• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Large Youtubers Hide Ownership of CSGO Lottery Site

Status
Not open for further replies.

O.v.e.rlord

Banned
UnXm45g.png

Rot in jail douche bag! No amount positivity is going through this
 

PtM

Banned
I'm on mobile but if someone can compile a simple timeline of events I can add it to the OP when I can (or a mod can edit it if they feel that it is appropriate).
  • December 2015: Together with Josh Beaver (JoshOG) and some other guy, Trevor Martin (TmarTn) & Thomas Cassell (ProSyndicate) found CSGO Lotto
  • Commence the videos
  • June 19th: The initial kickoff: CSGO News accuses some other players (Faze) of broadcasting faked wins in skin gambles (CSGOwild)
  • June 27th: HonorTheCall outs the CSGOLotto owners.
  • June 27th: TmarTn2 uploads his panic rant (mirror)
  • June 30th: HonorTheCall refutes his BS
  • July 3rd: h3h3 cover it
  • July 4th: Tmartn does have a lawyer after all, deletes his videos
  • July 4th: Steam browser puts a disclaimer up on the lottery site (but not for long).
  • July 4th: Reported to the Federal Trade Commission.
  • July 4th: Martin disables comments on his videos.
  • July 4th: Steam removes the disclaimer from the site, because it is not malicious per se.
  • July 5th: JoshOG deletes a stream record of him talking about his "sponsorship".
  • July 5th: Steam-community discussions regarding the lottery site have been deleted.
  • July 6th: Martin is sorry (mirror)
  • July 6th: Martin hides dislikes, not sorry
  • July 6th: Martin's lawyer is sorry
  • July 6th: Video Game Attorney speaks his mind how messed up this whole thing is
  • July 6th: Dislikes are back, sorry
  • July 6th: JoshOG is sorry, tells his story though
  • July 6th: Martin isn't sorry anymore, removes video
  • July 7th: Martin and Cassell get sued within that gambling lawsuit against Valve.
  • July 10th: Cassell picks up his business as usual.
  • July 10th: Martin picks up his business as usual.
  • July 12th: JoshOG can't decide if his CSGOLOTTO games were rigged or not.
  • July 13th: Valve going against gambling sites (receipts)
  • July 16th: in other news, looks like phantoml0rd owns CSGOshuffle and exploited the shit out of it (plus more indications against Faze/CSGOwild)
  • July 18th: phantoml0rd gets banned from twitch, likely for having used subscribe bots
  • up to July 23rd: HonorTheCall with incriminating stuff on Faze
  • July 27th: HonorTheCall on his private conversations with Tmartn (including a seemingly faked threat sent via emkei.cz) and how he made the Valve-lawsuit guys aware of CSGOLotto
  • July 31st: meanwhile down under, a senator wants to kill off loot-box monetisation
  • July 31st: more private conversations between HTC and Tmartn, citing "sweepstakes" (no consideration/entry fee) and "virtual items" (no prize) as legal defenses, plus the email header of the emkei sent threat
Video recap from July 5th with nice background info on skin gambling and Valve's involvement
 

OCD Guy

Member
Just show the Judge this pic and he's good, right?

/s

All he needs to do (and will do) is release a video on his channel titled "I'm sorry", it will get millions of views and all will be forgotten.....

Anyway he's not sorry for what he's done, just sorry he's been caught.
 

Revven

Member
I'm partially surprised and partially not surprised. I've seen one or two of tmartn's videos before, I think it was a GTAV Online video like one or two years ago -- mainly when I just searching around for GTAV Online stuff. And I just clicked on it and in the video he just seemed like one of those YouTubers that would get popular just off of how loud and obnoxious he was. I think at that time he was already popular or something but nearly as much as he's gotten now, I guess. Anyway, from those videos it seemed to me like he might be the type to clickbait and what not so this development doesn't surprise me but it surprises me it goes this far.

Regardless, this is quite the controversy and I can't imagine they'll be getting off of this scott free. The more people that report on it or do videos on it, the less likely it will be for it to be forgotten and something will definitely happen to these two. And I hope something does because this is all kinds of wrong and illegal. Exploiting young people like this is unreal.
 
Mock me all you want, I only watch his vlogs I have no interest in CSGO Betting, Case Openings, etc..

He's not the type to flash his cash, he always stops for fans out and about, recently he did make a wish for a young fan who is fighting cancer who wanted to meet him and took them out the day after on a helicopter ride out of his own pocket, he buys cars and stuff for his family.

I do agree it is shady as shit to not disclose you are the owner of something you are trying to entice people into doing and he should be punished for it but I don't think he intentionally scammed people by rigging the site in his videos.

Don't take it too personal, but that's very naive. Just because someone's outward appearance seems nice doesn't mean the person behind the mask actually is a nice person.
 

Tecnniqe

Banned
This keeps getting better and better.

Logged in as the loot bots and pewd's comments.

Oh boy oh boy.


VbTYQdy.gif

I expect FTC and whichever other instance to notice this mess, if not knowing already, to slam a few hammers.
 

sn00zer

Member
I generally dont like h3h3 videos only for the fact they reveal how horrible large portions of the internet are, but got damn this one is interesting.
 

Dubz

Member
As a new parent and long time gamer I find this appalling. I'm also very concerned with the trend of gambling for cosmetic items in games, whether is be CSGO, Overwatch, or whatever.

Gambling is a serious issue, and not having any age restrictions for these virtual slot machines is insane.
 
I hope this case brings to light and actually spark regulations for these types of sites and other digital good gambling, all the way down to games that include random crates for purchase. It's important that these types of games of chance are not rigged and the odds are completely transparent. It's bad enough to exploit the weakness many have with gambling, but if it's going to exist, it needs to be 100% fair with strong repercussions for any rigging.
 

Tecnniqe

Banned
As a new parent and long time gamer I find this appalling. I'm also very concerned with the trend of gambling for cosmetic items in games, whether is be CSGO, Overwatch, or whatever.

Gambling is a serious issue, and not having any age restrictions for these virtual slot machines is insane.

Its true. I don't mind purchase of cosmetics, as long as you pay for THAT item and not a chance of X items in a roll.

However, the way some games does the gambling is better than others.

Woo! Jail time lol. Stay in school kids! *dontdropthesoap*

Soap jokes still not funny.
 

BowieZ

Banned
As a new parent and long time gamer I find this appalling. I'm also very concerned with the trend of gambling for cosmetic items in games, whether is be CSGO, Overwatch, or whatever.

Gambling is a serious issue, and not having any age restrictions for these virtual slot machines is insane.
Yep, if this gains traction in the media, I think it opens a can of worms, but it's a can of worms that needs to be opened (with the worms taken out and buried in the garden or something).
 

Dubz

Member
Yep, if this gains traction in the media, I think it opens a can of worms, but it's a can of worms that needs to be opened (with the worms taken out and buried in the garden or something).
Remember when buying horse armor was unseemly? Oh the times they are a changin'.
 
This dude is definitely a grade-a idiot lmao.

Not an idiot, just a sociopath

As a new parent and long time gamer I find this appalling. I'm also very concerned with the trend of gambling for cosmetic items in games, whether is be CSGO, Overwatch, or whatever.

Gambling is a serious issue, and not having any age restrictions for these virtual slot machines is insane.
Agreed

We already know that the software and gaming industry are the lawless wild west, but exposing children to gambling compulsion loops is way over the line.

Imagine if someone opened a gambling parlor in your neighbourhood, decorated the shop and marketed it all specifically to target children and teenagers and lured them in to turn them into little compulsive gamblers.
There would be blood.

But if it happens online noone fucking does anything.
 

Vena

Member
Highly illegal and they both deserve to goto jail quite frankly.

I'd imagine that if the FTC gets involved, and at this point I can't imagine that they don't eventually step in, he's going to get put to trial at the very least. Jail will depend on the results, he may just end up being fined into oblivion.
 

Boke1879

Member
You would think the best option from Tmartn would be stop talking.

I mean with him going back and deleting comments, retroactively putting the CSGO lotto disclaimer in his bio. I assumed he would have talked to a lawyer.

But he just keeps talking. Any lawyer would advise him to shut the hell up.
 

Did I miss anything?
If nothing is missing I will copy and paste this in the OP. Thanks!
 

Apathy

Member
I'm no lawyer but that tweet seems like a bad idea if he has any intention to fight this in a future court case.

He either has a terrible lawyer or a competent lawyer that is losing his shit right now.

Any competent lawyer will tell his client to go on a complete media blackout and just get offline for a while.
 

tci

Member
As a new parent and long time gamer I find this appalling. I'm also very concerned with the trend of gambling for cosmetic items in games, whether is be CSGO, Overwatch, or whatever.

Gambling is a serious issue, and not having any age restrictions for these virtual slot machines is insane.
I am as well. Been keeping a great distance to these kinds of crap. I will never understand why people waste money on virtual items. The practice needs to die.
 

rrs

Member
easy to say once you are verified and make big ass bucks off of exploiting people
I agree, I think you are right. Either way let's hope something happens because it's disgusting, that video of him ranting in his two storey waterfront property paid for based on kids gambling on his site and his lies is so morally corrupt I don't even know where to start.

How can he sleep at night?
Uses whatever a GOP politician does, perhaps the sheer blindness to the pain they bring
 
Like someone said, Youtube should unpartner these asshats and twitch shouldn't let him get any revenue from streaming.

edit: Oh and jail time.
 

aravuus

Member
Mock me all you want, I only watch his vlogs I have no interest in CSGO Betting, Case Openings, etc..

He's not the type to flash his cash, he always stops for fans out and about, recently he did make a wish for a young fan who is fighting cancer who wanted to meet him and took them out the day after on a helicopter ride out of his own pocket, he buys cars and stuff for his family.

I do agree it is shady as shit to not disclose you are the owner of something you are trying to entice people into doing and he should be punished for it but I don't think he intentionally scammed people by rigging the site in his videos.

Wow, that's... Really, really naive.
 

Faenix1

Member
He doesn't do either of those things, or hasn't in the vlogs I've watched over past 4-5 months.

Dont know any of these folks, since I dont care about youtube culture, but one of em like just posted within the last day or two a video of him walking around his house and talking into the camera.

How is that not flashing when in the background it's all "LOOK HOW BIG MY HOUSE IS". lol
 

OCD Guy

Member
The one thing I'm not quite ok with is how TmarTn appears to be getting the majority of the attention.

ProSyndicate appears to be flying under the radar in comparison.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom