• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Arkham Asylum Mafia |OT| It's time to kill the Bat

acohrs

Member
Unless Absolutbro and Nudull are scum working together, which is a possibility given that they've both come out on the same dayphase with the same info, seems unlikely though. Probably more likely that both my reads are off, hmmm...

vote:zippedpinhead

guess it's onto the only one I scumread still that hasn't claimed, zipped, please don't claim, my reading pride can't take it
 
N1 - Sorian; No one targeted my target
N2 - Nudull; Target targeted themself, which is why I believe his doctor claim AND that he is town. I couldn't think of a scum role that gained anything by targeting themself that night.
N3 - Fat4all; No one targeted my target

I don't know if it matters, but I will throw it out there for clarification.

N1 - Sorian; "Your target wasn't targeted"
N3 - Fat4all; "Your target wasn't visited"
 

Sorian

Banned
Lol you'd rather lynch a potential confirmed town than a neutral that has confirmed he is going to continue killing people? This is just the weirdest game.

I have literally every stake invested in wanting to kill scum. It's not even a point of argument, you can see my win con from a confirmed flip already, both are aligned with needing another scum death at this point.

And yes, I'm sure you are still fine with killing me. I bet you were ecstatic when I didn't actually have a red check on you.
 

Timeaisis

Member
I see no reason in lynching Sorian, btw.

Part of the reason for my claim.

Well who are you on then?

I have literally every stake invested in wanting to kill scum. It's not even a point of argument, you can see my win con from a confirmed flip already, both are aligned with needing another scum death at this point.

And yes, I'm sure you are still fine with killing me. I bet you were ecstatic when I didn't actually have a red check on you.

So you are a runaway vig. I understand your win con sorta kinda aligns with ours, but you are still killing random people at your own discretion.
 

Verelios

Member
There's no point in me not claiming if im just going to get shot at night by Sorian.

Im Anarky.
Im Town.

My ability is a one-shot Override that I can use during the day by typing ILikeToWatchTheWorldBurn and my target for lynching into the thread.

I'll use it today to prove this.
Hm? What does this entail, just to know.
 

Faddy

Banned
There's no point in me not claiming if im just going to get shot at night by Sorian.

Im Anarky.
Im Town.

My ability is a one-shot Override that I can use during the day by typing ILikeToWatchTheWorldBurn and my target for lynching into the thread.

I'll use it today to prove this.

Well I think you should use it to clear yourself but I don't think you should use it on Sorian. Let scum worry about him.

As I said I like Zipped or Verelios. Take the shot at one of them and I would be fine with that today.
 

Timeaisis

Member
There's no point in me not claiming if im just going to get shot at night by Sorian.

Im Anarky.
Im Town.

My ability is a one-shot Override that I can use during the day by typing ILikeToWatchTheWorldBurn and my target for lynching into the thread.

I'll use it today to prove this.

Here ya go.
 

Sophia

Member
May we get a vote count please?

Ask and ye shall receive.

timeaisis (3)
sorian 2090
flame_ac 2203 (2495)
faddy 2294
nudull 2492

ccs (0)
timeaisis 2159 (2165)

sorian (1)
timeaisis 2165

verelios (1)
faddy 2199 (2294)
zippedpinhead 2478

nudull (0)
acohrs 2230 (2497)

fat4all (2)
fireblend 2318
zippedpinhead 2355 (2478)
penguin 2440

zippedpinhead (2)
ccs 2397
acohrs 2501

acohrs (1)
fat4all 2438

lone_prodigy (1)
verelios 2487

Day 4 ends:
bla_1494284400.png


8 votes for majority.
 

acohrs

Member
Someone quote my claim from the last page

Fucking bottom of the page

Can't quote myself on mobile

will do, since good doggo and don't want to see a good doggo lynched

There's no point in me not claiming if im just going to get shot at night by Sorian.

Im Anarky.
Im Town.

My ability is a one-shot Override that I can use during the day by typing ILikeToWatchTheWorldBurn and my target for lynching into the thread.

I'll use it today to prove this.
 

Sorian

Banned
There's no point in me not claiming if im just going to get shot at night by Sorian.

Im Anarky.
Im Town.

My ability is a one-shot Override that I can use during the day by typing ILikeToWatchTheWorldBurn and my target for lynching into the thread.

I'll use it today to prove this.

Well that puts a damper on things.

Well since you'll be needing the info more than I do.

Zipped is Natiko's other check. He's Bat-mite which I googled again like an hour ago and I'm still lost on if this thing is supposed to be a villain or hero, could really go either way. With how weird he is, my first thought was Zipped cursed Natiko in retaliation for targeting him but that is also a vague power that could be town or scum and is also just baseless speculation, though no one else getting cursed means it's either one-shot or something like this.
 

Faddy

Banned
Well that puts a damper on things.

Well since you'll be needing the info more than I do.

Zipped is Natiko's other check. He's Bat-mite which I googled again like an hour ago and I'm still lost on if this thing is supposed to be a villain or hero, could really go either way. With how weird he is, my first thought was Zipped cursed Natiko in retaliation for targeting him but that is also a vague power that could be town or scum and is also just baseless speculation, though no one else getting cursed means it's either one-shot or something like this.

On the Bat-man wiki it says affiliation Batman Family

http://batman.wikia.com/wiki/Bat-mite

Scum.
 

Sorian

Banned
On the Bat-man wiki it says affiliation Batman Family

http://batman.wikia.com/wiki/Bat-mite

Scum.

Yes, but then you get lines like this one from the same link:

"Bat-Mite's favorite is Batman, and visited Batman on many occasions, often setting up strange events to see his hero in action. However, Bat-Mite is more of a nuisance than a supervillain, and often leaves when he becomes aware that he had angered Batman."

We debated it and then just kind of dropped the thread because we weren't sure.
 
His first post about being poisoned and fat4all, indicated he was 1-shot. Now his role gets posted and it's two-shot(thanks BTW), and he died last night.

Trying to get the order of events right, especially if someone else gets poisoned.

I agree, mazre' claim has to indicate that he didn't know who the rest of the scum team is. He obviously wanted to make a role that sounded too powerful and attract the scum team but also so powerful that we wouldn't want to kill him. Just scum got caught being scummy.

Shame about flush. Did anyone else get poisoned?

I have been saying I believe flush for most of the day, but this claim puts us in a better spot.

If we lynch flush, when he would have died tonight anyway we are essentially taking a kill from scum. It would also prove or disprove mazre (so we could deal with him tomorrow).

Dorry flush, for town I gotta switch my vote:

For the record: I think you are being most accurate on your job just lying about the name so scum can't get an extra kill.

vote: Royal_Flush

I would rather have you in the game, and if you would rather me not lynch you (and have you get healed tonight). tell me and I will swap it back to Faddy (who I still think is scum)

Having been a 1-shot lightning rod in a role madness game I believe RF. Of course, when I had that role I also had a 1-shot nighttime bulletproof to go along with it. I don't even think I will vote for him tomorrow if he lives the night, as long as someone else gets poisoned.

Not voting for him today. I might swap my vote is a better case can be made but the more I think about flush the more I think he is town.

Revealing you are poisoned makes sense regardless of alignment. It's the only way you can stay alive. That's why poison is such a frustrating mechanic. It can benefit town more to let the poisoned die (if 1-shot) than to save them and risk exposure. If multi-shot then it benefits town more to save them. With the first poisoning being Day 2 no one knows where we stand.

I'm the poison doctor as I have been trying to breadcrumb for the past two days. I have two shots and sent one to flush last night. He must have used his lightning rod on someone and it got nullified.

I tried to tell him.

The way it was explained to me is that I'm a bat-fan, but angry at the writers for removing me from the comic books, so I am trying to prove my worth to to the Villians by healing them.
 
IF we lynch/override Zipped and IF he flips Bat-mite, we will know Sorian is telling the truth. Will that impact your thunder dome list?
 
Top Bottom