• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

2011 US Open Thread of Pushin' it to the Limit

Status
Not open for further replies.
Update: U.S. Open cancelled; title awarded to Simon, Djokovic & Young. 1st 3-way champion in sports history.
 
MIMIC said:
Worst Grand Slam, or worst Grand Slam?


Yeah I usually don't agree with this because someone says it EVERY time, but I may have to say that this is the worst non-tennis event I've ever seen.

Injuries, rain, bitching about players' rights, no Del Potro in later rounds, few great upsets.
 
I'm just glad I'm not a ticket holder. I can only imagine the frustration with the people who are actually THERE.
 
Makes you wonder why they bother to host these events at venues that aren't equipped to handle less-than-perfect weather conditions...
 
mclem said:
There's a crack in the court, and water's seeping up from below.

Yes, really.
I just saw the videos, lmao, I really can't wait for this clusterfuck of a Grand Slam to implode further.

As awkward looking as Isner is, I'd to see him pull out a win here, definitely quite the fight going on.
 
Im watching the Isner/Simon match and with no commentating going on, its actually enjoyable. Its not like tennis is hard to follow.
 
I stopped rooting for Serena Williams for a while, too.

But I've really been rallying for her in her comeback. She's been so much calmer and focused. Easier to root for her when she's not being arrogant. And after her health scare you can tell she has a better appreciation for the game.
 
I have no problem rooting for her after the PE she had. She had one just a month after I had mine, I had to make a comeback in bodybuilding/fitness and she is making one in tennis. I dunno, strikes a personal chord with me.
 
I dont dislike Serena as a person I just think that a lot of her matches tend to be slugfests where she outmuscles her opponents.

Like whenever shes playing poorly and down a few breaks of serve she'll make a comeback. The commentators will go on about how she's demonstrating her skill and ability. When usually all she's doing is hitting the ball harder than she was before.

I just find it very boring.
 
Clegg said:
I dont dislike Serena as a person I just think that a lot of her matches tend to be slugfests where she outmuscles her opponents.

Like whenever shes playing poorly and down a few breaks of serve she'll make a comeback. The commentators will go on about how she's demonstrating her skill and ability. When usually all she's doing is hitting the ball harder than she was before.

I just find it very boring.

That is the EXACT problem I have with Maria Sharapova. The most one-dimensional game on the woman's side, in my opinion.

I don't think Serena gets enough credit for her shot selection. She has her preferences, of course, but there's really no shot that she's uncomfortable with. I think this is why she has such a good record against players who can hit the ball just as hard as her...like Stosur and Sharapova.
 
rando14 said:
I must be the only one who likes Serena. She's about as good as it gets in women's tennis.

I like her. My brother likes her ass even more.

And it's nice that in a sea full of clowns and pretenders, Serena is the only one that emerges as a legitimate contender, despite her ranking. She gives the WTA some credibility.

But it would be nice if she had some competition. She's just running over people.
 
royalan said:
That is the EXACT problem I have with Maria Sharapova. The most one-dimensional game on the woman's side, in my opinion.

I don't think Serena gets enough credit for her shot selection. She has her preferences, of course, but there's really no shot that she's uncomfortable with. I think this is why she has such a good record against players who can hit the ball just as hard as her...like Stosur and Sharapova.

I think folks underestimate Serena's intelligence.
 
royalan said:
That is the EXACT problem I have with Maria Sharapova. The most one-dimensional game on the woman's side, in my opinion.

I don't think Serena gets enough credit for her shot selection. She has her preferences, of course, but there's really no shot that she's uncomfortable with. I think this is why she has such a good record against players who can hit the ball just as hard as her...like Stosur and Sharapova.
I dont watch too many Sharapova matches even though I'd actually like to.

As soon as I hear one of her goddamn wails I change the channel. So I dont actually know what kind of player she is anymore.
 
rando14 said:
I must be the only one who likes Serena. She's about as good as it gets in women's tennis.

i just hate their smugness and she said and done some stupid things. and i don't like how they play the game part time. sure they still win the slams (which shows how weak women's tennis is atm) but i don't think it's good.
 
Diprosalic said:
i just hate their smugness and she said and done some stupid things. and i don't like how they play the game part time. sure they still win the slams (which shows how weak women's tennis is atm) but i don't think it's good.
?

they play the game just like the other top women, except with a superior serve and mental toughness that borders on intimidation.
 
Diprosalic said:
sure they still win the slams (which shows how weak women's tennis is atm) but i don't think it's good.

I agree....how dare they have lives outside a Tennis. Who do they think they are?

Also....slams ARE the only events that matter in tennis. Everything else is warm up....and if you don't feel like you need a warm up skip em imo.
 
scorcho said:
?

they play the game just like the other top women, except with a superior serve and mental toughness that borders on intimidation.
Why should anyone credit Sharapova's mental toughness when her concentration is poor and makes 40 plus unforced errors a match. She doesn't have the mental toughness to concentrate enough. Her mental toughness is a myth.
 
06nbarnhill said:
I agree....how dare they have lives outside a Tennis. Who do they think they are?

Also....slams ARE the only events that matter in tennis. Everything else is warm up....and if you don't feel like you need a warm up skip em imo.

certain events are mandatory they just don't bother showing up ("injuries") or loose first round. of course they can steam roll slams being fitter than the whole field.
 
Diprosalic said:
certain events are mandatory they just don't bother showing up ("injuries") or loose first round. of course they can steam roll slams being fitter than the whole field.

If they were really mandatory then there would be some repercussions for not showing up.

Tennis is an individual sport (well doubles but meh). The way you play it is your choice imo.
 
Rafa=FedKilla said:
Why should anyone credit Sharapova's mental toughness when her concentration is poor and makes 40 plus unforced errors a match. She doesn't have the mental toughness to concentrate enough. Her mental toughness is a myth.
aren't we talking about Serena now
 
As soon as I hear one of her goddamn wails I change the channel. So I dont actually know what kind of player she is anymore.

Sharapova's recent game has been thus:

Hur-da-hur Me keep hitting big ball. Me win Hur-da-hur...

Seriously, there are juniors playing smarter tennis than her these days. One almost pwned her first round, in fact.

Her saving grace (and about the only compliment I can give her) is that she has crazy stamina. So she can play that level of caveman tennis consistently through three sets. So what usually happens is she gets blown away the first set by the smarter player, but counts on the them to tire out...which usually happens.

But put her against a player who employs smart shot selection and can keep it up through three sets, and she is guaranteed to lose even if they're weaker at racket. Exactly why Panetta put her away in the open, and why Serena shut her up in two sets earlier this Summer.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom