Swift_Star
Banned
Sad that this comment was ignored, you’re on point.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Gaming journalist refuses to cover Hogwarts Legacy due to its "ties" with J.K Rowling.
- Thread starter CheeseCake
- Start date
Clear
CliffyB's Cock Holster
Is it really the same though?
Consider, JK Rowling's claim to fame is as a writer. That's why most people are aware of her and her views, which are separate from her work. For sure, the thorny issue of biological sex vs gender identity I highly doubt will come up in any Game based on her IP.
Khan's claim to fame, miniscule by comparison, is as a games journalist. Furthermore as part of his activism, his views are strongly reflected in his work. Due to his political stance, he is choosing to censor a game based on a JK Rowling related property.
The appeal of the product in question doesn't mean shit to Khan. Rowling has enough money not to care about any potential sales damage caused by her views.... So....
Bottom line, Khan is unquestionably making an entirely performative gesture. Its the definition of virtue signalling.
Catphish
Member
I honestly can't think of a more unnecessary profession than political game journalism. Maybe I'm not trying hard enough.
Now, people who play games, and review them objectively, I appreciate those people. The ones who take the time to make YouTube videos, or write lengthy articles, commenting on their quality, describe their content, or offer tips on how to have a better experience with a game, I love those people and am truly grateful for them.
But others who waste time editorializing on a game's adherence to cultural or political views, and actively attempt to financially harm their creators if they disagree with them? Those fuckers are a waste of life, and offer nothing of benefit to anyone.
They are absolutely, objectively, worthless. Well, except maybe to those who get paid by the click.
Now, people who play games, and review them objectively, I appreciate those people. The ones who take the time to make YouTube videos, or write lengthy articles, commenting on their quality, describe their content, or offer tips on how to have a better experience with a game, I love those people and am truly grateful for them.
But others who waste time editorializing on a game's adherence to cultural or political views, and actively attempt to financially harm their creators if they disagree with them? Those fuckers are a waste of life, and offer nothing of benefit to anyone.
They are absolutely, objectively, worthless. Well, except maybe to those who get paid by the click.
DispatchNinja
Banned
Shouldn’t he discontinue covering PlayStation then as well since they’re hosting state of plays for this “problematic” game, along with their recent harassment allegations?
tpieman2029
Member
Gene Park is doing the same thing and is blocking people who try to talk to him about it
Atanascovich
Member
Aren't they all?
Guy isn't genuine in the slightest, but there's nothing wrong with someone self-censoring themselves. Hell, even if his own publication decides to not cover it, that's still fine.
There's nothing wrong with a journalist being an activist. If a journalist really cared about exposing the extent of child trafficking you'd really finger wag them? The problem with this guy is that the "activism" rings hollow. Rowling is a wildly easy target and boycotting a game that likely wasn't going to have much engagement on their website anyway has zero risk for them. That's the issue, not that the guy has "opinions."
Punished Miku
Member
TheGreatMusashi
Member
I guess remove the “art” from the “artist.”
Adults into Harry Potter have always been embarrassing.
I wouldn’t cover that bullshit either.
Adults into Harry Potter have always been embarrassing.
I wouldn’t cover that bullshit either.
rickybooby87
Member
JK Rowling isn’t even associated with the game right? (According to FAQ on Hogwarts Legacy site). Like, by Imran’s logic, he’s doing the opposite of what he’s intending by tweeting about it, hence the “look at me everyone!” Virtue signaling.
tpieman2029
Member
Gene's response to people calling him out on it
Halo is Back
Member
FunkMiller
Gold Member
Kacho
Member
Holy shit. There is a promotional tweet for the game directly before the virtue signaling tweet (the virtue signal tweet has the comments disabled of course). Clown shoes.Check out this "essay" from Gamespot :
JK Rowling's Anti-Transgender Stance And Hogwarts Legacy
With a brand-new Harry Potter game on the way, now is the time to unpack and try to understand the impact of franchise creator JK Rowling's discriminatory behaviour.www.gamespot.com
These people are delusional.
Arioco
Member
I'm not worried about "journalists" that don't want to review the game, I'm worried about those who will review it just to try to boycott it and harm J. K. Rowling.
I'm afraid we can't teus Metacritic this time (could we ever?). Not even the user score, many nolifers will give it a 0.
This situation is pretty crazy, to be honest. People can't distinguish between the author and the work. Many of my favorites authors were horrible people (which I don't think J. K. Rowling is, she's just someone being devoured by the monster she helped create), but that doesn't make their novels or poems any worse. Should we stop reading Shakespeare, Cervantes or Dostoyevski because we might not agree with some of their statements? That's so silly that I can't believe some people actually think like that.
I'm afraid we can't teus Metacritic this time (could we ever?). Not even the user score, many nolifers will give it a 0.
This situation is pretty crazy, to be honest. People can't distinguish between the author and the work. Many of my favorites authors were horrible people (which I don't think J. K. Rowling is, she's just someone being devoured by the monster she helped create), but that doesn't make their novels or poems any worse. Should we stop reading Shakespeare, Cervantes or Dostoyevski because we might not agree with some of their statements? That's so silly that I can't believe some people actually think like that.
Vognerful
Member
Swift_Star
Banned
It is the same thing. The journalist is free. He can do whatever he wants.
Umbasaborne
Banned
How brave
FunkMiller
Gold Member
In an ideal world JK Rowling wouldn't get called a Nazi, have people advocate for her hanging, have her address doxxed, and be called a cunt TERF because of her opinion... and this guy wouldn't get roasted by a bunch of smooth brains like us on Twitter for having his.
Umbasaborne
Banned
Im all for trans rights, but i love harry potter and im sure as fuck not going to ignore this game. I guarantee you that most of these journo’s will set their online status to private so they can play it without fear of being cancelled. How the fuck did this video game become a political statement
luffie
Member
This is true.
I don't follow JK nor care about what she says. But there was a period of time where she kept on getting heat and the HP stars were in support of trans. I got curious and went to see what she actually just tweet. She simply tweets, quoting an article that says "menstruating people"
JK: wasn't there a word for this?.....'woman'? (not exact words)
There it is, she is transphobic because she says "women menstruate".... Most of the comments were screaming how Trans women(men) also menstruate. Until there's one guy who sincerely asked "I'm really curious, is there really a case where men menstruate, if there is can someone explain to me?"
A reply came, saying "yeah, it's called Swyer syndrome"
Curious, and wanting to learn more, I actually checked what Swyer syndrome is. Turns out that there is 0 case of men ever menstruating in this world.
So it turns out that the person who tries to reply the genuine question with "Swyer syndrome" is LYING. There is 0 men in this world that has ever menstruate, and JK is transphobic for saying that.
Really, anyone who has ever said JK is transphobic has never read what she says/tweets. And if they have ever read, then they are insidious and deliberately lying to push an insidious lie.
Bryank75
Banned
Craig of War
Banned
when did he shave can't remember the last time i saw him without a beard
FunkMiller
Gold Member
When or how? hahaha
Been back a couple days!
And already roasted by
davidjaffe
.Next week’s task for you: get called a cunt by Neil Druckmann. Get on it.
Elginer
Member
I know I shouldn't say anything but this comes across as narcissistic ass wipery. For fucks sake, if your job is to write about games, write about games not your personal agenda to be a cuck and somehow try and save the world (which you are not) you simply come across as an entitled dick bag. That's like me working at McDonalds and talking shit to my customers because I'm a vegan. My job is to serve hamburgers not wax poetic about my beliefs.
mortal
Gold Member
Being a journalist and being an activist are two very different things.
If someone wants to be an activist on their own time, they are more than welcome to do so. Simply don't do it under the guise of journalism
Journalists are expected to relay news and stories as they happened, not as they choose to see things.
Journalistic integrity, be it in gaming or otherwise, has taken a nosedive because of this conflation of journalism and activism imo.
Last edited:
Syphon Filter
Member
Journalists are irrelevant these days for the most part. Big youtubers will cover it along with twitch streamers.
Ezquimacore
Banned
Lol imagine thinking his opinion is THAT important. He should stop covering Nintendo games, since they made Birdo a woman and not a trans like the first iterations the transgender community have been suffering too much.
Bryank75
Banned
The Pleasure
Member
Virtue signaling is the new gang sign. Check out my tiger wolf hybrid virtue stance!
balls of snow
Member
Also a muslim. Wonder how he reconcile that as the Quran says there are only 2 genders.
Zeroing
Banned
Wait, Neil called him that ? lolAnd already roasted by
Next week’s task for you: get called a cunt by Neil Druckmann. Get on it.
Cyberpunkd
Member
But she is not, her stance is controversial only in the US, in the UK it is part of mainstream feminism that focuses not on identity, but practical challenges women face in life - education, employment, etc.
This reminds me when Trevor Noah decided to be a smartass and referred to “Africa winning a World Cup for France” while applying US ideals on race and completely misunderstanding the French stance on nationality. Boy, did this cause a shitstorm over here.
Yes, she choses to refer to people by their biological gender, not gender identity - the whole mess with “people who menstruate”. Yes, to have a period you need to be a biological woman, no way around that. So what she might be doing is not very nice, but she should be getting that amount of vitriol - just move on.
Abriael_GN
RSI Employee of the Year
Check out this "essay" from Gamespot :
JK Rowling's Anti-Transgender Stance And Hogwarts Legacy
With a brand-new Harry Potter game on the way, now is the time to unpack and try to understand the impact of franchise creator JK Rowling's discriminatory behaviour.
These people are delusional.
I don't think the comparison with the article in the OP is fair, and I believe those who are attacking Gamespot's article should read it with a bit more attention (or at all, because I'm sure some stopped at the headline).
The article in the OP basically baits the readers under the guise of news to read the writer's hostile stance on a game based on a person's ideas, without providing any of the news promised by the headline, and basically proclaiming that the writer or their colleagues won't do their job reporting news about the game.
Gamestop's article is an extensively argumented (and clearly titled and labeled) opinion piece feature on the controversy surrounding the author of the novels from which the world of the game derives. It's actually quite balanced and doesn't demonize those who will purchase and enjoy the game, nor those writing about it. Of course, it's opinionated. Of course, it's critical of Rowling. And of course, it explains why the author won't support the game. That's what opinion pieces are for. You can agree or disagree with it, but the writer is expressing their opinion pretty literally in the most appropriate form in a journalistic outlet about an entertainment & art medium. It's likely one of the most balanced articles I've read on the topic, and it certainly doesn't take a stance as extreme as many's.
It also doesn't tell you "we're so much against this game that we won't report about it" (harming its developers in the process). In fact, Gamespot came out with a proper news article about the State of Play, for those who simply want to read the news. Don't care to read the opinion? You don't have to. But it's fine for it to be expressed in the article form that literally exists for that.
Games are art, and art will generate opinions that go beyond the sphere of pure entertainment. There's really nothing wrong if these opinions are expressed in opinion pieces as long as the outlet's editorial line allows it (some do, some don't. Obviously GameSpot's does). If they annoy you so much, you can simply skip them. They're not rubbed in your face with an automatic unskippable popup. But it happens with movies, with paintings, with poetry, with books, and has happened for centuries, even in forms that predate journalism.
I haven't read a single Harry Potter book, nor watched a single movie (I've seen a couple of trailers), but today's gameplay video sold me on the game, because it looks awesome and right up my alley. I'm 99% gonna buy it at launch, and I'm likely gonna have a hell of a time if the promise of what we've seen today even comes close to be realized (besides, I tend to love games made by Avalanche). But games don't exist in a vacuum, and if there are people who don't want to play it because it's against their principles and want to express that in article form, that's certainly their prerogative.
Last edited:
bender
What time is it?
davidjaffe
, couldn't Spielberg doing BFG also be the ultimate fuck you to Dahl? Good video btw. Miss the beard though.
SlimySnake
Flashless at the Golden Globes
lmao at the Bryank call out. When Jaffe knows your ban history, you've made it my man!
InfiniteCombo
Banned
Wikipedia definition of journalism: "Journalism is the production and distribution of reports on the interaction of events, facts, ideas, and people that are the 'news of the day' and that informs society to at least some degree."
Based on the Tweet in the OP... it is then clear as day that the activist who some people call a journalist is, in fact, NOT a journalist.
Based on the Tweet in the OP... it is then clear as day that the activist who some people call a journalist is, in fact, NOT a journalist.
SlimeGooGoo
Party Gooper
.
Last edited:
balls of snow
Member
Its because she wont back down on that 1 % and be bullied. Its more that she has the audacity to stand up for her belief rather than the belief itself. They cant handle that amount of backbone and willpower.
Wesleyalucard
Member
The creator of Twisted Metal and God Of War
BadBurger
Many “Whelps”! Handle It!
When or how? hahaha
Been back a couple days!
Welcome back man, often got a laugh out of your enthusiasm heh
TheInfamousKira
Reseterror Resettler
Sweet. Every time I don't feel like doing my job, I'll just take this dude's example and claim bigotry on anyone who criticizes me. Hell, this should spread all over.
"Doctor, she faces a serious risk of exsanguination if we don't staunch that wound and stabilize her. We need you up here, stat. Everyone in the room are just interns!"
"You know...I don't think I will. But hand her this list of trans charities. THAT will be how I perform surgery today," *yawns loudly*
Or
"Please officer, my child has been missing for twelve hours! I've put up fliers, organized neighborhood searches, but I need the police resources!"
"You know, that's terrible Mrs. Peter's. You know what else is terrible? The amount of trans people who go missing on a daily basis due to bigotry and hate. Here's a charity. I'ma hit the drag show, peace,"
"Doctor, she faces a serious risk of exsanguination if we don't staunch that wound and stabilize her. We need you up here, stat. Everyone in the room are just interns!"
"You know...I don't think I will. But hand her this list of trans charities. THAT will be how I perform surgery today," *yawns loudly*
Or
"Please officer, my child has been missing for twelve hours! I've put up fliers, organized neighborhood searches, but I need the police resources!"
"You know, that's terrible Mrs. Peter's. You know what else is terrible? The amount of trans people who go missing on a daily basis due to bigotry and hate. Here's a charity. I'ma hit the drag show, peace,"
