Support NeoGAF

[Iva Demilcol]

This cosplayer did it right:

just google "ridiculously photogenic joker"

 

[kess]

The Joker requires a bit of kitsch to really pull off right, that said, the Bolland design works because you can see echoes of his old persona flash through. I still prefer the classic Joker color design, though.

I love that cheesy "Joker" logo, which is exactly as it should look, like Richie Rich went psychotic.

 

[dan2026]

They literally wrote DAMAGED on his head.

How did no sane person in the production look at it and say, 'wait, this is fucking awful'?

 

[Stallion Dan]

Best dances to Prince.

 

[MechaX]

They literally wrote DAMAGED on his head.

How did no sane person in the production look at it and say, 'wait, this is fucking awful'?

How would the audience know he is DAMAGED if it weren't for that?!?!

 

[Azure Dream]

Unpopular opinion, but I think Ledger's Joker was bad as a Joker, but good as its own thing. He was a modern design of a villain that really resonated with people, but to do it they threw out way too much of what makes the Joker in the first place.

He was a different, great character that got called the Joker because they had to.

 

[ElRenoRaven]

I love em all except Leto. That Joker is without a doubt the worst hunk of shit ever put on screen/paper when it comes to Joker. WB should be ashamed of it and should never be allowed to live it down.

 

[Imbarkus]

Weighing on on the bad ones... I'ma go with staple-face Joker as the worst:

Young Justice Joker didn't quite do it for me:

I don't give a fuck that he is Cesar Romero, shave the 'stache for the role, dude:

 

[NeoRausch]

.

Damm!

 

[Nev]

Injustice 2 joker is like they tried to make a less edgy Leto but failed and created some bland in-between.

Leto is the absolute worst. Trash for 16 yo edgelord/lady deviantart/tumblr kids.

It is to Jokers what Twilight is for vampires.

 

[cr0w]

And done.

Close second is Jim Aparo's.

 

[NotTheGuyYouKill]

the dark knight joker conceptual

I think Ledger's Joker and Arkham Origins Joker are the best ones by far, but I would have loved to have seen this horror-oriented Joker.

Stuff of nightmares.

 

[Akainu]

Ok? What?

Don't just post a picture and leave you lazy sobs.

 

[Einchy]

I'll be honest: Ledger's joker is still a terrible design. There's a reason people balked at it when they first saw it; he sold it 100% on the strength of his performance, while the aesthetic design remained completely terrible through and through.

Not, like, Jared Leto wangsta Joker terrible, mind, but it's still low-tier design work.

I don't remember this at all.

I remember people being iffy when that black and white picture came out since you really couldn't see the design well but everyone changed their tune once the trailer and final images came out.

 

[Astral Dog]

 

[NOLA_Gaffer]

I have a soft spot for Brave & the Bold's Joker design because just about everything about that show is underrated and underappreciated as fuck.

 

[Azure Dream]

I have a soft spot for Brave & the Bold's Joker design because just about everything about that show is underrated and underappreciated as fuck.

That show was underappreciated because 75% of it was in-jokes you already had to be a DC nerd to actually get. On the surface it wasn't a particularly great show.

 

[Imperial Bishop]

This cosplayer did it right:

just google "ridiculously photogenic joker"

I would kill to see a movie design for the Joker that was similar to this.

 

[gfxtwin]

Dig the Ledger and Arkham jokers the most. Wasn't feeling the Suicide Squad or most recent one from Injustice at all.

 

[Burbeting]

I personally don't like the "thrown into acid" backstory much, so I prefer the joker designs were his face is more clearly make-up, inperfect and muddied. So I guess I like TDK joker most? TAS Joker is the best one out of the acid-jokers though.

Suicide Squad Joker looks like what Joel Schumacher would have put into his film. So that is the worst.

 

[jasonng]

This thread made me realize I don't like most of the Jokers' design.

 

[Camoxide]

How bad would Leto's Joker be if it didn't have the grill and damaged?

 

[The Adder]

And I personally really, really liked Kevin Michael Richardson's performance. Very high energy, and could turn it up even higher or tone it down appropriately. He could really do a less refined and less mafia bossy Joker.

Easily the best Joker after Hamill.

 

[TheRedSnifit]

Weighing on on the bad ones... I'ma go with staple-face Joker as the worst:

People are in here criticizing the DAMAGED, and for good reason, but even that looks clever and subtle compared to faceless Joker. It's contrived, trite, and gratuitous.

Spoopy

 

[LionPride]

 

[ElBoxyBrown]

People are in here criticizing the DAMAGED, and for good reason, but even that looks clever and subtle compared to faceless Joker. It's contrived, trite, and gratuitous.



Spoopy

I thought it was amazing the way different artists drew his deteriorated mask. But visuals aren't everything as strong writing will carry your design, which Leto Joker didn't have.

 

[Salsa]

imma go Bruce Timm's purely because I think his version of The Joker is the most recognizable and he brought it down to basics, you'd recognize him just by silhouette

 

[Dipper145]

Really liked jared letos joker look, definitely one of the best, and heath ledger.

Recently started reading older comics as well and almost can't believe the old joker designs, doesn't even look like its possible for a face to be actually shaped in the way he was portrayed, If everyone is stylized with non-human faces in a similar manner its fine, but when it's pretty much just the joker being a triangle head its real bad. It's really unfortunate that joker is most often portrayed that way.

 

[Salsa]

Lee Bermejo Joker is one I've always been partial to. It's the basis for the Ledger Joker:

I have a big ass print of his cover without the words and it might be my favorite Joker image ever

but im not a huge fan of the whole design

 

[DrForester]

Can't be the best Joker without a mustache.

And man was his laugh infectious.

 

[JohnTinker]

http://www.cbsnews.com/news/miami-j...arrested-pointed-gun-cars-miami-dade-florida/

 

[J-Tier]

I like most Joker designs. TAS may be my favorite though.

Meh on Injustice 2 Joker. Too close to Leto Joker for my taste. Try-hard edgy.

Hate Leto Joker with a fury.

 

[joeygreco1985]

I don't give a fuck that he is Cesar Romero, shave the 'stache for the role, dude:

In his defence you probably couldnt see the stache in SD back in the day

 

[jviggy43]

How bad would Leto's Joker be if it didn't have the grill and damaged?

Still ultra bad. Walking around growling at everything and his over extended animations and features for every action he did was groan worthy.

 

[J-Tier]

Still ultra bad. Walking around growling at everything and his over extended animations and features for every action he did was groan worthy.

The smile tattoo he has on the back of his hand was particularly stupid for me. The way he put it up to his face...

 

[Shake Appeal]

The original Joker is pretty great. TAS, too. Bolland's Killing Joke, obviously. I think Capullo's is pretty good. The best videogame depiction is Arkham: Origins.

There is no great film depiction, but Ledger's is the most interesting one.

The worst are Nicholson and Leto. I also kinda hate the non-Origins Arkham ones, especially the first game.

 

[Fancyarcher]

Best: Batman: the Animated series.
Worst: All Star Batman & Robin Joker, he doesn't even smile the fuck?

 

[Serrato]

imma go Bruce Timm's purely because I think his version of The Joker is the most recognizable and he brought it down to basics, you'd recognize him just by silhouette

Impressive how that version of the this Joker is better with just the red lips.

 

[blummer102]

Giving a nod to Norm Breyfogle Joker.

 

[ArtHands]

Best

Worst

Agree.

 

[ffejeromdiks]

People are in here criticizing the DAMAGED, and for good reason, but even that looks clever and subtle compared to faceless Joker. It's contrived, trite, and gratuitous.



Spoopy

Different strokes, I loved this look. You don't get the artist that drew Spawn for a decade on a Batman run and then ask him to do a completely straight edge adaptation of the Joker.

 

[DiscoJer]

In his defence you probably couldnt see the stache in SD back in the day

I watched that show as a kid and I never noticed until now. And I had to look really, really closely.

 

[cr0w]

Giving a nod to Norm Breyfogle Joker.

Breyfogle's art was always incredible. I loved his style. He's been having a rough go of it the past few years, I've kept up with him on FB. Had a stroke, lost use of his drawing hand, and just generally had a bad time. He seems to be doing better though.

 

[Loxley]

Since all the greats have already been mentioned, I really liked the look of the Joker in the Batman: Dead End fan film from a decade ago:

The hair could use some work, but overall it's perfectly creepy.

 

[CO_Andy]

Tetsuya Nomura knows what's up (also Yoshitaka Amano below, but that's Final Fantasy)

 

[Jumeira]

Best: Heath Ledger Joker

Worst: Leto

 

[Boss Doggie]

I really hate Arkham games Joker

 

[TheGreatDirector]

Leto Joker is a mixed design. I like some parts, hate others, but I don't mind the attempt - Suicide Squad has this weird "faux-gangsta" feel to its characters and he fits that world.

Absolutely awful performance though. Just bafflingly bad. Between that and Lex Luthor is was a rough year. But on sheer design merits? I can live with it.

The best, though? Shout-out to Gotham Central. There's something super unsettling about a pudgy, middle-aged man in clown makeup. If you go too far, he's just "scary" and you lose the uncanniness. He's a wolf in sheep's clothing to the Nth degree.

Yeah, Gotham Central's design is extremely underrated. It helps that for the short time appears he's written great too, being a complete wild card for the police to try and handle.

Another underrated design in my opinion is the Man Who Laughs Joker.

I really like the black fingernails and yellow and green eyes really stand out.

 

[Maximo]

Probably this one from Mask Of The Phantasm.

 

[Iva Demilcol]

I would kill to see a movie design for the Joker that was similar to this.

They would have to acknowledge that the Joker is a comic book character first.

Tetsuya Nomura knows what's up (also Yoshitaka Amano below, but that's Final Fantasy)

lol @ Joker with Cloud's hairstyle.