It's really not, though. It's an
improvement, sure, but the difference is really pretty minimal, especially in comparison to past gens.
It was one thing during the PS3/360 era, when games were 720p (or lower, ugh) and barely 30fps. Then, a moderate PC (still more than the cost of a console, but not too much more) would net you a
significant jump.
- 720p => 1080p, especially due to the lower quality of AA at the time, makes a huge difference in image quality.
- Obviously, going from 30fps => 60fps is also transformative.
- Beyond resolution and framerate, games often had noticeably improved higher end graphics options for PC: physx, shadows/AO, higher res textures, etc.
Today though, PS5 and Xbox SX already get you 4k (or close) and 60fps in pretty much every game. The higher the baseline gets, the less noticeable any further jump is.
- Even if the game is only 1440p on console, the difference between 1440p and 4k is much smaller than 720p => 1080p. Depending on the quality of the AA, it's honestly almost imperceptible on my 65" TV from my couch.
- 60fps => 120fps is half the improvement in frametime as 30 => 60. It's better, sure, but it's just not that different in most games.
- It seems like 90% of games don't even have any extra graphical options at all for PC any more.
So to have any real improvement, you need a system that can do 4k or higher at 120fps at max settings, which is going to be
multiple thousands of dollars - five or more times as much as a console - for less and less meaningful improvements.
And that's completely ignoring all the issues and headaches you'll run into on PC: shader compilation stutter, vsync/fullscreen/HDR issues, settings not staying set, no rest mode/quick resume... those are the real reason I'm sick of PCs.
So yes, if you don't care about the things the consoles can do that PCs can't (quickly jumping in and out of rest mode), and you don't mind or miraculously avoid the numerous bugs and issues, you can definitely get some improvements. The "it's a different game" rhetoric is just a bit silly - it's a nice, fairly minor improvement.
Now, as the gen goes on, if games start running at 30fps again and/or closer to 1080p - then I completely agree.