-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Election 2016 [Mafia] | Everlasting GOPstoppers
- Thread starter Ourobolus
- Start date
- Status
Bananaspaceprincess
Neo Member
Please I'm not against lynching me as long as it doesn't happen simply because it's the easiest choice and you have nothing to lose.
Sure, and I agree. This post is a whole lot better than your previous one.
nin, who do you think is worth investigating atm? You have established yourself as a townie, so I trust your intentions.
Yes, sorry for not taking my time with my previous posts. I am currently on mobile and I just wrote down things before thinking
I keep getting massive scum reads off of posts like this, and then I realise it's just nin fucking around.
It's really unhelpful man :/
I put down a far better post down with my thoughts. Like I said sorry for that.
You don't think there's any chance this is actually a Sk, or just plain scum?
The possibility is there, yes but I am inclined to believe her for now.
I just don't want to see another witch hunt.
Hyperactivity
Banned
Idk, two neutrals is IMO on the high side for the number of neutrals for a smaller game. If bsp is indeed voteless, than there's probably some other thing she's hiding from us
Btw bsp, will you say whether you're neutral or not?
Btw bsp, will you say whether you're neutral or not?
Thanks for reposting it. So assuming we trust you, Nin is either GoP, or something that tricks your scan.
I still feel like we have to go after BSP. Maybe Hyperactivity or Kalor.
I agree that a vig should generally not start killing immediately, but in practice, most vigs can't resist using the power.
I'm still inclined to think SK though. There's probably only 3 scum, so a lucky vig could shorten this game drastically, while a SK is invested in killing both sides.
I'm leaning Hyper, if only because Kalor is MIA and I want reads from him before he dies.
He still has not posted, would love to hear from him.
Please don't edit my posts in that way when you quote them. It's fine if you're cutting out bits to shorten it, but you've literally changed what I was saying.
Sorry, my bad wanted to put down some dots.
I still agree that we should look into those players aswell.
Lone_Prodigy
Member
Images are blocked for me. Is cabot suggesting a limited-shot vig/SK ability for BSP? Could explain what happened to Burbeting.
I think we wasted enough time on BSP, everything that will be said now ist just icing on the cake. How are you doing LP?
Will put down my thoughts in a bit. Currently at work.
CornBurrito
Member
Disagree. It makes most sense as a neutral role. How can you be electorate if you can't vote?
CornBurrito
Member
The might be too meta, but given Trumps talk on illegals being murderers and rapists, BSP may actually be SK material.
CornBurrito
Member
Though he did say some were probably good people. Yeah not comfortable with the vote against her right now unless nobody better comes up.
Sorry for not posting much today, I went to bed shortly after I posted at the start of the day phase and can't post here until I get home.
I don't think we should bother with BSP today, their role seems believeable to me and I feel like the Electorate would try to say that the role is GOP aligned as soon as possible to prevent furthur suspicion. It makes more sense as a neutral role to me and it seems to match with the flavor for what that's worth.
For a Election themed game, having a lot of vote based roles makes some amount of sense. I don't know if we have an override but someone mentioned a double vote on the first day and that stuck with me.
I don't think we should bother with BSP today, their role seems believeable to me and I feel like the Electorate would try to say that the role is GOP aligned as soon as possible to prevent furthur suspicion. It makes more sense as a neutral role to me and it seems to match with the flavor for what that's worth.
For a Election themed game, having a lot of vote based roles makes some amount of sense. I don't know if we have an override but someone mentioned a double vote on the first day and that stuck with me.
CornBurrito
Member
Just read this. Ok I absolutely hate when people do this "oh woe is me, just vote for me it will help town win" garbage. It just irks me the wrong way. Not enough to policy lynch.
You want him dead?
Sorry maze but it's kind of tough to communicate with you atm
Never Forever
Member
awfully sorry for my absence guys, I had an unexpected early start and have been pretty rushed off my feet on a day that I thought would be far more leisurely
thoughts on some of the things that have presented themselves in the first half of this day phase
Bananaspaceprincess - I don't think that the roleclaim and the flavour match, with the 'illegal immigrant' role not really matching the rest of the GOP-aligned players. I think that she's the most likely candidate for the third-party killer based on what little info we have. I'm leaning towards this mostly because there's no way there could be a player whose sole defining quality is a lack of vote. Moreover, I think that if she were GOP-aligned she would have been upfront with her lack of vote immediately as opposed to waiting until somebody noticed. There's more to unpack here than meets the eye.
Also 'there is a chance my visa might get approved'. Hmm. I would think that there would be a fixed condition clearly stated in the role PM, but who the fuck knows considering that the kingkitty mess turned out to be 110% true.
Lone_Prodigy - The main issue with L_P is that he replaced Launchpad, who quite a few people thought was acting suspiciously, and so in occupying his role he naturally falls under scrutiny. Everyone has remarked that Launch defended Salva, but the Defender of the People was also strongly in opposition to the nin and cabot votes, and I think he also commented on the kingkitty vote but I'm not sure. Launch also made some very strange non-statements that I think Fireblend picked up on, where he basically used a lot of words to say nothing at all.
Maybe that's just the way Launch is, but in that case the way Launch is is scummy as hell and L_P is left with a lot to answer for by standing in his shoes.
Kalor - I'm unfamiliar with Kalor but I still have absolutely no opinion on him, which nearly halfway into Day 2 in a 16-player game is a bit weird. His posts are quite MOR and he doesn't really engage that much aside from when pushed.
also I think on reflection that it's most probably a Serial Killer on the loose for balance reasons
more to come as I think of it
thoughts on some of the things that have presented themselves in the first half of this day phase
Bananaspaceprincess - I don't think that the roleclaim and the flavour match, with the 'illegal immigrant' role not really matching the rest of the GOP-aligned players. I think that she's the most likely candidate for the third-party killer based on what little info we have. I'm leaning towards this mostly because there's no way there could be a player whose sole defining quality is a lack of vote. Moreover, I think that if she were GOP-aligned she would have been upfront with her lack of vote immediately as opposed to waiting until somebody noticed. There's more to unpack here than meets the eye.
Also 'there is a chance my visa might get approved'. Hmm. I would think that there would be a fixed condition clearly stated in the role PM, but who the fuck knows considering that the kingkitty mess turned out to be 110% true.
Lone_Prodigy - The main issue with L_P is that he replaced Launchpad, who quite a few people thought was acting suspiciously, and so in occupying his role he naturally falls under scrutiny. Everyone has remarked that Launch defended Salva, but the Defender of the People was also strongly in opposition to the nin and cabot votes, and I think he also commented on the kingkitty vote but I'm not sure. Launch also made some very strange non-statements that I think Fireblend picked up on, where he basically used a lot of words to say nothing at all.
Maybe that's just the way Launch is, but in that case the way Launch is is scummy as hell and L_P is left with a lot to answer for by standing in his shoes.
Kalor - I'm unfamiliar with Kalor but I still have absolutely no opinion on him, which nearly halfway into Day 2 in a 16-player game is a bit weird. His posts are quite MOR and he doesn't really engage that much aside from when pushed.
also I think on reflection that it's most probably a Serial Killer on the loose for balance reasons
more to come as I think of it
As of right now I've been thinking a lot about Hyperactivity and SalvaPot. With Hyperactivity it's been less more what they've posted and the list that Palmer came up with at the start of the day. I know that that I'm GOP so I've voted for Hyper. However something about SalvaPot has been bugging me since the game started. I'll need to go find the specific.
Launchpad did seem scummy yesterday but in a way that seemed too obvious. I want to hear more from Lone_Prodigy but I feel like that if they are Electorate then they will play in a low key way since suspicion is naturally on
Also Ouro, it still says Launchpad in the OP instead of Lone_Prodigy.
This I can agree with. Voting for him because of how inactive or unhelpful he has been is fine for me, but I just dislike how hyper piles on l_p for something launch did.
I can understand Hyper since L_P and Launch are the same person !
There was a player change but his role is the same.
As I said to hyper, I can understand it too, but it just feels weird to me to expect a new player to give you information about something the player he replaced it did, it seems pointless to me.
So my point is that Hyper should be aware of how pointless it is, yet he still decided to go after l_p, that tells me he either is that desperate to find scum following his previous hunch, or knows something we don´t.
I can follow your line of thinking there salva
Is that a can or was it meant to be can't? I don't know anymore. If I didn't know any better I'd guess you're under an effect similar to cabot's that forces you to misspell your posts
And yeah, I think we're approaching an inactive lynch. It kinda sucks, I don't think scum is hiding behind inactiveness.
I am inclined to agree but we should wait a tad longer there mate
this feud between salva and Hyper as risen my interest and i would love to hear what Hyper has to say about all this.
Is that a can or was it meant to be can't? I don't know anymore. If I didn't know any better I'd guess you're under an effect similar to cabot's that forces you to misspell your posts
And yeah, I think we're approaching an inactive lynch. It kinda sucks, I don't think scum is hiding behind inactiveness.
I meant that i can understand him, but i with everything that is said its something i will take with a huge grain of salt, would love to hear from LP and Hyper some more since they are on the spotlight.
CornBurrito
Member
i think whether or not she is the sk will become apparent in a day or two. we can afford to wait, possibly. nin seems to think the risk is worth it.
Bananaspaceprincess
Neo Member
If I'd had a voice I would go for L_P right now. I think Hyper had a point earlier this morning. And as nin said. Launchpad and L_P are the same role after all. Should he flip town he can blame Launch for making him look scummy.
- Status