DennisK4 said:
Why are people upset?
I get told over and over here that graphics don't matter and its gameplay that counts. I guess its only when the comparison is with PC that graphics aren't important but when the Sony and MS consoles go head to head suddenly its a different story.....
Graphics do matter. They don't matter in comparison to PC gaming because PC hardware can be updated much more frequently. Comparing a $300 - $500 machine that has been out for years to a $1,100+ dollar machine customized with all of the latest technologies isn't really a fair comparison. However, when waiting several years for a new breed of hardware, gamers will expect it to be significantly more powerful than the last revision.
In regards to 'it's all about gameplay', if that was the case, there would be no need for new hardware. We can stick with what we have now. And on another note, more powerful hardware can definitely have gameplay ramifications, whether it comes to player count (Battlefield 3 PC vs. consoles), physics and more.
If Sony is going to make a casual machine and implement some wiggly waggly, shakey, touchey gimmick to draw in people who don't normally play games, then they'll face the very risk of alienating the hardcore/noncasual crowd and leaving that to Microsoft while entering a territory that they are sure to lose, which is Nintendo with the 'innovative gameplay mechanisms.' That's not a great position to be in.