Also Killzone 2 was way better than Halo ODST. Halo ODST was the most disappointing game I played that wasn't called Brutal Legend. Worthless.
About the FPS category. I don't see any reason why Killzone 2 doesn't deserve. Over all, it was probably the best I played this year(I liked Killing Floor More). But it came with a very nice online, and SP campaign. It didn't help MW2 had Broken Online, Borderlands PC edition was a joke, and L4D2...While being great still soured allot of votes. Now if you want to say how pathetically weak the year one(Probably the most true for FPS). Then go for it. But don't try to make it out to be that some how Killzone 2 is weaker then the competition.
I wonder what will take it for 2010. If Zelda, Mario and Metroid all make it we might see a Wii centric top 10. Bayonetta netted some early love here from those who played it in 09. Then of course there are the next main entries in the God of War, Halo, and Gran Turismo series and stuff we don't even know about yet (HL2 Ep3 please oh dear god please)
You'll have your 2 or 3 Sony exclusives being pushed(Most likely GT, Trico, and GoWIII)
Starcraft II should also becoming out next year.
Mario Galaxy is a shoe in also..Metriod M(If it delivers) will also take a spot.
I think Bayonetta like movies released now for the Oscar season is going be forgotten. Not to mention it came out in Japan last year. So there is going be allot of split voting.
The only catagory that seems like shit is the shmup one. Pixel Junk is fun...but no way in hell it deserves to be above Mushihime-Sama Futari Version 1.5 or Raiden Fighter Aces. Both of them were leagues above Shooter. And I'm sure once I play Sin and Punishment 2. It's going to get a third that deserved it far more