• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Moore's Law Is Dead Claims To Have Received Insider Information About the PlayStation 5 That is Amazing If It's True

geordiemp

Member
Moore's Law is such a hack. For starters, they're using 14 Gbps chips, not 16 Gbps. What was his source, Foxy the cardboard box?

If PS5 had these amazing features, why were they not mentioned in Road to PS5 in detail? We know that is when Sony generally gets into the technical presentation of their new hardware, yet they did not mention these details. What would they gain by holding out on any of this if true? Could've saved themselves a ton of embarrassment in terms of perceived power disadvantages if this were true, and they got out clarifying/confirming it officially to steal Microsoft's thunder.

See how all of this falls apart when you break it down logically? I've heard the same RDNA3 rumors (ironically from RedTechGaming who's a more neutral/better tech channel, and at least he clarifies the reason he speaks mostly on PS5 stuff is because his contacts are PS guys, though he's heard of RDNA3 customizations for the Series systems too), but they are likely very small customizations in the grand scheme of things, otherwise we'd of heard more about them. The closest thing to an RDNA3 spec in PS5 we've actually heard a lot about are the GPU cache scrubbers, which we can assume will be in RDNA3 thanks to Sony introducing them in PS5's design.

Moore's doing nothing more here than cobbling out new clickbait rumors based on older rumors from oddball sources trying to drive traffic to his channel. It's a bit pathetic honestly.

Discuss the points, not the person.

The New geometery engine was briefly mentioned by Cerny in road to ps5, just nobody listened

Cerny has patents on an improved VRS for sectioned priority rendering but mainly for VR, so likely highly custom. But RDNA2 is not out = custom meaning RDNA3 is a bit silly.

So it is likely GE in Ps5 is very unique, but the comments about relative performance is reaching, all you can say is its likely different to PC /. XSX for now

God of war is likley, anyone can guess that.

ps5 manufacturing started in June, so Sony would have had to make serious changes to supply and test well in advance o fJune for any of the hardware changes to be true. Technically possible, commercially unlikely.
 
Last edited:

Md Ray

Member
See, PS5's memory runs at 14 Gbps with a 256-bit memory interface for 448 GB/s of bandwidth. The post mentions 16 Gbps to 18 Gbps. If it was 16 Gbps then it would have given the console 512 GB/s of bandwidth with 256-bit. So I call BS on that one. The 38 CUs claim also seems like another BS.
 
No, bruh, just no. To echo others, would love for it to be true, but let’s be clear here;

He’s suggesting multiple hardware/software component bumps (one going so far as to skip from RDNA2 to RDNA3), his proof is literally “these things that just got revealed, I knew about them months ago, trust me”, and the timing is immediately after a massive console war pile-on from the average at best Xbox showing?

Please at least try to think critically. This ain’t it, chief.
 

Greeno

Member
I'm beginning to literally hate insiders. They hype stuff up to levels that just make impressive things look unimpressive.

the PS5 showcase event was supposed to be extremely impressive according to guys like Shinobi and NateDrake. I was damn disappointed in the end.

Halo Infinite was supposed to look next-gen and beautiful according to virtually all insiders. We know now that that is not true.

I will wait for the August event to judge for myself. I also believe this guy is full of lies. Fable was the worst kept secret in the industry. Any "source" could have predicted that game coming up. It, simply put, doesn't validate that "source".
 

Pallas

Member
"The polygonal rendering of the Geometry Engine will take about a year for third-party developers to master but that Sony's first-party developers have already mastered it"

I stopped reading here.
Sounds like “power of the cell” shit. I don’t doubt it’s a impressive system but cmon ...
 

Pallas

Member
Idk about all this but what I do know is the gameplay tht was showed at Sony's presentation was infinitely better than the very little that was shown at Microsoft's and I don't think thts just due to Microsoft being held back by Xbox one. Ppl keep downplaying PS5's efficiency and modifications as if it doesn't matter, you shall see 😊
Nah, just overall better developer studios with Sony at the moment, plus that Microsoft show didn’t show much gameplay, so it’s hard to gauge what truly next gen Xbox series X only games will look like.
 
PS5 clock speed is tied to power draw, not temps.

Actual TDP is unknown but every system is guaranteed to have some buffer zone. Upping the clocks/CU may just require a fan speed bump to compensate for the higher heat. A trade off of noise for performance.
Sure but thermals are proportional to power draw and the thing was PS5 design was supposed to be constant or deterministic power draw profiles capped by an assumed TDP vs cooling performance.

The only leeway is the overhead you talk about but thats playing with fire in a design that isn't accounting for the ambient temperature of the console (they want a constant low audible fan speed) which is where I'd expect most of the overhead is relying on to work. You eat into the overhead and your eating into the ambient temperatures you can reliably run the console in without overtemping.
 

Kerlurk

Banned
 
Last edited:

Tqaulity

Member
First, I don't think the spec bumps are happening but...I wouldn't totally rule it out. It's entirely possible that Sony released the "lower" baseline specs back in March knowing full well that they were aiming higher. It always looks better to under-spec and over-deliver than vise versa. The biggest impact of any of those specs would be the memory bandwidth bump. I hope that one at least is true. The extra CUs and 100Mhz CPU increase would have minimal impact at best.

In terms of the mystery reboot, I believe that it will be one of the following (in order of probability):

1. Jak and Daxter - Cerny worked on the original for PS2 as well...and let's not forget the clue during the Road to PS5 when he referenced Jak II (seemed pretty random at the time huh?)
2. Socom - been rumored for a while. Now would be a good time. PS4 would have held back some of the ambition for a modern Socom
3. Siphon Filter - been rumored since the PS3 days. I think they are waiting for the right time and right hardware to deliver to true leap. When you think about, the stealth genre has virtually disappeared this past generation...hmmm
4. Twisted Metal - tried to bring it back on PS3 but it didn't do well. Still potential in this franchise and one of the PlayStation's biggest sellers back in the day. But they already have Destruction All Stars and this genre has been all but dead for a while now
 

Gamernyc78

Banned
Nah, just overall better developer studios with Sony at the moment, plus that Microsoft show didn’t show much gameplay, so it’s hard to gauge what truly next gen Xbox series X only games will look like.

We've been hearing this for over a decade. Alot of variables but nahhhh I stand on what I'm saying. But I do agree Sony's first party devs are just better pound for pound overall.
 

Roronoa Zoro

Gold Member
First, I don't think the spec bumps are happening but...I wouldn't totally rule it out. It's entirely possible that Sony released the "lower" baseline specs back in March knowing full well that they were aiming higher. It always looks better to under-spec and over-deliver than vise versa. The biggest impact of any of those specs would be the memory bandwidth bump. I hope that one at least is true. The extra CUs and 100Mhz CPU increase would have minimal impact at best.

In terms of the mystery reboot, I believe that it will be one of the following (in order of probability):

1. Jak and Daxter - Cerny worked on the original for PS2 as well...and let's not forget the clue during the Road to PS5 when he referenced Jak II (seemed pretty random at the time huh?)
2. Socom - been rumored for a while. Now would be a good time. PS4 would have held back some of the ambition for a modern Socom
3. Siphon Filter - been rumored since the PS3 days. I think they are waiting for the right time and right hardware to deliver to true leap. When you think about, the stealth genre has virtually disappeared this past generation...hmmm
4. Twisted Metal - tried to bring it back on PS3 but it didn't do well. Still potential in this franchise and one of the PlayStation's biggest sellers back in the day. But they already have Destruction All Stars and this genre has been all but dead for a while now

It's always amazed me that there's never been another big car combat game. Like that was an awesome concept and with online play it could be truly spectacular and competitive
 
I don't believe it but i wish it was true.
Now that i know for sure my next gen console of choice.

Problem is saving for a 75x950h...suddenly the consoke looks cheap !
 

_Spr_Drnk

Banned
Who here remembers the 3DO and the Atari Jaguar? The 'most powerful' machines of the time.

Now footnotes in VG HW history.
 

SlimySnake

Flashless at the Golden Globes
lol Dont do this to yourself people. This guy has a bad track record. The PS5 specs are locked.

I get it. its tempting. but dont fall for it.
 

sircaw

Banned
I'd like a Mag or Resistance to come back but no thy don't need one we've had tons of great third party fps games filling tht gap New COD, Doom, Metro plus ftp ones tht dominate like Apex and others.

never played them but i know the resistance games are highly regarded.
 

the_master

Member
What a pile of lies.
Nome of his claims have ANYTHING to do with the things he says he heared about the xbox event.

Now it is very easy to get the hype on ps5 after the xbox event but who tells us that guerrilla devs are now at home being thankful that they did not show any gameplay cause it happened like Halo infinite. Great in emgine trailer and disappointing during gameplay.
We have seen almost nothing on both consoles. Get ready for more disappointments
 

Gamernyc78

Banned
What a pile of lies.
Nome of his claims have ANYTHING to do with the things he says he heared about the xbox event.

Now it is very easy to get the hype on ps5 after the xbox event but who tells us that guerrilla devs are now at home being thankful that they did not show any gameplay cause it happened like Halo infinite. Great in emgine trailer and disappointing during gameplay.
We have seen almost nothing on both consoles. Get ready for more disappointments

Sony hype isn't made off one presentation but off of decades of goty winners, contenders and awesome games. Last two months I just played tlou2 and Got and Sony keeps tht quality through generations. Idk what your referring to about Killzone but Killzone on PS4 looked like it's presentation. Campaign was meh but mp was great BTW. Barring gameplay in Halo the visuals looked dated and not next Gen when killzone released it looked next Gen by far.

Excuses for Halo are like the excuses as Crackdown 3 got closer. It went from omg you saw tht destruction shown on a high end pc to crickets when game released.

Why wouldn't ppl believe the Sony hype? They've earned it and consistently deliver, you can't act like Microsoft should get tht same benefit lol two totally diff situations. As Sony consumers they have nothing to worry about I can go in blind and know the next Naughty, Sucker Punch, Guerilla, etc will be eye candy ab
Nd good.
 
Last edited:

sircaw

Banned
Sony hype isn't made off one presentation but off of decades of goty winners, contenders and awesome games. Last two months I just played tlou2 and Got and Sony keeps tht quality through generations. Idk what your referring to about Killzone but Killzone on PS4 looked like it's presentation. Campaign was meh but mp was great BTW. Barring gameplay in Halo the visuals looked dated and not next Gen when killzone released it looked next Gen by far.

Excuses for Halo are like the excuses as Crackdown 3 got closer. It went from omg you saw tht destruction shown on a high end pc to crickets when game released.

Fs it pains me when you come across so well thought out.

Destroys my plans of calling your a meat head with all those damn muscles.

Sigh. :messenger_bicep:
 

Larvana

Member
It's neither. RDNA 1 was pushing pushed by religious Xbox fanatics, and RDNA 3 is being pushed by clickbait youtubers. It's RDNA 2, nothing more, nothing less.

The talk is about certain features that may be in the roadmap for RDNA 3, and that may not be as unlikely as you may think. The PS4 Pro got Vega features 1 year ahead.
Actually RDNA 1 rumour had more with what happened on someone who works for Sony, but trying to bait fanboy war I see.
Moore's Law Is Dead is a YouTuber who talks about video-game technology and purports to receive exclusive information about impending products from industry insiders. In his latest video, which is embedded below, he claims to have received a scoop about the PlayStation 5 and the most recent Xbox game show (July 23rd) months ago but has kept it to himself since then because it was initially unbelievable. He says that the reason that he is revealing it now is that it has recently been proven partially true; supposedly, the scoop revealed - months ago - that the most recent Xbox game show would announce Fable 4 and that it wouldn't reveal the price and release date of the Xbox Series X, both of which are accurate. Hence, he claims that the information in the scoop pertaining to the PlayStation 5 must be true; it is as follows:

1. The PlayStation 5's Geometry Engine will be included in the micro-architecture that will be RDNA3 and that it implements a variant of Variable Rate Shading that runs circles around the Xbox Series X. Its ability to draw polygons will be difficult for the Xbox Series X to compete with.

2. The polygonal rendering of the Geometry Engine will take about a year for third-party developers to master but that Sony's first-party developers have already mastered it, which is why Horizon Forbidden West will actually look as good during gameplay as it does in the in-engine trailer that was revealed during the PlayStation 5 game show last month.

3. The PlayStation 5's ray tracing capabilities are much more customized and subsequently better than they have been revealed to be.

4. The yields of the PlayStation 5's APU at Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company have been better than expected, which has resulted in a sufficient percentage of them having 38 functional CUs on the GPU. Hence, Sony may bump up the official specs of the PlayStation 5 to include 38 active CUs on the GPU rather than the previously announced 36.

5. The PlayStation 5's memory chips may be upgraded from 16 gigabits per second to 18 gigabits per second.

6. The PlayStation 5's CPU frequency may be bumped up by 100Mhz.

7. Sony will be announcing God of War 2 (or 5, depending on how you look at it) in August via a very graphically impressive gameplay demonstration ("jaw dropping graphics that approach photo realism").

8. A reboot of a mystery franchise: "a mainstay of PlayStation, one that used to be a bigger, tent-pole franchise and Mark Cerny is working on it."


This is just nonsense, stop.
 
I predict Twisted Metal reboot based on the life of Charles Manson, but with cars killing people instead of people killing people.
Made by Cerny, but the project was originally called Knack 3 before it got changed into Twisted Metal: Charles Manson.
 
Last edited:

LordOfChaos

Member
4. The yields of the PlayStation 5's APU at Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company have been better than expected, which has resulted in a sufficient percentage of them having 38 functional CUs on the GPU. Hence, Sony may bump up the official specs of the PlayStation 5 to include 38 active CUs on the GPU rather than the previously announced 36.


I always pondered this possibility when it came out that the PS5 was lower in Tflops than the Series X, but never posted it as a serious theory because it would come off as fanboy dreaming. But this would be interesting if true. Kind of mindful of the XBO last minute overclock, but hey, a 5.5% bonus is something, assuming it lets the boost clocks stay where they used to be.

If the other advantages are also true, they need to start talking about them rather than letting narratives run away with a few leakers catching the points.
 
I predict Twisted Metal reboot based on the life of Charles Manson, but with cars killing people instead of people killing people.
Made by Cerny, but the project was originally called Knack 3 before it got changed into Twisted Metal: Charles Manson.

My bet is on Resistance or Spyro the Dragon, since Mark Cerny has worked on those franchises before.
 
Last edited:

Pallas

Member
We've been hearing this for over a decade. Alot of variables but nahhhh I stand on what I'm saying. But I do agree Sony's first party devs are just better pound for pound overall.
If you think he’s telling the truth than Cerny would had undoubtedly talked about “RDNA3” features. I mean you can believe it if you want, but that doesn’t make it true.
 

the_master

Member
Sony hype isn't made off one presentation but off of decades of goty winners, contenders and awesome games. Last two months I just played tlou2 and Got and Sony keeps tht quality through generations. Idk what your referring to about Killzone but Killzone on PS4 looked like it's presentation. Campaign was meh but mp was great BTW. Barring gameplay in Halo the visuals looked dated and not next Gen when killzone released it looked next Gen by far.

Excuses for Halo are like the excuses as Crackdown 3 got closer. It went from omg you saw tht destruction shown on a high end pc to crickets when game released.

Why wouldn't ppl believe the Sony hype? They've earned it and consistently deliver, you can't act like Microsoft should get tht same benefit lol two totally diff situations. As Sony consumers they have nothing to worry about I can go in blind and know the next Naughty, Sucker Punch, Guerilla, etc will be eye candy ab
Nd good.
This is not even hype, it is a false rumor.
And no, I won't blindly believe anyone's hype. I may feel the hype, follow the hype, hype others, but I am always ready for disappointment.
Sony has made great games, Ms has made great games and nintendo and sega also made great games.
Most games are multiplatform by the way, so a company does not guarantee quality in all cases.

After the xbox disastrous event, think about why sony also didn't show gameplay for its games except for ratchet (wich already was nothing like the cinematic gameplay pretend from the beginning of crazy world swapping)

We have seen close to 0 real gameplay on both consoles. They are not ready for launch, they may launch regardless. Expect some disapointments at launch.
Also expect great games and better games later on.
 
This is kind of a bullshit "scoop." How the hell would a person have knowledge of both an Xbox showcase AND Sony's Hardware AND Sony's software strategy AND know how third party developers have been handling PS5?

Also, the whole "Sony might change the system to have 38 CUs and not 36" statement is such bullshit and Sony would in no ways do that after the consoles have already begun production, and since supposedly the PS4 backwards compatibility revolves around the 36CUs, I also don't think they would do that.
 

93xfan

Banned
Can’t wait! Does it reactivate servers they shut down as well and do PS1-3 BC? I heard it does, but want a reliable source
 

LordOfChaos

Member
Also, the whole "Sony might change the system to have 38 CUs and not 36" statement is such bullshit and Sony would in no ways do that after the consoles have already begun production, and since supposedly the PS4 backwards compatibility revolves around the 36CUs, I also don't think they would do that.

Whether this rumor is true or not, I never really bought that their API was so un-portable that the GPU would need to have the exact CU count for BC. Just like the Pro could disable half for unpatched games, it should be able to write off CUs at the OS and API layer so that the chip doesn't need exactly 36 CUs for BC. This was always just theorycraft from similar people behind the no RT rumors and so on.
 
Last edited:

vpance

Member
Sure but thermals are proportional to power draw and the thing was PS5 design was supposed to be constant or deterministic power draw profiles capped by an assumed TDP vs cooling performance.

The only leeway is the overhead you talk about but thats playing with fire in a design that isn't accounting for the ambient temperature of the console (they want a constant low audible fan speed) which is where I'd expect most of the overhead is relying on to work. You eat into the overhead and your eating into the ambient temperatures you can reliably run the console in without overtemping.

If they end up bumping perf then it’s basically a similar situation to X1 launch. As in the hardware had enough TDP headroom and adequate cooling for them to do it.

We can only speculate what the impact would be, but IMO I think they over-engineered the thing. It’s a lot bigger than I expected, so I think they could easily bump it slightly given the current spec.
 

ZehDon

Member
When will Papa Cerny drop the second GPU ATOM BOMB and DESTROY Xbox? I don’t know, but I’m sure MLID will give us a 10:01 long video on it!
 

Tripolygon

Banned
Some good questions to ask yourself when it comes to these "rumors" is

How likely is it that one person not super high up in the company to have all these information?
If the answer is not very likely then it is not true

Does it sound too good to be true?
If the answer is yes then it is likely not true.

Is the rumor being spread on Youtube by the people who have not gotten anything right?
If the answer is yes then it is likely not true
 
Top Bottom