• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Rumor: Destiny DLC Plans leak. Major addon "Comet: Plague of Darkness" coming sep. 15

Foffy

Banned
So that means a game like Fallout or Dragon's Age must be the mother-load on Content/Money ratio amirite?

1 a subscription MMO that has been around for close to 10 years vs a game that has been out less than 5 months, yeah very comparable, when the genres they are in don't even match up

Put the real full price of how much a WoW player has spent over the course of 10 years against Destiny once it hits 1 year and see how they stack up
Vanilla WoW was content dry too, people forget that shit

Not to the level Destiny is, though. The fact the current expansions look like content that should have been at launch, only to "trail" the user into the big one seems very shady, but most of all, entirely lazy.

If you can dig it, fine, but the fact quite a number of people have called it out as lazy should also be considered, too. Something probably happened during development because I don't think a developer openly sits there and goes "we can get more for less when trying to build up our titles". Especially when their expansions really look like the base game with little changes or additions.
 

Afrocious

Member
This question may not be for this thread, but I'll ask it anyway.

Does the fact that Destiny is a fun shooter at its core along with the fact that you can find online communities to play the game with excuse the how its DLC is being released with such bare bones content, at their price point? What about with how Bungie responds to criticism, with either ignoring complaints or stating that folks are playing the game wrong? What about with the lengthening of the grind players have to do for weapons and light?

As someone who was with Destiny on GAF from Day 1 and stopped playing months before The Dark Below was released, my personal opinion is no. Despite the fun I had with DestinyGAF and making clans for folks that people still try to use to get into the game, I can't say I can support Bungie any longer for Destiny unless the game gets a huge overhaul.
 

Marcel

Member
You have a twisted logic that because you hate the game everyone else does to.

It seems you have an issue with anyone that likes the game.

When did I say that explicitly? Other than in your misrepresentation of my thoughts, of course.
 

cakely

Member
Compared to something like World of Warcraft this game IS barebones and it charges you more to play then WoW.

6 expansions in a year is 120 euro, plus the game for 60 is 180, plus 40 euro for Comet is 220 euro in total for 1 year of playing.

That coupled with the fact it has less content then vanilla WoW is crazy.

What?

The first year of Destiny will be:

Destiny
The Dark Below
The House of Wolves

How in the hell do you think that possibly adds up to "six expansions"?
 
lol Destiny threads on gaming side are such a mess. I open it up and first thing I see is a dude asking how many unique posters is in the OT. Bravo, Ein Bear.


Anyway, please take my money. Comet will probably be amazing. My warlock needs arc and my titan needs solar. New vehicles would be nice too.
 

GraveRobberX

Platinum Trophy: Learned to Shit While Upright Again.
When did I say that explicitly? Other than in your misrepresentation of my thoughts, of course.

You clearly stated that a segment of people play Destiny must have some sort of Stockholm Syndrome...

They are happy that a segment of their player base is essentially a captive audience with Stockholm syndrome, yes.

How about this:
I'm glad the game equivalent of buffet food is good enough for you. Some people expect more for their money, though.

Why attacking and being hostile towards a group of gamers who enjoy something you might not... Oh right a HATER!
 

Marcel

Member
You clearly stated that a segment of people play Destiny must have some sort of Stockholm Syndrome...



How about this:

That has nothing to do with me apparently saying (without me actually saying it) "I hate the game so everyone else must as well." You could at least bother to actually read what we're talking about.
 

Moobabe

Member
Its tit for tat really, you need this DLC to keep playing in a meaninful way. It's just another form of a subscription.

Anyhoo enjoy the game, I hope Destiny 2 will deliver what was promised to us.

Bingo - you're getting locked out of "story," strikes etc by not picking up these DLC packs.

Also - for the gentleman posting how much "content" he's had out of Destiny you should bare this in mind.

You could also play any game for that amount of time, repeating the same amount of content over and over. It's not necessarily a measure of how "much" content is in the game.
 

Kosma

Banned
You said Vanilla WoW was dry on content though Graverobber

You could also play any game for that amount of time, repeating the same amount of content over and over. It's not necessarily a measure of how "much" content is in the game.

+1
 

Ponchito

Member
Comet doesn't look bad. There should be more new locations. Guess we'll have to wait for Destiny 2.

I like that HoW is coming till March, I'll have time to grind to level 32.
 
I love all the people in this thread doing the math on total cost of all the DLC but then no one bothers to factor in that this is all taking place over 2 full years.

So when you add up your $200ish number, why don't you go ahead and divide that out a bit?

paying $100 a year isn't that much, it's a game and a half.

Hell, if I wanted to think about it like an MMO I'm paying $8.33 a month. Pretty sweet deal if you ask me.
 

Ein Bear

Member
What keeps GAF from being an echo chamber of haters then?

Honesltz the internet period is a echo chamber since people seek out like minded communities that stroke their own preconception and egos. Or at the least they go on it to bitch, whine, and complain.

Its why negative reviews of products and people looking for help frequently outnumber positives. People with no problem aren't going to the net to post their happiness and no problem.

See, but again, you're saying that anyone who doesn't like Destiny is 'bitching', 'whining' and a 'hater'.

It's ridiculous, dismissive, language to use against people discussing the many legitimate issues that the game has. There is definitely a lot of good, healthy debate to be had about the merits of the final product, but dismissing everyone who dislikes the game because they aren't posting in the Community thread is ludicrous. Several people have said that there are 600+ unique posters in there, but a quick look at the figures shows that there are fewer than 50 with more than 100 posts. That's ultimately a drop in the ocean compared to GAF's overall userbase, and you shouldn't be surprised to find that your opinion doesn't match that of the majority.
 

cakely

Member
You know, after carefully reading that reddit post I'm actually a little excited for this. :)

Assuming this is in the $40 range, I'm probably in.
 

DNAbro

Member
Comet doesn't look bad. There should be more new locations. Guess we'll have to wait for Destiny 2.

I like that HoW is coming till March, I'll have time to grind to level 32.

Well Hard mode Crota is coming in January so better get up real quick.

*still needs to get to 30 to even try Crota*
 

GraveRobberX

Platinum Trophy: Learned to Shit While Upright Again.
You said Vanilla WoW was dry on content though Graverobber

How many Raids did Vanilla WoW have at the beginning?
How many patches/updates/changes did it take for WoW to reach to where it is now...

Shit by month end people were re-rolling toons just o squeeze out content from WoW to see the other side from the faction

people forget the 2005 era, everyone think 2015 WoW today is the same WoW from 2005
 

Marcel

Member
I love all the people in this thread doing the math on total cost of all the DLC but then no one bothers to factor in that this is all taking place over 2 full years.

So when you add up your $200ish number, why don't you go ahead and divide that out a bit?

paying $100 a year isn't that much, it's a game and a half.

Hell, if I wanted to think about it like an MMO I'm paying $8.33 a month. Pretty sweet deal if you ask me.

Many people including Bungie have made it clear it isn't an MMO but that seems to be a more protective statement owing of the lack of substantial content in Destiny than anything else.

"We shouldn't compare it to an actual MMO because that would make Destiny look even worse", or something like that.
 
You said Vanilla WoW was dry on content though Graverobber



+1

I'm not agreeing or disagree with what he said, but take note that Launch WoW and WoW 2 months before Burning Crusade was very different.

Over twice as many raids, PvP Battle Grounds. World Bosses, etc...

Many people including Bungie have made it clear it isn't an MMO but that seems to be a more protective statement owing of the lack of substantial content in Destiny than anything else. "We shouldn't compare it to an actual MMO because that would make Destiny look even worse".

Bungie and whoever else can say what they want, but in my eyes, I'm playing an MMO, or at the very least, something that fills that niche.
 

Bizazedo

Member
Destiny's a weird game. I like the game, a lot, but it's the only game I've ever loved where every complaint / dislike I've heard I've nodded and gone...."Yeah, pretty accurate."

Must be the core gameplay loop. As for these expansions, bring 'em, I can afford them.

They better get matchmaking into one of these "expansion packs", first one was such a rip off for the amount of content.

Everything that needs / is appropriate for matchmaking has matchmaking.
 
Sounds good, although September is a long time to wait after March, but it obviously has a lot more content.

It's going to be difficult keeping my interest all the way to then, especially as there's lots of games coming out in between. Though it's managed to keep my interest for 4 months currently, which is generally 3 months and 3 weeks longer than most games. So we'll see. I'll be level 32 shortly though so I'm not sure what there will be to do up till March either. I know the Hard Raid is coming but not sure if that can hold my interest.
 

Jito

Banned
Destiny's a weird game. I like the game, a lot, but it's the only game I've ever loved where every complaint / dislike I've heard I've nodded and gone...."Yeah, pretty accurate."

Must be the core gameplay loop. As for these expansions, bring 'em, I can afford them.



Everything that needs / is appropriate for matchmaking has matchmaking.

But weekly strikes, daily heroic and raids would all be possible with matchmaking.
 

Marcel

Member
Bungie and whoever else can say what they want, but in my eyes, I'm playing an MMO, or at the very least, something that fills that niche.

It's an MMO insomuch as you fill bars, make numbers go up and do...stuff. After that the comparisons to the big boys in the MMO yard (and even some F2P games) only make Destiny look worse. If it meets that need for you then more power to you.
 

ElRenoRaven

Member
Sounds plausible and based off what we already know follows the pattern set up in the lawsuit documents. I'm all good for all that. Bring on more content Bungie.
 
Sounds good, although September is a long time to wait after March, but it obviously has a lot more content.

It's going to be difficult keeping my interest all the way to then, especially as there's lots of games coming out in between. Though it's managed to keep my interest for 4 months currently, which is generally 3 months and 3 weeks longer than most games. So we'll see. I'll be level 32 shortly though so I'm not sure what there will be to do up till March either. I know the Hard Raid is coming but not sure if that can hold my interest.

Well, if they do something similar with Wolves, the Hard raid for it probably wont come out until the beginning of May. That'll keep your attention for 3 or 4 weeks at least.

So then it's just June to Sept. 3 and a half months. If they finally figure out that Trials of Osiris thing, then I think we'll be okay.
 

Bizazedo

Member
But weekly strikes, daily heroic and raids would all be possible with matchmaking.

Raids? No. Not unless they made a dumbed down LFR version.

Weeklies / Daily Heroics could use them, yes, I forgot about those. Well, Daily Heroics are easy as is, so maybe not, but the Weeklies, sure, why not.
 

RdN

Member
It'll be a shame if the bigger DLC doesn't include new locations.

But.. After seeing The Dark Bellow, I really regret my Season Pass purchase. Have absolutely no faith for the next DLC, and unless Bungie deliver a huge overhaul of the game with this Comet expansion, at a very competitive price, I don't see myself buying it.
 

TyrantII

Member
See, but again, you're saying that anyone who doesn't like Destiny is 'bitching', 'whining' and a 'hater'.

It's ridiculous, dismissive, language to use against people discussing the many legitimate issues that the game has. There is definitely a lot of good, healthy debate to be had about the merits of the final product, but dismissing everyone who dislikes the game because they aren't posting in the Community thread is ludicrous. Several people have said that there are 600+ unique posters in there, but a quick look at the figures shows that there are fewer than 50 with more than 100 posts. That's ultimately a drop in the ocean compared to GAF's overall userbase, and you shouldn't be surprised to find that your opinion doesn't match that of the majority.

But that's not what's been going on.

Instead every topic is drive by snark or people calling other gamers that do enjoy it stolkholm syndrome candidates; as said a few pages back. That's hater, and its prevelent on GAF.

And look, I have many, many issues with the Game and DLC design myself. I also can acknowledge how popular it is and how disappointed that seems to make some people that don't like it.

I don't like RE4 and will argue its a travesty of the IP and conclusive of Capcoms problems with game development on a whole. I know that is a minority position and I don't attack the fans who love it as somehow delusional or lackeys. I know it scratched a itch for them I don't have.

Edit, case in point:
JA0Xt0O.png
 

Jito

Banned
Raids? No. Not unless they made a dumbed down LFR version.

Weeklies / Daily Heroics could use them, yes, I forgot about those. Well, Daily Heroics are easy as is, so maybe not, but the Weeklies, sure, why not.

Raids could be done though, VoG isn't difficult but I've not tried the new one yet. If all other MMOs can manage raids with matchmaking, why can't Destiny the "MMO Lite" game?

But yeh, more options for matchmaking the better. If you don't want to or don't need to use it, don't then? It's for us who don't have massive groups of friends on this game and can't be fucked with waiting about using LFG sites.
 
It'll be a shame if the bigger DLC doesn't include new locations.

But.. After seeing The Dark Bellow, I really regret my Season Pass purchase. Have absolutely no faith for the next DLC, and unless Bungie deliver a huge overhaul of the game with this Comet expansion, at a very competitive price, I don't see myself buying it.

If you look through the OP, you'll see there is a new destination.
 

Kosma

Banned
How many Raids did Vanilla WoW have at the beginning?
How many patches/updates/changes did it take for WoW to reach to where it is now...

Shit by month end people were re-rolling toons just o squeeze out content from WoW to see the other side from the faction

people forget the 2005 era, everyone think 2015 WoW today is the same WoW from 2005

Lol by months end...

Even if you were leveling a mage it would have taken at least 140/160 hours to hit level 60. Leveling in Destiny takes what, 15 hours?

I'm not agreeing or disagree with what he said, but take note that Launch WoW and WoW 2 months before Burning Crusade was very different.

Over twice as many raids, PvP Battle Grounds. World Bosses, etc...
.

I'm talking WoW at launch, not after PvP patches etc. :)
 

Marcel

Member
Raids could be done though, VoG isn't difficult but I've not tried the new one yet. If all other MMOs can manage raids with matchmaking, why can't Destiny the "MMO Lite" game?

Nothing in VoG (the raid I've played) is harder than the Binding Coil of Bahamut, FFXIV's most difficult raid, which has matchmaking for some of the Turns. I'm not sure what is so special about Destiny's raids that allow it to not have matchmaking.
 

Bizazedo

Member
There's a standard for matchmaking for raids in existing MMOs. It's not as if people are pulling this idea from another dimension or something.
Yep. Brain dead LFR's with neutered loot. A mode explicitly designed as a sightseeing mode so that people could at least see the raid and the storyline if they couldn't participate in the real raids.

If they did that, in totality, sure. But the current raids? No, as they're not LFR braindead quality raids.

That ignores cheese, of course.

Raids could be done though, VoG isn't difficult but I've not tried the new one yet. If all other MMOs can manage raids with matchmaking, why can't Destiny the "MMO Lite" game?
Hah, they don't, though. LFR's are raids in the very loosest sense of the word.

VoG isn't hard when cheesing the hell out of it or with a real group, you're right. CE is even easier to be honest.

Still a lot harder than an LFR equivalent.

But yeh, more options for matchmaking the better. If you don't want to or don't need to use it, don't then? It's for us who don't have massive groups of friends on this game and can't be fucked with waiting about using LFG sites.
It's not in Bungie's interest. Assuming it's not braindead LFR, what would happen is a bunch of people join and get eviscerated. They then start badmouthing the raid / quality etc. It'd be a horrid experience.
 
WoW is around 120-130$ per year plus 40/50$ for the xpac every two years but it also has at least 10x the content so I don't know where are the comparisons come from. Blizzard charge a lot for WoW yes but they also deliver content appropriate for the money. By the end of every expansion the content is usually two or three times larger than launch.
 

Marcel

Member
Yep. Brain dead LFR's with neutered loot. A mode explicitly designed as a sightseeing mode so that people could at least see the raid and the storyline if they couldn't participate in the real raids.

If they did that, in totality, sure. But the current raids? No, as they're not LFR braindead quality raids.

That ignores cheese, of course.


Hah, they don't, though. LFR's are raids in the very loosest sense of the word.

VoG isn't hard when cheesing the hell out of it or with a real group, you're right. CE is even easier to be honest.

Still a lot harder than an LFR equivalent.


It's not in Bungie's interest. Assuming it's not braindead LFR, what would happen is a bunch of people join and get eviscerated. They then start badmouthing the raid / quality etc. It'd be a horrid experience.

See what story? We're talking about Destiny dude.
 

DNAbro

Member
Sorry, should have been more specific.

I want to see new planets like Jupiter, Saturn.. Both have Grimoire cards and lore involved.

Or the other locations Bungie had promised, like Chicago on Earth.

Destiny 2 and 3 lol
 

RDreamer

Member
I hope somewhere during this they actually add some social tools. Matchmaking would be great. I just got the game and it's boring as fuck to play by myself, but I don't know anyone low level, and I've not seen anyone walking around that's my level. It's pretty abysmal compared to my experiences with MMOs where even if I didn't physically know people I could usually gather a party or find some people to group with in game.
 

panda-zebra

Banned
This game is designed specifically to get people on a validation threadmill

That's your honest appraisal of what Bungie set out to achieve with Destiny? Would you care to elaborate, in detail, and cite credible sources to support your claims? I personally think you need to do exactly this if you're going to make such claims, otherwise you're bordering on shitposting.

Personally I think they probably set out to make a fun game that branched out into areas that challenged and interested them. They might not have fulfilled the potential thus far, but that hardly makes their game some kind of brain-washing production line of evangelists all too eager to white knight the interwebz and beyond.

If anything it seems to have worked in a slightly inverse manner... it's the anti-Destiny guys and the constant and deliberate validation of their own opinions that look more like some kind of hamster wheel at this point. I especially feel this is the case when detractors refer to out-dated play mechanics that no longer exist in the current game, that does little to further a position when it's built upon dormant mechanics and information. A thread the other day was rife with it, even from the guys actually trying to offer help to a newbie.
 

Afrocious

Member
I really don't see an excuse for not having matchmaking for VoG normal now that there's a new raid, with whatever currency Destiny has now that people are grinding for as a reward for clearing it using matchmaking.
 

Jito

Banned
It's not in Bungie's interest. Assuming it's not braindead LFR, what would happen is a bunch of people join and get eviscerated. They then start badmouthing the raid / quality etc. It'd be a horrid experience.

Why would you assume they'd bad mouth the content? This is a bit of a stupid assumption. Is this a problem in other MMOs when people whipe on Raids? They bad mouth the content and blame the dev instead of thinking about why they failed, or is this from personal experience?
 

Bizazedo

Member
Sorry, should have been more specific.

I want to see new planets like Jupiter, Saturn.. Both have Grimoire cards and lore involved.

Or the other locations Bungie had promised, like Chicago on Earth.

I want better lore, period. That's one thing I want to know more about the DLC / expacs, the added lore. It's so jarring, for lack of a better word, that Dinklebot says nothing about VoG when we're inside. Not an intro, no comments, no exposition, nothing.

What's worse is that Eris flat out insults Ghosts and he doesn't react at all.

It's like Bungie forgot that one of the things people loved about Halo was the lore.
 

Marcel

Member
I hope somewhere during this they actually add some social tools. Matchmaking would be great. I just got the game and it's boring as fuck to play by myself, but I don't know anyone low level, and I've not seen anyone walking around that's my level. It's pretty abysmal compared to my experiences with MMOs where even if I didn't physically know people I could usually gather a party or find some people to group with in game.

Those games also have better social tools in-game for meeting people and grouping up, with the understanding that not everyone wants to go to, say, a GAF OT or DestinyLFG in the off-chance that you find someone you'd actually want to play with.
 
Top Bottom