• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Legendary Shipping Meltdowns (SPOILERS)

LotusHD

Banned
The only real ship is Zoro and Kuina's sword.

Or Usopp and Going Merry D:

are people actually putting luffy and nami together? why?

That's how shipping works, you don't care how unlikely it is, ya just do it anyways.

But yea, they just look at all the early moments where Luffy gave Nami his hat to keep safe, and how he often defers to her for stuff, and yea, shippers gonna ship
 

SDBurton

World's #1 Cosmonaut Enthusiast
youre gonna have to make new qualifications then, because people are always bitching about the lack of women, when there are tons. and unless i missed something, kevins mom is still alive
My qualifications were always that they'd have to fall into a dateable age range for Sam or Dean—mostly Dean. I actually remember if Lauren Tom's character is dead or not, but she falls outside the age range.

There are also plenty of women on the show. It's just that the recurring ones that could potentially date Sam or Dean are usually killed off.
 

Toa TAK

Banned
The thing about Korrasami if I remember correctly, is that there were people who (correctly) proclaimed it was underdeveloped (which is putting it lightly) and those who were too blind to recognize they hooked up at all in the end.

Either way, it was lame because it took away from the star of the season:

tumblr_nf6wq7V3ib1ths8nao6_500.gif
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
At the very least the downfall of Sakura into a needy idiot unable to move on gave us one of the best female characters in the franchise.

tenor.gif


Looking forward to see how they ruin her!

by pairing her with boruto
 

wandering

Banned
The thing about Korrasami if I remember correctly, is that there were people who (correctly) proclaimed it was underdeveloped (which is putting it lightly) and those who were too blind to recognize they hooked up at all in the end.

Either way, it was lame because it took away from the star of the season:

tumblr_nf6wq7V3ib1ths8nao6_500.gif

Metal Hitler was a terrible villain. Evil floating Dalai Lama was much more interesting.
 
The thing about Korrasami if I remember correctly, is that there were people who (correctly) proclaimed it was underdeveloped (which is putting it lightly) and those who were too blind to recognize they hooked up at all in the end.

Either way, it was lame because it took away from the star of the season:

tumblr_nf6wq7V3ib1ths8nao6_500.gif
To be fair weren't all the romantic relationships in Korra underdeveloped? :p
 

SDBurton

World's #1 Cosmonaut Enthusiast
The thing about Korrasami if I remember correctly, is that there were people who (correctly) proclaimed it was underdeveloped (which is putting it lightly) and those who were too blind to recognize they hooked up at all in the end.

Either way, it was lame because it took away from the star of the season:

tumblr_nf6wq7V3ib1ths8nao6_500.gif

Kuvira would've been the star if she got with Suyin. :p
 
There was Bleach as well. Also can't wait for our first pairing in Voltron Legendary Defender. The meltdowns will be good.

Oh I've already witnessed the meltdown of hardcore Keith x Lance fans on tumblr after the show runners were saying (as well as Keith's VA) saying that there would be more Keith and Allura interactions in S3 during the Wondercon panel.

Another one that I've seen and was wholly amused by are the diehard Johnlockers (John x Sherlock) after S4 aired earlier this year. The amount of people claiming queerbaiting or the show runners being homophobic and everything in between was legit like watching the Titanic sinking in slo-mo. I don't care for the pairing at all (I prefer Sherlock and Irene personally)

There are more, but those two are the most recent I've seen tumblr turn on in a blink of an eye.
 

aly

Member
Tenzin and his wife were cute. Also the whole thing about him used to date Lin was better than the main cast's relationships.

I felt bad for Lin in Korra. They couldve at least let her get with Mako.

Oh I've already witnessed the meltdown of hardcore Keith x Lance fans on tumblr after the show runners were saying (as well as Keith's VA) saying that there would be more Keith and Allura interactions in S3 during the Wondercon panel.

Another one that I've seen and was wholly amused by are the diehard Johnlockers (John x Sherlock) after S4 aired earlier this year. The amount of people claiming queerbaiting or the show runners being homophobic and everything in between was legit like watching the Titanic sinking in slo-mo. I don't care for the pairing at all (I prefer Sherlock and Irene personally)

There are more, but those two are the most recent I've seen tumblr turn on in a blink of an eye.

Oh yes, he Keith/Lance shippers who take their interaction as romance and Keith and Allura as underdeveloped and stretch the producer statements on representation and deviation from the old show. The worst part is them harassing the voice actors.

I kinda liked Sherlock/Janine even though it was fake, but yeah that's another extreme fandom.
 

SolVanderlyn

Thanos acquires the fully powered Infinity Gauntlet in The Avengers: Infinity War, but loses when all the superheroes team up together to stop him.
The Naruto one is kind of tragically hilarious in how seriously people took the romance in that series
 

Maximo

Member
I remember browsing gaf's Overwatch fanart thread and apparently the lesbian couple of Mercy and.. Pharah (I think?) is a popular "ship", but when Blizzard put out a comic hinting of a Mercy and Genji well.. much salt.

https://www.kotaku.com.au/2017/01/overwatch-shippers-clash-over-new-mercy-genji-voice-lines/

Ships have turned me off from some communities it can get a bit much, the Overwatch one was delicious salt when it was semi confirmed Mercy and Genji were together and not Pharah.
 

Kimaka

Member
The meltdown over Spock and Uhura getting together in the new Star Trek movies. A bunch of slash fans, most white women, opposed to it because they wanted Kirk/Spock when it was really a cover for their racism. I remember them saying that Uhura assaulted him when they kissed, that she was too aggressive for him, and that he was forced into the relationship.

Harry x Hermione shippers had some amazing meltdowns.

The mad H/Hr shippers ruined finding good H/Hr fanfiction for a while. Stories of Ron being an abuser and Weasley and JKR bashing were increased by 1000%.
 

Aikidoka

Member
This is why Yuri on Ice / Ah My goddess (and a lot of other romantic anime) are so fucking childish and never make the relationship official. Fans of this type of situations and shippers are only in for the ride as long as nothing is confirmed and the characters behave like middle schoolers around each other forever.

what ?
Yuri and Victor practically get married......
 

Veitsev

Member
Nisekoi

Still see salty Onodera fans in the most random of anime/manga comment sections. When you argue that you feel like Nisekoi of all fucking mangas is "rushed" because your trash tier waifu lost you know you got issues.

Like it was clear as day what direction the manga/anime was going in but you had people get so invested in by far the most boring character imaginable. Onodera gets little to no character development, is a complete doormat, and her sister and mother are more interesting. How can you be best girl when you aren't even the best girl in your own family? Lots of dismissals of Chitoge because she is a "tsundere" archetype but she at least had a clear character arc. Although I have to say I enjoy her being called Gorilla all the time. Onodera isn't any less cliched and is clearly meant to be the traditional submissive sweet Japanese waifu archetype. There is also something to be said of the outright boring ending that would have resulted from a Onodera end. Chitoge? Married duel heads of mob families. Marika? Daughter of the police chief and son of yakuza together. Tsugumi? Badass espionage hijinks. Onodera? Lets take over the family sweets shop....wow how exciting.

Nisekoi was always a well executed but trashy harem manga full of cliche upon cliche so when it chose the most obvious route that it had clearly been building up to for fucking ever these creepy people lost their shit because they had literally fallen in love with a cartoon character. This wasn't a manga where there was any real doubt which direction things were going to go in past chapter 50 or so and if you have ever read a harem manga before it was clear by chapter 01. Onodera fan desperation got particularly annoying to read late in the manga's life because at some point you are just actively rooting for asspulls and bad writing in a series already full of asspulls and bad writing.

At some point if you hate the main girl of series that much maybe IDK stop reading it? There are plenty of better manga out there. The Onodera faction always seemed like the most overly invested creepy of the bunch and the most actively aggressive toward everyone else. I guess thats what happens when you choose Team Loser and slowly watch the inevitable drenched in your own salt and tears. At least Tsugumi and Marika were cool/fun! Fucking weirdos.
 

megachao24

Unconfirmed Member
I think there was another ship that got sunk with Destiny. I think the guy's name was Dearka and I'm afraid I can't recall what the others name was.

Miriallia.

Thinking about it, Fukuda was really one spiteful dickhead during Destiny's run.
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Honestly the thing in Bleach was kind of whatever. I assumed Renji x Rukia was really obvious given the plot of the Soul Society arc, it just never actually got expanded so the resolution of it came off as a complete out-of-nowhere despite the fact it wouldn't have been if it had been timed properly.

Rukia x Ichigo never really seemed to be a thing. I legit thought Rukia x Byakuya was more likely - I mean, Byakuya wasn't actually related to Rukia and adopted her because his dying wife who happened to look identical to Rukia told him to. It wouldn't be that far out of the blue if he happened to be into his wife's sister who looks just like her. The only particular way I saw Ichigo x Rukia was that he's a dude and she's a girl.
 

StoneFox

Member
The Voltron: LD fanbase isn't as large as others, but according to most fanfics I've read if you don't ship Lance and Keith together you are wrong. *shrug*

I'll be reading something relatively normal too and out of nowhere Lance is attacked by the gay feelings.

Even the token girls aren't shipped as much as these two together.

Some fans attack others for shipping Shiro with anybody but Allura, calling them pedophiles for even trying to ship him.
 

Toa TAK

Banned
To be fair weren't all the romantic relationships in Korra underdeveloped? :p
YES
Kuvira would've been the star if she got with Suyin. :p
Ugh, no

Why do people want this? They're like, mom and step-daughter.
Metal Hitler was a terrible villain. Evil floating Dalai Lama was much more interesting.

No

Hell no.

Kuvira was the best villain in the series and 100% justified in everything she did.
 

Fj0823

Member
You mean they haven't already? The costume change already took her down a couple notches in my opinion.

The anime said fuck that shit and toned it down, like a lot.

tumblr_onjfrk7jW41tm63qvo2_540.jpg


They also kinda retconned it, this costume is from before she becomes a ninja now.

The problem with the manga artists persists, but it's nice to see the studio not wanting any of that shit.
 
Sonic the Hedgehog fandom is basically one giant shipping war that's been going on since the comics started, to the point that they had to reboot the entire comic to try putting a stop to it.

Oh it got rebooted for much bigger reasons than shipping. Lawsuits got that ball rolling
 

Metroidvania

People called Romanes they go the house?
This is why Yuri on Ice / Ah My goddess (and a lot of other romantic anime) are so fucking childish and never make the relationship official. Fans of this type of situations and shippers are only in for the ride as long as nothing is confirmed and the characters behave like middle schoolers around each other forever.

I mean, this is kind of an entire genre (the harem scenario), although to be fair, I don't think Ah My Goddess is actually gonna generate a whole lot of salt - it's pretty much 100% Belldandy, or at least 90%. The beginning starts off a little harem-y, but flattens out to the daily life hijinx relatively soon.

But yeah, Nisekoi and Naruto meltdowns were a thing to behold. The Overwatch one was just hilarious, the # of explanations people were trying to come up with to explain the gay away were truly something.

Also, I'm not so sure some small subdivision of Tumblr going off the walls (and incidentally, had no idea gay Jack is a thing - asexual maybe, but I don't think he displayed any real interest in either gender before this season) is grounds for a 'meltdown' on a similar level to the ones mentioned above.

The one that comes to mind recently was Cap/Bucky when Civil War came out.

Cap/Bucky (and Cap/Tony for that matter) is kind of its own beast among slash shippers. But that's kind of always been a pipe dream, or at least as soon as Sharon was introduced in Winter Soldier.

To be fair (and serious), there's only one official canon: Tracer and Emily. Nothing else exists canon-wise at this point.

There's also Amelie and Gerard!
 

Strimei

Member
For a reverse example where most everyone was on the same page and the media itself threw a curveball before bouncing back, remember the bizarre romantic undertones between Cortana and Chief in Halo 4? That were somehow supposed to resonate in spite of, y'know, Cortana steadily going insane over the course of the plot due to mechanical failure?

ArJB0mt.gif

How about the fact that Cortana is based off Dr. Halsey's brainscans. Dr. Halsey, aka Master Chief's mother figure?

Hello, Oedpial issues~

Ehh i imagine most people who watch romance/harem animes knew Chitoge would win.

Yeah, first girl wins is the trope, after all.
 

rackham

Banned
Korassami ending up being canon is probably the biggest meltdown ever.

Both who are in favor and who supported it from the start EXPLODED because the chance of it becoming canon was like 0,005%
It was pandering garbage. Would have accepted it if there was even one longing look from either character throughout the entire series but it just happened in the final scene as a big pandering look at us moment.

I was asking for that relationship too but they (writers) handled it poorly


Also Cortana and master chief. Just lol. Garbage.
 
The anime said fuck that shit and toned it down, like a lot.

tumblr_onjfrk7jW41tm63qvo2_540.jpg


They also kinda retconned it, this costume is from before she becomes a ninja now.

The problem with the manga artists persists, but it's nice to see the studio not wanting any of that shit.

That is better. She still has those fucking high heels on, but it's better.
 
what ?
Yuri and Victor practically get married......

But did they really? It almost like everything was made for laughs. And through the whole season it is a clear pairing without a contender that could realistically make a triangle or anything like that. Imagine a Harem anime, you'll just want to make all the fans happy so you let the joke play on repeat.
 
Top Bottom