StarSketch
Banned
Ok, what the heck are you doing?
Are you trying to egg everyone on to vote for you?
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Ace Attorney [Mafia] |OT| Turnabout Scum
- Thread starter Sorian
- Start date
Ok, what the heck are you doing?
Are you trying to egg everyone on to vote for you?
TheWorthyEdge
Member
We made it pretty far too! XD
Yeah, that time I was going to name call. I realized afterwards that role claim would've been more anti-town than a name claim.
The inactives.
TheWorthyEdge
Member
This is interesting here.
So you're saying that as more people come they are simply going to throw a vote at me, and that I want to get voted out?
What am I doing? Trying to prod anyone for any type of discussion. Any type of discussion is better than no discussion. People can't just throw a vote down 1 day and a half before the day ends and call it quits!
You guys say I'm so anti-town, and give good reason, but you're not doing anything right now to further the Town win.
Current Vote Count:
TheWorthyEdge (5)
CornBurrito
ScraftyDevil
Xamtheking
Matt Attack
roytheone
CornBurrito (4)
TheWorthyEdge
EzekelRAGE
TheGoddamn
Ri'Orius
Hipster Cthulhu (2)
Xamtheking
squidyj
CrimsonFist
Drago
TheWorthyEdge
TheGoddamn (1)
CrimsonFist
CrimsonFist
StanleyPalmtree (1)
Bowlie
Xamtheking (1)
roytheone
ScraftyDevil
Zubz
TheWorthyEdge
CrimsonFist
Drago (1)
RedFalco
EzekelRAGE (0)
TheWorthyEdge
squidyj
StarSketch
Redfalco (0)
Xamtheking
Drago
Ri'Orius (0)
CrimsonFist
squidyj (0)
CornBurrito
Matt Attack (0)
TheWorthyEdge
10 votes are needed for majority
Day 2 ends in:
TheWorthyEdge (5)
CornBurrito
ScraftyDevil
Xamtheking
Matt Attack
roytheone
CornBurrito (4)
EzekelRAGE
TheGoddamn
Ri'Orius
Hipster Cthulhu (2)
squidyj
Drago
TheWorthyEdge
TheGoddamn (1)
CrimsonFist
StanleyPalmtree (1)
Bowlie
Xamtheking (1)
Zubz
Drago (1)
RedFalco
EzekelRAGE (0)
Redfalco (0)
Ri'Orius (0)
squidyj (0)
Matt Attack (0)
10 votes are needed for majority
Day 2 ends in:
ScraftyDevil
Banned
Can I just say that I feel very uncomfortable about Corn, who's basically confirmed town at this point, hovering at only 1 vote behind the vote leader? If Edge is a villain, then it'd be very very easy for them to jump on Corn at the last minute and save their teammate.
Ezekel, Goddamn, I'd be very pleased if you were to place those votes elsewhere. Especially you Mr. Rage; those two votes could mean the difference between life and death.
Ezekel, Goddamn, I'd be very pleased if you were to place those votes elsewhere. Especially you Mr. Rage; those two votes could mean the difference between life and death.
CrimsonFist
Member
He is? You getting confused with Squidy?
CrimsonFist
Member
I think Star, Hipster and StanleyPalmtree are the only ones without a vote right now.
ScraftyDevil
Banned
No, I mean Corn for sure.
CrimsonFist
Member
Fair enough.
EzekelRAGE
Member
How is corn confirmed town?
EzekelRAGE
Member
Only confirmed town who isn't dead is Scrafty.
StarSketch
Banned
To be honest, I'm wondering where you got that too.
ScraftyDevil
Banned
Trust me on this. I'd have no reason whatsoever to deceive you.
I'm not avoiding it though? As I said in the post I made last night:
I was planning on putting my vote on you tonight, unless any shocking developments came up today. That's why I put a prod vote on Hipster instead, which seems to have done nothing at all. You still haven't done that name claim you said you were going to do hours ago so at this point I'm just going to vote for you now.
VOTE: TheWorthyEdge
Sorry that I haven't been able to add much of anything to discussion. That reads list I put up Sunday night was originally much longer but I realized that a lot of my reads were essentially just repeats of what others had posted, so I just put up ones for people I thought I could add something to, but I guess I still didn't add much then. My next reads list will have everyone on it.
Xamtheking
Member
Pretty sure Scrafty is scum because she isn't taking all of the thoughts in her head and putting them into the thread.
...
That was a joke.
...
That was a joke.
TheWorthyEdge
Member
The first post that technically proves someone is scum.
You put a vote on me because I didn't name claim. Do you understand what you have done? My suspicions of you have been fully backed up right now.
There is absolutely no other person that is more scum to me than you currently. With the whole QBro thing, you not voting me when you even said you wanted to vote for me, and what you just did there's no doubt in my mind you are scum.
VOTE: Drago
You wanted me to name claim. Thats, even though it's less anti-town than role claim, horrible. You put a vote timer on me so that I could do an Anti-town act.
CornBurrito
Member
Wish you'd been more subtle about that.
CornBurrito
Member
Anyway I don't think it benefits anyone for me OR scrafty to elaborate. So I won't for now. Let scum sweat it out.
That doesn't prove anything, though. It's weird, sure, but it's something you said you'd do, and the post made it sound like you genuinely had a reason to want to name claim, and it could be assumed that it'd be pro-town. Granted, after last night, I'm guessing that name claim was probably a joke, but it didn't sit right with me, either. This post just screams of someone scrambling to find an argument. This isn't a new development, but at this point, it's starting to feel weird.
You've definitely become the most suspicious player, Edge. I don't want to do this to a former Combat Buddy, man, but at this point, your many erratic actions are striking me as weirder than Xam's constant points of zero substance.
Vote: TheWorthyEdge
TheWorthyEdge
Member
That doesn't prove anything, though. It's weird, sure, but it's something you said you'd do, and the post made it sound like you genuinely had a reason to want to name claim, and it could be assumed that it'd be pro-town. Granted, after last night, I'm guessing that name claim was probably a joke, but it didn't sit right with me, either. This post just screams of someone scrambling to find an argument. This isn't a new development, but at this point, it's starting to feel weird.
You've definitely become the most suspicious player, Edge. I don't want to do this to a former Combat Buddy, man, but at this point, your many erratic actions are striking me as weirder than Xam's constant points of zero substance.
Vote: TheWorthyEdge
IT'S RIGHT THERE! HAHA!
Cmon.....I did say I was going to do it, but then people were like it probably isn't the best of ideas as nothing would come out of it and then Drago votes me for not name claiming?
Zubz. Man. I thought you were better than this. Nothing I've done screams scum more than what Drago just did...
StarSketch
Banned
Too bad I can't vote for two people, because both of you are looking scummy to me. :/
And I don't think this is a bus attempt either.
And I don't think this is a bus attempt either.
TheWorthyEdge
Member
Bus attempt? What's that?
StarSketch
Banned
Scum player trying to get a teammate lynched.
EzekelRAGE
Member
*sigh*
Unvote
Unvote
TheWorthyEdge
Member
I actually did that last game too Nin. Lol. Did not fucking work at all.
Wait, who's the other scum? ... Did I do something wrong?
TheWorthyEdge
Member
Drago and I.
Xamtheking
Member
Lollipop Dave still has metro tickets for eternity
Wait, who's Lollipop Dave? And my Killinger question was never answered, either. :/
StarSketch
Banned
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
i think im missing something here,
what about what drago just said was so assuredly scummy?
what about what drago just said was so assuredly scummy?
TheWorthyEdge
Member
He placed his vote on me because I didn't role claim.
Xamtheking
Member
And you call yourself a detective
For shame
Killinger is a callback to Werewolf 2 in Season 4
Lollipop Dave was bussed so hard in Werewolf 1
TheWorthyEdge
Member
Xam what's your take on this Drago thing?
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
okay so im not missing anything, but i think you are.
that was far from the only reason he voted for you.
also i dont think you ever said you had changed your mind about the name claim, someone (i think matt attack?) said it was a bad idea, and then silence from you.
Also if im wrong about any of this please correct me, i dont really have the time to go back and read through the actual posts.
TheWorthyEdge
Member
You're not, but I said I was going to roleclaim and I didnt because it's stupid. I WILL roleclaim if it comes time tomorrow before I'm going to die but I feel like the thread will be so dead that no one will even bother.
StarSketch
Banned
So to recap:
Drago:
Edge:
...I'm going to go with my gut for this one.
Vote
rago
That being said, TWE you need to settle down.
People have lives, it's not your job to constantly bump the thread.
Drago:
- Is pushing for a roleclaim even though that's a really bad idea and should not be egging Edge on
- Was holding his vote on Edge instead of just voting for him after calling him suspicious
Edge:
- Has been...On edge...for a while now
- Repeatedly said he was going to roleclaim (one instance was a joke that went sour, the other sounded like an attempt to get people off his back)
...I'm going to go with my gut for this one.
Vote
ragoThat being said, TWE you need to settle down.
People have lives, it's not your job to constantly bump the thread.
I never said I was a detective. So wait, was there a Venture game?!
TheWorthyEdge
Member
That's why I even debated about whether I should role claim or not, because if I did do it tomorrow chances are no one will even be there to bat an eye.
StarSketch
Banned
Also, TWE if you don't stop wigging out, I'm going to reconsider where I put my vote.
TheWorthyEdge
Member
So to recap:
Drago:
- Is pushing for a roleclaim even though that's a really bad idea and should not be egging Edge on
- Was holding his vote on Edge instead of just voting for him after calling him suspicious
Edge:
- Has been...On edge...for a while now
- Repeatedly said he was going to roleclaim (one instance was a joke that went sour, the other sounded like an attempt to get people off his back)
...I'm going to go with my gut for this one.
Vote
That being said, TWE you need to settle down.
People have lives, it's not your job to constantly bump the thread.
Finally. Someone with some common sense...I know I need to settle down, but I can't right now.
TheGoddamn
Member
2. Bowlie [m] - Fairly inactive, but I think that's because he's new. Seems to be doing his best to learn the ropes.
3. CornBurrito [m] - I'm onto his scent. I've made my feelings on him clear, and I think they're easy to follow. However, this new development by ScraftyDevil, which came up as I was writing this post, must complement, if not supersede, my scrutiny. I have to rethink my position and consider other possibilities.
4. Crimsonfist [m] - Good contributions. Leaning town, funnily enough because of his prod votes on me. Still, I've only spoken at length about CB because that's all I could focus on at the time. I don't really play the more conversational, active GAFia, mostly because of my time zone being so out of sync with that of everyone else (especially with the seeming majority of players on the American continent/s).
5. EzekelRAGE [m] - his power has been conclusively proven, although that isn't proof positive that he is town (even if his claimed AA character was a good guy). I do like that he came out and said it without prompting, but as squidy-- today's recipient of Zeke's power-- pointed out, it was also driven by his need to appear clean in the event that the vote tally was scrutinized. Likely neutral, given the nature of his power to do as much harm to town as good. Xam's claim is reliant on his power.
6. Hipster Cthulhu [m] -- Notable by his absence. Null, but anti-town.
8. Matt Attack [m] -- Excellent read of TWE. That was a town move; I doubt scum would bus this early (although considering that TWE's weird behavior could be seen as an extension of what his normal playstyle apparently is, this could all be a high-risk charade between fellow. But that can be tabled for now, and is a speculation train that leads to madness).
9. QuantumBro [m] Drago [m] -- He's done an okay job of repenting for the sins of his father. I'd like for him to contribute more, though.
10. Redfalco [m] -- null.
11. Ri'Orius [m] -- null. Also voted for CB, but interestingly enough, not named by Scrafty in her request to remove votes.
12. RobotNinjaHornets [m] - Died N1
13. roytheone [m] -- Town, for similar reasons as Crimsonfist. Good insight, too. Plus, I don't think he would have any reason to lie about being blackmailed.
14. ScraftyDevil [f] -- I trust Sorian 100%, so I trust ScraftyDevil 100%. Divine intervention goes a long way. I felt weird about her ultimatum, and yet I followed it. Why? I respect that she's the only living confirmed town to every player, and so she has to work in absolutes. The ultimatum mostly worked, thereby generating material that will be good for reads. Although I'm worried about her bringing CB out into the open like this (with a smaller, converse worry that she may be being led on by CB), I'm trusting her plan again now:
Unvote
15. squidyj [m] -- I'm leaning town, not least because of Xam's investigation (which I believe). But I do have a bit of a blind spot for squid given my Archer experience with him, which I'll have to rectify, especially with Scrafty's vouching for CB (i.e., at least one of the most active players has to be scum. But as it stands, that's likely TWE).
16. StanleyPalmtree [m] -- Notable for that opening post that CB jumped on. Voted on by Bowlie, and they had a little exchange about that.
17. StarSketch [f] -- Under my radar. Good insight about the events of N1.
18. TheGoddamn [m] -- I'd like for him to post more.
19. TheWorthyEdge [m] -- my entries on Matt Attack and squidy referenced this my thoughts on TWE, but his erratic behavior does point to scumminess. I've not played with TheWorthyEdge previously, but he seems to jump on every minor talking point with illogical arguments-- an easy way to seem active. If this really is his play style, it's still anti-town. Nearly every post of his that I've read has had me wondering what he was doing, and not in a semi-entertained way like those of Blarg and to a lesser extent Xam. However, if he really were scum, I doubt he would be so brash as to make the mistake of going for (sometimes unreadable) quantity over quality. I doubt anyone would be that ill-advised. Speaking of which...
20. Xamtheking [m] -- I believe Xam's claim. It was idiotic, and could have been saved for a better time, but the way he presented it was straightforward and logically sound. It was extremely fortuitous that Xam/Zeke/Squid we all involved in night actions so that Xam could make this claim. It's something that's unlikely if they were all scum and would try a gambit like this, drawing attention to each of them. Their being among the top most active players also suggests against them all being in on a farfetched house of cards.
21. Zubz [m] -- I like his stream of consciousness posts. Real hardboiled. Under my radar as well.
Finally,
Vote: TheWorthyEdge
I was actually considering voting for EzekelRAGE-- a probable neutral-- at this point, but as I was writing down the reasons for my decision (and correspondingly why I wasn't voting for TWE), it just made no sense to do it today. The main factors are the amount of time left and TWE's bizarre behavior, which is verging on a meltdown (in true Ace Attorney style). Points I was raising for a Zeke lynch include the fact that the win condition requires neutrals to be gone, the unwieldiness of Zeke's power, as well as the information we would get from his flip. However, we stand to gain just as much, if not more, from TWE's flip.
Initially, I was hesitant to cast my vote for TheWorthyEdge because I was adamant in my refusal to believe that someone who was scum would play so fucking badly. Nothing TWE says makes any sense. Had I avoided voting for him, I was going to say that if TWE was a town PR and was hiding something in his posts of "jokes" and being all over the place, it would take a much more patient and considerate reader than me to pick up on it. But that's already been done, by Matt and roy. But even if they were wrong, and TWE flipped town, the way he's been playing is just appalling.
Xamtheking
Member
FOR SHAME GUMSHOE
StarSketch
Banned
BTW, Edge now has 8 votes.
TheWorthyEdge
Member
My role!
You are Marvin Grossberg, Keeper of the Hemorrhoids
Your role is Vanilla Town
A veteran defense attorney that served as mentor to Mia Fey and Diego Armando. Not the brightest attorney but easily able to stand toe-to-toe with Winston Payne, as long as your hemorrhoids dont act up again.
You do not have any actions, but you may judge your peers in the court of law (which means you can vote).
There ya have it. I'm worthless lol.
You are Marvin Grossberg, Keeper of the Hemorrhoids
Your role is Vanilla Town
A veteran defense attorney that served as mentor to Mia Fey and Diego Armando. Not the brightest attorney but easily able to stand toe-to-toe with Winston Payne, as long as your hemorrhoids dont act up again.
You do not have any actions, but you may judge your peers in the court of law (which means you can vote).
There ya have it. I'm worthless lol.
TheWorthyEdge
Member
Headed too bed now.
Hopefully I don't get the hammer before then and when I wake up in 8 hours.
Want to be there for my inevitable death.
Hopefully I don't get the hammer before then and when I wake up in 8 hours.
Want to be there for my inevitable death.
EzekelRAGE
Member
Should I hammer?
TG - If anyone pointed out the thing with my voting, it was me in several posts, I explained each scenario.
Sidenote - Earlier this day phase we were saying how it made no sense SJ was still alive since they would target someone like him due to activity, his activity has slowed down a lot compared to ystrday. Could be due to being busy, could be due to slowing down activity to not appear to be a good target so we don't question why he wasnt targeted. I know the xam read, but it was so weird, I'm still on the fence about it.
TG - If anyone pointed out the thing with my voting, it was me in several posts, I explained each scenario.
Sidenote - Earlier this day phase we were saying how it made no sense SJ was still alive since they would target someone like him due to activity, his activity has slowed down a lot compared to ystrday. Could be due to being busy, could be due to slowing down activity to not appear to be a good target so we don't question why he wasnt targeted. I know the xam read, but it was so weird, I'm still on the fence about it.
EzekelRAGE
Member
My post was before TWE roleclaimed
and it seems like he did his rolepm word for word, are we allowed to do that?
and it seems like he did his rolepm word for word, are we allowed to do that?
Xamtheking
Member
You're not supposed to
But Sorian will probably forgive that transgression