smashmouth pound the rock team. Ivory is a workhorse RB2 putting up RB1 numbers, and with Bilal Powell hurt he may see some receptions in the passing game now.

That was what I was thinking. Decker and Ivory were out in week 3 (the game they lost to the eagles). He runs hard like vintage Marshawn Lynch. Now I have Bell, Ivory and Dion Lewis was my backs in fantasy.
 

Apath

Member
I've got Dalton and Newton with jack shit in the RB position. Maybe I should try to trade Dalton while everyone is high on him for a solid RB..
 
would love some advice this week. Thanks!

1/2 ppr league

Looking for 2 WRs, 1 RB, and a Flex

Amari Cooper vs. Den
John Brown vs. Det
Leonard Hankerson vs. Was

Danny Woodhead vs. Pit
Andre Ellington vs. Det
Jeremy Hill vs. Sea
 
Lamar Miller and Chris Ivory both on bye... Looking at either Shane Vereen or Charles Sims at RB2. 12 Team PPR League. Thoughts on which is slightly less garbage? Or if there's a hidden gem in the waiver wire I should be looking for?
 

bigkrev

Member
I got offered Jimmy Graham straight up for Mike Evans. I don't have a real replacement for Evans (Boldin, Stevie Johnson) as my WR2, but I also don't have a TE with Jordan Read going down, and Jared Cook is the best player available. Do I do this trade? 14 Team league
 
would love some advice this week. Thanks!

1/2 ppr league

Looking for 2 WRs, 1 RB, and a Flex

Amari Cooper vs. Den
John Brown vs. Det
Leonard Hankerson vs. Was

Danny Woodhead vs. Pit
Andre Ellington vs. Det
Jeremy Hill vs. Sea

I'd say Cooper, Brown, Ellington and Hankerson, respectively. Cooper and Brown I feel like you gotta start out of principle. Brown has been disappointing thus far but can break out and Detroit sucks. Same reason you go with Ellington; I hear he probably could have gone last week and stayed out because CJ was doing fine. I don't know how Cooper will fare against Denver but I have to imagine it'll be better than Woodhead against Pit (I normally have Woodhead at FLEX but moved him out this week). Atlanta is playing Washington and our secondary blows bungholes and I'm sure Hanky wants some targets against his former team.

Lamar Miller and Chris Ivory both on bye... Looking at either Shane Vereen or Charles Sims at RB2. 12 Team PPR League. Thoughts on which is slightly less garbage? Or if there's a hidden gem in the waiver wire I should be looking for?

Tough. Probably Vereen. I was actually reading about him recently because one of my opponents has him; basically said he's a dart-throw, but that's still more positive than what is being said about Sims.
 

Hazelhurst

Member
I got offered Jimmy Graham straight up for Mike Evans. I don't have a real replacement for Evans (Boldin, Stevie Johnson) as my WR2, but I also don't have a TE with Jordan Read going down, and Jared Cook is the best player available. Do I do this trade? 14 Team league
I wouldn't, Evans will soon start dominating. I think Graham is a bit overrated at Seattle, sort of how Demarco Murray was expected to dominate at Philly.
 

Cagey

Banned
Pick 2:
Michael Crabtree v. Denver
John Brown @ Detroit
Kendall Wright v. Buffalo

I'm leaning the latter two.

Lamar Miller and Chris Ivory both on bye... Looking at either Shane Vereen or Charles Sims at RB2. 12 Team PPR League. Thoughts on which is slightly less garbage? Or if there's a hidden gem in the waiver wire I should be looking for?

As an obsessive Giants fan, Vereen's value will come in games where the Giants are playing from behind or against teams that can't defend RBs in the pass game (terrible LBs, basically). Otherwise, in the course of a standard game where the Giants are ahead or the score is knotted up he's going to get occasional carries and a small number of targets but nothing intensive, so you're hoping he can pile up big yardage in limited opportunity. I would guess the LBs are the only thing left of SF that's not a trainwreck so I wouldn't start Vereen unless you had no other good option.
 

Dazzler

Member
Just traded DeMarco Murray for CJ Spiller and Andre Ellington

I think I did ok there. Murray has been an appalling bust for me
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom