-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
IGN: Retro Studios Working on Donkey Kong Revival
- Thread starter Skiesofwonder
- Start date
I think I've said it several times before. Nintendo does not seem to want new franchises from Western development studios on Wii. They've killed the Headstrong Games title, they've killed the n-Space title. It appears as if they want to rely on their old franchises.
Of course, quite a few Retro employees would've loved to work on an original IP. As a result, some left after Metroid Prime 3 was finished, some others (Armature) left after the Zelda title was cancelled.
All in all, I've heard that Retro might have some management issues - of course not to the extent we can see at NST. At NST, most veterans left in the last 3 years because of shelved projects and bad management (Where did they go? Many went to Microsoft)...
For E3 I only expect their "Escape Room" puzzle collection...
Then there's another bit. Factor 5 DID work on a Kid Icarus project, as evidenced by artwork and character animations of Pit and some enemies. However, and this is speculation, it was only a project pitch; we do not know whether Nintendo approved the concept or whether they didn't. It is a fact nonetheless that Factor 5 worked on a Kid Icarus game, either with or without Nintendo's approval.
Returning to the question whether Retro is working on a Donkey Kong game, yes. Wouldn't it fit pretty well into how Nintendo deals with its Western partners? :lol
Of course, quite a few Retro employees would've loved to work on an original IP. As a result, some left after Metroid Prime 3 was finished, some others (Armature) left after the Zelda title was cancelled.
All in all, I've heard that Retro might have some management issues - of course not to the extent we can see at NST. At NST, most veterans left in the last 3 years because of shelved projects and bad management (Where did they go? Many went to Microsoft)...
For E3 I only expect their "Escape Room" puzzle collection...
Then there's another bit. Factor 5 DID work on a Kid Icarus project, as evidenced by artwork and character animations of Pit and some enemies. However, and this is speculation, it was only a project pitch; we do not know whether Nintendo approved the concept or whether they didn't. It is a fact nonetheless that Factor 5 worked on a Kid Icarus game, either with or without Nintendo's approval.
Returning to the question whether Retro is working on a Donkey Kong game, yes. Wouldn't it fit pretty well into how Nintendo deals with its Western partners? :lol
Stumpokapow
listen to the mad man
rezuth said:
Well, given that Wario Land Shake It was animated by a professional 2d animation studio... and given that Retro doesn't actually have any 2d animators, I'd say that this might not really be something you want to see happen
[Nintex] said:
yeah, most likely some random developer like nibris and similars had a Kid Icarus build to offer to nintendo and THAT is what casamassina meant with KI coming back from the dead. I am sorry if I am being overly sensitive but that's bullshit.
As a game journalist, I claim a game is coming when a game IS COMING not when someone somewhere showed me an unapproved, certainly not green lighted and maybe never seen by nintendo build of a particular game.
tea_and_crumpets
Member
It had better be a platformer and not some sort of abomination like Banjo Nuts n' Bolts.
Katana_Strikes
Member
tea_and_crumpets said:
Well it's not from Rare so I think we're safe.
RockmanWhore
Member
Kinda disappointed if true, the Wii needs a solid shooter, and Retro seems like the best team at Nintendo to deliver that. Or maybe is it a Donkey Kong FPS, there were weapons in DK64 :lol
Probably, but I'm not sure Nintendo ever pursued western studios with this in mindupandaway said:
I mean, the shining example is Retro and Nintendo had to come in with a weed whacker and prune out all the nonsense and dictate exactly what sort of game Prime would be. And now that most of the top creative people have fled, I'm not sure who's left at Retro except really good modelers and artists who are adept at taking other people's ideas and making them into a good game. NoA being nothing more than a marketing division doesn't help either.
Can't really speak to n-space or NST, as they've never produced anything I took interest in.
I was hoping for a star fox or a new western IP, somehting like a WRPG or TPS or something, at leats a star fox 
AceBandage
Banned
I'll reserve judgment (mostly until I see if it's real).
However, I think if anyone could do any Nintendo franchise justice
it's certainly Retro.
However, I think if anyone could do any Nintendo franchise justice
besides EAD
Gamer @ Heart
Member
Some of the comments here have left me confused.
Retro is completly first party. That would mean that have about as much control oveR their projects as an R&D unit in japan no? I'm not talking about creative choices but more like choosing an IP to work on next. The producers and managers at nintendo ultimatly tell them what to do next. Why are people complaining that they aren't allowed to do what they want? Fuck guys, let's all complain how the Zelda team haven't been able to make a new IP in all these years.
Anyway, the thought of a refreshing take on DK has me PUMPED.
Retro is completly first party. That would mean that have about as much control oveR their projects as an R&D unit in japan no? I'm not talking about creative choices but more like choosing an IP to work on next. The producers and managers at nintendo ultimatly tell them what to do next. Why are people complaining that they aren't allowed to do what they want? Fuck guys, let's all complain how the Zelda team haven't been able to make a new IP in all these years.
Anyway, the thought of a refreshing take on DK has me PUMPED.
IAmtheFMan
Member
IGN confirmed that Retro was working on Metroid Prime 3 when all sorts of rumors were abound after MP2. They also more or less did this same thing with a "hot or not" post on their boards for a "Mature" Zelda, albeit a day before E3 2004.
comedy bomb
Banned
I smell a rail shooter coming out of this.
AceBandage
Banned
comedy bomb said:
Well, his coconut gun, it does fire in bursts.
No, but seriously, it's probably more like DK64.
OR!
A New Donkey Kong Country on the 3DS!
Stumpokapow
listen to the mad man
TEJ said:
... but very few of those shooters are on the Wii, and many of those platformers are!
comedy bomb
Banned
If this rumor turns out to be true, Nintendo better show off Kirby Wii too. Dammit.
The Dutch Slayer
Member
For me personally if true, OMG !!!!
DeathbyVolcano
Banned
So...why does everyone think this is true?
Nothing confirmed but I'd love to see a new Donkey Kong game. It's been a long time coming.
One of Nintendo's shortcomings with their Western development houses is that they simply don't know how to retain talent. While they've done an excellent job of keeping their Japanese employees for decades, it's very common for people in the Western to jump around development houses or freelance if they are unsatisfied with their current employment. It's a different culture and Nintendo is unwilling or unable to make compromises in order to retain talent.
Gamer @ Heart said:
One of Nintendo's shortcomings with their Western development houses is that they simply don't know how to retain talent. While they've done an excellent job of keeping their Japanese employees for decades, it's very common for people in the Western to jump around development houses or freelance if they are unsatisfied with their current employment. It's a different culture and Nintendo is unwilling or unable to make compromises in order to retain talent.
Everything else would just make it even worse. I don't want a DK 3rd person shooter based on the DK64 weapons or something.Shiggy said:
Actually, if it's true I'll end up disappointed whatever it will be, since my hopes were up that Retro is finally working on something original.
AceBandage
Banned
I will say this though.
Grandjedi brings up and excellent point.
If we're going to believe this, we have to believe Craig when he said the 3DS was as powerful as the PS3/360.
=/
Grandjedi brings up and excellent point.
If we're going to believe this, we have to believe Craig when he said the 3DS was as powerful as the PS3/360.
=/